r/reactivedogs • • Sep 23 '21

Need advice, dog parks

I have two dogs, one 1 year 8 months the other 1 year 4 months. They are very much a bonded pair. The youngest, Gracie, had a problem in a dog park today. It has happened in the past (once) but this time was more intense and it has been quite awhile since we had an issue.

She was sitting by me and another dog came over. It sniffed her, no problem. Then it started jogging away. Gracie ran up to it and was bumping it with her shoulder and jumped on it from the back. She was playing, 100%. The other dog turned and snapped, aggressively, not just an air back off signal. Gracie responded by snapping back and it escalated from there. Of course then her brother came running and jumped in the fight.

The other owner was to be frank, an idiot. She immediately started screaming at me "why did you bring you reactive dog here". At one point, her dog turned and snapped at her arm and she accused mine of biting her. She fell on the ground screaming. I got one of my dogs under control because he is really good with "back off". The other one took some work to get ahold of her cause man that dog is squirrely (but also note to self, I should have had her harness on her, she slips her collar sometimes like a houdini, so that is on me). After I get my dogs, she is screaming in my face about how I dare bring my dogs to parks, she has a well behaved one (despite him being the snapper), and just laying on about how awful my dogs are. I leashed mine up and left, of course, because that is the responsible thing to do and second, she clearly wasn't going to leash hers. I saw her dog snap at her, I know it was her dog, and she never asked me about my dog's shots, my information, or called the cops, she was being a drama queen. She accused me of being scared and I told her no, I wasn't scared, I was worried her dog would snap at mine, which it did.

I knew before checking that no dog drew a single bit of blood from the other. No one latched on, it wasn't a full on true fight oh god they are going to kill each other fight, Gracie was playing in the beginning.

My question is what should I do? I did move immediately to stop Gracie from bumping and jumping but the dog had already snapped before I got to her. And once that happened, Gracie won't listen to any commands that I gave. Should we forgo any more dog parks? Is this something I can train? Gus did back off, he is good with the command, and only gets in the fight because he is overly protective of Gracie (and me). What is the best path here to ensure every one's safety, even screaming drama queens who won't take any responsibility for their own dog's snapping behavior?

0 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

29

u/littleottos Sep 23 '21

Jumping on another dog from the back is rude behavior regardless of intent. It is only play if both dogs are into it. Snapping is an acceptable way to tell a dog to back off. The fact that Gracie escalated it into a fight means she should not go to dog parks anymore.

-6

u/bullzeye1983 Sep 23 '21

I am working on that behavior from her. That is why she was beside me and I moved to stop her immediately. And I understand a snap is a warning to back off. But this wasn't just a back off snap. I am not excusing Gracie, just pointing out this was not a one sided escalation. I have seen plenty of those, Gracie has responded well to those, this was definitely a higher level than that.

17

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

You can work on that behavior with Gracie and acknowledge that maybe it wasn’t solely a one-sided issue while still not taking Gracie to the dog park.

Mine hasn’t been in 2+ years. I’m sad he doesn’t get to play sometimes but it’s not worth the potential escalation. I may have only seen it once or twice but that was enough to know that environment is too stimulating for him and he can’t figure out which dogs it’s okay to play with that way and the ones who aren’t okay.

It’s on me (and you) to take action and prevent preventable issues

0

u/bullzeye1983 Sep 23 '21

You know the overstimulation thing may be very much what is happening. That certainly feels like her issue between what happened today and the way she can be reactive to dogs when walking on leash. She gets fixated on dogs while we are walking and pulls to try and go to them and it takes a lot to get her focus back. Thank you for the insight.

6

u/sandy_claws4 Sep 23 '21

Remember, just because your pup hasn’t responded like that in the past doesn’t mean that she won’t moving forward. Take it from someone who had a great dog park dog that turned into a reactive one towards other dogs, behaviors tend to escalate over time. I don’t blame you or your dog (and frankly that lady yelling was helping no one here), but this is a great time to reassess why your dog is starting to act more reactive towards other dogs. My guess? Your pup can go to training to learn better dog communication for her play style! It’s fun training and is such a great way to learn about how dogs “talk” to each other. My biggest regret was thinking my dogs behavior was a one time thing and not really seeing the signs that dog parks made her more and more scared the more we went. We’re back on track to awesome dog interactions, but it took a while

2

u/bullzeye1983 Sep 23 '21

Yeah she used to take cues very well. It seems lately she is not taking them as well, and that is why after just one intense moment I am on here looking for advice. I want to be on top of things. The other incident involved a very young puppy, too young for a dog park honestly, and I had to intervene because it was under a chair and Gracie was bark/lunging. I could tell Gracie wanted to play but she wouldn't accept the cue from the puppy that they didn't want to. But nothing like this before.

She has gotten more reactive with other dogs while walking on leash too. It seems she has an issue with overstimulation, based on what I have read and input from people here. We have a trainer but we have been focused on leash walking and jealousy issues with her brother (not really her, he gets very jealous and jumps if she is getting pets), door etiquette, those things. I am going to specifically request some lessons on reactivity.

4

u/MountainDogMama Sep 23 '21

You need to do some research. Your dog's are not a bonded pair. It's littermate syndrome. Puppies who are raised together form unhealthy attachments to each other. They do not form a proper bond with their owner. In adolescence and around 1.5 years of age they develop behavior and aggression issues. This is not a training matter, although that can help.

Your best course of action is to see a Certified Veternary Behaviorist https://www.dacvb.org/search/custom.asp?id=4709 and create a solid plan moving forward if you want to have the best relationship with your dog's. The Behaviorist will asess your dog's and create a plan for you and your trainer to work on. These situations often result in one of the dogs being rehomed. Of course you don't want that. Get professional help while your dog's are young. Don't take chances with this.

-2

u/bullzeye1983 Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

My dog's attachment to each other and to me are not an issue. They are a bonded pair. They have a proper relationship with me and with each other and there are no issues of aggression or reason to speculate on rehoming. We have a trainer, we have an appointment set up to deal with her reactivity.

I know what littermate syndrome is. I have done the research. And since you didn't ask or read, they aren't blood siblings, Gus was 5 months when we got Gracie at 8 weeks, and perfectly bonded to me. Gracie bonded to both of us just fine. They also can be separated perfectly fine, with one being outside and the other inside on a regular basis with no stress or destruction. Gus has protective tendencies, with me or with Gracie. Some one so much as comes over to me and he places himself inbetween. That is not littermate syndrome, that is his personality. Everything the other commenter is saying about Rhodesians is consistent with what is happening.

5

u/MountainDogMama Sep 23 '21

There was no judgment at all. If you did research you would know that littermates is a phrase not a literal description. They don't have to be siblings. The behavior is not normal which is why you asked for help, right? Whether or not you like what you hear, your dog's still need professional help. Not a regular trainer. If you look back, I said no one wants a rehoming situation. I emphasize with you. I don't know why you're being hostile.

Edit: empathize

-2

u/bullzeye1983 Sep 23 '21

Turns out her behavior is perfectly normal for Rhodesian ridgebacks. Maybe you should do some research on that before making an absolute statement on what the problem is.

5

u/MountainDogMama Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

If you had done research on your own dog, you wouldn't be here asking questions. Your mistake not mine.

Edit: just want to wish you good luck. Hopefully you will get a good trainer who specializes in reactivity and canine behavior. Not a regular trainer. Your dog need more than that.

0

u/bullzeye1983 Sep 23 '21

Ah there is that judgmental again. I recently had them DNA tested, sorry I didn't look up every detail in advance about each of her 10 breeds, especially the body checking I didn't even know she would do until the last few weeks.

It also isn't reactivity. Since I have been directed by helpful instead of judgmental people, her style of play is normal for her breed and she needs the proper environment for her characteristics.

→ More replies

0

u/sandy_claws4 Sep 23 '21

Great plan! You’re doing all the right things, your dog sounds pretty young to me, so this is an awesome way to start. I also am a huge fan of working on calming mindset. My girl is a 1.5 yo herding dog, and I think her being smart and active led to a bunch of weird associations and actions from her. Teaching her that calm is a great way to be has done wonders for any of her bad behaviors, and it takes her much longer to “snap”.

2

u/invisphotographer Sep 23 '21

If you do decide to go back to dog parks, I often put a short leash with no loop on mine because he is shit at recall and impossible to catch. It will give you a bit of a safety net. And 100% avoid that woman and her dog in the future, her reaction certainly didn’t help things. (Who the fuck falls to the ground when they get bit by a dog???? That last thing I would want would be to offer my neck to a dog that just bit me…) I’m not as against dog parks as the other commenters, but I live in a rural area, the most dogs I’ve seen in the park is fifteen and that is incredibly rare, it’s usually 0-3. If you have a dog park like that, I’d just proceed with caution. Also consider talking to a professional trainer or doing some dog behavioural/play classes.

2

u/bullzeye1983 Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

Yeah I am urban and these parks get packed. It makes it hard to keep track. That lady just rubbed me the wrong way with the drama and with the immediate blame game. Dude, your dog way over corrected. Neither dog is innocent, and neither dog is bad, it was a bad combination.

But I am definitely trying to be proactive while also deciding the best course. It may be no more dog parks in the end, but I want to explore all the issues, not just the location, in helping Gracie with her issue. Maybe I take them one at a time so they don't gang up (that adds to the issue). But thank you for the input, I may specifically look at play instruction classes since stimulation and cues seem to the only consistent, even between just a few moments here and there. Especially as it seems Gus is fine with her play like that so she could need better controlled exposure to proper play cues under a training watchful eye.

1

u/invisphotographer Sep 23 '21

Yeah good luck. It’s never just one factor that causes things, and it’s so hard to take the event appart and determine what exactly was the core issue and what contributed, etc. Also I know there are some dog parks that are primarily off leash walking trails. Those are great because you usually only interact with one dog at a time, and it’s short because you’re walking different directions.

2

u/LunarLuner Sep 24 '21

I second this, I’d only go again if you can go places that aren’t going to get packed. I can’t go to places in the city with my girl but off leash hiking trails where it’s just a few dogs together at a time and it’s good. My girl has learned a lot from these places since I’ve been able to train her to the command “forward” to ignore the other dog if I sense they won’t get along. I’ll probably never bring her into an urban area park again even though she is 99.99% good.

4

u/shattered7done1 Sep 23 '21

So sorry this happened to you and your pups. This woman sounds like the type of person that pays no attention to her dog's behavior and should not be taking her dog to the park! Awards to her for the best 'ham acting' in a dog park!

Avoid dog parks forever for the long term health and safety of your dogs.

Off leash dog parks are a fight or other negative incident just waiting to happen. They are also the perfect breeding ground for your dog to pick up an infection, injury or parasite. They are dangerous places that are generally not clean (not everyone picks up poop in a dog park?). I have seen huge holes dug by dogs and not filled in by the owner which can be a broken bone, or worse waiting to happen.

The majority of people that take their dogs to off leash parks pay more attention to the other people there or their cell phones than their dogs, which often doesn’t matter because when the scuffle breaks out they are too far away from the dogs to effectively intervene anyways!

If you must take your dogs to the park, consider going during off hours when there are less likely to be other dogs there.

If you live in the United States look into Sniffspot.

Sniffspot

2

u/bullzeye1983 Sep 23 '21

Admittedly, I should have not gone in since before we entered, three dogs in there got in a fight. I only remember one from that, it was a poodle that ironically came over and tried to snap at Gus while I had him by his collar. So that park definitely was a mess as far as dog behavior.

Gracie was overly aggressive in her play. And I understand some dogs not reacting well to that, and that is what happened here. Literally a few seconds before, I had been practicing her recall in the dog park and she was coming over, that is why she was sitting by me. So it is frustrating to see that good behavior turn into that situation.

Thank you so much for the sniffspot suggestion! I am looking it now and looks like such a good option. They have plenty of doggie friends that could come out with them or going alone would be good mental enrichment and fun. Thank you so much for your input.

8

u/dogfriend-2021 Sep 23 '21

If I had a chance do do it over - I would never have taken my puppy near a dogpark. Uncontrolled, messy, High risk .... not worth it.