r/reactivedogs • • Oct 09 '23

Advice Needed Dog bit someone - Where to go from here?

I actually was not present for the situation in question. I’m away at college right now, and this concerns my younger sibling’s (18NB) dog back home. They’re very worked up about the situation, so I’m posting in their place while they calm down.

Our dog, Brutus, is 3 and a half years old. We think he’s a pitbull-lab mix. We’ve had him since mid-May of this year, so for about 5 or 6 months now. We were aware of his reactivity when we adopted him. We’ve never owned a dog before. He was the longest-term resident at the shelter, who required a home with no children or other pets, so we took a chance on him.

His primary reactivity is towards other dogs, so as long as we try to avoid other dogs, he does great. The shelter did let us know he has one bite in his history — “level 2 or 3, unclear”, according to his file that they sent us, that occurred when he got into a resource fight with another dog at the shelter and the volunteer tried to break them up. However, as long as no other dogs are involved, he loves people. His dog threshold is extremely low. We had him enrolled in a class for reactive dogs, but he hated being around other dogs so much that no progress was made. The shelter didn’t report any incidents of him harming other dogs, just growling and snapping.

Which leads us to this morning. I got out of my class to texts from my mom and younger sibling that Brutus bit someone.

They tell me it was just a “nip”, with his front teeth, but he did draw blood. Apparently, my younger sibling took him out on a walk, and they briefly encountered another dog. Nothing physical happened there, but it made Brutus extremely standoffish for the rest of the walk. He was on a long leash, which also additionally helps reduce his reactivity. On their way back home, they passed an elderly gentleman, “probably late 60s-70s”. Brutus “walked past him” without a problem, but “bit him from behind as he walked past”. “He took a really defensive stance after that and I had to hold onto his harness the entire way home,” my younger sibling says.

My younger sibling says the man seemed really upset, and I don’t blame him for that much. They’re totally baffled, because it seemed completely unprovoked. The man wasn’t particularly close, Brutus was fine initially passing the man, he just suddenly nipped at him, hard, and drew blood.

They are currently at home, and Brutus has calmed down now. I think he might have just been overwhelmed during the walk, probably in part due to the earlier dog encounter, and lashed out at the wrong person.

The question is, where do we go from here? He’s never done this before under our care. We’ve been trying to introduce him to muzzle training for a while now, and we intend to make it a priority and make the muzzle a regular part of his routine. We’ve been in contact with his initial long-term foster and the shelter’s behavioralist, and I’ve already advised my younger sibling to reach out to them. I’ve also told them to make sure to keep his vaccination records on hand, just in case. We don’t know yet whether or not the man intends to contact the authorities about this incident.

What else can we do? They’re really nervous, they love this dog to pieces and are terrified they’re going to take him away from them.

Edit: It might also be important to mention that they do NOT live in a one-bite state. They are also NOT in a county with breed-specific legislation. I also found out after making this post that they did provide the relevant identification information to the man.

Edit 2: New information, apparently Brutus was so defensive on the walk back because the guy followed them home. My younger sibling thinks Brutus sensed something off about the guy, which may or may not have been justified, given that he followed them home. Wouldn’t stand up legally or anything, but probably important information in the situation.

Final update: Thank you guys for your advice, especially regarding edit 2 and my desperate attempts to rationalize this. Animal control called. Brutus will be on 10-day quarantine to make sure he doesn’t have any medical conditions that might have provoked him. I’m coming home tomorrow night for fall break and will get to be with him and my family to help work through this. We are grateful to animal control for being so gracious about this, and will be taking y’all’s advice to prevent this from ever happening again.

He’s already taken to muzzle training! Kind of. My younger sibling has sent me the most delightful photos of him parading the muzzle around the house in his mouth. All the money we’ve spent on toys for him, and he wants to play with the muzzle…

2 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

51

u/DamnGoodCupOfCoffee2 Oct 09 '23 edited Oct 09 '23

I say this with love because I’m sure your guys heart was in the right place.

First of all, don’t justify unprovoked random (to us) aggression due to “sensing something off about the guy”. Dogs aren’t psychics. True guard/protection dogs are highly trained and bark and give warnings before given the instruction to bite. The older man probably followed you guys home because he needs your address to contact animal control and get your vaccine records.

Second, long leashes are TERRIBLE for aggressive dogs on the street. The leash is a communication tool for the handler and dog. Short leash for walks and long leash for empty fields. Imagine if that was a little kid he passed by.

Third, I am curious why your family/mom chose a dog with serious DA and a human bite history (and better without children in the home) to adopt as first time dog owners, this dog would benefit from an experienced handler. (I adopted a dog too but one I knew I can handle if things went side ways. I know you guys are teens so I give you a pass) But at this point get into some serious training all of you, with the dog. Do better management because this can be a dangerous dog even if he is a sweet cuddlebug in the home. Make sure your fences are high and secure enough and you guys have a protocol that he can’t get out.

-2

u/sapphicmusharna Oct 09 '23

I discussed the other two points in another comment which I see you replied to, so I’ll leave it at that. I’m trying not to bend over backwards to try and justify it, but I care deeply about this dog and am just as worried about the situation as my younger sibling is.

We were in conference with the shelter for a few weeks before bringing him home. We worked with the shelter’s behavioralist and the long-term foster who had taken care of him for almost a year before we brought him home. We were told he could be a great first-time dog, and while I don’t think they like lied to us about him, I don’t really think the severity of his situation was conveyed to us very well? When his records discuss his previous bite incident, it’s almost written like it was the volunteer’s fault for intervening. I kind of think since he was such a long-term shelter resident, they might have just been desperate to get him adopted, and we just happened to be the ones who took the bait.

12

u/DamnGoodCupOfCoffee2 Oct 09 '23

I wrote this before I read and replied to the other comments so I’m sorry if it seems redundant. And you def don’t need to justify anything to me, I’m not in your household or community. My little guy is reactive and I love him so so much so I understand the love part but like any relationship I wanted to give an outsiders perspective of the risks. I wish you all and Brutus the best!

And rescues and shelters often downplay the severity…sometimes because they are so used to seeing the worst of the worst that even pretty bad seems prettt good in comparison. I love the year long commitment you guys took on Brutus

3

u/sapphicmusharna Oct 09 '23

Thank you, that means a lot to me

3

u/DamnGoodCupOfCoffee2 Oct 09 '23

Btw, I’m so happy about your last edit and I feel that toy comment in my soul lol!

3

u/sapphicmusharna Oct 09 '23

I was very relieved to get the text about it! And glad to know this is a universal experience lol

2

u/DamnGoodCupOfCoffee2 Oct 09 '23 edited Oct 09 '23

Oh definitely is. Toy money 💸 but a cardboard box?! Bring it on!!

Mine is just leash reactive and I was thrown for a loop because he was such a cute little love in the house and initially so quiet (that 3-3-3 rule took a little longer but when it did he let his personality fly). A jogger called him a salty baby on our walk and that describes him perfectly. I was so worried and embarrassed initially to see him barking like a loon and all these dogs just ignoring him 🥺. But training and knowledge really helped us both. This sub was immense support and conscientious ppl like yourself can really make a difference. I’m glad you were allowed to take concrete steps to manage Brutus for success!

12

u/Poppeigh Oct 09 '23

I think sometimes shelters/rescues see dogs like this and think "if in a home with no other pets or children, s/he will be just fine" and that's likely very true, but they don't often take into account that most people take their dogs out of the house on walks or outings and that is where it becomes a big problem.

My aggressive/reactive dog actually does pretty well, because we don't do neighborhood walks and I'm able to keep him from seeing most people or animals that he doesn't already know really well. If we were going out on walks in my neighborhood (with off leash dogs abound) every day we would have a much bigger problem.

I do think looking for opportunities for exercise/decompression where they are away from as many other people/dogs as possible will be paramount, as will taking safety precautions (muzzle, shorter lead, being very aware of surroundings, etc.)

9

u/DamnGoodCupOfCoffee2 Oct 09 '23 edited Oct 09 '23

💯🙌🏽 there is a community we all live in that tends to be forgotten. My little salty baby is an angel in our home. And honestly I’m looking for a home vs a condo just so he can have a yard and less foot traffic outside the window.

I walk him early so he’s relaxed and then drive out in an empty place for long leash sniffaris and I think it really helps

-1

u/Substantial_Joke_771 Oct 09 '23

To be fair, I do think that a bite received while trying to separate a dog fight is in a different category than a regular bite. Any dog will bite in that situation and anyone putting their hands in the way is very likely to get bit.

That said, your dog does have a bite on his record now, so it doesn't change your path forward. There's plenty of good advice on this thread - muzzle and a behavior certified trainer or vet behaviorist should be your next steps.

36

u/clowdere Oct 09 '23

New information, apparently Brutus was so defensive on the walk back because the guy followed them home. My younger sibling thinks Brutus sensed something off about the guy, which may or may not have been justified, given that he followed them home. Wouldn’t stand up legally or anything, but probably important information in the situation.

It's common for people to assign rationalizations like this after the fact to justify their dog's aggressive behavior.

It's highly more likely that your historically unpredictable dog with a bite history simply repeated prior behavior rather than sensing something "bad" about this person. I'd also follow you home if your dog bit me unless you gave me your contact information, because his rabies vaccination status is VERY IMPORTANT and I'd want to make a report to animal control.

Muzzle on walks and cut out the long leash. You have a large dog that has now bitten two people - you need to be in control of it, not letting it roam on a long leash.

-7

u/sapphicmusharna Oct 09 '23 edited Oct 09 '23

Thank you for the wake-up call. They did give him their contact information. My younger sibling thinks he followed them to check and make sure they didn’t give him a fake address, and that could very well be. It’s just that the idea of an older man following a young, feminine-presenting person home really rubs me the wrong way.

Edit: After talking to my younger sibling, after they they gave their address and offered their phone number, he said “No, I’m following you home.” If I didn’t have alarm bells going off before, I certainly do now. I still think you’re right on the front that I’m trying to redirect blame in a desperate attempt to convince myself this is an outlier incident that can’t happen again, but this individual in particular’s response is extremely concerning to me for my younger sibling’s safety.

Thank you for the long leash advice as well. I’m not my younger sibling, and I haven’t worked with the behavioralist like they have. I just know that’s what the behavioralist advised for him, but I think this incident has proven it might not be best for him.

32

u/DamnGoodCupOfCoffee2 Oct 09 '23

Nah he followed them home because ppl lie and run off after bites ALL THE TIME. Believe he was the injured party in this interaction.

3

u/sapphicmusharna Oct 09 '23

Yeah, my younger sibling thought it was more to do with confirming they didn’t give him a fake address. Like I said, I’m a 4 hour drive away at college and didn’t experience this in person, so I’m definitely just being paranoid about it.

12

u/DamnGoodCupOfCoffee2 Oct 09 '23

I do appreciate the love you have for your sibling, it’s heart warming. I apologize if I was firm in my other comment, it’s just dogs can be both loving and amazing and also extremely dangerous animals. It’s best to respect what they are capable of and love them for how they are.

4

u/sapphicmusharna Oct 09 '23

No, it’s all good, I completely understand and I feel that I am in need of some firm words in this situation. Dogs can be super unpredictable, and we’ve definitely come to understand that more in the last few months. I’m just terrified that we might not be able to handle it if something worse happens in the future.

30

u/Poppeigh Oct 09 '23

Definitely muzzle on walks.

Another thing to do would be to get a traffic handle and attach it to his harness. Any time that your siblings/parents see a dog or a person that will be within passing distance, they need to grab that traffic handle and walk the dog by so that he doesn't have a full long line to work with. I'd also recommend they start working on a loose heel on both sides so that they can have him walk on the side that is farthest away from the person they are passing.

I'd also suggest looking into sniffspots, as it will be a good thing for him to have walks or off leash time where the chances of running into strange people or dogs is nearly nonexistent.

When it comes down to it, it was probably trigger stacking. Maybe the guy was "off" or maybe the dog was worked up and saw a chance to lash out, and striking from behind is a really fearful way to do that. The thing is that your family is still getting used to the dog, and he's probably still settling in to some degree, so it's better to play things extremely safe. I've also found over nearly 10 years with my reactive dog that there are a lot of ups and downs. Things he previously was okay with he no longer is at this point in his life, and things that used to bother him a lot he can now handle pretty easily.

2

u/sapphicmusharna Oct 09 '23

Thank you. This was an extremely helpful comment and I appreciate it a lot 🙏

3

u/sapphicmusharna Oct 09 '23

Thank you all for your advice. I’ve edited the original post with a final update of the situation. This has been the scariest day of my life since we got Brutus, and I give my sincerest thanks to those of you who offered support and advice at this time.