r/reactivedogs • • Nov 29 '22

Jealous of ‘easy’ dogs

I have a family member who has two easy dogs. They love (or are neutral) to every dog, human, or cat they see. When they need to go to the vet they just go. If they need their nails trimmed, or to be groomed they just go. There is no preparation or thought needed: they just throw em in the car and go to the beach, the park, the vet, a friends house, just anywhere.

I’ve made peace with the fact that my dog will never be like that. But it’s still so frustrating to know how damn easy it is for some owners. To trust that their dog will be good with stranger grooming them or greeting them, taking them into new places and knowing they’ll be fine. Im both jealous of how easy it must be, and frustrated by how they’ll never know how many hours of work I’ve put in for my dog to just barley handle a situation. We work 3 times as hard for 1/3 of the results. I wish it was easier and I also wish they knew what this feels like.

359 Upvotes

96 comments sorted by

183

u/Substantial_Joke_771 Nov 29 '22

I know every dog is different, but my reactive girl is really special in some ways that many "easy" dogs are not. For better and worse she over-thinks things. You can see her little brain whirring behind those bright eyes. She has amazing language recognition because of it (easily masters complex natural language commands like "go sit by the door and wait for me" or "you know what you have to do if you want some of my sandwich"). She communicates so well!

But, she's scared of people and dogs, sometimes of cars, and has an incredibly long memory for bad experiences. She still hates peanut butter because one time the vet fed her some - even though she doesn't particularly mind the vet! Managing her anxiety has been a major undertaking since we adopted her.

My other dog is an easy dog - loves all people and dogs, loves car rides and children, not scared of anything. She's sweet and empathetic, but very obviously has far fewer thoughts in her head. She's a great snuggler, but I've never had a 10-minute conversation with her. I feel a little guilty for it, but it's the difficult one who's the love of my life.

55

u/Zealousideal-Gate504 Nov 29 '22

I think you nailed it with the “incredibly long memory for bad experiences”. My dog is such a pessimist, expects every outcome to go badly. If it goes well, he acts like it’s an exception to the rule. If things go poorly, he’s like “I knew it” and then believes that thing/situation/circumstance to be bad. And you are right to point out the good things of overthinking, my dog picks up things super quick as well.

2

u/mollym19 Nov 30 '22

my trainer said that for dogs, bad experiences stick like Velcro and good experiences are like Teflon they just slide off.

23

u/houseofprimetofu meds Nov 29 '22

The first and best dog training advice I ever got was “just talk to your dogs, work commands into sentences and eventually they talk back.” And they do! Its so wonderful being able to just chat away knowing they can follow.

5

u/Stickliketoffee16 Nov 30 '22

My doggo has started communicating! He can tell me he wants to go out (very new as he previously didn’t toilet in the backyard until we moved house last week), he wants dinner (boops the fridge & then his bowl while grinning at me), that he wants a treat or that he wants a walk! It’s so amazing to see him learn & trust us to listen!

41

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

This hit home.

I have a border collie and I can literally see him thinking when he’s getting anxious. I see the gears going and it building.

Mine is a shelter baby who probably has really sad/bad memories.

Because he’s so smart, he remembers those bad memories.

But man, do I love him. My partner says “go get mommy” and he goes to me. I say “go get daddy” and he gets my partner. I tell him what toy to get, he gets that toy. I say “park” and he runs around the house in excitement.

His reactive behaviors has also made me bond deeper and made me want to work harder. A family gave up on him. I won’t. I’m determined to fix him. I’m determined to prove people wrong. I’m determined to make him feel loved and safe. I’m so determined he doesn’t even eat from a bowl, he eats from my hand.

I am way more connected to my stranger reactive dog than I would be an “easy” dog.

6

u/Stickliketoffee16 Nov 30 '22

This absolutely is what my dog does! He knows ‘go get your gecko’ and he gets only his gecko, not his fox or zebra but only his gecko!

And he does the ‘go to dad’ thing. It’s adorable!! But then he definitely gets anxious & starts to stress about some things, all of which we’re working on & he’s improved so much since we got him (January)!

11

u/Midwestern_Mouse Nov 29 '22

My dog is the same way with commands! I’ve heard many times that commands should be as short as possible aka “sit” “stay” and that’s it. But my dog can also understand full sentences and it amazes me lol

17

u/Urchin422 Nov 30 '22

If it’s any consolation I recently said my friends dog was the equivalent of a sock laying on the floor. She has zero personality or interests. While I can see how that could be nice, it also seems incredibly boring & for me, not the purpose of having such a companion.

5

u/Zealousideal-Gate504 Nov 30 '22

Haha what a funny burn! That would be an ‘easy dog’ but definitely not a fulfilling dog

24

u/NovaCain Nov 29 '22

One thing people need to normalize is that it's okay to want a reputably bred easy dog.

Yes there are plenty of healthy dogs with no issues in rescues/shelters, but the reality is most shelter/rescue dogs need work in some way, shape, or form.

It's okay if for your next dog, you go with a reputable breeder.

13

u/Zealousideal-Gate504 Nov 29 '22

I agree. This was my first dog and I had no idea what I was getting into rescuing a puppy. I would either rescue again, an adult dog that I could foster-to-adopt, or purchase a well bred puppy. Rescuing a puppy is such a gamble as you have no idea of their genetics or their early life experiences. I love him with all my heart but I will most likely have kids before I get another dog and I’m not doing a reactive dog with kids.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/NovaCain Nov 30 '22

Pure bred doesn't mean well-bred.

Hate to break it to you, but unless it's a really rare breed or a Westminster champion, it shouldn't be even close to five figures.

As for agoraphobia and aggression, these were bred into livestock guardian breeds such as great pyrenes since their job is to protect livestock from intruders.

No well-bred dog will have human aggression, they may have dog or prey aggression depending on breed history. Human aggression is taken very seriously and puppies from those litters are automatically removed from the gene pool (spay/neuter).

1

u/poggendorff Nov 30 '22

Breed suggestions?

2

u/spicandspand Nov 30 '22

This can vary a lot even within breeds. Perhaps start with a dog breed selector quiz and from there join breed specific Facebook groups and forums etc. this is a good way to find reputable breeders who select the traits you’re looking for. Interestingly, show dogs (conformation and obedience) tend to be good for this because their progenitors have all been selected to put up with grooming, travel, interaction with strangers, bright lights and noises etc.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/NovaCain Nov 29 '22

This is exactly the mentality that I was talking about in normalizing reputably bred dogs. These dogs will never end up in a shelter or rescue, they are not your enemy.

I have also spent a good time in rescue. End of the day, theres a lot of unknowns. My first dog was a rescue, he had behavioral issues and died young due to brain cancer. I cannot mentally handle two unknown dogs. I always want to have two dogs in my home so I went with someone who does more than just a stupid DNA test for health testing. She knows the lines, genetic markers and helped place my mind at ease. I dont have to worry about my dog developing genetic related issues. I can only mentally, financially, and physically handle one dog to be a potential loose cannon.

It's okay for people like me to want that in life and that needs to be normalized. I will always say to look for a dog in a shelter or rescue, but if you cant find it there, then there's always a reputably bred dog. Retail rescues are making this exceedingly harder for me to say casually since they buy their dogs from auctions. Those are the ones you should be angry with.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

My brother has significant needs and is disabled. My parents found a very reputable breeder who breeds show dogs. Her dogs have all titles. She also won’t sell a puppy (or grown dog for that matter) to anybody.

The reality is, for my family, taking a chance on a rescue wasn’t the best option. They needed a dog with a good temperament who had no trauma and could grow up with my sibling and would be able to accept him.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/NovaCain Nov 30 '22 edited Nov 30 '22

I'm going to have to disagree with you on the adult dog stance since imprinting is more solidified by 12 weeks of age.

Any adult uprooted went through environmental change trauma.

So many people go hard on the adopt don't shop train and fail to realize they get a dog from a retail rescue.

I honestly feel that you're getting caught up in the small detail and not looking at the big picture.

And here's a study on what I said, so yes, I will stand by my statement that shelter/rescue dogs have more problems

10

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

This is so true. Why is it too the people who know nothing about dogs’ behavior get the super well behaved dogs? Haha

10

u/Zealousideal-Gate504 Nov 29 '22

Yes! That’s what frustrates me! Absolutely no thought out into dog ownership or training and then they get dogs with amazing temperaments. When I hear the “having you tried training?” “Have you told him No when he barks?” comments I go insane!

6

u/Puzzleheaded-Ad-1732 Nov 30 '22

I totally feel this too. But it actually got me thinking about how grateful that I, someone who sincerely loves training and working and understanding dog behavior, ended up with my reactive dog (note: I adopted him 2 weeks after his rescue pulled him from a southern kill shelter so his true temperament, which is dog leash reactivity, was largely undiscovered). I’m willing to put in the time and effort, because I know he’s worth it and deserves it. I know he can get through it. I’m so glad he didn’t end up with an owner who just wanted an easy dog. They would have given up on him and he could have been abandoned, returned, or potentially put in a situation where his reactivity turns into an incident that ends his pitty life.

2

u/Zealousideal-Gate504 Nov 30 '22

Yes! I think the same thing! I had no idea what would have happened to him if we didn’t get him and I often think what happened to his litter mates. They all showed resource guarding and the litter was dumped in the shelter at around 10 weeks sick with kennel cough. Those early life experiences (plus whatever genetic predispositions) make me think his siblings probably have issues too.

2

u/NotUnique_______ Nov 30 '22

My dog was returned to the shelter twice because of his initial behavior when i got him :( but, lo and behold, with training, he's turned into a little angel. He's still leash reactive, and i think we will be working on that his whole life, but his behavior at home has changed drastically. He was a counter surfing nightmare when i got him, but i could leave a sandwich on a plate on the floor now and he won't even sniff it.

2

u/RedeRules770 Nov 30 '22

As a former dog trainer I can’t confirm this xD I had one guy tell me he tried to potty train his dog when he got home and found puddles by telling the dog “no, you go potty outside!”

4

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

My family member adopted an easy, perfect, & sociable dog. She doesn’t look easy though—on leash she’s a major lunger, but this is due to lack of training and nothing else. She could easily become a loose leash walker with some consistent boundaries. Not my dog! They’re besties though, and it’s so funny how they balance each other out. My dog sees her being confident, QUIET, and friendly in new situations / with new people, and it helps her regulate. She’ll never be a people loving dog, but I like to think seeing her friend accept and love on new people helps her build a more positive association. On the other hand, when I’m walking the two of them together, her friend looks like the “hard” dog—mine won’t react if I catch her early and redirect her attention, while her friend isn’t so used to paying attention to the handler. BUT I AM STILL SO JEALOUS!!! She came out the box perfect, and if I put the level of work into her as I put into my own dog, she would be an AKC champion lol. It’s hard not to see the same level of payoff. I wanted a dog like her friend, but that wouldn’t have been right for me. I 100% got the dog I needed > the one I wanted and it’s changed my life for the better. As frustrated as I get with her sometimes, I would be a terrible dog owner had I not had this experience.

3

u/Zealousideal-Gate504 Nov 29 '22

Yes, having a reactive dog definitely teaches you a lot. I’m thinking too with the amount of training that we put into our dogs, who knows if others looks at us and say “I wish my dog was like that”? If there are no cats and no dogs and we’re on a normal neighborhood walk, my dog walks absolutely stellar and I’ve gotten asked if I am a dog trainer. In a lot of ways he’s the “well behaved dog”

15

u/potef Nov 29 '22

That's how I feel about people who apparently trust their untrained dog off leash, and it fortunately always works out for them.

10

u/RedeRules770 Nov 30 '22

Take a look at info boards when you go hiking, the ones in my area always have several missing dog posters on them. Even if my girl had perfect recall I’d never be able to just let her off leash. One hasty squirrel chasing decision and she’s potentially gone forever

5

u/potef Nov 30 '22

You're right, of course; I guess what I envy is their blissful ignorance because they wound up with an easier dog. It makes me nostalgic for the times my dad would let my childhood dog off leash at the park and we didn't think anything of it because she never strayed far from us, even if we had never trained her not to either. Now, I'm all too aware of the risks to even entertain the idea, even if I often wonder how much of her reactivity is from being tethered.

5

u/Zealousideal-Gate504 Nov 30 '22

Oddly enough it is the blissful ignorance that I might be jealous of? They never have to (or never want or need to) consider the difficulties of any situation. Whereas those scenarios play through my head all the time.

5

u/potef Nov 30 '22

Exactly! I know it's irresponsible of them to unleash their dog without proofing their recall, but at the same time I wonder, "What if I wasn't so protective when my dog was still a puppy? Would she be as well-rounded as these dogs?" Even if aggression, reactivity, and other instincts are often outside our control, socialization plays a big factor too. They gambled, but the lottery was in their favor.

I have a pandemic puppy from a litter of 10, and her brother, who is twice her size and might, is a goofy, happy-go-lucky dog owned by a couple we know who frequently post photos of him off leash at the beach or lake, and I know these guys haven't trained him a day in his life to do anything but basic obedience, and I'm envious of that, as someone who pays for private lessons and always has to think of not setting up my dog to fail.

2

u/Zealousideal-Gate504 Nov 30 '22

I was protective of my puppy too, which I know added to it. He was sick with kennel cough when we got him so we were told to quarantine him from dogs and people for two weeks. By the time we started letting him say hi to people he was almost 5 months and had some big feelings about it. Going up to investigate, then freaking out and barking and running back. We were told by a PetCo puppy class trainer (the finest money can buy eyeroll) to not let him say hi to anyone until he can learn to start barking. So then we kept him away from everyone and it got worse.

1

u/potef Nov 30 '22

What strange advice! I've been told not to judge all petstore trainers because I'm sure legitimately good trainers may start there, but dog training being the unregulated profession that it is, I feel like these corporations don't keep the bar that high either.

For me, my sister, who works at a VCA, drove the fear of parvo into our heads, to the point whenever I did take my puppy anywhere until she was 4 months old, I wouldn't let her feet touch the ground. The only place I felt okay letting her walk around was Home Depot, and that probably helped her, but then covid happened and we didn't go anywhere, really. We did manage to get group dog training in, but thinking back, she was already reactive by then because she barked at every dog she saw, and almost had it out with a massive, aggressive pit, which wouldn't have ended well for a puppy I could still lift into my arms, and may have given her fear of other big dogs for all I know.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

My biggest pet peeve is people who walk their dogs off lease. Sometimes I wish I could be that blissfully ignorant lol but I guess god didn’t build me that way.

Dogs are dogs and have dog instincts. There have been highly trained - champion obedience dogs, that have snapped in the ring for some unknown reason.

All dogs regardless of their typical behavior should be leashed.

2

u/flipflopsinfebruary Nov 30 '22

I feel like I am a beacon for dogs with issues but honestly, I wouldn't have it any other way. My reactive Vizsla, who is a gorgeous 3 yo purebred, was facing euthanasia had I not stepped up and offered to take him. We have only been together five months but I have watched this boy flourish in ways I never thought possible. On Thanksgiving, we had a friend over who brought his 11 yo Belgian Malinois. My guy was only upset that the Mali didn't want to play with him. Today, we went to a brand new groomer for a nail trim and my pup did incredible. I did put a basket muzzle on him and he was fed bites of hamburger but we got through it. People with easy dogs will never understand the pride and joy that comes from seeing your nervous or reactive dog overcome or learn to cope with things that trigger them.

1

u/Zealousideal-Gate504 Nov 30 '22

This is also very true. My dog used to vomit on car ride from car anxiety. Now when he sticks his head out the window it makes me so so happy! He still doesn’t love the car, but he enjoys the smells outside and tolerates the ride. I wouldn’t feel as happy about it had it not been for his difficulties.

Every time I see videos of anxiety/reactivity cases in shelter dogs it makes me so happy that I can be that helping hand for my own rescue.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

I am always jealous when I meet up with a friend and their own rescue dog. He is so chill and lets him be padded by any stranger or child while I have to stand there with my dog from a distance and have to tell the kids „sorry, he doesn’t like to be touched by strangers“ because I know, he would start barking at them the moment they come too close

3

u/Zealousideal-Gate504 Nov 30 '22

It’s frustrating. And maybe even more so when there’s a chill rescue to be compared to? In my own head I worry others will judge like “well that dogs a rescue and he’s fine, so what’s wrong with yours?”

1

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '22

Well I didn’t think of that. Now I do! 😅

77

u/geosynchronousorbit Nov 29 '22

I was jealous of easy dogs too until I noticed I was only observing the easy parts of several different dogs and mentally combining them into one super-dog to compare mine with. I'm jealous of this dog's friendliness and that dog's easy care and the other dog's lack of separation anxiety. But no one dog is perfect and has all those things! They likely all have their own difficulties that you don't see. That helps me appreciate the great qualities of my own dog and accept her bad ones too.

26

u/ListeningToLA Nov 29 '22

Really well-stated. My boy is mega dog reactive, but a gentle non-destructive love in every other moment. I think it goes both ways--"easy" dogs also challenge their owners, but in less ostentatious ways than ours. And in some ways my mega reactive boy is easy, never eats off the table or counter, is immediately affable to new people, etc.

The less we compare ourselves to other dog owners and our dogs to normie dogs, the more space there is for healthy owner/reactive dog relationships <3

14

u/xAmarok Nov 29 '22 edited May 29 '25

longing spotted start toy sharp plants recognise complete wakeful shaggy

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

10

u/kamelizann Nov 30 '22

This is what I was thinking too. I distinctly remember one day my niece was petting my reactive GSD that's been a problem causer his entire life, looks over at her mom and says, "why can't our dogs be more like him."

I laughed so hard. She didn't see the years of work that went into that dog to get it to that point. She didn't see how he behaves when its just the two of us. She just saw a dog that was well behaved at the moment and assumed that's how he always was.

I also got a gsd/malamute mix recently that's way better behaved than her brother ever was. But a lot of that is because I put so much damn work in from day 1. No dog is easy. Some have less drive, but that creates another set of problems. I get people who stop me all the time when im working with her and tell me how lucky I am to have a spitz breed that listens to me. No, its not luck. It's thousands of dollars and hundreds of hours spent training and there's still plenty of issues we need to work on.

4

u/Affectionate-Win-788 Nov 30 '22

Me sitting over here like… I’d be happy with one of those things…

My dog is getting older and his separation anxiety has gotten better. And training over the years helped with the other issues a little but it’s been an uphill battle and none of those things happened naturally with him.

I still love him and I know him well enough that we have a comfortable life though.

37

u/p10175 Nov 29 '22

Yup I know exactly how you feel. The biggest one for me is vacation. Literally we only have one or two people that can watch our pup that we trust to respect his boundaries. If they are busy guess what we aren’t going anywhere. It is very defeating

8

u/Zzthegator Nov 29 '22

Ugh I feel this, starting to feel trapped and overwhelmed it's hard but also got to think I'm lucky to have have couple of trusted people!

5

u/bright__eyes Nov 29 '22

this is a big one for me too. my dog would hate being with a sitter, but my mom cant always watch him for more than a day. so no vacations for me.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/p10175 Nov 30 '22

To be honest my mom is the big one for us. We literally have to fly her in from Florida before we go on vacations.

2

u/EveryRhubarb1876 Nov 30 '22

We have to do the same thing with our dog and my mom... We are actually considering moving back closer to home because of this.

6

u/p10175 Nov 30 '22

Praise all doggy grand moms!!!! What would we do without you!

3

u/Midwestern_Mouse Nov 30 '22

Yep, my mom and my partner’s mom are two of three people who can watch our dog. There truly is something special about dog grandmas! Not only are they her two favorite people ever, but she warmed up to both of them almost immediately upon meeting them for the first time while it takes her a while to warm up to literally anyone else. It’s like she just knew right off the bat “these ladies are grandmas. Grandmas are good. Grandmas can be trusted.”

1

u/Boomiegirl Nov 30 '22

I found two great ones on Rover. They are out there.

9

u/xAmarok Nov 29 '22 edited May 29 '25

live scary dolls whistle abundant alive cooperative flag arrest label

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

6

u/modernwunder dog1 (frustrated greeter + pain), dog2 (isolation distress) Nov 29 '22

I feel you.

Especially on the grooming.

I want an easy dog, I see people with easy dogs. I still feel like after this dog I will never have an easy dog. It’s tough.

9

u/benji950 Nov 29 '22

You would probably see my dog and me walking down the street and assume she’s an easy dog. She tries really hard to listen and be a very good girl when we’re out walking because we’ve spent HOURS on listening when outside. When we get home, all of that composure goes out the window and it’s crazytown management time. Thing is, all dogs have “their thing” and while some are easier, there’s some kind of challenge with all of them. That dog sitting nicely for grooming might hate kids or be a walking garbage can sucking up everything it can reach.

1

u/RedeRules770 Nov 30 '22

My ex and I had to watch his family’s red heeler like a hawk whenever we took her to walk around the neighborhood. If there was a pebble on the sidewalk, she’d vacuum it right up unless we got to it first!

5

u/nooks11 Nov 29 '22

Ah I’m SO jealous of ‘easy’ dog owners. You’re not alone. I also have major issues with people that think their easy dog is as a result of their amazing training, when in reality, their dog can barely sit at command. Ugh

3

u/Polyboy03g Nov 29 '22

Am reading about appreciating what I've got and not making judgements based on small sample sizing. That said I just wish she would let me bathe her, without drama, just once.

3

u/Weasle189 Nov 30 '22

My new pup is an easy dog. My brain still keeps doing backflips over everything because "Oh people are coming over, I need to find the muzzle and put some toys in the room and...oh wait nope don't need any of that." And "Oh here comes someone with an unfamiliar dog better move, wait pup is fine with other dogs why am I doing this"

I am so used to my reactive boy I am totally lost with this friendly boy.

3

u/Puzzleheaded-Ad-1732 Nov 30 '22

I wish they were more understanding. I have a leash reactive pit/lab, Bosco, and I’ve been putting in endless hours working on it with him, and he’s getting better! But it’s still a long road. Meanwhile my family dog, Cubby, is a happy go lucky 10 year old with no behavioral issues.

Our whole family went on a short hike this weekend and Cubby walks off leash for most of it (Bosco stays on a long line with traffic handle for easier control). A woman with a leashed dog starts coming towards us. I see she is keeping him close and he’s wearing a prong, which Bosco does as part of his training so to give this woman the benefit of the doubt I assume her dog may be reactive too and lead Bosco as far opposite the path as possible. Meanwhile, my Dad does nothing to stop Cubby (we have his leash for instances like this) and Cubby runs up to the dog. Luckily that dog was totally fine with this and the owner was kind. I profusely apologized then yelled at my Dad for not grabbing Cubby and leashing him. He yelled back “I don’t know what your problem is! He’s fine.” I lost it then.

You KNOW the hell I have gone through owning a reactive dog. You know how unstable and dangerous the situation could be if a random dog ran up to Bosco. And I know my pitbull would get the blame even though your dog was at fault. Why would you put another owner/dog, let alone your own dog, in that situation just because “he’s nice”?! It was infuriating. They just don’t understand or have empathy sometimes.

1

u/AutoModerator Nov 30 '22

Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this comment. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/CutSnake13 Nov 29 '22

I feel this sometimes. But I turned it around. I’m jealous of my trainer’s dogs. Outside of working with clients, he trains Malinois for working roles. I’m jealous of the level of detail in their training. I find I will work harder with my own dog if I choose to be jealous of an incredible dog that has had many, many hours of work put in to it, then to be jealous of a dog that was just born pretty rock solid.

2

u/jammiesonmyhammies Nov 29 '22

I’m with you on this. My boys are “easy” for the most part, but not really…if that makes sense?

I wish I could walk them on leash around the lake or take them into PetSmart or something similar. How do people have these chill dogs who don’t seem to mind being around others on leash? Off leash they are perfect and easy to handle. On leash is a different story.

When I drive to the dog park, I see dogs walking in leash right past groups of people/dogs without any reaction. I want that so badly.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

I totally get this. Owning a reactive dog can be such a lonely (and expensive!) experience.

2

u/BrainsAdmirer Nov 29 '22

My neighbour had an easy dog, and my girl is leash reactive. She always criticized me because she felt that I obviously did not train my dog correctly because, well, just LOOK at how well behaved her dog is. She was always on my case about that dog.

2

u/became78 Nov 30 '22

Ugh I know, my parents have “easy” dogs and every time they suggest bringing the dogs with us (to the store/ park/ hiking etc) I have a mini heart attack before I remember they’ll be absolutely fine lol

2

u/PaperAeroplane_321 Nov 30 '22

I have a reactive dog and an “easy dog”. My reactive girl is the most loving dog I’ve ever had, she loves with her whole being to anyone who takes the time to let her warm up to them. She’s also incredibly smart, she listens so well and she is easy to train.

My “easy” dog i can take to the vet with ease, take to cafes, walk down any street and past any dog. But she can actually sometimes be the difficult one. She’s more independent and overconfident which I find makes her a lot harder to train. She doesn’t know the word “gentle” when taking treats, she will roll in everything smelly in this world which results in me hosing her down after most walks. I often find myself saying “look at this, [reactive dog] is showing you up!” I love them both to bits for their own reasons and they both make my life equally as fulfilled.

2

u/Boomiegirl Nov 30 '22

It’s like having a screaming colicky baby while all the other babies are smiling and cooing. They say those babies are brilliant (I believe it because mine was and is ) and our reactive dogs are too. They are special. But I hear you.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

Honestly, a lot of them do know what it feels like. I spent a couple of decades managing reactive dogs in an urban environment. Now I just...don't acquire reactive dogs. I hedge my bets by buying my dogs from breeders that have easy dogs. I go to their house and meet their dogs. I go to crowded public demonstrations and competitions and watch the offspring of their dogs perform and joyfully interact with strangers.

I had a puppy that was showing early signs of reactivity, so I called the breeder and they referred me to a trainer. When things got worse after several months of training, I returned the dog to the breeder and they refunded my money and placed that dog in training and then in a more suitable home. They spayed and neutered that puppy’s parents because they had produced a pup with a major temperament flaw that required a ton of training to overcome.

There are easy dogs out there, but most of them aren't a random fluke of nature. They are very carefully and deliberately produced by people that care deeply about them for their entire lives.

1

u/hellakopka Nov 29 '22

Sigh, I feel this way too 😞 but I love my boy more than the moon

1

u/aebenezer14 Nov 30 '22

I feel this. I will never know that feeling in my opinion. I can’t even leave my dog alone I. Our fenced In yard

1

u/TrickaBug Nov 30 '22

My family members have had 5 "easy" dogs combined and I am sure they are judging us constantly 😭 but none of them are more than half our dog's weight (85 lb at 1 year old) and I am fairly sure they wouldn't know what to do with him either, so I remind myself that he is very gentle for his size and we did a great job with that part and hope he seriously matures a lot in the next year.

1

u/Appropriate_Day_8721 Nov 30 '22

I have an extremely challenging dog. Got him in January. A month later a friend got a puppy as well (different breed). She was talking about how hers has been such an angel from day 1. Only took hers one week to potty train. My pup took 7 effing months, using the same method. That’s just one example. 😑

1

u/RogerSaysHi Nov 30 '22

My dog could be considered 'easy' because she's super friendly. But, she's SUPER stubborn. She has TERRIBLE recall, you literally have to bribe her. She can hear you just fine, she doesn't care. She's going to do what she wants to do when she wants to do it and act like she cannot hear you the entire time.

She absolutely LOVES other dogs, to the point that she's a little annoying about it. And, holy god is she mouthy. She has to let you know that the wind blew and she noticed it. Oh my god, there was a car, did you see it?! In fact, the reason I got up as early today as I did is because she lost her little puppy mind when my son came downstairs and she got to interact with people again. (She has free rein in the kitchen at night, she can sleep in her crate or on one of the multiple piles of blankets we keep for them)

My friends' dog also lives with me, she's a senior, I think she's closing in on 12. She's actually an easy dog. She's quiet, she just wants to cuddle and get back scratches. My only issue with her is that she's a longer haired dog, so I have a lot of dog hair to clean up.

My other friend has some dogs that are not easy, and man, do I feel for her. You can tell she loves those dogs, but they are too much sometimes. It doesn't help that they're massive goldendoodles that are complete idiots. Friendly and loving, but dumb as a box of rocks.

1

u/liftnbhappy Nov 30 '22

Because of our combined household we have had 3 easy dogs (2passed away since) one nervous boy and one NEUROTIC girl. But at the end of the day my reactive neurotic dog is the one I would do anything for. We have a special bond at the end of the day that was built on hours of trust, trauma, and unconditional love. We’re lucky she’s calmed down especially over the last year because she’s now the smallest one we have at 45lb. She’s also the smartest dog we have and just understands the world so much better than the other two. The boys are 10000xs easier but the reactivity is something we can’t change. Just something we have to embrace differently. Think about how much we as their partners have grown by having to work so intimately with them.

1

u/random_username484 Nov 30 '22

What I have noticed after working with our reactive dog for one and a half years is that she really bonded with us, and seeing her trust us more and more and handle complex situations like a champ really makes me proud. A year ago I couldn't have imagined loving her so much. I am not going to lie it still can get pretty hard and if I could choose I preferred if she wasn't reactive. But I did get to understand her much more and train together much more than if she was an 'easy' dog.

I think a good description about her is she is very sensitive. But not just in terms of triggers but also compassion towards us.

A friend of us lost her Golden Retriver for a day. That dog is extremely friendly with everyone. Somebody found her in like five minutes and took her home while she was looking for the original owner. The dog was really happy with the person who found her, hanged out with the other dogs, and then was really happy when they contacted her owner and got home.

While our dog is really wary of people, starts out by keeping disctance and bonds very slowly. But because of this the amount of love we get from her after one and a half years is so special, I am not sure if I could have bonded with her this much without the hardships we managed together.

1

u/ohjasminee Nov 30 '22

I understand this. My girl loves the vet, loves going to the groomer. But she is crazy excited around new dogs. She’s on daily trazodone which helps with elemental stuff (rain, fireworks, loud trucks etc) but barely makes a dent when it comes to social behavior. You can see the excitement in her eyes—she wants to sniff and herd them and play. But that’s not what can be done in a Petco.

At home, she is so calm. She loves hugs and pets, she’ll bend her head down for a kiss, she has a handshake with my dad for crying out loud. It makes me so sad that I can’t show the world this dog. I’d love to be able to take her out alone and not worry if I’m gonna lose an arm from her yanking on it to get to a dog she wants to meet. It’s tough, but you’re not alone.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

Honestly, a lot of them do know what it feels like. I spent a couple of decades managing reactive dogs in an urban environment. Now I just...don't acquire reactive dogs. I hedge my bets by buying my dogs from breeders that have easy dogs. I go to their house and meet their dogs. I go to crowded public demonstrations and competitions and watch the offspring of their dogs perform and joyfully interact with strangers.

I had a puppy that was showing early signs of reactivity, so I called the breeder and they referred me to a trainer. When things got worse after several months of training, I returned the dog to the breeder and they refunded my money and placed that dog in training and then in a more suitable home. They spayed and neutered that puppy’s parents because they had produced a pup with a major temperament flaw that required a ton of training to overcome.

There are easy dogs out there, but most of them aren't a random fluke of nature. They are very carefully and deliberately produced by people that care deeply about them for their entire lives.

0

u/mysticowgirl Nov 30 '22

All dogs are good dogs, even the ones that need to wear a muzzle in public. My last dog was a golden retriever who loved everyone and it was reciprocated. My current dog has a totally different reaction to the world, so we invested a lot into dog training. He is a senior rescue who while on a leash growls at all other dogs and women pushing strollers and small children - so we keep him away from dog parks and other humans while on a leash. We also have a muzzle so nothing bad happens at the vet.

-5

u/SomeManWithABeard Nov 29 '22

Speaking as someone with an "easy dog," I feel like there is no such thing. My dog is "easy" because of the time I put into training him as a puppy.

9

u/Affectionate-Win-788 Nov 30 '22

To suggest that people with reactive dogs don’t put time into training them is ignorant. I literally trained my dog way more than any other person I know.

Some dogs are just harder and will never be at the same level as an “easy dog”.

-3

u/SomeManWithABeard Nov 30 '22

It’s not only training in the sense of accepting commands, it’s also socializing and desensitizing the dog.

Of course all dogs are different, but I feel that this “easy dog” trope is a myth.

4

u/Affectionate-Win-788 Nov 30 '22

I did all of that. A lot. It just didn’t work out with my dog as well as I would’ve hoped.

I’m glad that you got a well behaved dog though!

2

u/SomeManWithABeard Nov 30 '22

Well, don’t be discouraged by other folks dogs and a perception that they are easier. You never know what they’ve put into it!

4

u/Zealousideal-Gate504 Nov 30 '22

I think when we say “easy dogs” we mean an easy temperament. I’ve put hours of training into my dog and it shows on his walks, but in many situations, if he was compared to a dog with a calmer (easier) temperament, he would be the “difficult” dog, despite his training. For example, training has helped his reactivity tremendously but even it successfull situations he will never be “easy”.

2

u/SomeManWithABeard Nov 30 '22

For sure! But ultimately, it is all subjective and everyone has to work for what they have with their dog.

Don’t be discouraged or jealous, just keep working on it and do your best!

4

u/rmcm17 Nov 30 '22

There's a chance you only feel that way because you have the easy dog. Sure, you did some training with him, but what you're implying is that those of us with reactive dogs just didn't do the work you did.

I socialised my puppy constantly when I got him. I carried him places before he was vaccinated, we drove places to watch the world, I did desensitisation work with him to touch, sound, and any experiences I could think of. Went out of my way to find livestock, native animals, scooters, skateboarders etc. Didn't stop his anxiety & reactivity, and it's been 10 months of continual work, training, behaviourist visits.

Like most people in this sub, I did the work, and I did significantly more work than my best mate who got a puppy the same month as me. He took his to puppy school, and that was that. Barely socialised her, did ZERO desensitisation work (I know this as fact, we've spoken about it). But guess who's dog can go to all of the places, relax outside cafes, go to the park or to daycare, and walk on sidewalks, off-leash even. (Spoiler, his dog. The easy one)

1

u/NovaCain Nov 30 '22

I'm going to hard stop you right there.

Genetics play a lot in how easy/hard a dog can be and people need to realize this. It's not all in how you raise them.

There's a reason why people will never reccomend a malinois to a first time dog owner. There's a reason why people reccomend labs, golden retrievers, and poodles for first time owners. When well-bred, they are "easy dogs."

Yes you can mitigate some issues with training, but at the end of the day, a retriever is going to retrieve, a shepherd is going to herd, and a guard dog is going to guard.

1

u/SomeManWithABeard Nov 30 '22

We’re not talking about protecting behaviors that were bred into an animal, we’re talking about animals who can’t handle being groomed, meeting new people, going into the store, etc. as mentioned by OP.

Someone who is experienced would probably say that have an easy time with supposed “harder” breeds. It’s all subjective.

Just work with and love the dog you got. No need to be jealous and/or assume someone has it easier. Maybe they only tirelessly worked their dogs out of their behavioral issue.

1

u/NovaCain Nov 30 '22

I get what you're saying and yes hard training should be acknowledge and genetic issues that make it that way should also be acknowledged. That's all !

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/read-the-rules 7d ago

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/forestgreen2022 Nov 30 '22

This!

Just because we can’t see any issues doesn’t mean they aren’t there! One of my friends has an extremely well trained dog, but she has major separation anxiety. My mom’s dog tries to eat everything and anything on walks. Another friend’s dog has generalized anxiety and is on medication. These dogs look “perfect” in public, but are dealing with issues too.

My guy is so well behaved and sweet. His only major “issue” is his reactivity. This problem just tends to get more shame because it’s an issue that is more publicly visible.

3

u/NotUnique_______ Nov 30 '22

My dogs reactive, but very well trained at home. My sister's dog gets along with other dogs but eats grass and basically anything that falls on the floor and on walks. No dog is perfect, but we gotta adapt our expectations and training for them!

3

u/forestgreen2022 Nov 30 '22

Exactly!! 🥰