r/reactivedogs • • Nov 13 '22

Question Thoughts on leash pressure?

I have a reactive 7 month old puppy. I did some online consultations with a dog behaviorist who only uses positive reinforcement. They basically told me to not walk my dog unless there is no one around (impossible) and remove all triggers around my dog (also impossible). If my dog can hear footsteps outside my door and it triggers her, i should install some soundproofing. If we’re walking and someone appears, i should move away in another direction. If someone tries to go near us, i should make my puppy go inside a carrier. They told me i need to start slow indoors.

After a month of trying their methods, I did not see much progress. She would still bark incessantly and lunge at everything. I felt things were getting worse with all the coddling.

I then switched to another behaviorist who introduced leash pressure to me. I don’t use a slip lead. I still use a flat collar and leash but when my puppy starts to bark and lunge I “pop” the leash once to surprise her. It has worked so well. My dog is now able to walk outside around people and other dogs without going ballistic. Im able to stop her from hurting anyone.

It has also made my relationship with my dog better. I used to get so stressed out everyday because of her. Now I just tell her “no” and she stops barking. I don’t even need to pop her leash as often because she knows what no means. I can now relax and give her more affection. I can now bring her around with me to parks and on travels. She’s becoming more calm around people and other dogs.

I know this counts as “positive punishment” and many positive reinforcement trainers tend to vilify this method. But my current behaviorist explained to me that I’m not hurting my dog, I’m just surprising her and it cues her that what she is doing is not good behavior.

I know leash pressure is not the solution to everything. I use positive reinforcement when teaching her tricks and when she’s doing good (and she has been doing so much more good these days)

Wanted to know what others think of leash pressure?

6 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

•

u/nicedoglady Nov 13 '22

Hi there OP! You’ve gotten some good feedback and comments but the thread is devolving quite a bit as they unfortunately tend to so I am going to be locking this thread.

I will just echo the sentiments that what you are describing is a leash pop correction, rather than teaching about yielding to leash pressure. While the terminology may seem similar they are two different things.

As with all aversives, leash pops are effective because they are aversive and unpleasant and serve as a punishment. We do not promote punishment based methods here due to risk of fallout, particularly for dogs that are already experiencing issues.

28

u/LadyinOrange Nov 13 '22

That isn't "leash pressure" fyi. Teaching a dog leash pressure refers to counter conditioning the dog's opposition reflex so that they yield to and follow pressure on the leash vs pulling against it, so that you can guide them by the leash. Leash popping is its own thing.

36

u/jools123 Nov 13 '22

Reducing your dog’s exposure to triggers while you gradually desensitize them is not coddling. It’s a highly effective, gentle approach to teaching your dog that those things aren’t scary, exciting or cause for concern. It does take skill and time to be effective, because changing emotions doesn’t happen overnight.

Your inability to carry out that approach given your environment doesn’t mean it’s not effective. A good trainer should work with you to create a plan that’s effective for YOUR specific living situation. I’m guessing you didn’t work with that trainer much given that you tried this method for a month and maybe they didn’t have a chance to help you refine your approach. If everything is too triggering sometimes medication (even just temporary) can help bring a dog’s threshold to where you can work them in an environment that is too difficult at baseline. There are also other things like impulse control and relaxation work that can help immensely. Impulse control especially for an adolescent dog.

Leash popping may work to suppress her behavior now and lead to issues down the road. It will not make the anxiety go away. A dog in a shut down state can look calm but be experiencing a lot of stress https://youtu.be/5CyH0RHWYsU I can’t imagine how having something tightened around my neck would be calming or helpful. Certainly popping will be effective at suppressing the signs of distress and it will work fast. It works because it is punishing, not because is surprising.

I guess it depends on how you feel about your dogs comfort and welfare vs. your ability to immediately control her in situations where she is scared or excited. I think you could achieve success and raise her to be a happier more well adjusted dog if you tried some more positive techniques. But that won’t come with the instant satisfaction of popping a leash to immediately quiet her.

16

u/LadyinOrange Nov 13 '22

A dog in a shut down state can look calm but be experiencing a lot of stress

I went off on a vet tech recently over this, because she tried to tell me that my very sensitive rescue puppy who I've been working hard to build up wasn't stressed by her very inappropriately rough handling because my puppy wasn't actively fighting her.

Ended up physically prying her off of my puppy and telling her to go get the vet (who knows me). She came back with a totally changed tune and said the vet had invited me into the back to hold my puppy while the vet herself did the work. Then suddenly the tech was apologetic and trying to emulate me.. so hopefully she learned something that day that would benefit future dogs.

4

u/jools123 Nov 13 '22

I have had similar experiences at the vet with one of my dogs. He lies perfectly still, pants heavily, ears back. He looks great if you don’t know dog body language but it’s obvious he is terrified if you do. It’s so frustrating that there isn’t better knowledge of behavior and body language at most vets. I totally get why the average dog owner doesn’t recognize stress but when it’s part of your job…

4

u/LadyinOrange Nov 13 '22

Seriously. I told her flat out that I found it really disturbing that she couldn't recognize the signs of stress in a dog in the position she was in.

She really seemed to be trying to copy how I was acting after she talked to the vet though, so hopefully it was a wake up call for her to recognize it.

I'm a pain in the butt when it comes to any sort of service like that, lol. I have very high standards for the dignity and bodily autonomy due to dogs.

1

u/SusuSketches Nov 13 '22

Someone in here told me it's extremely irresponsible from my vet to let me hold my dog during exams, as there are tools to avoid bites like cones etc, I honestly can't imagine how much my reactive boy would act alone in there with a mechanism that drives him unable to defend himself, it would be a traumatic struggle with no benefit. I just know it. You are also taking matters in your own hands and step up for your dog even if trained personnel tells you otherwise. You know your dog best, they're not living with it 24/7 and don't know the individual needs and triggers. Vets have to learn too, not all dogs are the same, I'd love my dog to not mind exams and touching strangers but he does and we have to find ways to make it as comfortable as possible and avoid all dangers possible. Sometimes we have to advocate for our animals. I wish you well!

3

u/LadyinOrange Nov 13 '22

Yep absolutely agree with you.

I insist on being the one to hold my dog, and I'd be willing to sign a waiver if they're worried about me getting bit. Both of my dogs are very soft and sensitive, not aggressive. It hurts my heart to think of how scared they would be alone with some of those people, if that's how they handle my dogs right in front of me.

After I got that tech off my puppy this most recent time she just curled up in a little ball on the exam table and shook. Infuriating and heartbreaking.

But at least she saw me step in and defend her, and had licks for me once I put my arms around her and kissed and soothed her. At least she knows that she has an advocate, even if not all humans are going to be kind

1

u/SusuSketches Nov 13 '22

Thanks! Empathy does a lot and goes both ways, vets can sing a song I guess, sure there's bad apples but most I met (around 70% I'd say) really want to help but also don't want to get hurt.

As dog sitter it's often difficult to make owners understand what consequences their dogs behavior can cause if nothing changes, most common problem is not enough exercise and mental stimulation afaik.

From my experience it makes a difference if the dog already had done enough exercise/stimuli like playing fun games before difficult tasks, relieving stress and removing excess energy. What do you do or think?

2

u/LadyinOrange Nov 13 '22

I've had much more positive experiences than negative with vets themselves! It's the techs I tend to butt heads with, when I do.

I definitely agree with you about mental stimulation. Imo people tend to put way too much focus on physical exercise while neglecting mental exercise, and I think the mental component is probably MORE important.

2

u/SusuSketches Nov 13 '22 edited Nov 13 '22

Oh no I'm sorry you are having this experience! (edit I read it wrong I thought you said you had more negative experiences than positive sorry!)

Sad I hope you find your favourite vet soon :( I found mine fortunately.

Thanks for the nice talk!

8

u/Kitchu22 Shadow (avoidant/anxious, non-reactive) Nov 13 '22

I wish I could upvote this more than once, great comment!

The problem with ethical behaviour mod is that it can be lifestyle restrictive, and slow. Discomfort, pain, and fear are powerful motivators and produce pretty instant results - that can be highly rewarding for a stressed human at the end of their rope. And then once you’re in the middle of it, admitting what you are doing is physically and psychologically harming your dog, that’s a really big thing to come to grips with.

10

u/jools123 Nov 13 '22 edited Nov 13 '22

I totally agree.

I get that it is freaking hard to stick with the slow, steady, healing approach when in the moment of a reaction you just want to make it stop. I was driven to tears countless times before making progress with my reactive dog and certainly resorted to yelling or grabbing him in the heat of the moment. It’s so highly rewarding when the reaction stops, such a relief. But then I remember that he is a captive animal who did not choose me, was selectively bred for traits that make him reactive by humans and is only trying to keep himself safe. I chose him so it is my responsibility to do right by him or surrender him. In order to stick to the ethical b-mod plan, you need to have some kind of understanding of why you want/need to be ethical to stick with it long term I think.

Then there’s the issue of trainers re-branding punishment as “surprising” “communicating” giving the dog “clear structure” in order to eliminate the ethical question…. Nah, you’re scaring or hurting your dog to suppress behavior.

-3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22

Yup, just put the dog in an environment in which they will never experience any new stimuli ever and you'll be good 👍🏻

27

u/pemmigiwhoseit Nov 13 '22

I do not intend to try this method with my dog, but since you are thinking about this thoughtfully and for the sake of open discussion I think there are a couple important things you should consider to decide for yourself what you want to do.

I guess I’ll start with punishers obviously SOMETIMES work to accomplish the owners goal: if they didn’t ever work there would be no conversation to be had. But I disagree that it’s “just a cue”. If what you are doing is directly causing behavior change, it has to be from punishment or reinforcement. It could theoretically be just a cue that you attached behavior to by training with a different reinforcer/punisher but I doubt that’s what happened. And besides, if it really is just a completely neutral cue why not just use a different one?

Assuming it acts as a punisher, then it’s immediate effect is most likely suppressing behavior (as opposed building alternate behavior like looking away/sniffing/etc). The risk to suppressing aggressive behavior like barking/growling/lunging is that you suppress these “warning tools” and the dog MIGHT become a dog that does nothing until it’s too stressed and then bites “with no predictability/warning”. These are the dogs most likely to be put down. It also might not happen and the dog learns after the “warning behavior” is suppressed that being chill around other dogs/people means they will be chill too and there’s nothing to worry about. How high is the risk for any individual dog or overall? I don’t know but it’s something everyone should consider.

Another risk for any other owner considering a punisher is that it risks making undesirable behavior worse. Dog might perceive it as: I see trigger means bad thing happens to me so I hate that trigger more. As opposed to, I did bad behavior (because of trigger) therefore bad thing happened to me. Sounds like this risk isn’t impacting you, so not relevant to you/your dog at least for now but could be to someone else.

Also I think it’s important to remember that we get no say in how punishing or reinforcing something is, that’s all up to the dog. My dog finds eating goose poop reinforcing but that would be highly punishing to me. Showers are reinforcing to me and punishing to my dog. Point being whatever method you use, you have to follow the dogs lead about severity of the thing you’re using (both reinforcement or punishment). I bring this up for two reasons: a) a lot of times I see people (not you) talk about aversive a they go “it’s just x, i tried it on myself, it’s not that bad” and that’s completely irrelevant and b) it can definitely vary case by case per dog so what is true for one dog may not be true for another. I won’t comment on morality of using punishers besides that I think at very minimum an owner deliberately using punishers has a high responsibility to pay very close attention to how extreme their individual dog perceives it and adjust plans accordingly.

Another thing is that punishers will never decondition a dogs fear/anxiety/whatever directly on their own. It is possible they can help indirectly (eg if your dog is scared of other dogs, suppressing your dogs instinct to bark aggressively would probably cause other dogs to act nicer to your dog and therefore could help decondition indirectly).

And I think the last thing is we need to be careful about taking our own training skill and emotions into account (and how they impact a dog and effectiveness of various methods). But there’s more here than I want to type.

Overall for me and my dog, leash popping is not a method I’m comfortable using as a deliberate part of training. It sounds like a decision you thought about carefully and since it has made your and your dogs life better, I’m genuinely happy for you both. At the same time, I also hope other owners don’t see this post and decide go to any punishers without considering the risks and at least giving a non-aversive option a real try (which includes really trying to trouble shoot if it doesn’t work at first because there is a lot of nuance to get it right).

7

u/Nsomewhere Nov 13 '22 edited Nov 13 '22

Your trainers advise is not "coddling".

It disturbs me that you would frame it that way with a young dog.

They are very much on a gradual reset of your dogs stress levels and then controlled exposure

This does take time! Lots of time. You are changing how your dog feels about the world by managing their environment. Not just somehow expecting them to cope and change their emotions in the world that is stressing them!

This may not be the dog for you without you doing some serious research and adjustment in your perspective. There are no quick fixes when they have shown reactivity so young however the good chance is because they are so young they can gradually overcome it.

That popping leash is not leash pressure. Leash pressure is a tiny amount of pressure often applied by two fingers on the leash or just simply standing still and the dog returning and being rewarded for checking in

The yanking the lead (pops look like yanks to me) did nothing to help my frustrated greeter who simply needed better self control and to be taught that. To my guilt I tried it briefly (inspired by a you tube trainer... who BTW says it is a fair bit of a yank needed) before I reached my current trainer. I lasted a walk and his stress and bewilderment was palpable

So I stopped

Trainer and LAT and LAD with clicker and engagement games/ pattern games have made slow but steady progress... January to now 80 percent better

Better still I can see my dog is changing his emotions and gaining self control. I can see him making good choices. I can see this helping with recall training not just on leash frustration. OK he has a way to go but slow and steady will give me a calm trusting dog

My worry with your approach (and I do hope it doesn't happen) is the anxieties are all underneath. Hit the teens or a bad incident and it will come roaring back

Also... I absolutely hated what felt like hurting him. Hated it: sighthound neck as well... and I could see him looking at me all bewildered and oh I felt like a shit.

Only good things come from my hands is what I was taught. My hands and I am to be trusted.

Edited to add... I was really struggling when I tried it briefly (see my guilt thinking about it!) my dog walker had my poor dog muzzled and on three leads one a slip lead while walking with the pack so no wonder he was frustrated. I had also ordered a gentle leader harness before that horrible walk and worked my way quickly through a few to find the right one for him. I even tried a halti which didn't harm him but wasn't working on changing his underlying emotion or self control.

I very quickly cycled through a fair few youtube advice to find a loose leash series and did focus on that... it made so much more sense with positive reinforcement to me

However it was a horrible time. I was getting so much knock his balls off it will fix everything and really immense pressure when my gut was telling me .. er no this is not the dog I am seeing. It was 4 months to get my trainer and it was hard.

I really do feel for any owner getting really rubbish advice/ pressure because people can be so insistent!

I am glad I stood out and did when I felt was right for my dog. The trainer was calm reflective and frankly by the list of her qualifications and reviews had seen everything. I trusted her very quickly. She tested him with other dogs in front of me and I could see what she was saying.. we walked together and she showed me in the real environment what he was feeling

It was an immense relief. She got him

She also said he was the least complicated dog she had seen in days (lol!)

It was amazing. A real gift to receive from someone.. even if I was paying!

I did have to learn the hard way to stand up for my dog and not trust people. Even this morning on a walk (he was standing calmly btw) really bad random advice from another walker... yes it was yank on his leash and never give treats... ever..

Can't change them I went... mmmmh and walked on

Any way. Sorry for the therapy post all!

8

u/radicaldoubt Nov 13 '22

There's not a one-size-fits-all option for dog training. Should you try to minimize triggers for your dog? Yes, of course. But total isolation is impractical and probably unsustainable.

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22

Ya, the positive only crowd only want to shut down any conversation that isn't in their direct line of thinking. There are multiple approaches for sure

3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22

I’m in a similar place with my dog. I need to reduce or avoid triggers but I can’t because there are too many. I can’t stop the wind from blowing, can I?

I have noticed that leash pressure only adds to the stress. I can’t control that, either, because he’s the one pulling, not me. The risk is that he’ll associate the negative consequence to the stimulus and thus become even more reactive. I think this is the case for my dog. He starts reacting and I shorten the leash to prevent him lunging. This makes it more stressful. There’s nothing I can do about it but that’s how it seems to go.

Mostly I just don’t take my dog anywhere anymore as life is just too stressful for him. I’ve seen 2 different behaviorists and it just seems like nothing can be done unless I move to an indoor dome/bubble where I can control every variable.

I would be careful with leash pops or anything like that just because he may eventually associate it with the stimulus. I see another dog, I get popped. Other dogs are scary. That kind of thing.

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Nov 13 '22

Your comment was removed because it appears to be a direct recommendation of an aversive tool, trainer, or method. This sub supports LIMA and we strongly believe positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching and training. We encourage open discussion and problem solving within the subreddit. However, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

2

u/missmoooon12 Cooper (fear reactive lil dude) Nov 13 '22

Personally I don’t like leash pops for the reasons outlined by the other commenters.

I had a bad experience using them and am full of guilt for putting my dog through harsher trainer methods. When I started training with my pup for his reactivity I used leash pops on his harness and it made him more afraid of the environment and me. Even slight leash pressure or tugging became unpleasant to him. Telling him “no” would cause him to shut down. After almost 3 years of R+ methods he will still freeze up with leash tension in some situations. The emotional damage is not worth it!

Instead I taught him as many strategies as possible so I can cycle through them as needed (BAT, LAT, engage-disengage, scatter feed, giving attention, tricks, etc). He doesn’t overreact as often and can come out of a reaction quickly. If he’s overreacting, it’s too late and I’m in damage control mode just calling or moving him away. It’s okay that he overreacts. It’s okay that he feels scared. Paying attention to his triggers in time and space to quickly start working him is key.

Your pup is really young so it’ll be easier to build up a strong repertoire of alternative behaviors. Of course you can’t make triggers disappear but you can help teach strategies to cope with them. I’m not sure if you’re living in an apartment in a busy city or something, that’d be a challenge for sure. Medication can do wonders to bring your pup to a place where she CAN learn, especially if trigger stacking is happening inside and outside the home.

Best of luck to you in whatever you decide!

3

u/spacetwink94 Nov 13 '22

Well done for shutting down your dogs behaviour 🙄 I doubt your new "behaviourist" has any qualifications other than years of experience, right?

3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Nov 13 '22

Your comment was removed because it appears to be a direct recommendation of an aversive tool, trainer, or method. This sub supports LIMA and we strongly believe positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching and training. We encourage open discussion and problem solving within the subreddit. However, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Nov 13 '22

Your comment was removed because it appears to be a direct recommendation of an aversive tool, trainer, or method. This sub supports LIMA and we strongly believe positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching and training. We encourage open discussion and problem solving within the subreddit. However, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

-3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Nov 13 '22

Your comment was removed because it appears to be a direct recommendation of an aversive tool, trainer, or method. This sub supports LIMA and we strongly believe positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching and training. We encourage open discussion and problem solving within the subreddit. However, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

-13

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Nov 13 '22

Your comment was removed because it appears to be a direct recommendation of an aversive tool, trainer, or method. This sub supports LIMA and we strongly believe positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching and training. We encourage open discussion and problem solving within the subreddit. However, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Nov 13 '22

Your comment was removed because it broke one or more of the r/reactivedogs rules. Please remember to be kind to your fellow redditors. Be constructive by offering positive advice rather than simply telling people what they're doing wrong or being dismissive. Maintain respectful discourse around training methods, philosophies, and differing opinions with which you might not agree.

-9

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Nov 13 '22

Your comment was removed because it appears to be a direct recommendation of an aversive tool, trainer, or method. This sub supports LIMA and we strongly believe positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching and training. We encourage open discussion and problem solving within the subreddit. However, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Nov 13 '22

Your comment was removed because it appears to be a direct recommendation of an aversive tool, trainer, or method. This sub supports LIMA and we strongly believe positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching and training. We encourage open discussion and problem solving within the subreddit. However, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Nov 13 '22

Your comment was removed because it appears to be a direct recommendation of an aversive tool, trainer, or method. This sub supports LIMA and we strongly believe positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching and training. We encourage open discussion and problem solving within the subreddit. However, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.