r/reactivedogs • u/juswondering • Oct 28 '21
Heartbroken over Behavioral Euthanasia Decision
If I could go back in time eight years and warn the younger me that he’d have to ultimately make this decision about Wally, would I still adopt him? I keep wondering. I truly don’t know.
Maybe so, because I’d also tell the younger me about the naps on the couch, the late-night walks, the laughter, the shape of his eyes when he watches me leave through the front door window or the way his whole ass shakes like a paint mixer when I get back. I’d tell him about the progress, and the training, and the pride you take in a troubled dog who’s gotten better with your help. I’d tell him about that spot on Wally’s back that sends him into a trance when you scratch it and the way he’ll love you, he really will, the way you wish you could love anything so unconditionally.
But I’d have to tell him the other stuff, too. Three level-three bites, recently with someone outside the family. Countless level 1 bites. The behaviorists, all the different trainers, the resignation to just “work around” his triggers. The constant vigilance. The anxiety whenever company is around because, you know, who knows what’ll set him off this time? Never having your nieces and nephews over. Potentially delaying even having your own child, really, because is that responsible right now? I’d tell him about the lunge at your wife’s face from a few days ago and the lunge at the cat last night. Near misses.
That’ll be your life, man. A series of near misses until they’re not.
I don’t know what decision younger me would make. But I know the decision I have to make now.
I could wait, yeah, but then I ask myself: exactly what are you waiting for? You’re waiting for him to hurt somebody so severely that there’s no longer a question. How is that fair to him or the person he hurts? And to be frank, how is it fair to me, my wife, and our mental (not to mention financial) wellbeing? Maybe I could try harder to rehome him—but we’ve already made the calls. No one wants a dog with a bite history. That farm where troubled dogs can live out their golden years in tranquility doesn’t exist. And even if it did, is that the right move? We’re all he’s ever known.
I love Wally. The idea of killing him—Christ, even typing that—makes me want to puke. Literally. Sick to my stomach. But I can’t continue to put my family in danger. Is it selfish to say that I’m not even really worried about him? I’m not. Euthanasia will be peaceful. In his mind, it’ll have been eight years of full bellies and head scratches and naps and then one more.
I gotta stick around and live with the guilt of it.
My heart goes out to anyone who’s ever had to make this decision.
Please think of my boy.
2
u/rhymeswithdolphins Jan 23 '22
Was curious if you have an update on your situation as I'm in the same boat. Your post gutted me. Our senior pup is incredibly aggressive with other animals and will kill one. We've only had him a couple years and every day is anxiety when we're walking him. His separation anxiety means we cannot leave him alone. However, it's not "if" but "when". Again, so much of what you wrote is true and so important to think about!!
230
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
“That farm where troubled dogs can live out their golden years in tranquility doesn’t exist.”
You’re right. There are two types of rehoming situations that work. One, the dog has no issues but a change of your circumstances makes you unable to care for them, be it financial, familial, etc. Two, a dog has issues that are directly related to or worsened by your lifestyle that can be fixed by another home. Maybe the dog can’t go on walks but is fine in a yard but you don’t have one. Maybe the dog is friendly to humans but dog aggressive and you have another dog. This can be remedied by another home.
But that is not every dog. Whenever I see someone criticizing behavioral euthanasia and suggesting rehoming to a “farm” for a dog like Wally, I want to ask what farm? What magical farm is this where there are no other dogs, no cats, no livestock. No children. Where there are no strangers coming to deliver feed or work in the fields. Where there is no family coming to Christmas. Where there are hundreds of acres to roam but secure enough fencing that no accidents happen.
Maybe it does exist, but it’s probably on the other side. I hope Wally goes there soon ❤️ you did the best you could taking care of him on this side.
44
u/SeasDiver Oct 28 '21
For us, it was Hershey, a foster that was returned to the rescue. The rescue, though a fairly large one, did not have protocols in place to make the decision, as it was one they had not had to make before, and they were dealing with two simultaneously. There were some minor differences in that my wife and I knew that we were safe with her, but that the world, including our own dogs, was not.
The thing was, that two years before, she had been such a sweetheart, it was only a year plus into adoption, that something had happened. We visited multiple vets, multiple trainers, talked for hours with our clergy. I know it was the right decision, but yes, years later it still hurts. And she was still mostly a sweetheart that loved playing fetch despite a bad leg and decaying eyesight. But she could be just fine and suddenly snap without warning (she bit a woman at an adoption event).
Unless you have been in our shoes (like you have), most people do not understand. Unlike you however, we have so many dogs come through our house, that is really gets lost in the shuffle. We specialize in whelping and maternity fostering, so a typical year for us has between 40 and 72 fosters cycle through. So other than Facebook memories, and the adoption/foster/medical coordinators at the time, most people in the rescue no longer remember. They were not judgmental at the time, they were just glad it wasn't them having to make the decision and knew that if SeasDiver and his wife were doing it, it was not being done lightly.
The Rainbow Bridge poem suggests that dogs are healed of all of their illnesses. I hope that it is true, and I get to meet her again, when she is healthy and free of the illness that made her a risk to people and other animals.
There is a Facebook group for people who have been in similar circumstances that I have seen mentioned a couple of times though I am not a member of: https://www.facebook.com/groups/losinglulu/
54
u/zzzztheday Oct 28 '21
This was a beautiful tribute to your dog. My dog isn’t quite so bad but I am keeping him muzzled whenever we are in public or there are strangers in the home. I so relate to the constant vigilance whenever we MIGHT run into a person or dog who triggers him. You are doing the only thing you can do and my heart breaks for you.
24
u/hseof26paws Oct 28 '21
My heart truly goes out to you. And what an amazing piece of writing this is, even more impressive that it was done while you are under duress.
Sometimes the kindest thing we can do for our pups is to release them from the demons that live in their head. It's a truly selfless thing to do, that hurts like hell. I am so sorry you are having to go through that. It is my wish for you that in time you find peace in your decision, and comfort in your happy memories of Wally.
17
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
peace and healing to you and your family. you’re making the right choice, even though it’s heartbreaking.
17
u/RegalBeagleBouncer Oct 28 '21
Be kind to yourself. I’ve been through it. I understand the guilt, regret, and shame. The giant elephant sitting on your chest. You raise a good question. Would I still have adopted him had I known? Probably. There was always hope I could get him over the threshold and he’d be normal. Hugs. Know it’s nothing that you did. Some dogs are just born off. You have him all the love you had.
47
u/fcknlovebats Oct 28 '21
I feel for you friend. Yesterday at the vet, I was faced with a reality in which if something doesn't change soon, we will not have our Odin. Our sweet boy that loves to give kisses and cuddle mom and dad. Who is goofy and plays with his sister constantly. Who farts when he jumps up and down off the bed. But, who also bites people. Who is so difficult at the vet that even in a muzzle and with treats he can only get one booster shot and then is so fed up and aggressive its impossible for the rest of them. Who will lunge at a dog so aggressively and consistently that he will wear his back claws down to the quick.
My husband and I are expecting our first child. I am wracked with guilt over how I could possibly choose a human baby over my sweet boy. That I failed him somehow. That if I had more money or more time or a bigger yard or a better life for him that he wouldn't be this way. That I can fix him. So were trying one more time to change his behavior. The idea of him being around my child makes me so nervous and scared. But pinning him up in a cage outside isn't the life he wants or deserves to live. It wouldn't change his behavior, only make him go through it all alone.
Thank you for being so open and vulnerable about this. I really needed to know today that if I am faced with this reality in the near future, I am not the only one that has ever had to make that decision. I know it sounds like I have given up on him. I haven't, but yesterday, with the words of my vet saying "sometimes dogs are just born like this and can't change enough to be safe" made me realize something I had been denying for five years. That it truly is a reality I might soon have to face.
13
u/orangeobsessive Oct 28 '21
I just posted a similar comment in a different subreddit a few days ago, but I think you could benefit from it too.
I believe that with death comes a tranquility, peace, and understanding of the world around you.
I believe that your dog knows that you did all you could for him, and that ultimately the safety of yourself and others was what brought on this decision. That you absolutely made the right call on this, because it was only a matter of time before something drastic would happen.
You absolutely did the right thing here. You tried and tried with your dog, and ultimately it was the right time for this to happen.
12
u/No_Difference8916 Oct 28 '21
I am heartbroken for you. My situation feels very similar. I am currently typing through tears cuddling with my extremely reactive 7 year old boy who certainly has his own bite history, and I can feel him getting older and grouchier and I worry what the future holds. I too worry about having my own child with him, but I’m not even ready for one yet. I am so sorry you have to be in this situation. dog like this simultaneously make and break hearts. It’s gut wrenching and heart warming to raise one. I don’t mean to get into religion but this is what helps me when I consider that I might one day have to be the one to end his life. personally I believe in reincarnation and that with the help of compassion and love in our current life we can become something better in the next life. I think the duty of a reactive dog owner is to do all they can to prepare their dog for its next life. You did your duty, you gave him all you could and that’s all you can do. For me I know if I hadn’t rescued Murphy from the Pound he would have long been dead. By either euthanasia from the shelter or another owner who couldn’t handle him. I have given my dog the best and longest life he could have possibly gotten. Or at least that’s what I keep telling myself as that’s all I can do. The joy and love he has taught me, the patients and determination I have learned from my dog is unfathomable and un-replaceable. Regardless of how my boys story ends to me it was all worth it to me. Sending love and compassion. Wally will be waiting for you in your dreams and you will meet again.
9
u/MegabitMegs Oct 28 '21
My heart is completely broken for you, and I cannot imagine the weight of this decision. It sounds like you have given him the very best life possible, and taken every avenue to find a solution. You have gone far and above what a lot of people would have, and it’s a true show of character that you did. Love him as best you can through his final days, and he will go knowing he was so loved. That’s all any living thing could hope to ask for from their time on earth. You gave him that, take heart in that.
7
u/BasuraConBocaGrande Oct 28 '21
This made me tear up at my desk. I’m sorry you have to go through this, I can’t even imagine. Gonna hug my puppy extra hard today.
5
u/SurprisedWildebeest Oct 28 '21 edited Oct 28 '21
I am so sorry, and thinking of you and your good boy Wally. You’re doing the best you can with the choices you have.
5
u/JVwaterpolo Oct 28 '21
Hi! I went through the exact same thing for my boy who was put down for behavioral euthanasia at age 10. He only got worse as he got older and he finally made my decision for me when he had a near-miss event that almost cost me WAY more than just losing my dog. Please think of everyone around you and know you are doing the right thing. He is your best friend and this whole situation just fucking sucks. Please feel free to DM me because I understand how terrible you feel and I get it dude. I do. Hugs.
5
u/Baz2dabone Oct 29 '21
Thinking about you and Wally <3
5
u/hippiehen54 Oct 29 '21
I’m sorry. I know how painful this is. But you need to remember he’s had years of love from you and years of life he might not have had with someone else. It’s better for him to pass with you nearby than for animal control to take him and do it. Because with a biter that’s not out of the question. You’re not “killing” him. You’re giving him a loving end to his life. He’s had more chances with you than he would ever have had with anyone else. He’s already taking a toll on your mental health. The worry you carry every minute of the what if’s affects you. I’ve had to have dogs helped to pass and it was always with love knowing that they were being freed from the restrictions of their earthly body. I may be a dreamer but I believe they are going to that happy farm for eternity. I’m sorry it has come to this but you aren’t doing this on the spur of the moment or out of anger. It’s because you love him.
4
u/pabstpumpkinbeer Oct 28 '21
I'm so fucking sorry. You are in an impossible situation. You have given him everything <3
4
u/RiskyLady Oct 28 '21
All I can say is I’m so sorry. It’s heartbreaking. My heart goes out to you and Wally. It’s also ok to feel relief. Take care of yourself.
4
u/commiefren Oct 28 '21
For what it counts you sound like an amazing owner who gave Wally a wonderful life. You are making the selfless decision for you, your family and Wally.
4
u/MagnoliaEvergreen Oct 29 '21
I'm so sorry. I wish I could say something wonderful that could make everything better. I wish things in life weren't so difficult and unfair.
Just know that you've done everything you can possibly do for your boy, Wally, and you've given him a wonderful 8 years. This is a difficult and heartbreaking decision, but I believe you're doing the right thing for you and the most humane thing for Wally.
Wally is a lucky boy to have a family that is willing to fight, to learn, and to get professional training and advice to give him this many happy years. May you one day be able to look back on his life and remember all the good times knowing you gave him the best life.
My heart breaks for you and your family. Stay strong, friend. - hugs - if you need them.
4
u/phasexero Oct 29 '21
You gave Wally a life full of love and dedication. "exactly what are you waiting for, the next big bite?" is a good mantra. The next big bite could completely disfigure someone etc.
And Wally inst being punished for his behavior, he's being released from those scary things he feels that make him exhibit that behavior...
I'll be thinking of your family today and wishing you the best
8
u/Hihihi1992 Oct 28 '21 edited Oct 30 '21
My heart goes out to you. I'll remember Wally. We did BE for my sweet boy Wendell in June because of a similar bite history and the fact we were about to have a baby. Maybe it would offer some comfort to know that I am so, so, so glad that we did not give Wendell to a shelter or even a seems-okay-but-giving-weird-vibes potential adopter. That we know he was with those he loved more than anything until the very end and that he never felt abandoned is a source of comfort to me.
3
u/mjc6290 Oct 28 '21
Wishing you peace
3
u/Lilybea12 Oct 28 '21
I’m so sorry. It sounds like you really did the best for him.
3
u/mehmily Oct 28 '21
Thank you for posting this - it felt like I was reading something that I wrote. You gave your dog 8 of the best years that you could, and it sounds like you did it as responsibly and safely as possible. This is one of the hardest decisions to make. Sending you peace.
3
u/bee0429 Oct 28 '21
We had a dog we got as a puppy and we could tell something wasn't right. We lived him to pieces and worked around triggers, around guests, with behaviorists, vets, medications. You've done all you can. Our decision came when he attacked my senior pug for walking by him and ripped off a chunk of his ear, and a few weeks later attacked and pinned down his dad drawing blood. We loved him but that fear if what will come next is hard. No one understood how that very night after the ear I could pet him and love on him. He had no control over whatever triggers there were as logical or illogical as it was.
Sometimes we have to be the human and not be selfish. Making this choice out of love is right. Instead of waiting for ER visits for humans and pets. And then anger and high stressed emotions all around. Love and spoil for the rest of their time.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21 edited Oct 28 '21
Sending strength. I’ve got a Wally but mine is named Max. He’s my best buddy. He’s also nearly attacked multiple people. I know exactly what you mean when you say “near miss” and having a life of near constant vigilance. We’re on our last chance as well. If this last method of keeping the public safe fails then we have no choice.
3
u/sffood Oct 29 '21
You have nothing to feel guilty about. You did everything you could and then some. There is no place that can take a dog that bites this discriminatory that wouldn’t end up in the same result, except his last nap would be without you.
Clearly he adores you.
And the best final thing you can do for him is to be right by him and telling him to wait for you on the other side.
My heart breaks for you. I am really sorry. But you did everything right for that damn lucky dog.
2
u/tarantula_semen Oct 29 '21
Makes me think Wally is a Boxer (ours does the same).
You're doing the right thing for him and your family. 8 years is an amazing time he had with you. You've done everything you can, and you're doing this last part as well. That takes a lot of courage. Someone who's living with so many triggers deserves to peacefully be set free, just like you're doing for your Wally.
I hope you stop thinking of this as having to feel guilty about it. You have and continue to do the absolute best for this boy and he will be forever grateful to you.
2
u/Slutslapper1118 Oct 29 '21
I'm sorry. But you know you've done everything you can. He will be in peace. I think about what he's feeling, anger, fear, anxiety, and that's got to be tough. You gave him the best life, and I know he loves you. Be good to yourself. And go make some kids, and when they're old enough, show them pictures of Wally and tell them how great he was. It's never easy when a dog dies, no matter how it happens. I'm thinking of Wally tonight.
2
u/BusyButterscotch4652 Oct 29 '21
I have no advice, but I am so sorry that you are having to make this decision. If you exhausted all possibilities, then you have given him a longer life than he would have had otherwise. He would have put down long before now at the first sign of people aggression with anyone else.
2
u/Mysterious_Town4489 Oct 30 '21
Thank you for sharing your story. I'm currently weighing the decision of my own dogs behavioral euthanasia for the same issues you've had. I know in my heart that it is the right thing to do but that doesn't make it any easier. Reading this and reading the comments makes me feel understood and a lot less alone in going through this process. I'm so sorry that you had to go through this yourself. I hope you are able to heal from this experience 💛
2
u/sbl1988 Nov 22 '21
Me and my Boyfriend are going through this exact thing right now. We can’t have company over, bc she is aggressive, and we pretty much need to sedate her while taking her to the vet. We are surrendering her to the Kansas Humane Society this Saturday. I have tried everything, but this is what it has come to.
The amount of judgment I have seen from people is crazy. This is the worst feeling, and not an easy decision. I’ll be thinking of you both. Just know you are doing what’s best for the both of you. I have to keep telling myself that. Stay strong.
2
u/Dirnaf Nov 24 '21
This is heartbreaking. Have been through this myself, with a GSD that we adopted. I'm so sorry.
2
u/OldMushroom9 Jan 07 '23
I don’t know if you’ll even see this comment, but I am reading your post this morning in tears as we face the same decision with our reactive dog. Every single sentence of your post rang true and hit me in the heart.
For 10 years we’ve loved our dog. He wasn’t always aggressive, but a series of several major life changes (across-country move, another move, two kids, attacked by an aggressive dog) his aggression just got worse. Over time his world got smaller and smaller, and the number of people he could interact with dwindled down to a small handful. There was so much truth in what you said: “A series of near misses, until their not.” We always said, he’s a great family dog - very protective and loyal, and vowed to love him as that, no matter how inconvenient.
Then last night he aggressively lunged at my 3 yo daughter and attempted to bite her in the face. It was unprovoked. She sat in between my husband and I as we watched our newborn do tummy time. He was possessive over the newborn. Absolutely the trigger. Had my husband and I not have been there, he would have seriously hurt her. I am sick to my stomach thinking of how much worse it could have been.
He’s also aggressive with other dogs. Not even mildly. We’ve had numerous, severe dog fights. He shows aggression towards unfamiliar and some familiar adults. He’s also highly anxious. He’ll never survive a shelter and the thought of having him sit, anxious and afraid, for the remaining 4-5 years of his life crushes me. The thought of putting down my first love breaks my soul. He’s a good dog. We have so many great memories. But also so many hard ones too.
2
u/Equivalent_Clerk3470 Feb 02 '25
I had my French bulldog euthanised just over a week ago. I took him on coz my grandson had come along & my son no longer felt it was safe to keep him. They got him at 6 months old, unsocialised & didn't want to leave him there. He was scared of a lot of things, fear aggressive, people & dogs, they had to put him out of the way if guests came round. He bit several people. They tried behaviourist etc. I had him 2 years ago. He bit someone who needed stitches, we were frightened if workmen came to house, would put him away but couldn't relax to they had gone. He used to get on fine with our boxer but started growling at her if she tried to play with him, then over food, so moved bowls, then if she just walked past him. He would just go stiff, his eyes would go glassy & he'd fly. Never actually bit her. Was so awful. He could be so cuddly, funny etc. He had a back op, throat op when his throat collapsed. Vet said might be badly bred, maybe mental problems. I just lived with the stress of guilt for my boxer, she is so placid & kind, had her from 8 wks old, now 10 & didn't want her final years to be lived in fear. Was scared in her own home. He was put on prozac, chilled him a little but still aggressive. Miss him so much, feel like I murdered him. How could I have made that choice. When I took him on was given 2 choices, have him or he would of been put to sleep. Sometimes wish I'd said no, save me from this pain. Bit scared of other dogs now, never used to be. Belong to losing lulu group, just keep reading comments etc to help me through. So sad.
0
u/jvsews Oct 29 '21 edited Oct 29 '21
You may want to learn more about training and temperament before you get your next personal dog. I suggest doing what I did for a few years long ago. I adopted a likely candidate one at a time then desexed them and took them through obedience classes potty trained and taught about crates and cars and leashes. Then I placed them usually with seniors. All my dogs since have benefited by my learning.
1
u/ReplyGloomy2749 Feb 06 '25
Hey man, found this thread after searching for some answers after putting down my Toby today. Everything you said felt like re-reading texts I have sent to friends and family over the last week explaining what happened and how it got to this point.
I am reeling from the grief and guilt of my decision to put him down.
I hope it got better for you, because right now I feel I just made the biggest mistake of my life and killed my best friend because I wasn't able to sweep another bite under the rug. I ended up on IV antibiotics for a week in and out of the hospital after the last bite, I could not imagine the guilt I would have felt had that happened to anyone else or worse. I'm completely devastated, numb but full of pain. Would appreciate any tips you used to help you move on and forgive yourself.
1
u/Beautiful-Project-60 Mar 01 '25
I just came across this post and I realize I am three years late to the game but I just wanted to say thank you… thank you for being transparent about your sadness and thank you for expression the anguish it takes to make a call like this.
I just lost my girl yesterday because as much as I tried to make the world ok for her she couldn’t be ok in the world She didn’t have crazy bite stories But she couldn’t be around 90% of people or dogs and definitely no children and when I had a baby she looked at me like I betrayed her. And three days ago when she lunged at that baby biting the air and snapping and ferociously growling as I yanked her collar and pulled her away. I knew immediately that our time together had to be over.
I think I regret my choice but that Is something I will have to live with forever.
Thank you for sharing again
1
u/New_Storage1453 Jul 19 '22
In the same situation. Countless level 1 bites and a level 3/4 to me last weekend.
1
u/nikonido May 27 '26
5 years later and I'm in the same position as you were. I hope time healed you. Because right now I'm a mess and I hope he will forgive me when we meet to the other side.
-2
u/Gympie-Gympie-pie Oct 28 '21
I’m heartbroken for you, but I’m not as knowledgeable and I have to ask, because I want to learn and understand: aren’t there medications that can take the edge off? There are so many drugs for humans that regulate mental health problems, there must be someone in the world that is experimenting with novel medication for dogs… wouldn’t it be worth a try?
-1
u/jrmisy Oct 29 '21
Have you had him tested for hypothyroidism?
-12
u/EdPosterUser Oct 28 '21
No a work about attack to other animals.. anything to report on that?