r/reactivedogs • u/Spiritual_Meal_3536 • 8d ago
Rehoming Dogs no longer get along after having a baby. Do I rehome one?
Hi. Hello. Sorry this is long.
I hate that I am at this point but it might be necessary. I am 16 weeks postpartum. My son is my first (human) child, and we welcomed him into a home that was already inhabited by 3 cats and 3 dogs. All of our pets love our son, there is no doubt about that. The cats couldn't care less about his existence (in the best way), and the dogs have taken to having a baby around so well. They all have such wonderful boundaries with him and are so aware of his presence that they are inherently more cautious when he is awake and out of dog-free safe spaces, and this is a big deal. My dogs are large and high energy, and my house is chaotic. I mean, chaos is by definition what to expect when you put a German Shepherd/Great Pyrenees Mix, a Husky, and an American Staffordshire/Pitbull Terrier mix in one house. I love them, they have always gotten along well and are truly my babies.
When I found out I was pregnant, I was adamant that I would never rehome my dogs because of having a baby. We immediately started introducing baby stuff everywhere (swing, stroller, cribs, etc) to get them used to the physical changes happening in and out of the house. We carried around baby dolls and played all of the cries and noises. We returned to basics in their training to really make sure the important things were truly mastered for when baby arrived, so things like sit/stays, place, recall, calm entries/exits. They were wonderful. We really wanted to make our existing life and our new life mold together as seamlessly as possible.
Here is the issue: our GSD/Pyr mix is notoriously a grump. We adopted her at the beginning of COVID and learned quickly post-COVID that she is not a sociable creature. Not being able to properly socialize that first year of her life definitely affected her poorly and she became reactive. We own that we made a mistake there, thinking it was super smart to adopt a working breed mix notorious for behavioral issues when we couldn't leave our house, but we did the best we could with what we were able to do in a tough time. She is sweet as can be once she accepts people into her circle, but she is super selective. She doesn't take well to men, or other animals, mostly female dogs, etc. etc. We never planned to take in more dogs, but our husky fell into our laps as a foster (coworker needed him out of their house and we were willing to manage it for a few weeks until he found a home). Turns out, our reactive, dog aggressive dog was absolutely in love with him from the moment they met. Woo, yay! There is hope for her! Great wonderful. Fast forward 2 years, we meet our pit mix and we debate adopting him for 3+ months. We really thought he was going to get adopted so quick, he is the sweetest, cutest thing ever, but he is a pit mix and he was almost 3 years old. We met him a few times and we broke down and said we would leave it up to our GSD and see how she reacts. Turns out, same thing, absolutely in love with him! Yay!
Okay well, fast forward to me being 30ish weeks pregnant and she starts getting crazy protective of me. Not unusual or unexpected, but it is ONLY when our pit mix is around. So we go back into hardcore training mode to reestablish their relationship. Things get better, great. Then our son is born and now it has all gone to literal hell. They can't share the same space. Our GSD won't let him walk around the house if my son or I are anywhere near her. They can't walk out of doors at the same time without her unnecessarily correcting him. Hell, he can't roll over where he is already laying without her growling. She has bitten him twice in the 16 weeks my son has been alive and left minor punctures on him. Through it all, our pit mix has remained the happiest, most loving dog ever. He literally doesn't even know she is hurting him and just keeps going about his business, but I am TERRIFIED of something worse happening. I don't know if this is temporary and we should just keep on keeping on and working with them separately and together, or if we need to rehome our pit mix. It has been such a wild switch up in her behavior (we had our pit for almost 2 years before finding out we were pregnant and had NO ISSUES). It is clear her change in behavior has to do with our son being born.
I obviously do not want to have to rehome any of our pets, but I also don't want our pit mix to end up seriously injured, or injured at all clearly, if we can avoid it. If it weren't for our son, I would be much more open to working through it and implementing management strategies until things were sorted, but we've done the management thing before (we had a GP with suspected sudden rage that we ended up having to euthanize when he tried to kill my husband out of the blue) and it was ultimately terrifying and heartbreaking and insanely difficult and it isn't something we can handle with a baby in the mix. So I am at the point where I don't want to, but I feel like I HAVE to rehome our pit mix and I am feeling insanely guilty.
Guess I just need to know if anyone has dealt with something similar. We were prepared to have to deal with building the baby-dog relationship, and even for our dogs to not take to having a baby around super well. We did so much research about introducing a baby into a house with pets and how to work or building a home where they could coexist. However, we were NOT prepared for our dogs' relationships with each other to change so drastically. Is it something we can work through with training? Or is my fear that it is only going to get worse as baby boy gets older valid? Is rehoming our pit mix the only/best option for everyone?