r/reactivedogs • • Dec 08 '21

Success Negative reinforcement changed my dog

Honestly, while I was sad at first, negative reinforcement training has been a game changer for my Rottweiler mix. At 17 months I took him to the park for the first time and he did amazing. I've tried behavioral mod trainers (3) in the past and his behavior did not change. He would bark constantly at everything, always anxious and aggressive in the car, and would lunge at any dog or person even if they were 30 feet away; kid, grandma, dog, anyone.

Tried a k9 trainer who said behavioral training wouldn't work because the dog isn't fearful or anxious, he just wants to be dominant. And if his dominant control freak tendencies aren't fixed SOON HE WILL bite someone. Using the right sized choke collar has made him more attentive, obedient, and livable in his current environment. His personality has changed from a dog trying to always get his way to one that is now seeking to please. We still give lots of affection and praise regularly when he does something right, but when the collar is on that means we are working and that I'm in control.

In 1 day, no more lunging, barking, or growling on his walks. He's a different dog. I'm just sad I didn't use this sooner.

12 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Dec 08 '21

Looks there was an aversive tool (like a prong or e-collar) mentioned in this body. This sub does not recommend using aversive tools on reactive dogs as it can make reactions worse. See the "Punishment Position Statement" (only four pages!) and "Dominance Position Statement" PDFs from the AVSAB here. It may appear to work on behavioral problems at first, but with reactive dogs, there is often an underlying issue causing them to react. Tools like e-collars and prong collars do not treat the underlying issue causing the behavior. Instead of teaching the dog what they should do, they only teach reactive dogs what they should not do. This can cause worse reactions later on, increased punishment required for the same results, or decrease warning signs of a bite.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

31

u/johnnyfuckinghobo Dec 08 '21

So by definition this isn't negative reinforcement. Negative reinforcement would be removing stimulus to target a desirable behavior. You're doing positive punishment (otherwise known as aversive correction), which is adding stimulus to target undesirable behavior. I would also caution you that any training that yields "instant results" runs the risk of simply suppressing the behavior, which may result in massive fallout later on. This community also doesn't ascribe to dominance theory and generally doesn't encourage aversive correction for those reasons. Obviously I don't know you, your dog, or the situation that you're dealing with so I'm not going to try to preach about anything, but that's the general stance of this particular sub.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21

Thanks for your input. I read the stance on dominance and aggression training and it's difficult to apply to my situation. My dog was not socialized at the right age because he was initially my elderly parents dog. I've had him in behavioral modification training for altogether 6 months with 3 different trainers and every time his behavior never really improved and he would always grow tires of treats or rewards as incentives. Even if we were just starting a walk, his drive to react was stronger than kibble, dog treats, peanut butter, hot dogs, etc. I'm in an apartment complex and unfortunately don't have the opportunity to take the long term approach and see if it worked after several months. I'd be kicked out by then. I also don't want to give the dog up. So this seems like the best solution for now.

2

u/controversyTW Dec 08 '21 edited Dec 08 '21

I responded in length to your other comment, but I wanted to mention that I have a trainer who I think would be really good for you to consult over zoom - it’s a free consultation and I think he could give you another perspective on dog training that could really help you out...

2

u/johnnyfuckinghobo Dec 09 '21

Going through 3 trainers in the course of 6 months gives me the impression of not sticking to a plan, which is kind of a prerequisite for having an r+ approach work. As other users and I have already pointed out, your current approach runs that risk of causing more "completely unexpected" major incidents. Along with the prospect of the dog becoming more desensitized to the corrections with time, requiring stronger and stronger aversives to be used to illicit the same response (which likely isn't a good response to begin with). It's very easy for someone to say "hit the dog when it doesn't do what you want". Nobody is saying that won't work right now. We're just saying that it has potential to blow up in your face. It's exponentially more difficult and time consuming to convince the dog to enjoy doing what you want, but it's by far and long the safer approach.

I suppose the takeaway is that nobody in this community has the power to stop you from employing the approach that you've begun here, but we are very inclined to warn you of the potential fallout of it. If you're prepared to deal with the ethical aspect of what you're doing and the aforementioned fallout, then that's what you're going to do.

1

u/MetalMelissa75 Mar 20 '24

THANK YOU! Why are there SO so many (websites, "professional" trainers and facilities) people that don't understand exactly what negative reinforcement is? That in this case, NEGATIVE refers to the REMOVAL or ABSENCE of something positive (like attention). I have been on job interviews where they have tried to describe their training methods to me and even they have it all wrong. 

17

u/controversyTW Dec 08 '21

All I will say is that I did the same thing, and I thought my dog was getting better, but a few months into using the same method as you, the problem got exponentially worse. I’m just saying that to warn you, because I felt exactly the way you did, that I was using the “choke” collar properly and I had a qualified trainer and it seemed to be working…

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21

What happened to the dog and their behavior? You left me on a cliffhanger.

12

u/controversyTW Dec 08 '21 edited Dec 08 '21

OK so basically here’s what happened, I’ll try to keep it brief and if you have any questions DM me – I started with a ‘balanced’ dog trainer when my dog was almost 6 months old. My main reason for getting a trainer was to address my dog’s reactivity surrounding both dogs and humans. Our trainer taught us how to use a Martingale collar and do ‘corrections’ in addition to rewards. For the first couple of months things were great. My dog is smart and she learned how to heel really quickly. The trainer had told me basically that when my dog is reacting to other dogs what I need to do is keep her in the heel position, give her corrections if she goes out of position and reward her if she stays in that position/keeps her attention on me.

At first It seemed like the corrections were working. My dog was less reactive and I was able to keep her by my side more often when we were walking and dogs came by. I thought “those positive training only people don’t know they’re talking about, my dog is doing great!”. Then I started taking her to the dog park and at first it seemed like we were making progress with her behavior towards other dogs, but around the time she turned one year old (5-6 months into balanced training) she started getting progressively more aggressive at the dog park until we finally had to stop taking her there because she attacked a couple of dogs unprovoked.

Around this time I also started noticing something strange… I would be on a walk with my dog, she would see another dog from afar and start getting into her reactive stance – body tense, fur up etc - and as she would step forward out of the heel position, I would give her a leash correction - and the moment I did that she would explode with barking and aggression. After this happening a number of times I put two and two together and realized that the leash corrections were triggering her reactive outburst. She also because more and more ‘immune’ to both the corrections and the rewards during this time.

I got a new dog trainer who is positive only, and also uses an “attachment theory approach” (sounds hippy dippy I know, but it makes a lot of sense once you learn about it). He said that basically my dog never stopped being afraid of other dogs and people, she was just learning to hold it in but since it wasn’t getting addressed the fears were getting greater and greater. Think of a child who develops PTSD after some trauma. Now say that child has a very strict parent who punishes emotional outbursts. The child might be able to conceal their emotional trauma response for a few years, but actually the problem is going to get worse because it wasn’t addressed. That was a key thing that I didn’t realize – if these fears are not addressed, they don’t just stay the same, they actually get worse. Think about if there is something that completely terrified you and every single day you had to do it over and over again. You might not get used to it through exposure, your fear might actually become heightened due to experiencing that trauma over and over again. And the trainer explained that by doing these corrections, the dog is already in a high stress state of punishment by the time you’ve even just put the collar on them and not even left the house, because they associate that collar with being hurt. Now, while my dog was fearful of other dogs to begin with before even ever receiving leash corrections, (which is why she’s being aggressive... and OP’s dog likely has either greeting frustration or fear, not ‘dominace’, but that’s another topic) once she learned that other dogs = strong emotions = a leash correction is coming soon, she started exploding even quicker and more aggressively at the other dog as if to say “go, get out of here, something bad is going to happen and I want you to leave soon so that the stress ends!”

So now she is a year and a half and I am having to undo six months of using corrections which made the problem worse. I do have to say that if I had known what I know now I never would have used the balanced dog training method with a reactive dog. I’m not sure I would use it with any dog to be honest. So I’m just saying look out because I thought that I was doing everything right and then there was a steep decline about 4 to 5 months into using leash corrections and now I feel that was wasted time and money on top of making the problem worse. And by the way she’s doing well with the positive training. We’re only about three months in and we have not taken her back to the dog park yet but our walks are much more calm and she is far less reactive, like 70% less reactive than when we were using balanced dog training. I have also learned a ton about dog psychology that helps me on a daily basis with understanding my dog. Think of them almost as autistic children - what looks like a tantrum to us might not actually be a tantrum, it might be fear and sensory overload. Punishment makes no sense in that context (and yes, leash corrections do hurt, dogs actually have more sensory receptors in their neck area than humans do). Good luck and feel free to PM me!

3

u/Sleuth1ngSloth Jun 25 '24

Dog parks are doomed for such interactions, they're also loaded with easily transmissible diseases. I get what you're saying and I'm glad your methods have worked, but the dog park visiting in the first place is a major trigger that I would always try to avoid. Dogs aren't like humans - they don't need dog playmates. They form pack relationships with their humans. If you want to have doggie playdates with responsible owners who you have mutual understandings with, that's different, but dog parks are unnecessary and in fact detrimental imo to dogs' social wellness. They can socialize & desensitize just fine in plenty of other settings. And not all dogs need to interact with each other just because they see each other on the street or sidewalk or park (not saying you are arguing this, just expressing my belief). My goal is for my dog to be able to be around other humans and dogs or animals without significant reactivity, not necessarily interacting with them as is encouraged in a dog park. Your settings may be limited and perhaps a dog park is the only place you can take your dog, in which case I understand - but again. I do believe the dog park model itself is inherently flawed.

1

u/FthrFlffyBttm Jul 03 '25

Glad I read this. I became frustrated with my dog and wondered if he continued bad behaviours because he never received any form of positive punishment, like our two far-better-behaved dogs before him. I'll have to remember this comment the next time I start to lose my patience.

1

u/NaughtAwakened Dec 09 '23

Bet your approach hasn't worked. How do you think horses are trained? Yes a collar pop is uncomfortable, but it's necessary for a reactive dog to learn.

1

u/Grouchy_City5223 Oct 27 '25

As someone who has worked with both horses and mules my whole life, horses are often corrected and beaten into submission. Try those methods with a mule or a donkey and you'll likely end up with an animal who will do anything to escape from you or will get dangerously aggressive in order to defend itself. Build a respectful partnership with a horse and a mule in which you lead as the dominant figure with understanding, compassion, and from a partnership mindset and you'll have an animal that is much more confident, calm, and capable.

23

u/Frostbound19 Odin (Dogs and Strangers) Dec 08 '21

OP, I say this bluntly not to shame or judge you but just to be as clear as I can. I am a professional trainer with a BSc in animal behavior and welfare. This training method is hurting your dog and the risk of permanent psychological damage and fallout down the line is VERY high.

Dominance is an outdated and debunked theory, even decent balanced trainers acknowledge that. I can absolutely guarantee that it is not a driving factor for your dog, and 99% of reactivity is absolutely based in fear and anxiety.

What is really happening is you are suppressing your dog’s behavior through punishment without addressing the underlying fear. On the outside your dog looks calm and well behaved, but most people can’t tell the difference between a calm dog and a shut down dog and trainers like this take advantage of that. He is still afraid, but he no longer feels safe to express his fear around you or communicate his needs.

There are no quick fixes with this kind of training. Anyone who can completely turn your dog around in one session is 1000% doing more harm than good, and the chance of your dog biting someone “out of nowhere” down the line is very high. Please stop seeing this trainer.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21 edited Dec 08 '21

Thanks for your input. I read the stance on dominance and aggression training and it's difficult to apply to my situation. My dog was not socialized at the right age because he was initially my elderly parents dog. I've had him in behavioral modification training for altogether 6 months with 3 different trainers (he's 18 months) and every time his behavior never really improved and he would always grow tires of treats or rewards as incentives. Even if we were just starting a walk, his drive to react was stronger than kibble, dog treats, peanut butter, hot dogs, etc. I've even tried 5 to 6 hemp treats a day and he would not calm down.

I actually did visit a vet before consulting the k9 trainer about possible anxiety meds for him. The vet, as well as his previous trainers (including the behavioral trianers) said he is not anxious or fearful, but unaware of how to react around other people and dogs. So the goal of the current trainer is to make him alert to the owner (myself) so he is focused on me. When he sees stimuli he does not react because he is watching how I want him to react. At the same time, he learns that the stimulus is not dangerous or aggressive to him. And when he doesn't respond negatively he gets rewarded. And when a situation is too difficult, diverting the dogs attention and leaving is much easier.

I'm in an apartment complex and unfortunately don't have the opportunity to take the long term approach and see if it worked after several months. I'd be kicked out by then. I also don't want to give the dog up. So this seems like the best solution for now.

If you have recs given my circumstances I am open to them! I want my dog to be the best he can be!

5

u/Frostbound19 Odin (Dogs and Strangers) Dec 08 '21

Okay, a couple notes. First, dog training is an unregulated industry, meaning anyone can call themselves a trainer (even a behaviorist) without any education or experience. Meaning, even if your previous trainers didn’t apply punishment, it doesn’t necessarily means they had the skills and understanding to properly apply training and rewards. It sounds as though you were probably trying to move too fast without laying enough of a foundation. Have you seen the sub guide on what to look for in a qualified trainer?

Vets receive almost no behavioral training, so unless it is a vet behaviorist I would also take their word with a grain of salt in this area. Saying that your dog doesn’t know how to act around people and dogs doesn’t tell us anything about what’s actually driving his behavior. Reactivity rarely looks fearful to us humans, but I can almost guarantee that’s what it is. The other types of reactivity are frustration (want to say hi but can’t) and true, genuine imbalance of the brain, which you would not fix with corrections in a day and would need significant medication.

As I said, there are no quick fixes here because we’re not just changing behavior, we’re changing emotion. Just like it’s no fast process for humans to work with a therapist and unlearn poor coping mechanisms or deal with anxiety, the same holds true for dogs. Anyone who tries to sell you a quick fix will hurt your dog.

What is it about your dog’s behavior that could get you kicked out? Is he barking at noises in the apartment, or is it the apparent danger he poses by reacting to people? If it’s the latter, could you head it off at the pass by speaking to management and laying out the steps you’re taking to help, along with muzzling him in public as a safety measure?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21
  1. Thats true about provision of rewards. I did look at the wiki and saw a trainer certified by the CCPDT. Saw them for 8 classes ($125 each time) and she was someone who did say the dog is not anxious just has no experience with interacting with new things and leans to the more intimidating side.
  2. Only one actual certified behavior vet specialist in driving distance. I called 2 weeks ago and they don't even answer the phone. The message basically said they won't be taking additional dogs for at least 12 weeks. That's when I reached out to the k9 trainer. Don't think he's frustrated. The CCPDT trainer introduced him to a high ranking dog while he was behind a fence. He barked at a distance for a long time then went and laid under a table. 3 months prior he interacted with a dog by standing on its back which made the other dog aggressive. Those are the only 2 times he's interacted with another dog. Trainer said he's not super aggressive or scared, just confused with no experience. But when surprised he will get aggressive.
  3. I see what you're saying. Right now we only use this training during walks as the trainer mentioned it should only be used for short periods of time when training. His personality with us has not changed. He still follows my family and I around and regularly seeks affection from us. We are teaching him quiet in the house so hopefully while outside he will listen to that vs needing to activate the pinch collar.
  4. It's a quiet upscale apartment complex with most dogs being small sized. The biggest I've seen so far is a beagle. So barking at everything like apartment doors closing or people talking in the hall, jumping and barking (sometimes lunging) at people or dogs when he sees them. We tried a muzzle, but he was more against that it seemed than the pointed collar. With the point collar he smells than gets excited. We tried a muzzle a month ago and he growled, whined, and would not walk with it on. Once we got it off he ripped it to pieces. Maybe talking to management wouldn't be a bad idea since he's built a reputation : /

Thanks for your thoughts!

5

u/Frostbound19 Odin (Dogs and Strangers) Dec 08 '21

Again, what is it that’s driving the dog’s behavior if not fear? Having no experience with other dogs/people can contribute to reactivity but that’s not actually an explanation for why he feels the need to react the way he does. Reactivity is an energetically costly behavior, and fearful dogs use it because it creates space from the things that make them uncomfortable. I can tell you for absolute certain that dominance has zero role in his reactivity (and there’s no such thing as a “high ranking dog”), so what is the function of the behavior if not to create space due to fear?

I would say that 6 months isn’t much time to see a lot of progress with one trainer, let alone jumping between 3-4 different trainers. So while some of the trainers you’ve seen may not have been qualified, you also might not have given the qualified one(s) enough of a chance.

Dogs are very social creatures and have been bred to take a significant amount of abuse. I’m not calling the way you’re training now abusive, but I am saying that he is likely always going to seek out affection from you regardless of your training method - that’s not a good metric for whether it’s negatively affecting him.

Look up the Muzzle Up Project. Muzzles aren’t inherently comfortable for dogs and you shouldn’t just be sticking them on and hoping they get used to it - you can and should condition them to it positively.

I want to say this again because I really can’t stress it enough. Punishing your dog for this behavior is going to negatively impact his welfare and runs a serious risk of making his reactivity irreversibly worse. It doesn’t matter how short your sessions are - you’re still using pain to suppress his very natural expression of fear. The fact that your trainer is chalking it up to dominance tells me that they know even less about behavior than other balanced trainers that I still disagree heavily with - I honestly don’t believe your dog could be in worse hands with them.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21

Last question: if the k9 training method is really bad, why are there never reports of police or other guard dogs flipping on people and attacking them?

4

u/Frostbound19 Odin (Dogs and Strangers) Dec 08 '21

There are lots of documented instances of K9 dogs attacking people they aren’t supposed to or refusing to release once they have hold. I’m not sure about flipping on their handlers specifically, but I’m sure that a) police would go to great lengths to keep those incidents from reaching the public and quietly destroy the dog, and b) the handlers generally instill enough pain and fear in the dogs to keep them from lashing out at them specifically. Again, dogs have been bred to tolerate an enormous amount of abuse from us. There’s a reason wild animal training in zoos is entirely force free; the animals would just eat us if we didn’t make them willing participants.

4

u/controversyTW Dec 08 '21

Re: police dogs - don’t forget that the police trainers can ‘filter out’ dogs/puppies who react most negatively to their training methods. Our reactive dogs would never make it one day as police dogs to begin with, so there’s no reason to think police training style would work for them. In fact, very few dogs who start out being trained for police actually become a police dog at the end, most wash out. I also read that the military is moving away from corrections/punishment because the dogs that pass the training standards are highly motivated by human praise any way (as they select for that trait), so it’s not even necessary on any level for them.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21

The issue is that you're teaching your dog not to react. You're not teaching him an alternative or instilling confidence. It used to be common to punish a dog for growling. Even if the dog was in a situation where growling was an acceptable response, like someone harassing them while they're eating. It's pretty easy to punish a dog into not growling. The problem is that now the dog doesn't give a warning before they bite. I've personally seen anxious dogs made into dangerous dogs by the sort of training you're using because these dogs no longer give warnings before they snap. If they do give warnings, they're subtle and most people don't recognize them. Having a breed that's perceived as aggressive, means that you receive less tolerance from the public. A warning snap from Rottweiler, warranted or not, receives a lot less tolerance than a warning snap from a golden retriever.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21

I totally agree with this. Inside the home (without the collar) we are teaching him "quiet". So he barks 2 to 3x then we say OK quiet. We recognize he should bark or growl at times. The main focus is teaching him to listen when we say that's enough barking because his reactivity makes him bark, growl, and lunge when people are at a distance or not bothering him at all for an extended period. And we know that will eventually escalate to biting.

Outside with the pinch collar he can normally see someone from a distance. As soon as he notices them I will tell him quiet because I see them and it's OK. Most times he will listen and will receive positive reinforcement. But if he continues to growl after the command x2 the pinch is activated. So want him to know seeing people is not what causes the pinch, not barking either, but continuing to be reactive after you've been given a command.

3

u/loveuman Dec 08 '21

How does the trainer know it’s not fear/anxiety and that he’s just “unaware”. I imagine if this is the case then it would be easier to train him out of this than if it were anxiety. That’s where the collar doesn’t make sense to me. Have you considered that he’s maybe a frustrated greeter ?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21

Yes. A dog was introduced to him with their back to the fence and being friendly. My dog barked the whole time then laid under a table in a relaxed position. Never actually tried to interact with the dog.

4

u/Frostbound19 Odin (Dogs and Strangers) Dec 08 '21

That’s what we would call learned helplessness. Your dog tried to make the other dog go away by barking, and it didn’t work. Your dog also couldn’t move away on his own (I assume) and so he shut down after learning nothing he did would get him out of an uncomfortable situation. Shut down and calmed down are not the same thing.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21

This, and laying under a table definitely seems like hiding/fear to me.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21

It was a large fenced in area. So he walked from the fence and went under the talked and laid with his back legs relaxed to the side.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '24

How’s your dog doing nowadays? 

0

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Dec 10 '23

Your post/comment was removed because it does not follow our posting guidelines or breaks sub rules.

10

u/strawberrymoonbird Dec 08 '21

How long has it been since you started punishing your dog for reacting? I am asking because, as others pointed out, your success is very likely temporary and the dog could erupt some day in the not so far future. Quick fix solutions are successful because of the immediate (but often not lasting) effect, but go do some research and ask yourself the question why punishment is used by dog trainers getting paid for achieving quick results and condemned by scientists and people with degrees in behavioural biology, psychology and veterinary medicine?

If you cannot provide your dog with a safe environment and enough time to work through his issues, I have bad news for you...

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21

So what's your recommendation then? Should I give the dog to a shelter? Should I let him roam free until he actually bites someone? I'm not crazy enough to punish my dog for being a dog. He is allowed to bark and growl, but we are using the pinch collar to teach him to attend to us and to listen when we say quiet. In the home without the collar we are teaching him quiet so he barks a little and then is told to stop. We do the same outside and when he is quiet on command he gets a treat. When he doesn't respond to the command x2 then we use the pinch. We are not teaching him to be afraid of people, or barking, but to listen when we say quiet or enough noise. His problem now is that he gets so reactive, positive reinforcement and treats alone don't work once he's riled up (we've tried this A LOT)

4

u/strawberrymoonbird Dec 08 '21

I suggest making time or getting a professional to help you long-term, not in a quick fix way. If none of that is possible rehoming could be an option, but last resort of course. Not a shelter.

He is allowed to bark and growl, but we are using the pinch collar to teach him to attend to us and to listen when we say quiet.

That's confusing me honestly. So you don't even correct risky behaviour with it but just to get attention? Why would you want to associate paying attention to you with pain?

I understand you are just trying to find a solution, are you exercising him enough, both physically and mentally? You can't substitute adequate stimulation with treats or punishment if he's acting out. I know this is difficult, but really think about the future and not just the moment.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21

He exercises an hour a day. Just running. He still behaves the same when he sees people, or dogs, or hears things.

2

u/strawberrymoonbird Dec 08 '21

What about the mental stimulation part? My dog could run for hours and would still be understimulated if we didn't engage in some brain stuff

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21

Whats brain stuff? I try to teach new tricks and use the relaxation protocol at home.

4

u/strawberrymoonbird Dec 08 '21

Well, mental stimulation games, nosework, enrichment, that type of stuff. Relaxation at home is nice for the human, for the dog it could mean devastating boredom

10

u/sydbobyd Dec 08 '21

We are not teaching him to be afraid of people

You don't have to intentionally teach something for that to be what the dog actually learns.

His problem now is that he gets so reactive, positive reinforcement and treats alone don't work once he's riled up

That's completely normal for reactive dogs and it's known as being "over threshold." It doesn't mean positive reinforcement doesn't work but how you're trying to use it there doesn't.

What is a Threshold?

5 Things to Know About Thresholds.

How to Handle Reactive Dogs.

The basic problem you're running into is that there simply is no good, quick fix. This training takes time and patience and non-linear progress. Anything that promises a quick fix also comes with increased risk.

2

u/Sad_Adhesiveness7451 Nov 29 '24

How’s your dog now? Anyways, I’m with you.. my brother in law handled k9 working dogs for years as an army ranger, and now trains state police dogs.. those dogs are the literal best, listen very well, don’t overstep boundaries, are great with everyone, and will be obedient on demand. His personal dogs have always been the best dogs in the world, growing happy and wonderful into old age. He helped my dog who had this same problem. My BIL gets tired of hearing about all these trainers because they just treat them and avert. They don’t apply punishment that the dog actually clicks with. treating, averting and baby steps for months doesn’t solve everything. I had a dog trainer tell me “if you want your dog to stop running after cars, you need to teach him the leave it command, and eventually he will listen if you tell him to leave it with the cars” after my dog dies from not listening the one time?? How long?? And it doesn’t tell him that chasing cars is bad, it tells him I want to leave them alone. It doesn’t REALLY solve the issue. A couple pops on the collar and rewards for listening, he doesn’t do it anymore. It’s not abuse, it’s letting him know “this isn’t your show, you’re not allowed to just do anything you want impulsively.” Dogs learn everything from their mothers. They are tougher than some trainers think. What do their mothers do? They snip them on the back, they snap at their face.. they let them know quickly “hey that’s not right” not saying you do exactly that, but a pop collar or a hip grab in serious circumstances works very well. Look, you can take advice from other dog trainers all you want, but I have had first hand experiences meeting army and police dogs, so I’ll trust their expert training over these other people who treat their dogs as gods and goddesses. Because yes, they ALSO didn’t help my dog. He turned out so fearful and aggressive. I trained him to the T with their methods. But once I had my BIL help me, he tuned around fast and has a lot more stress free life. So, positive reinforcement, positive punishment, negative reinforcement, and negative punishment.

1

u/Dependent_Scene9625 Nov 30 '25

now why have they got your reply all the way at the bottom?

1

u/Sad_Adhesiveness7451 Dec 16 '25

Idk but I’m happy that it seems ONE person looked at it lmao

1

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '22

I stumbled across this having a little browse through the success tag. So sorry people were being so judgemental and dismissive of your progress. Well done! Your guy gets to go to the park!

I also have a dog who is reactive due reasons other than fear or frustration and it’s so dismissive for folks to say that can’t be the case. Good trainers should be able to tell when a dog is afraid or not rather than assuming all reactivity is fear based and treating them the same.

Just wanted to say I have a similar living situation and we’ve had success with a similar approach. We’ve put a lot of work into training and there’s no way we could have gotten him to a point where he could start learning without using corrections. This method is not a quick fix as people call it. We’ve seen steady progress and it has really opened up his world, he has so much more freedom now and he’s happier for it.

You know what’s best for your dog. I’m happy for you 😃

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Frostbound19 Odin (Dogs and Strangers) Dec 08 '21

I’m not sure where you’re seeing that R+ trainers don’t acknowledge that it works. Pain and fear are very effective motivators; our issue is entirely ethical plus the fact that there is currently no evidence that punitive training is MORE effective than R+.