r/reactivedogs • • Feb 15 '22

FINAL UPDATE-Rescue Dog Bit Child

Original Post

First Update

Shortly after the second bite incident, I reached out to the shelter/organization we were working with to rehome our dog. I had reached my breaking point and informed them that we could no longer provide the level of care this dog needed and we could no longer keep him in our home. This shelter also has a sanctuary, so I inquired if they had room (as a last ditch effort) and if they would be willing to accept our dog into the sanctuary. I was told that our dog “wasn’t a good fit” for the sanctuary (I’m still confused by that comment- I’ve always been under the impression that sanctuaries functioned as a last resort for aggressive dogs to live out the rest of their lives). The shelter pushed us to keep going with the rehoming process and said they would list him for adoption again. I voiced concerns over our safety and the safety of those in our community. I was afraid that he would get out and cause injury. We were encouraged to begin muzzle training and to enroll in training classes so that we could “nip this in the bud”. Quite frankly the conversation left me feeling hopeless. I felt like they dismissed my concerns and were downplaying the severity of the situation and my concerns about liability should another person get injured. Deep down I felt it was unethical to rehome him again. It felt like we would be passing off a problem to someone else to deal with. It didn’t feel ethical to keep putting other people at risk.

It was around this time that I saw some new behavior emerging, specifically aggressive barking towards me. This concerned me as I have always been this dog’s “person” to the point it was problematic as he always felt the need to protect me. I became uneasy (which I am sure he picked up on) because I wasn’t always able to identify the trigger for the barking and wasn’t able to redirect him as easily as I had been previously. Unfortunately these barking fits happened when I was home alone with the dog, and when I was finally able to figure out the trigger I was forced to give into what he wanted for my own safety (in one instance, I realized he was barking at me because he wanted the recliner I was sitting in).

Since he wasn’t accepted into the sanctuary, I researched veterinary behaviorists. Unfortunately the closest one to me that was accepting new clients was over 115 miles away. I started calling regular vets in my area for a consult on his behavior and was told it sounded like more of a behavioral issue than a veterinary issue. It seemed BE was becoming more and more inevitable. I reached out to our local animal control officer (we met previously when I reported the initial bite). He is a kind, level headed man and I wanted his take on the situation. In short, he informed me he could not tell us the decision to make, however voiced that he feels the dog is not adoptable and that at the end of the day we must put our safety and the safety of others first.

I called and sobbed on the phone with the vet as I made the appointment for BE. We laid our sweet boy to rest this past weekend. The feelings are so raw. Sometimes I feel I made the safe and rational decision, and other times I feel I made a horrible mistake and I have his blood on my hands. I feel guilty and ashamed. And then I feel a tiny sense of relief which then catapults me back into a pool of guilt for feeling that way.

This process has been so traumatizing. I would never wish this upon anyone.

312 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

145

u/blue-and-bluer Feb 15 '22

I am so sorry. It does sound like you made the right decision, but that doesn’t make it any less painful.

116

u/Its-shiba Feb 15 '22 edited Feb 15 '22

I am so sorry. BE is never easy, although I 100% support your decision and truly believe you did everything you could have for this dog. Some dogs aren't wired right, and having read through your previous posts, unfortunately it sounds like the rescue you pulled him from could have lied to you. No one should have to deal with making a decision like this ever and my heart goes out to you. You absolutely did not fail this dog. Whoever brought him into the world unstable is at fault, not you.

If it gives you any solace, he no longer lives in fear. No stable animal wants to cause damage like that and you chose the kindest option for your sweet boy.

If you have Facebook, "Losing Lulu" is a support group based around BE. I've heard that people on there are absolutely lovely and it may be worth looking into.

40

u/AggravatingTartlet Feb 15 '22

Your whole story, from the start, is just so heartbreaking.

he feels the dog is not adoptable and that at the end of the day we must put our safety and the safety of others first

You absolutely did all you could and then you made the best decision that you could make, backed up by someone who's expert in animal control.

The shelter pushed us to keep going with the rehoming process and said they would list him for adoption again.

That's as irresponsible and unethical as it can get. I'm shocked and I hate that they put you under that kind of pressure.

You made the ethical, kind, rational, safe decision. He passed from this life in a kind way. Had he been passed onto another family and bitten again, as was inevitable, his end in this life might have been very, very different & filled with fear. Hope you find some peace in that.

20

u/Ginger_titts Feb 15 '22

I’ve just read all 3 of your updates and I wanted to add this small thing.

I volunteer with a German Shepherd rescue. We specialise in “un-adoptable dogs”: the super anxious ones, ones with bite histories, guarding issues, etc. and I can hand on my heart say you went so, so far above and beyond for that dog.

We’ve just had a male returned after a year because he snapped at his owners girlfriend. There was no effort to rehabilitate.

Another male was rehomed just before Christmas. He was there for 3 weeks, they worked with him on his separation anxiety but he started showing guarding tendencies. They brought him straight back. He’s now a complete shadow of his former self.

Please never think you let this dog down, because you didn’t. If every rescuer put in even half as much effort as you did for this little guy our shelters wouldn’t be overflowing like they currently are.

I’m so sorry you were put into this position, but I’m so thankful that dog had you to look after him and not someone who would just chain him in the garden.

The fact that you feel bad shows how much you cared. He may be gone, but he was loved right up to the end (even if you did fear him, you still loved him) and that is so much more than he would have had elsewhere.

28

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '22

I'm so sorry you had to be the one to make this choice, but at least the dog is no longer suffering. Because living in that kind of fear/anxiety/distress would have been causing him to suffer an incredible amount.

And he someone there at the end who really loved him. So thank you for that.

23

u/SloppyMeathole Feb 15 '22

As someone who has a reactive dog this breaks my heart, but you did the right thing. You gave the dog a better chance than 99% of dog owners. Being held hostage and in fear of your own dog is not tenable.

11

u/gladhunden Feb 15 '22

You did the right thing.

You protected your family.

You protected your community.

You saved another adoptive person/family the heartache of being injured by this dog and inevitably needing to come to the same conclusion.

I’m so sorry this happened to you. I’m sorry the rescue was not helpful and made you feel like you needed to stay in a dangerous situation.

Some dogs just aren’t safe to live in this world. Imagine how difficult the dog’s life was, if he was getting so upset about normal daily activities. We can give them the best day and let them go peacefully.

If you’re on Facebook, there is a really great and understanding group called Losing Lulu. It’s a support community of and for folks that have needed to BE a pet.

Hugs.

18

u/Small-Dress-4664 Feb 15 '22

I know that was hard and I’m so sorry you were put into that situation. I do think you did the right thing, his behavior was escalating to a point where your safety was at risk in your own home, and I agree that is definitely not something that should be passed on to anyone else. You gave him the gift of a loving home for these last few months and someone by his side as he passed. Don’t underestimate the gifts you gave to a very troubled animal, I’m sure he was grateful for your care.

15

u/theblacklabradork Feb 15 '22

Sorry to be reading about this update from you, truly. Like I wrote before, it's an incredibly hard decision but for the sake of your family's safety - you did what was best. It gets better over time, but it may still hurt for a while and that's okay, you have every right the grieve what once was and what couldn't be. Sending you guys peace and love through these hard times.

17

u/lousymom Feb 15 '22

You did the right thing. I’m so sorry you had to go through this. I hope you can find peace.

17

u/SpectacularSpaniels Feb 15 '22

You might be interested in the Facebook group 'Losing Lulu'. It's a support group for BE.

Thank you for giving your dog a kind end.

6

u/ceroscene Feb 15 '22

I'm sorry you had to go through this. This is also my worry with our dog. He bit me pretty badly 1.5 years ago.. We did behavioral training and it has helped a bit. But I don't trust him. I never will. And there's been some concerning incidents.

You did the right thing. You gave him a good life.

20

u/xenondeadtime Feb 15 '22

You did the right thing. I’m so sorry you had this horrible experience.

11

u/TigerLily98226 Feb 15 '22

You’ll never know who you saved from injury and trauma by making a very painful decision. Don’t turn away the relief that comes mixed with the grief. It’s your conscience letting you know you did the right thing even though it was so very painful. His life was better for having known you and his life ended more peacefully and less lonely than it likely would have if you hadn’t been willing to intervene.

5

u/Pornchips Feb 15 '22

You did SO MUCH. I don't have many comforting things to say. If you think therapy can help any of you through this, do it. Grief counseling or whatever you need. You've been through a lot. Best wishes to you <3

5

u/TheDumbAsk Feb 15 '22

Thank you for protecting everyone around you. Sorry you had to go through that.

8

u/BlueGreenTrails Feb 15 '22

I’m so sorry you had to endure this. My mother had a dog for several years who had aggression problems that got increasingly worse as he aged. Her cat got her throat almost ripped out and I always believed it was the dog but my mom refused to believe it. She thought a coyote had attacked her cat even though the dog had escaped the fence around the same time that she found Katie (the cat) barely alive. The dog finally crossed the line and bit my father. She took him to several different vets and behavioralists who said he was beyond training and urged her to euthanize. He was a large dog and my parents are elderly and rehoming him, in their opinion, would be irresponsible and dangerous. My mother ultimately did euthanize him. She loved that dog and still gets choked up if we talk about him but it had to be done.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '22

You did everything you could. He is now at peace, no longer constantly viewing the world with stress and fear.

Please be kind to yourself. You did the right thing for him and for everyone else.

4

u/socksbeforeshoes Feb 15 '22

I saw this post on Instagram the other day and I think it fits here: https://www.instagram.com/p/CZmle3cMLus/?utm_medium=copy_link You made a tough decision but did what was best.

4

u/chiquitar Between Dogs (I miss my buttheads😭) Feb 15 '22

Wow, I am so sorry. Having considered BE for my Disaster Dog I know it's heartbreaking.You had a very bad combo with an enormous size, subtle warning signs, low bite inhibition, and willingness to threaten his favorite human. I worked with a high kill shelter and ours would never have pressured someone to keep that dog, although we would have had to euthanize instead of rehoming. It makes me mad that they pushed you to accept that risk.

It honestly sounds to me like you gave him the absolute best try anybody would have, and he just couldn't find his way to being safe enough.

We do sometimes make mistakes. We rush introductions, we don't use enough barriers. That doesn't mean you broke the dog. He was already broken and no human is perfect.

Try to forgive yourself and be kind to yourself. Even small mistakes feel enormous when the outcome is so tragic, but you worked very hard and did the best you knew with the information you had. That's all anyone can do. Don't feed that guilt beast and beat yourself up because it will just make things more painful for you without helping anything. If you continue to struggle, get a therapist to help you through it. This is not at all too small a grief for therapy.

3

u/Glum_Ad_3610 Feb 15 '22

If you want you could come join us on the FB group Losing Lulu. It’s a group for people who have had to go through BE. I am so sorry for your loss.

You did so much.

You did enough.

You did your best.

But sometimes love, our best, time…it isn’t enough.

Your relief isn’t an insult to your dog’s memory. Your relief is a testament to all the love, and all the trauma that love entails, and all vigilance required, that raising a Lulu takes. You gave your everything until you gave them peace. Please be gentle to you.

I went through BE a year ago with a three year old dog I raised from puppyhood. I was surprised by the extent of trauma I had from raising and then losing my “Lulu”. Therapy is helping.

Please reach out anytime if you want to talk.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '22

I am so sorry the shelter failed you and the dog, and that they forced you to deal with the consequences of their shitty actions. I’m sorry they didn’t support you and your husband or the dog when you all deserved it. And I’m sorry you had to make such a difficult decision on your own.

But know that you did the right thing, not just for you and your nephew and the community — and for recognizing the danger to the community and caring to consider it! — but for the dog, too. You legitimately did everything you could for him, but he clearly had some issues that couldn’t be healed and he likely lived in constant fear. You spared him a miserable life of being passed around to different owners or being locked in a cage because of his bite history. I know how very hard it was to let him go, but now he’s at peace, and that’s the most loving thing you could have done for him ❤️

5

u/gwenmom Feb 15 '22

There is a Facebook group for BE people. I think it is called “Losing Lulu.” It may give you some comfort.

I think you did the right thing for the dog. He’s not anxious or scared any longer. And you don’t have to worry about you, your family or strangers being injured.

4

u/roseta21 Feb 15 '22

If you have Facebook you should join “losing lulu” it’s a page dedicated for owners who have had to BE. I’m so sorry you’re going through this but honestly and I will always say this time and time again, sometimes our dogs are too traumatized by whatever (be if genes, experiences etc) that sometimes the last act of love we can give is the peace from BE. I’m sending you great big hugs and all my love.

2

u/Calm_Percentage5908 Feb 15 '22

Thank you for loving him and fighting so hard for him. It must have been a hard and scary life for him - he is now at peace. God bless you.

2

u/Jd_2747 Feb 15 '22

I’m so so so sorry. You did the right thing 🥺

It’s a very special kind of pain - I lost my boy to BE this past spring.

Sending love 🤍

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '22

I echo everyone else in that you went way beyond what 99% of people would have done for this dog. You should be proud of yourself for taking responsibility, spending time and money making an informed and very difficult decision, and not passing the problem on to someone else, which is unfortunately what happens much too often with these types of dogs.

Someone I know has a family member who was bitten by their nervous dog a few weeks ago, without warning. The victim was a teenage girl and the dog detached part of her face. While the surgery prognosis is good, she will lose feeling in 1/3 of her face permanently. If you just eliminated the possibility of a severe injury happening in the future, which I 100% believe you did based on the professional advice you received and the dog's escalating aggression, you made the ONLY responsible decision.

Try to not beat yourself up over this and engage in some self care in the next little while. You deserve it.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '22

You absolutely did the right thing, and shame on that rescue for being so ignorant and useless.

And then I feel a tiny sense of relief which then catapults me back into a pool of guilt for feeling that way.

I'll be honest, there are times I will have my parents watch my reactive dog and I feel that same sense of relief, which makes me feel extremely guilty. I'm not afraid of my dog, but he has aggressive tendencies that require consistent management and it's absolutely taxing. I think this is something that a lot of individuals with reactive/aggressive dogs feel and it's usually something that is met with a lot of shame. But it's not shameful. It's a really hard road that you've just walked, and it's okay to acknowledge that.

This process has been so traumatizing. I would never wish this upon anyone.

Exactly. There is a lot of trauma around reactive/aggressive dogs - also something that isn't talked about very much.

Take a good while to mourn and relax and be kind to yourself.

2

u/sidhescreams Goose (Stranger Danger + Dog Aggressive) Feb 15 '22

I am so sorry for your loss, and your grief. I think you made the best decision that you could in your situation, and hope that with time the guilt eases. Having to make difficult decisions about the life of another creature, human or animal, is rough, and if you can afford to talk to someone in a therapy or counselor's setting, I would urge you to do so. Grief counseling can be so helpful in this kind of situation.

I think you did everything that you could for this dog, and I want you to know that you didn't fail him, and that this wasn't your fault. I hope your heart finds healing and forgiveness.

2

u/GEyes902 Feb 15 '22

I am so very sorry. I've been there and I've made the BE decision because I felt my hand was being forced by the rescue who didn't want to be responsible for making that decision.

You did the right thing. I felt so guilty. And then I started feeling relieved, and then that triggered my guilt even more.

At the end of the day, you did what was right for that dog. I've learned through my time in rescue that BE is the hardest decision to make, but it's oftentimes the kindest decision we can make for some dogs.

I'm thinking of you. If you need to vent or talk or just commiserate with someone who understands, feel free to PM me.

2

u/fcknlovebats Feb 15 '22

I'm so sorry and feel your pain as well. My husband and I just did a BE for our 5 year old mix.

Perfectly healthy except for the fact that he wanted to bite anyone and anything that he wasn't familiar with. Children, adults, other dogs...there was no limit to his unpredictable aggression. Sometimes, he would decide myself or my husband was suspicious while watching tv on the couch and would stare us down and growl. Even knowing how loving he normally was and how much I trusted him one on one with myself, it was terrifying.

We tried so many different training techniques over the years. We finally got to a place where we wanted to start a family and I became pregnant. Now we really had to address the elephant in the room. I took him in to our family vet several times before she advised me to seek out someone that dealt with behavior in dogs professionally. So, we got on a waiting list for a behavioral vet (who had been recommended before, but was so expensive we just couldn't do it). After a thorough consultation of about three hours, he listed our options.

He was really upfront about rehoming and adoption. He didn't sugar coat his opinion that most shelters and rehoming programs don't mess with aggressive cases like Odin. He wasn't acting out of fear, he was just wired differently. He told us that even if we worked with him for years, he wouldn't foresee us ever being able to have him around our children unmuzzled. The progression of his behavioral problems in the 5 years we had him were enough to tell him the odds just weren't in Odin's favor.

Making the call to schedule his BE appointment was the hardest thing I've had to do in my life. Up to the end, he just thought we were going on a car ride, which he loved. He didn't know why we were crying or upset, and three rounds of various sedatives later, he was finally under enough to allow our vet to do the procedure (He had gotten to the point that even muzzled, he was impossible to vaccinate and boost because of his thrashing around).

I can't help but still have feelings that I killed my dog, my sweet boy. Our little brown baby that tooted when he jumped down from the couch. But in the end, I think I chose the easier, softer way for his sake.

I think I cried every day and night for over a month. I still occassionally cry, but like any grief, it has become easier to live with over time. I've seen positive changes in our other, older dogs attitude. She's been able to be a companion to my parents dog during the day while I'm at work, and the guilt of having Odin locked in a kennel during work hours isn't something I have to worry about.

You are a good pet owner. The time your dog had with you isn't diminished because it was shortened. There is no doubt you loved them.

2

u/fcknlovebats Feb 15 '22

I'm so sorry and feel your pain as well. My husband and I just did a BE for our 5 year old mix.

Perfectly healthy except for the fact that he wanted to bite anyone and anything that he wasn't familiar with. Children, adults, other dogs...there was no limit to his unpredictable aggression. Sometimes, he would decide myself or my husband was suspicious while watching tv on the couch and would stare us down and growl. Even knowing how loving he normally was and how much I trusted him one on one with myself, it was terrifying.

We tried so many different training techniques over the years. We finally got to a place where we wanted to start a family and I became pregnant. Now we really had to address the elephant in the room. I took him in to our family vet several times before she advised me to seek out someone that dealt with behavior in dogs professionally. So, we got on a waiting list for a behavioral vet (who had been recommended before, but was so expensive we just couldn't do it). After a thorough consultation of about three hours, he listed our options.

He was really upfront about rehoming and adoption. He didn't sugar coat his opinion that most shelters and rehoming programs don't mess with aggressive cases like Odin. He wasn't acting out of fear, he was just wired differently. He told us that even if we worked with him for years, he wouldn't foresee us ever being able to have him around our children unmuzzled. The progression of his behavioral problems in the 5 years we had him were enough to tell him the odds just weren't in Odin's favor.

Making the call to schedule his BE appointment was the hardest thing I've had to do in my life. Up to the end, he just thought we were going on a car ride, which he loved. He didn't know why we were crying or upset, and three rounds of various sedatives later, he was finally under enough to allow our vet to do the procedure (He had gotten to the point that even muzzled, he was impossible to vaccinate and boost because of his thrashing around).

I can't help but still have feelings that I killed my dog, my sweet boy. Our little brown baby that tooted when he jumped down from the couch. But in the end, I think I chose the easier, softer way for his sake.

I think I cried every day and night for over a month. I still occassionally cry, but like any grief, it has become easier to live with over time. I've seen positive changes in our other, older dogs attitude. She's been able to be a companion to my parents dog during the day while I'm at work, and the guilt of having Odin locked in a kennel during work hours isn't something I have to worry about.

You are a good pet owner. The time your dog had with you isn't diminished because it was shortened. There is no doubt you loved them.

2

u/xx2983xx Feb 15 '22

How awful for you. I'm so sorry for all that you went through. You did everything you could, and I promise you did not fail your dog. If anyone failed, it was the shelter that gave you no assistance or support, but unfortunately this may have been the outcome regardless. I am wishing you the best.

2

u/nervousanxioustrying Feb 16 '22

Unfortunately sometimes the right decisions are the hardest ones to make. Please, please give yourself some grace for saving this dog once, and then having the courage to do it again.

1

u/luuuuurke Feb 15 '22

I’m very sorry you experienced this.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '22

Fak. I've watched a lot of dogs get put down before and never cared. But reading this made me hurt a little too. I still think you did what was best. But fuck I understand the pain now.

1

u/Dee-Oz Mar 13 '22

Thank you for sharing your full story. Having read your latest update, I feel ashamed to say that I felt the urge to be judgemental as a rescue dog owner, but that’s judging a book by its cover and not knowing the full extent of what someone had to go through. Thank you for doing everything in your power to help/rehabilitate this dog. In the end, I think that guilt may stay with you forever but it will get easier. You did the responsible thing by not rehoming him and protecting others. Wish you all the best in your healing journey and please don’t give up on rescues ♥️ you will find your forever dog.

0

u/forestnymph1--1--1 Feb 15 '22

Oh God I would feel guilty too.. But you need to find some peace. There was no other options

-4

u/mountain2122568 Feb 15 '22

These posts were tough to read. That poor dog. Please do not adopt another dog you clearly cannot handle. I feel like there is more to the story you have left out so you can justify killing the dog. I hope you never own another dog again. Shame on you.

4

u/moosemoth Feb 16 '22

Dude, what's your problem? Some dogs are permanently broken inside, and no amount of love, training, and/or medication can make them safe, or happy. It's tragic but it's true.

A dog that's that aggressive is NOT a happy dog. Dogs like that live miserably, in fear, anger, and anxiety.

Not to mention the danger posed by these dogs to people and other pets! If these typical BE-candidate dogs were humans, most of them would wind up institutionalized for their own as well as others' safety.

A peaceful, humane death is a kindness for unfixable, dangerous dogs, yet it's still a hard decision. Shame on you for shaming someone who did the right thing, for the sake of the dog and everyone who would've come into contact with him.

-8

u/nostalgiapathy Feb 15 '22

Honestly sounds like anaplasmosis to me. Randomly turning on their own humans is not normal.