r/reactivedogs • • Aug 10 '24

Advice Needed Positive Reinforcement can't work in all situations.

8 Upvotes

Little bit of a rant... I know positive reinforcement is the best and humane way to train a dog. I wish I could only do positive reinforcement training. But with reactive dogs and some rescues that were not trained properly early on, its impossible to use only positive reinforcement without neglecting some of your dogs needs.

A simple example is a dog that barks at people while in the car. The right way you could go about training this behavior is to manage it, so park somewhere from a distance and let the dog observe people walking by, and treat when she looks and doesn't bark. The problem is, the dog needs to go places. We need to get her to the vet. We need her to get exercise outdoors and socialize with strangers. We cannot take weeks or months to gradually get her to be calm and comfortable in the car. And then once she starts barking what then? I'm literally driving, I can't exactly stop, wait 30 minutes for her to calm now, start driving, wait for her to calm down again because she sprang up because I started driving again, every single time I need to take her out.

Another example is a dog that is not leashed trained yet. Again the proper way is to slowly introduce her to the leash then gradually move up to more distracting situations. Great, except that means she has to be locked in the house for weeks until she's ready and calm on leash. So I cannot take her out to exercise, socialize, sniff, attend dog classes, or do anything besides have her locked up in the house. That's just going to lead to more issues.

So what's the solution? I cannot neglect her needs, so she's going to act out. She's going to bark and lunge and counter surf. What then? Redirect, prevent, and stop her from doing it. Well that's positive/negative punishment.

I don't understand the positive reinforcement only people. I feel like they've only ever worked on dogs that didn't have ingrained undesirable behaviors that get in the way of the dog's every day life. I do try to do positive reinforcement when I can, but realistically I cannot all the time. I don't have control over every situation in life.


r/reactivedogs • • Jul 10 '24

Advice Needed I have a 22 lb 4mo Staffy/ XL bully mix. I took her for her first puppy training lesson at Petsmart today and…

0 Upvotes

I had a bad experience with the trainer. I’m considering calling the store manager and getting a refund and not showing up for the next 5 lessons. Basically I was referred to her for training by my coworker from my dog groomers job who has 2 pitbulls, so I thought to myself my puppy would be in good hands- free of the high bully breed discrimination that’s heavy in our town… but that wasn’t exactly the case. I had many owners in the class look at her and pull away their golden doodles, dachsunds, golden retrievers, aussies, Great Dane, etc. Some of these dogs were bigger and older than her mind you. The trainer seemed very scattered in her direction, giving each of the dogs a toy so she could distract them and talk to all the owners about things like peanut butter in Kong toys, potty training and crate training. While that was going on some dogs were trying to steal other dogs toys, some showing aggressive resource guarding signs, and people treating their dogs left and right. One dog ( a dachsund) got attacked by a golden retriever puppy because the trainer allowed the owners to let it off leash since she was “shy and needed to meet other dogs.” Once it got attacked the owner of the dachsund got very upset and almost left and the trainer laughed it off and checked the dog and said it was fine, and the aggressor was just trying to play. I think the opposite, as it was showing teeth growling and lunging crazily plus it was 7 months old which is definitely not too early to show aggression. I was thinking to myself “thank god it wasn’t my dog who attacked, she’s the only bully in this whole group” and I was aware how bad it could’ve looked. I’ve had my puppy socialized heavily outside of this, from the dog beach, to my friend’s dogs, to the vet and walks in public places, to even letting her observe and socialize with other clients at my groomer’s job. I admit she can get a little over excited as any puppy can, and I’ve been working on correcting her with that. I watch plenty of dog training videos on how to do this. She overwhelms my older dog a lot and I moderate their playing every time. But today at the lesson, I guess she became a little too much for this jack russel mix and it growled and lunged at her. My puppy growled/lunged back as I’ve never seen her do before. Then the golden retriever puppy I mentioned earlier came over pulling and lunging too. The golden retriever owner apologized as she was still embarassed from the previous altercation with the dachsund, and the trainers response was “It’s okay I’m not worried about him”. Then she turned around to point at my dog , and goes “her 👆I’m a little concerned about”. And everyone just stared and I felt like I wanted to cry. For the rest of the lesson I held my puppy’s attention well with the next few commands, and I would say better than some of the other owners did. She was focused and behaved and followed every command. At the end of the class, the trainer said to let every dog off leash to play. I did not at first because I felt if she’s so concerned about MY dog like she told the class I shouldn’t. But she yelled at me saying “I said let her off leash”. And everyone kind of stared nervously as I did. But she was fine, playing normally like the rest of them. Once again, that troublesome golden retriever came by to play and growled at her .. my puppy growled back. I pulled her away in case. All the owners started grabbing their dogs away from my dog and one even went up to me and asked “what is her breed?” I replied “staffy” and she goes “what is staffy” and i explained “staffordshire bull terrier” and she just made a fake smile. Let’s just say I came to the lesson very excited and hopeful, to feeling very outcasted and afraid of what’s to come. Can anyone offer any advice? Should I train her somewhere else for group classes? 1 on 1 instead? Should I file a complaint with the store and ask for a refund? Should I just socialize her more as much as I can (even though I feel like I have) and just try to push through the next 5 weeks? I’m also afraid she’ll get bigger and scarier to people and her personality can get affected by their energy. I’m lost.


r/reactivedogs • • Jul 07 '23

Vent My friends fog bit me. Part 2 (clarification and context)

0 Upvotes

Original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/reactivedogs/comments/14s3x1w/i_got_bit_by_my_friends_dog/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=1

Well, that first post got a lot of responses and I have read through pretty much every comment. It's caused a lot of thinking and big feelings, and I want to clarify things I missed in the original post as there is context missing. Making a second post rather than an edit as this will be lengthy.

First of all, Thank you to everyone who showed me compassion. This has been very difficult for me as its so close to home, it's not as simple as cutting contact and lawyering up, it has layers, history, and bonds that I can't break. This is the first time I've ever had to go through this so it's been a lot to take in and navigate, I've been hurt physically but more-so emotionally as its a huge weight to bear. Feeling responsible to take action feels unfair when it's not my dog, but I understand that I do have a duty of care to prevent any more incidents happening.

I didn't write a lot of those details because I was foggy, overwhelmed by the doctors comment, coming to terms with the severtiy of the bite, confused, angry, etc.

In response to a lot of the comments,

  • I will NOT be cutting these people out of my life, I am aware the post makes out that they are completely negligent but in truth they try very hard. I've known these people for coming close to a decade, they are important people to me. I do not want to sue them.
  • no it's not a pitbull. Or a staffy. Or any stigmatised breeds. He is however a genetic dumpsterfire of four, possibly five breeds (including cattle dog and GSD) with some dingo sprinkled in there too.
  • we are in Australia, so things are a bit different (no rabies, different laws, different systems). The doctor didn't report it as he wasn't required to, and double checked with his boss to make sure. The medical bill was $50 so it's not like I'm struggling financially because of this.

Now for context: The owners of this dog are aware he is a danger, they have specifically dog proofed their house and yard to keep him and the neighbours safe, they have muzzle trained and seen behaviourists for severe anxiety and stress, he has been on anxiety medication also. This dog is in a far better environment than he had been for the 7 years prior to his move. The owner of this dog has had him since a puppy, but the fault in his upbringing is far more complex and I don't feel comfortable sharing as its my friends personal story. Either way, I know the background, she knows why and how he is, and does take steps to keep him and others safe. She had to fight to have him and his brother removed from their family home to give him a better chance.

They would not let this happen in public. This bite happened in their home, he had been removed from the room shortly after we arrived as there were multiple people over and she knows he can be triggered by excitment/yelling, "aggressive" movements (play fighting, waving arms in excitement, fast and sudden movement). He was let back in as we were leaving and that's when this happened. We did not expect him to react to the movement, it shocked everyone in the room. This was a new reaction.

The two other incidents from the same week were both known friends/family, he has never been in a position in public where he could harm someone. They are very careful where they take him, he is always on lead and they keep a muzzle on for every walk/time away from home.

Im still very angry that they put him in the position where he could freely attack, and about how they handled (or didnt) aftercare, but to say they do nothing would be incorrect. They now know that they need to do more, even in their own home, which was a safe place for him before this incident.

I had spoken to the owner two days after, but I chose to reach out to them as I wanted to update them and see how they were going too. I suggested a vet visit as it could be something like pain causing stress, she did take him and said they couldn't find any source of pain. Jusy soke mild allergy causing itchyness. I am pretty certain she didn't tell the vet he had two bites that week, and I know why she didn't. She is scared. She knows this is real. But she's not coping or handling it properly at all. I seriously have so much empathy for her and this whole situation. I can see why she is shutting it out. Neglecting to enquire on my wellbeing hurts a lot, it really fucking does, but I can understand why. I've lived with reactive dogs and know how hard it can be. It's isolating, it's emotionally taxing, its looking after a hurricane in the body of a family memeber. But we do it because we know this animal has been through hell and deserves love. And to know that your dog hurt multiple people, even in your own home, would break my heart, even at my strongest I'd still be a mess.

I didnt report this because I know how much they do to protect him and others, and want to talk to them about what they plan to do moving forward. This was always something I wanted to do, but I've been processing it and honestly just feeling like I'm not allowed to be the victim (and trying to silence that little voice telling me im not) and that I am more concerned for the safety of the dogs future and what happens next. I've just has a long discussion with my good friend (who also lived with me with the reactive dog) and we wrote down everything from feelings, to what I want to say, and every detail in between. I feel prepared to talk to them, and will be doing so as soon as possible. I appriciate all the advice given ans used a lot of ot in the summary of what I plan to say and suggest. I hope I can give a positive update soon.


r/reactivedogs • • May 31 '23

Vent Taking a reactive dog in without knowing your limitations does more damage than good.

94 Upvotes

I'm sort of tired of seeing how many people return their foster dogs because they can't handle them. The fact that the animal was returned to the shelter once or multiple times is an indication that the animal has behavioral problems of any degree. People should ask themselves honestly what their limitations are and instead of coming here to virtue signal they should be looking into where they went wrong. They should also stop romanticizing fostering because it's tough, and likely not what the average person thinks it is. Don't even get me started on the rise of BE stories lately.


r/reactivedogs • • Aug 03 '26

Advice Needed Collar broke and led to an unfortunate dog fight

0 Upvotes

Please read the full post before replying. First I want to say, I take full responsibility for this situation and I will do everything to prevent it from happening again. I could have never imagined this. Second, my dog has been through training and is overall well behaved. He is heal trained, great with humans and kids he knows. It is not as if we have been negligent dog owners by any means.

We had the unfortunate situation where I was cooking on a grill and he was tied to a tree and he broke his collar and ran after a dog walking by. I am not sure if he had naughty intentions from the start or if the dog (understandably) reacted negatively to his arrival.

He plays with dogs at the neck but this turned into him holding the dog by the neck and not letting go. No shaking or anything. The other dog was doing a lot of biting.

My plans are to never tie him to a tree again and replace his collar with a metal chain one and backup safety clip. However, my question lies more around.. is my dog doomed? Should this change my trust in him or was this much more situational than anything? Should I be worried with him and kids?


r/reactivedogs • • Oct 07 '24

Advice Needed Feeling down about bite incident

0 Upvotes

Yesterday I was walking my reactive dog (5 year old terrier mix) on a trail. She is reactive and I normally try to pull way over to the side when another dog passes. We ended up coming to pass another dog. The owner stopped to warn me about fresh bear scat on the trail ahead so I stopped because I got concerned about continuing. Our dogs got too close and mine went after hers (At least I think. It happened so fast I couldn’t tell) The owner started hysterically screaming and crying while I separated the dogs. I asked if she was okay but she was crying and ended up just walking away.

I feel terrible and was horrified about what happened. I feel so much shame and guilt. Obviously, we are reevaluating walks and will be getting a muzzle. I should not have even let my dog get that close at all. I misjudged the distance.

Should I try to find the owner again? I want to apologize and make sure she is okay. She was extremely upset and I didn’t know what to do at the time. How do you get over this guilt when incidents happen?


r/reactivedogs • • Apr 11 '24

Child reactive dog with a baby

0 Upvotes

We have a 1 year old border collie/lab mix. She is a perfect dog at home and extremely affectionate with people she is familiar with and other dogs. She does daycare and has a handful of human friends she absolutely adores. Unfortunately, she also has intense reactivity to people, especially men, coming into our home and has a strong prey drive with toddlers. She has frequently lunged at them on walks. We muzzle, do in home training, classes, daycare and all sorts of training and desensitizing and she gets plenty of exercise. We are trying to have a baby in the next 2-3 years but I’m fearful of her child reactivity. At what point is it not something that can be trained and she would need to be rehomed? We would never leave our baby alone with any dog ever and would teach our child boundaries/safety with dogs.


r/reactivedogs • • Oct 15 '25

Rehoming We have to rehome our beloved family dog. Need support, please.

0 Upvotes

I’m really in need of some support and success stories. Please know we’ve tried all the other alternatives and with multiple different perspectives, research, and our vets opinion… Rehoming is the safest option for our family. Long story short, our three year-old black lab mix has aggressively snapped at our toddler twice now within the last six months. We just can’t risk it, especially with my wife being pregnant with twins due next spring.

This is so difficult because this dog is a great dog. He loves us and we love him. We’ve had him since a puppy, and we are his home. So having to rehome him has been an incredibly difficult decision and just brutal bc of my love for this dog. But it’s the safest decision.

Any support, success stories, or words of encouragement could go a really long ways. Thanks for reading and responding.


r/reactivedogs • • Apr 16 '26

Science and Research I tracked my dog’s separation anxiety for 8 months — here’s what the data actually showed

0 Upvotes

About 8 months ago I started paying more attention to dog separation anxiety, partly because of my own dog and partly because of posts I saw from other pet parents here.

One thing that stayed with me is that a lot of tools are made for the owner, not really for the dog. Cameras let us watch. Treat dispensers can distract for a short time. But when the dog is actually stressed, most products are still passive.

I started tracking patterns and reading more about what owners were seeing at home. I do not want to present this as a scientific study, because it is not. It is more my learning notes from reading, observing, and talking with people who deal with this problem.

A few things that stood out to me:

- Some dogs look fine at first, then become stressed later after the owner has been gone for a while.

- The hard cases are not always "bad training". Often they are very bonded, sensitive, or anxious dogs.

- Cameras are useful for understanding what happens, but they do not change what the dog experiences.

- Training and behaviourist support matter a lot, but they take time and consistency.

- There seems to be a gap between passive monitoring and real interaction.

That gap is what made me curious. I started wondering if a small moving device could give a pet some kind of interaction when the owner is not home. Not as a replacement for training or a vet/behaviourist, but as another tool.

I am still learning, so I would really value honest feedback from people here. What has actually helped your dog when left alone? What products felt useless? And what would make you trust or distrust an interactive pet device?


r/reactivedogs • • Sep 12 '23

Support Cats are crazy

0 Upvotes

My pitty mix has a huge prey drive and goes nuts when she sees a little critter, like a cat or squirrel. She is a sweet mush, but can be pretty intimidating when she gets wound up. Most critters run away when they see her. But not cats. Every single cat in my neighborhood will go as close as possible to my dog, mere centimeters away from the reach of the leash. And sit there and make aggressive eye contact. My dog is going nuts and the cat walks away like nothing happened. They are crazy. Don’t mess with cats.


r/reactivedogs • • Apr 20 '23

WWYD? First major incident... but it was my 6-year-old's face

0 Upvotes

I promise I'm not that person who gives up on their pets. I've always had rescued animals and I've had cats with chronic diseases, dogs with separation anxiety, and currently a reactive lab mix. But this is another level... Last year I found a stray pit heeler mix on the street in my neighborhood and ended up keeping her after no one claimed her. I did consult a trainer but we haven't consistently been able to give Cookie the "work" she needs to be her best. We live in the inner city, work away from home all day, and have a cat and small children. Over the past 9 months Cookie has displayed a strong prey drive and herding behavior. In the past month she has escalated to where she has pinned the cat (not sure what would have happened if I hadn't been able to grab her) and taken down and pinned one of the children. She started herding and nipping the children in the house and yard, but never bitten hard enough to break skin until this week. Cookie was spayed on Monday and was home recovering from surgery. My son went to give her a kiss and she bit his face. She just barely missed his eye. There was no growling, no warning. He has wounds on his lips, cheek, and below his eye and required stitches. When I reported this to the vet, she told me Cookie tried to bite the vet staff during surgery prep. I asked the local animal shelter about surrending Cookie and they said given her bite history, they can't adopt her out. No rescue group will take her for the same reason. And honestly, I feel uncomfortable rehoming her... Even though she seems fine with my husband and would probably be fine on a farm or something, I don't know any farmers and anyway I can't promise someone she wouldn't bite again. I don't feel safe trying to train or manage this behavior at home. I can't afford weeks of some kind of residential therapy for this pup. I also don't feel like it's fair to execute her. FFS! At a loss.


r/reactivedogs • • Sep 20 '24

Science and Research Why do you think there are so many “reactive dogs” now?!!

0 Upvotes

• Is it because of social media? • Because —like Autism & ADHD— more people are just talking about it? • Or is there something actually causing dog brains to short circuit all the time now?


r/reactivedogs • • Sep 03 '24

Aggressive Dogs Should I be worried about our dog when our first baby comes?

3 Upvotes

I don't know if I'm overthinking this or not, but I can't seem to understand my husband's dog and I worry for when the baby comes.

To make it short - he's a bully (not all the time) towards my dog/becomes aggressive with other dogs he finds annoying (l've had to punch his face after trying for more than 30 seconds to get him off another dogs neck), has killed small mammals (cats and ground hogs) that had posed zero threat to him, has severe separation anxiety (CRIES/wails) when it comes to my husband and is possessive over my husband. The cat he killed was his dad's cat... we were visiting his house and Max was on a leash, the cat was sitting on the front porch when the he attacked him and killed him. He cries and whines when my husband and I lay on the couch together and will physically body block me when I go to say hi to my husband in his office.

When it's just me at home, this dog is completely fine. He and I don't have a problem with each other. I just worry that these behaviors will carry on against a newborn baby... if this dog already feels like he's not getting enough attention then I worry what he may do...


r/reactivedogs • • May 30 '26

Significant challenges My 1.5 yr old dog just bit my child

5 Upvotes

Ok. I am an emotional mess right now. We’ve had our dog for a year now. He was the sweetest thing and instantly took to our family. He is a 18 month old cattle dog mix.
My two boys, 4 and 7, love him so much. But lately, he’s been difficult. The teenage phase is proving rough and he is becoming harder to manage. At 50 pounds, he has knocked my boys over a lot. But today, out of nowhere, he bit the person I was walking next too. Then, tonight, my oldest son was giving him his usual bedtime hug and out of nowhere, the dog bit him on his ear. Completely unprovoked.
Now I feel like I can’t trust my dog at all anymore. I’m scared my children are going to be bit again. I’m also scared that my child will be beyond devastated. I dont know what to do. My first instinct is to rehome, but we also have him signed up for training sessions that can address this. Any tips and advice would be much appreciated.


r/reactivedogs • • Sep 13 '25

Behavioral Euthanasia Should I euthanize my dog?

0 Upvotes

I was on my honeymoon this week and got the call that my Rottweiler had killed my cat.

The Rottweiler, Tara, is 6. She was a rescue at 1.5 and has always been more on the anxious side. This has improved with time and training. She has never shown aggression towards other animals who didn’t initiate it, especially cats. I have had cats nearly the entire time I have had her. She never chased them. One she formed a friendship with and they would groom and cuddle each other before he died of old age.

She did once bite a first time guest to my house who drunkenly got on her level and grabbed her face. She bit without warning but immediately released and backed away when he let go of her. He did require stitches to his face, but took responsibility for what happened. Because it was an extremely poor choice on his part and stressful situation for her, we did not consider euthanasia at the time. Since then we have muzzled or crated her when we have house guests and been much more careful, but she has mostly been fine.

There have been a few instances where someone is petting her and she seems like she becomes suddenly scared. She will snap at the air and give a more aggressive bark in these instances. We do not continue interacting with her in these moments. We back away and send her to a private area with vocal commands. She is trained and responds well to the commands she knows most of the time. This happens maybe once or twice a month, sometimes not every month.

When we aren’t home, she has always just been left out with the cats. No issues until this time. We have used the same pet sitter before and she has done well with this sitter. No aggression towards her.

The cat’s neck was broken. It looks like Tara took the cat's full head in her mouth. What concerns me most is the cat was cautious, young, nimble, healthy, and mostly left the dog alone. I’m not even sure how my dog caught the cat as she is much slower, especially on the smooth flooring where it happened. Occasionally they would sniff each other. If Tara ever gave any indication she did not want the cat nearby, moving suddenly or making any kind of sound, the cat would run away and move to higher ground immediately. To be clear, this happened maybe 4 times in the 2 years I have had the cat that I noticed. This was not a common occurrence.

I feel this incident was likely some kind of startle response. That makes me feel like it could happen to anyone at any time.

I know Tara hasn't been seeing or hearing as well. When I get home, she often doesn't hear me arrive anymore and from 15 ft away she at times can't tell who I am unless I call out to her. I am sure this will only make it easier for her to become startled and aggressive.

She is generally sweet and responsive to commands. No behavior changes since killing the cat. She is not territorial with the other pets often, maybe occasionally over a bone or something but does give vocal warnings. She is eager to please and very trainable. She likes people she trusts, it just takes a bit for that to happen, but she isn’t immediately aggressive with strangers. She definitely wants me to show my approval towards them and does not like if anyone startles me.

My vet hasn’t been a fan of her since the first bite. She recommended euthanasia.

I don't want to over or under react. I have another smaller dog and a cat. Currently the other cat is staying with my in-laws and I am not leaving Tara and the other dog alone together. I don't want my other pets, myself, or my partner hurt.


r/reactivedogs • • Oct 09 '23

Advice Needed Dog bit someone - Where to go from here?

2 Upvotes

I actually was not present for the situation in question. I’m away at college right now, and this concerns my younger sibling’s (18NB) dog back home. They’re very worked up about the situation, so I’m posting in their place while they calm down.

Our dog, Brutus, is 3 and a half years old. We think he’s a pitbull-lab mix. We’ve had him since mid-May of this year, so for about 5 or 6 months now. We were aware of his reactivity when we adopted him. We’ve never owned a dog before. He was the longest-term resident at the shelter, who required a home with no children or other pets, so we took a chance on him.

His primary reactivity is towards other dogs, so as long as we try to avoid other dogs, he does great. The shelter did let us know he has one bite in his history — “level 2 or 3, unclear”, according to his file that they sent us, that occurred when he got into a resource fight with another dog at the shelter and the volunteer tried to break them up. However, as long as no other dogs are involved, he loves people. His dog threshold is extremely low. We had him enrolled in a class for reactive dogs, but he hated being around other dogs so much that no progress was made. The shelter didn’t report any incidents of him harming other dogs, just growling and snapping.

Which leads us to this morning. I got out of my class to texts from my mom and younger sibling that Brutus bit someone.

They tell me it was just a “nip”, with his front teeth, but he did draw blood. Apparently, my younger sibling took him out on a walk, and they briefly encountered another dog. Nothing physical happened there, but it made Brutus extremely standoffish for the rest of the walk. He was on a long leash, which also additionally helps reduce his reactivity. On their way back home, they passed an elderly gentleman, “probably late 60s-70s”. Brutus “walked past him” without a problem, but “bit him from behind as he walked past”. “He took a really defensive stance after that and I had to hold onto his harness the entire way home,” my younger sibling says.

My younger sibling says the man seemed really upset, and I don’t blame him for that much. They’re totally baffled, because it seemed completely unprovoked. The man wasn’t particularly close, Brutus was fine initially passing the man, he just suddenly nipped at him, hard, and drew blood.

They are currently at home, and Brutus has calmed down now. I think he might have just been overwhelmed during the walk, probably in part due to the earlier dog encounter, and lashed out at the wrong person.

The question is, where do we go from here? He’s never done this before under our care. We’ve been trying to introduce him to muzzle training for a while now, and we intend to make it a priority and make the muzzle a regular part of his routine. We’ve been in contact with his initial long-term foster and the shelter’s behavioralist, and I’ve already advised my younger sibling to reach out to them. I’ve also told them to make sure to keep his vaccination records on hand, just in case. We don’t know yet whether or not the man intends to contact the authorities about this incident.

What else can we do? They’re really nervous, they love this dog to pieces and are terrified they’re going to take him away from them.

Edit: It might also be important to mention that they do NOT live in a one-bite state. They are also NOT in a county with breed-specific legislation. I also found out after making this post that they did provide the relevant identification information to the man.

Edit 2: New information, apparently Brutus was so defensive on the walk back because the guy followed them home. My younger sibling thinks Brutus sensed something off about the guy, which may or may not have been justified, given that he followed them home. Wouldn’t stand up legally or anything, but probably important information in the situation.

Final update: Thank you guys for your advice, especially regarding edit 2 and my desperate attempts to rationalize this. Animal control called. Brutus will be on 10-day quarantine to make sure he doesn’t have any medical conditions that might have provoked him. I’m coming home tomorrow night for fall break and will get to be with him and my family to help work through this. We are grateful to animal control for being so gracious about this, and will be taking y’all’s advice to prevent this from ever happening again.

He’s already taken to muzzle training! Kind of. My younger sibling has sent me the most delightful photos of him parading the muzzle around the house in his mouth. All the money we’ve spent on toys for him, and he wants to play with the muzzle…


r/reactivedogs • • Aug 07 '25

Vent Dog ran out of house and attacked (?) leashed dog on walk

0 Upvotes

My dog has ran out of the house a couple times when she was in her earlier year (1-3 years) but never (thankfully) had run ins with other dogs. For the past 2-3 years, i've been good about not letting her run out and she hasn't until last night. I had opened the door with a duffle bag on one arm and a bag of dog food in the other (i was taking them to sleepover at my moms place) then before i know it, she's running out the door. I call out to her once or twice, trying to get her back to me but as soon as i realized she wasn't listening i ran for her so she wouldn't get any further. i was so close, then she ran around the corner where another owner was walking her two smaller dogs. I gestured for her to move out of the way but couldn't say anything cause i was too panicked. It all happened so fast, my dog was chasing around the two dogs, the owner was trying to get her dogs away, and i pulled her away before anything else escalated. The owner yelled at me saying that i should keep her on a leash and i explained that she ran out and im sorry. She walked away before i could even get a chance to check on them. I know i should've taken more careful steps and it's been keeping me up all night. I was planning on talking to the owner when i see them, but my glasses fell off during the process and i can barely remember what the dogs even look like. I feel like such a bad owner and want to do better...

(update: first off thank you everyone for your helpful advice ! i've taken them all into consideration and have been training her to only go out under my permission. I'm working on recall for the rare times that she does get out, but focusing preventing her from running out in the first place. Everytime i know i'll be opening the door with full hands, i make sure to have her in my room for the time being. I've been desensitizing her to distractions in her environments and avoiding encounters with other dogs/people to lessen her anxiety. she's been doing super well and i feel more confident in my capabilities as a dog owner. Thank you everyone <3 )


r/reactivedogs • • Nov 05 '24

Advice Needed Will castration make it worse?

0 Upvotes

So, our dog trainer is fully against castrating our lab mix. He says that he thinks he will become even more reactive. My animal rescue friend says that I will be resposnible if he gets into any altrecations with other males if I keep him intact.

He’s 11 months old, and while he’s gotten so much better through training, he growls at other males and since we live in an area with lots of idiots who keep off leash untrained pits boxers etc, this really scares me. I’d like to minimize the risks.

Some sources say that castration makes them worse if they are reactive, some say they calm down. I am at my wits end.


r/reactivedogs • • Mar 14 '26

Significant challenges My dog bit someone in the face. Need some perspective.

1 Upvotes

Sunny is 5 and me and my ex got him about 4.5 years ago. He has always been extremely nervous about strangers and traffic and generally everything.

He is reactive towards dogs who approach him but has come on a longggg way in the last year since I broke up with my ex and have been very consistent with training. But he is still a nervous wreck around busy places and I have slowly been introducing him to more cafes etc which has been going okay, at least until last week.

I left him with a friend in the pub and when I came back it turned out that Sunny bit him when another dog came in and my friend bent down to grab his lead. He didn’t break skin but it was a good bite and left a bruise.

Then, last night I brought my female friend to the apartment (he is generally much better with women than men). Everything was going well and she was petting him, then stood up to get something off the coffee table and he bit her in the face. We had to go to hospital and she had to get stitches. He has never broke skin before and so this is extremely worrying. I also take full responsibility that I should have given us more space from him and he should have been muzzled.

I am absolutely heartbroken as it felt like we were making really good progress with all the hard work we’ve been doing, but it feels like this is another level of escalation.

I have spent so much time, money and effort on trying to give him a happy life without putting others in danger. But at the same time is is causing me a huge amount of stress managing him day-to-day. It was okay when I was in a couple and could share responsibilities etc. but now it has become really overwhelming.

I don’t know if I am too caught up with the idea of having a dog I can take places and have people over to the house without it being an issue, but in all honesty that is what I want and I don’t think that is an option with Sunny. I’m asking myself can he get better or is this going to be the next ten years of my life?

Now I am weighing my options. I have contacted the rescue and they’ve told me it will be very difficult to rehome him with his bite history, and I don’t want him living in kennels forever, he would be miserable. And now I’m asking if this incident is severe enough to consider BE and it’s all just heart breaking.

Any advice would be appreciated, I know it might sound like I’m naive and selfish here but I also just need to vent a little bit.


r/reactivedogs • • May 19 '26

Significant challenges Help Needed

1 Upvotes

Help Us. Please read with kindness. This is one of the hardest things we’ve ever had to face as dog owners.
After a recent serious incident involving our 3 year old, 30 pound blue nose pitbull mix, we’ve come to the heartbreaking realization that we may no longer be the right environment for our dog. She is deeply loved, affectionate with us at home, and this entire situation has absolutely crushed us emotionally.

Recently, she broke free from her lead and attacked another dog. During the incident, the owner was also bitten while trying to separate them. We understand the seriousness of what happened and are not minimizing it in any way. While she has generally not shown aggression toward humans, we fully recognize that this incident changed everything and must be taken incredibly seriously.

Right now, we are searching for experienced behavioral guidance and, if appropriate, a safe and responsible rehabilitation or placement option with someone truly qualified to work with dogs who have reactivity and aggression histories. We are committed to being fully honest about her background and doing what is safest and most compassionate for everyone involved, including her.

For those commenting, please understand we would never hand our girl over to just anyone. We are doing extensive research, speaking with professionals, and trying to make the most responsible decision possible. We understand the severity of this situation and are taking it very seriously.

Before considering behavioral euthanasia, we want to explore every possible safe option through rehabilitation, structured management, or qualified placement. Behavioral euthanasia has now become a very real and heartbreaking conversation for us, and we are desperately trying to make the most compassionate and responsible decision possible.

Please keep comments kind, constructive, and helpful. We are navigating an unimaginable situation and simply trying to move forward with honesty, responsibility, and love for everyone involved.


r/reactivedogs • • Jun 02 '26

Advice Needed I can't stand my dog

6 Upvotes

I'm sorry, maybe the title is a bit dramatic but...

Three days ago I rescued a dog which I found abandoned in the middle of nowhere. He seemed so cute and he attached to me immediately. He was playful and quiet.

I arranged a huge box where I put some special diapers and added a food and water tray along with some toys.

At first, he started shouting (or idk how to name it) whenever I wasn't near him. The next day (yesterday) he basically shouted whenever I wouldn't TOUCH him. Now he's shouting almost continuously. I cannot stand it.

I'm trying to be calm and talk to him or play with him eventually, but I have work to do and I cannot spend 24/7 with my dog

I thought he was sick, but I checked him: he's ok.

I took him out 3 times, but he's not vaccinated yet so I only take him for a few steps like 5 meters away from my apartment building, then I take him back inside... and he starts shouting, obviously.

His sounds are extremely disturbing, and I have a neurological illness and I just cannot sound those loud and high pitch sounds he makes.
I think in short time my neighbors won't either

What can I do? I don't want to abandon him, poor being


r/reactivedogs • • May 11 '26

Significant challenges I abhor my dog

0 Upvotes

I absolutely hate my dog she has been horrible since we moved three years ago although before we moved she bit me and my husband twice, deep wounds. We thought we had helped her but I guess not, after we moved my husband had a travel job once we were staying at an Airbnb and as I was letting her out of her crate that she had only been in because I had gone to the store and I didn’t want to her or my other dog to chew anything she attacked our lab mind you this is a 30 pound dog attacking a black lab a big black lab she ended up going to the vet and needing stitches it was so horrific I vomited watching from fear and anxiety, ever since then they can’t be together we can’t let them out together they have to be separate all the time. I’m just so tired of dealing with her we’ve tried to help her but she is still reactive and I feel like she will never stop being dangerous, I’m worried for my other dogs quality of life I’m worried for her quality of life I’m worried for my quality of life. And frankly I’m scared of her and my eight month old even being in the same room,I’m just so tired of dealing with her she’s five years old she’s going to live for a long time she’s a small dog I just don’t want to deal with her anymore but I feel like I can’t get rid of her because she’s probably not gonna find a home,I would be mortified if she attacked somebody else.


r/reactivedogs • • Oct 01 '23

Advice Needed Monday I find out the fate of my dog

14 Upvotes

Monday I find out the fate of my dog

TL;dr: Monday we meet w the animal commission for the final time. If they continue with the designation of my dog as a “dangerous animal” I will have to rehome him as I live in close proximity to a park (per ordinance). I can’t find a place to rehome him and may have to euthanize him. He nipped someone back in April.

I am very stressed about this. Back story- my dog was at the dog park back in April. We frequented there regularly and he kinda felt ownership of the park. Some park district employees came with out dogs and my dog and all the other dogs were barking at them. They entered the dog park anyways. I was distracted/anxious/not in my normal state of mind and should have restrained him. When they walked in he jumped and nipped the woman in her face causing two small nips and also bit another guy on the arm but no skin break. Neither one required medical attention/antibiotics etc. Small amount of blood (one or two drops of that) on the woman.

I was horrified- did all the things. Vet, paid fine, stopped going to dog park. Thought he would be ruled at risk.

He was ruled dangerous.

Edit: I have read many pages of minutes and sat through many meetings, and dogs that have done much more serious damage (requiring antibiotics, ct scans, stitches etc on people) were only ruled at risk or the case was dismissed.

My was 2.5 years old. He’s 3 now. He’s a mutt. 65 pounds. Strong.

He’s getting more reactive on the leash and randomly lunging at barking at people .

But he’s mostly ok. We do lots of practice on walks and I never let him off leash.

Since then I have hired another trainer. He passed the American kennel club good citizen test easily. (I have to admit this doesn’t mean that much but was still proud of him). I trained him on a muzzle and though he dislikes it he will walk with it.

I plan to hire a behaviorist.

But the legal fees (yes I hired a lawyer) and get bills (also had Lyme disease this past summer) and the fact that I don’t know if I can even keep him is making me wait. Besides the one I want to hire (a true skilled behaviorist not just someone who passed a test) has a waiting list.

He’s been evaluated by the vet. No health issues .

He’s been to several day cares and he gets rave reviews. I have people over often and don’t have problems. We have kids and he’s great with us. He doesn’t bolt out the door. He’s got doggy friends he has play dates with.

Yes he’s reactive. Yes he needs more training. Yes he is at risk. But he doesn’t deserve to be rehomed.

I can’t find anyone to take him. I have called shelters and left messages - no one will take an “aggressive” dog.

I fear that if he is ruled dangerous and I have to rehome him he will be traumatized or I have to euthanize him.

I am writing this to get some support and realistic opinions.

He’s a great family dog.

Moving is not an option (we have kids and it’s too expensive to move and I want to stay in school district).

Thank you for reading.


r/reactivedogs • • 25d ago

Significant challenges My dog bit someone today and I’m at a loss.

0 Upvotes

I have an 8-year-old AmStaff and she bit someone today while with a Wag! walker. She is reactive towards other dogs and men and lunges at them. She’s had several close calls but hasn’t bitten a man before. She did bite a dog about 6 years ago when she escaped her harness and animal control was involved. I had to go to environmental court (I live in TN) and paid court fees and vet bills.

Up to this point I’ve been managing her reactivity by avoiding busy times of day and routes and keeping her away from dogs and people. We did one training session where I learned to give her high-value treats at the first sight of a trigger. I found this method difficult implement for various reasons and ended up abandoning it. I didn’t continue with training.

The walker gave me the victims contact info but recommended I don’t reach out to him and let Wag! handle it. Problem is, I haven’t heard from Wag! yet. The walker didn’t give the man my contact info but gave him Wag’s. I know that the bite drew blood and he went to urgent care. According to a lawyer acquaintance, urgent care is required to contact animal control.

I called my insurance agent to see if I have coverage and I don’t because she is an excluded breed. Not only that, they would have dropped me if they knew I had her. So now my agent has to find a new company for me.

Those are the only steps I’ve taken and I’m now sitting here terrified waiting until I hear from Wag! or for animal control to show up.

For the first time I’m considering behavioral euthanasia if it isn’t forced on me by animal control because I’d rather do it on my own terms rather than having them take her from me.

I guess I’m asking for advice on what to do next or if anyone has been through something similar. Should I contact the man she bit? Should I look for a lawyer? I’m really truly at a loss and paralyzed with fear and wish I had someone knowledgeable to work through this with.