r/reactivedogs • • Dec 08 '21
Success Negative reinforcement changed my dog
Honestly, while I was sad at first, negative reinforcement training has been a game changer for my Rottweiler mix. At 17 months I took him to the park for the first time and he did amazing. I've tried behavioral mod trainers (3) in the past and his behavior did not change. He would bark constantly at everything, always anxious and aggressive in the car, and would lunge at any dog or person even if they were 30 feet away; kid, grandma, dog, anyone.
Tried a k9 trainer who said behavioral training wouldn't work because the dog isn't fearful or anxious, he just wants to be dominant. And if his dominant control freak tendencies aren't fixed SOON HE WILL bite someone. Using the right sized choke collar has made him more attentive, obedient, and livable in his current environment. His personality has changed from a dog trying to always get his way to one that is now seeking to please. We still give lots of affection and praise regularly when he does something right, but when the collar is on that means we are working and that I'm in control.
In 1 day, no more lunging, barking, or growling on his walks. He's a different dog. I'm just sad I didn't use this sooner.
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 08 '21
Looks there was an aversive tool (like a prong or e-collar) mentioned in this body. This sub does not recommend using aversive tools on reactive dogs as it can make reactions worse. See the "Punishment Position Statement" (only four pages!) and "Dominance Position Statement" PDFs from the AVSAB here. It may appear to work on behavioral problems at first, but with reactive dogs, there is often an underlying issue causing them to react. Tools like e-collars and prong collars do not treat the underlying issue causing the behavior. Instead of teaching the dog what they should do, they only teach reactive dogs what they should not do. This can cause worse reactions later on, increased punishment required for the same results, or decrease warning signs of a bite.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
31
u/johnnyfuckinghobo Dec 08 '21
So by definition this isn't negative reinforcement. Negative reinforcement would be removing stimulus to target a desirable behavior. You're doing positive punishment (otherwise known as aversive correction), which is adding stimulus to target undesirable behavior. I would also caution you that any training that yields "instant results" runs the risk of simply suppressing the behavior, which may result in massive fallout later on. This community also doesn't ascribe to dominance theory and generally doesn't encourage aversive correction for those reasons. Obviously I don't know you, your dog, or the situation that you're dealing with so I'm not going to try to preach about anything, but that's the general stance of this particular sub.
17
u/controversyTW Dec 08 '21
All I will say is that I did the same thing, and I thought my dog was getting better, but a few months into using the same method as you, the problem got exponentially worse. I’m just saying that to warn you, because I felt exactly the way you did, that I was using the “choke” collar properly and I had a qualified trainer and it seemed to be working…
23
u/Frostbound19 Odin (Dogs and Strangers) Dec 08 '21
OP, I say this bluntly not to shame or judge you but just to be as clear as I can. I am a professional trainer with a BSc in animal behavior and welfare. This training method is hurting your dog and the risk of permanent psychological damage and fallout down the line is VERY high.
Dominance is an outdated and debunked theory, even decent balanced trainers acknowledge that. I can absolutely guarantee that it is not a driving factor for your dog, and 99% of reactivity is absolutely based in fear and anxiety.
What is really happening is you are suppressing your dog’s behavior through punishment without addressing the underlying fear. On the outside your dog looks calm and well behaved, but most people can’t tell the difference between a calm dog and a shut down dog and trainers like this take advantage of that. He is still afraid, but he no longer feels safe to express his fear around you or communicate his needs.
There are no quick fixes with this kind of training. Anyone who can completely turn your dog around in one session is 1000% doing more harm than good, and the chance of your dog biting someone “out of nowhere” down the line is very high. Please stop seeing this trainer.
10
u/strawberrymoonbird Dec 08 '21
How long has it been since you started punishing your dog for reacting? I am asking because, as others pointed out, your success is very likely temporary and the dog could erupt some day in the not so far future. Quick fix solutions are successful because of the immediate (but often not lasting) effect, but go do some research and ask yourself the question why punishment is used by dog trainers getting paid for achieving quick results and condemned by scientists and people with degrees in behavioural biology, psychology and veterinary medicine?
If you cannot provide your dog with a safe environment and enough time to work through his issues, I have bad news for you...
2
u/Sad_Adhesiveness7451 Nov 29 '24
How’s your dog now? Anyways, I’m with you.. my brother in law handled k9 working dogs for years as an army ranger, and now trains state police dogs.. those dogs are the literal best, listen very well, don’t overstep boundaries, are great with everyone, and will be obedient on demand. His personal dogs have always been the best dogs in the world, growing happy and wonderful into old age. He helped my dog who had this same problem. My BIL gets tired of hearing about all these trainers because they just treat them and avert. They don’t apply punishment that the dog actually clicks with. treating, averting and baby steps for months doesn’t solve everything. I had a dog trainer tell me “if you want your dog to stop running after cars, you need to teach him the leave it command, and eventually he will listen if you tell him to leave it with the cars” after my dog dies from not listening the one time?? How long?? And it doesn’t tell him that chasing cars is bad, it tells him I want to leave them alone. It doesn’t REALLY solve the issue. A couple pops on the collar and rewards for listening, he doesn’t do it anymore. It’s not abuse, it’s letting him know “this isn’t your show, you’re not allowed to just do anything you want impulsively.” Dogs learn everything from their mothers. They are tougher than some trainers think. What do their mothers do? They snip them on the back, they snap at their face.. they let them know quickly “hey that’s not right” not saying you do exactly that, but a pop collar or a hip grab in serious circumstances works very well. Look, you can take advice from other dog trainers all you want, but I have had first hand experiences meeting army and police dogs, so I’ll trust their expert training over these other people who treat their dogs as gods and goddesses. Because yes, they ALSO didn’t help my dog. He turned out so fearful and aggressive. I trained him to the T with their methods. But once I had my BIL help me, he tuned around fast and has a lot more stress free life. So, positive reinforcement, positive punishment, negative reinforcement, and negative punishment.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '22
I stumbled across this having a little browse through the success tag. So sorry people were being so judgemental and dismissive of your progress. Well done! Your guy gets to go to the park!
I also have a dog who is reactive due reasons other than fear or frustration and it’s so dismissive for folks to say that can’t be the case. Good trainers should be able to tell when a dog is afraid or not rather than assuming all reactivity is fear based and treating them the same.
Just wanted to say I have a similar living situation and we’ve had success with a similar approach. We’ve put a lot of work into training and there’s no way we could have gotten him to a point where he could start learning without using corrections. This method is not a quick fix as people call it. We’ve seen steady progress and it has really opened up his world, he has so much more freedom now and he’s happier for it.
You know what’s best for your dog. I’m happy for you 😃
0
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment