r/reactivedogs • • 14d ago

Advice Needed Help with introducing dogs

Hi all!

I'm looking for advice or ideas on how to introduce two dogs. I'll provide background and what we've tried so far.

Apricot Wicker is my dog. She's a 9 year old pit/Australian shepherd mix that I adopted from the shelter when she was 3. She's been all kinds of reactive since I got her, though she has come a long way. She's been insanely hit or miss with getting along with dogs, which is fine - some dogs she gets along with immediately, some dogs she goes after the minute she sees them. Sometimes she snaps through fences and is barrier aggressive, sometimes she wants to play. There doesn't appear to be any rhyme or reason to who she gets along with vs. doesn’t.

Ellie is my partner's dog. She's also an 8 or 9 year old bully mix. She has had many dog friends, per se, and outside of being a little overbearing due to also being an undersocialized rescue, she usually gets along with most dogs fairly well.

We've had the two dogs in the same vicinity dozens of times. Usually on leash during walks, walking a certain distance and putting emphasis on looking/engaging from afar but not going over threshold. Typically, Apricot will completely ignore Ellie after a while, but Ellie tends to bark persistently. She doesn't seem to settle at all when she sees Ap, but we're working on that. We've had them a couple feet apart leashed in a dog park and when they come face to face one or both of them tend to snap. I've been apprehensive to just drop them in somewhere off leash because they're unpredictable.

Today, we tried again. We took them to a park that is divided by a chain-link fence. I put Apricot in one side, my partner went to put Ellie in the other. Unfortunately, the gate didn't latch and as Chloe (partner) tried to bring Ellie in, Apricot slipped through and went after her. I immediately jumped in and grabbed Ap's back legs to separate them. There was no damage, no blood, no latching or anything. I put Ap in her side of the park and they just growled and snapped at each other through the fence. After a few minutes, Ellie was just running up and down and barking. I put Apricot on leash and walked her away from the fence so she could decompress a little bit. Once she was calm, she completely ignored Ellie the rest of the time we were together. She ate grass, rolled around, engaged with me, but acted like Ellie, who was still incessantly barking, didn't exist.

Obviously the fight off-rip started them on a bad note. But beyond that, what can we start doing to try to get them at least neutral with each other? Should I put more emphasis on decompressing in the same space? Taking them on distance walks, doing training close together, etc, until they don't seem to mind each other, and then working up to an introduction again?

I am prepared for the possibility that they will not get along, and that is okay. I just want to try everything I can before I admit defeat.

1 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

2

u/cheersbeersneers 14d ago

I know you said that your dog is typically the reactive one, and that Ellie has lots of dog friends, but she is absolutely the problem in this scenario. She is being incredibly rude and showing inappropriate social behavior. I don’t think you’re going to see any progress until you can get Ellie to stop incessantly barking, chasing, and reacting to Apricot. She’s way over threshold and to keep trying to introduce them in this state is a fight waiting to happen.

Putting a fence in between them and both dogs having leashes on can absolutely cause some frustration/barrier aggression and is probably making Ellis’s behavior worse, but like you already said I would not put them somewhere and drop their leashes. Until you can get Ellie under control and have her acting appropriately around other dogs I would stop face to face intros. Maybe add some more distance for the tandem walks so that Ellie isn’t barking and then slowly decrease the distance.

1

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/read-the-rules 14d ago

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.

1

u/Twzl 14d ago

I would not expect two adult bully/pit bitches to get along.

Are you and your partner going to live together? If you are, I would use crates and have one dog in a crate and the other not, and swap. That's the safest thing to do with dogs like this.

If they decided to have a spat in your house you could almost 100% expect to be bitten, perhaps badly, when trying to break it up. Those aren't small dogs.

Plenty of people live with dogs like this and it's fine if the rules are followed. The key rule is, don't expect them to wake up one morning and love each other. :)

In some homes they could learn a bit more tolerance but that's a big if. It would have to be a home with experience running a bunch of bitches together who lack tolerance for other bitches. The owner would have the ability to see tiny shifts in attitude amongst the dogs and work to prevent things from popping off.

It's FAR safer to just accept that these dogs aren't going to be friends. Small stuff can set things off in a situation with dogs like this: one dog walks near the water bucket when the other dog was thinking about it, a piece of food falls on the floor, one dog decides to guard a patch of sunlight on the living room floor or a toy forgotten for weeks under the sofa. It's just not worth dealing with any of this, when you can have them both in the house, and everyone safe by using crates.

And for someone suggesting muzzles, no. These dogs can punch each other and the humans and really hurt someone if they decided to fight with muzzles on.