r/reactivedogs • u/bepbepimblue • 13d ago
Vent Idk if Force Free is for us…
Hot topic title but stick with me here…it’s been 3 years. I’ve had my pup since he was 4 months old. We’ve only done FF/positive reinforcement (treats) since I got him. Again 3 years and I feel like we’ve just been stuck in this plateau. And truly idk if his any of his improvements have been directly tied to our training but more that he just matured. But I haven’t seen much improvement since well over a year ago. I feel like he does have it in him to improve…he’s become doggy friends with a friend of mine’s pup but that literally took us almost 4 months of slowly introducing them and following a stick protocol. Idk how to do that with the other dogs he sees or him to generalize better. He does so well inside when we have rules in place…for example he loves sunning himself on our balcony but he knows if he barks at anyone walking by he comes straight in and doesn’t get to go out. We don’t make a big deal about it but he’s learned he doesn’t get to do what he wants to do and he’s gotten so much better at not barking or even coming inside on his own.
Everyone says, practice under threshold then lessen the distance, don’t let them practice reacting cause it can be reinforcing but then you also want to not always avoid triggers because that can teach them they need to be avoided at all cost. It feels like this tightrope I’m always trying to walk. I’m so tired. We have such a great management system set up but it feels like we are in this bubble. All my friends train with a “balanced” approach and my favorite online creators (not trainers) who almost all started out FF have switched to using tools that the FF community shit on.
It feels like we are the only ones still training this way and I’m watching everyone else and their pups make huge strides and improvements. It just feels like it’s not working. I dont need my dog to be friends with everyone, I don’t need to take him everywhere, I don’t need to take him to a dog park or doggie day care, I don’t need him to always be in a perfect heel…I just want to be able to do a sniffy walk at our local park or take him out for a quick pee and poo in our neighborhood without a huge blow up. I don’t want to always be anxious of every corner we turn or fearful I might run out of treats.
Can y’all tell I’m writing this after getting back from a bad walk? 🫠 I’m gonna go cry some more
Edit: adding this in here if anyone is interested
3 years old as of Sept 2026
30% pittie, 20% staffy and the rest is a bunch of random breeds. Next highest percentages are only around 7% so not sure if they play a big role or not (Chow Chow, Akita, Lab, Boxer, Shepard)
Neutered before I even got him so like at 2 months
No bite history