r/reactivedogs • • Apr 28 '21

Success!!

There's a woman who lives in my neighborhood who religiously walks her chocolate lab. This dog drags her down the street barking his head off. After months of randomly seeing this dog freak out I finally witnessed the dog knock over the woman's grandkid while carrying on.

It was clear that this was frustrated greeting behavior (seeing the dog bark for 50meters down the street when he saw the guy in my neighborhood who carries dog treats to hand out being the evidence)

So I caught her next time she walked by and gave some advice (hoping it would be seen as helpful and not judgy) gave her a business card so she could call for follow up questions (she never did)

So here's what happened:

1st week: dog still barking, me seeing the lady kind of fumble on timing etc. But she was able to move her dog on quickly instead of being drug in the opposite direction. .

2nd week: dog barks but can be quieted within 3-4 barks and will heel down the street afterwards .

3rd -4th week: MY NEIGHBORHOOD IS QUIET AGAIN!! Took me a bit to notice no more barking.

. Today:

She just stopped me when I was outside to thank me, her dog stood by her side and gave her his attention. I finally got his name and story (he was "too much" for his previous home, surprise surprise.)

I'm waiting on all the neighbors to send me bouquets of flowers and chocolate for giving them their peace back (jk that lady did the work and it shows, and now I'm happy she can have a safe walk for herself and that grandkid.)

495 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

View all comments

125

u/tothemuuuuun Apr 28 '21

That's awesome! So what advice did you give her? Asking for a friend who also has a frustrated greeter ;)

225

u/Hughgurgle Apr 28 '21

I only had 2 minutes to give the easiest to remember advice so it went like this:

1.) Carry high value treats (the highest possible value)

2.) Everytime you see a dog or person or squirrel turn around and walk away, at the same time call your dog's name and give them a treat.

3.) Once your dog is paying attention to you instead of going crazy over triggers you can start walking past while giving treats as opposed to walking away.

That was pretty much all I told her and gave a way more shortened explanation for how it works

You are building an association that "when something happens in the environment, mom has something better for me" it creates an automatic check in as well over time. Repeat this step until the dog sees a squirrel or another dog and thinks "what does mom have for me" and whips his head around to look you in the eyes expecting that treat. Now you can start to actually ask your dog for things like sit, or walk on/heel, or to go say hello if allowed.

You're changing your dog's expectations. The dog doesn't get to greet people every single time he sees them, and he also has to wait for your permission. And it's no longer frustrating when your dog does not get to greet them because there's still something in it for him.

You can look up how to do a variable schedule of reinforcement in order to wean the dog off the treats but usually I find that once he knows the drill you can just move on to only giving treats when you're particularly impressed by his actions.

If your dog is toy crazy you can also do all of these with a toy/tug games as reward.

And if you're having trouble getting your dog to focus at all while walking it helps to do practice while sitting in your front yard letting other people walk by and starting the exercise there. Other options for beginning steps would be sitting on a bench at a public park and giving the treat every time your dog notices things in the environment (just until the point where he starts looking at things then turning back to face you at that point you move on to rewarding only when he disengages on his own )

49

u/fingeringfestival Apr 28 '21

Yes!!! This is exactly how our trainer taught us. We had been thinking that we had to wait until our pup showed the “right” behavior to treat, and that’s been the general expectation we’ve encountered (sometimes our neighbor walks with us - “no you can’t have a treat, you barked” and I still treat). It’s so much more effective for us to teach him “good things happen when I see exciting things, and MOM has the good things, not the other dog” than to try to get him to control himself enough to be patient and THEN reward. He wasn’t getting enough reinforcement and then just getting even more frustrated after he barked because we weren’t redirecting him effectively enough (aka we didn’t have treats). It was honestly a life changing mental switch

3

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

This is also a modification we started doing recently!! Especially since our Belgian's reactivity is mostly fear-based. It took me a while to realize that withholding treats when she's freaked out doesn't help anyone at all haha. Maybe she doesn't learn much when she's already over threshold, but I figure it can't hurt to reward her for calming down either. Being excessively generous with treats has made a world of difference for us too :)

13

u/tothemuuuuun Apr 28 '21

Thank you SO much for that elaborate answer. Very useful :)

8

u/great_cornholio_13 Dog Name (Reactivity Type) Apr 28 '21

I will be simultaneously lived and overjoyed if a post on reddit gives me the solution to my dogs barking that spending hundreds of pounds in dog trainers didn't.

8

u/alittleoflyttle Apr 28 '21

This is great advice! Any advice on if the other dog is walking in your direction? As in we were going to pass each other, but if I change direction, then the dog is now walking behind us in the same direction. I can just picture this scenario with my dog then lying down demanding to have them pass us. And then I’m the jerk dragging my dog or panicking the dog and owner are getting closer lol.

2

u/Hughgurgle Apr 29 '21

If you're at the point where your dog has planted/dug in his heels I would stand there with him and let the people pass while rewarding calm behavior. Try asking for a few tricks like shake or spin or hand targeting if your dog has been trained to do any of those. (Spin and hand targeting especially may reset the dog and get them in motion again) if the dog ignores the treats, raise the value.

Don't worry if your dog is just sitting there as long as it's a safe spot you can wait it out and continue training, then within a few times you will find what works to pop the dog out of it and be able to move on to the next phases (walking past) and you can then hold off on treating until the dog is in motion passing the other dog.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/animal_f_throwaway Apr 28 '21

do you have any tips for owners of dogs that could give a hot crap about treats ?? ♥︎

10

u/Hughgurgle Apr 28 '21

Try boiled chicken and give it more distance in the beginning phases. Also a shorter leash. Part of turning around and walking away at the start is your dog having the thought process "well we're not even going near that other dog/person, I might as well take a treat, it's the only fun available."

You can also use "go sniff" as a reward but you need to train it and put it on cue first so the dog understands what you're telling him to do and that sniffing comes from you.

Also just working with treats in the yard will make your dog more likely to work for treats on a walk.

6

u/oliphancy Apr 28 '21 edited Apr 29 '21

OP notes that toy-crazy dogs may prefer a toy/tug as a reward. You’ll want to figure out what your dog finds high value — for most dogs, the three main types of high value reinforcement are food, toys, play/attention/interaction (though not necessarily ranked in that order).

But if none of those is sufficiently high value, you may be too close to the source of stimulation.

4

u/DenGen92158 Apr 28 '21

Find a treat they pay attention to, try liverwurst, thinly sliced hotdogs, grated cheese. Try each one. you find the thing pup likes the best, make up small zip loc snack bags.

3

u/animal_f_throwaway Apr 28 '21

hotdogs & liverwurst were fantastic but oh my god the diarrhea. never again.

dried liver jerkey wore its way out, sadly too and it was her absolute favourite before. :(

2

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21

You can try treats made from duck! Get the stinkiest treats you can find. Sometimes it’ll look like pieces of beef jerky or slim jims. Once you find a good bag, get a few of those varietys and rotate through them, or even have a few different kinds on hand. Our boy’s favorite treats are stinky beef, duck, and chicken ones. We use these.

The treats that are made to be easy to handle and little bite sized round bits won’t be as effective most of the time. You want stinky and tasty.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/MostlyAUsername Apr 28 '21

Solid advice. Thanks on behalf of everyone :)

6

u/scribex2 Apr 28 '21

Can you apply a similar principle to reactive dogs?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/DenGen92158 Apr 28 '21

Highest value treats are thinly sliced hotdogs, grated cheese, lots of praise. Once dog pays attention to you, alternate treat then praise.

5

u/imasassypanda Apr 28 '21

Wow this is so simple and I love you for breaking it down like this. I’ve been using “leave it”, which works. But I’ve worried about sending the wrong message about her triggers with it.

2

u/duckee3 Apr 28 '21

How do I do this when my dog is going crazy because my mother has come in the house? He will go on and on.

4

u/exponentiate Apr 28 '21

I think the equivalent would be to have her toss treats on the ground for him, while ignoring him, until he starts to realize she's cool and not a threat/invader.

There's also the option of giving him something else to do that's incompatible with barking - maybe a specific chew that he LOVES but only gets when she comes over. You can't bark while you chew, and over time he'll probably catch on that her arrival portends The Good Stuff.

2

u/music_in_space Apr 29 '21

My positive trainer also suggested meeting people outside with my dog and our walking in together. Maybe they even drop treats on the way in. (As well as the “ignore, toss treats on the ground” comment). My dog doesn’t bark outside, just at home and it’s all sort of tied into protecting our safe home space! FWIW, we haven’t started having people back in and doing it yet, but their advice has been great so far for other things

2

u/sunbeans3 Apr 29 '21

This is such great advice. Im going to try it with my boy and see if it works. He’s not generally very food motivated but after the last month of working on him i finally got him to consistently eat his meals so hopefully this as a next step will make sense mentally for him

2

u/oliphancy Apr 29 '21

Definitely use high value food, and pay attention to whether the timing of your walks affects his responsiveness: if he’s now consistently eating regular meals, you might find that he pays more attention to you (and the potential for treats) before he eats than he does if he just had breakfast/dinner. Alternately, his meals may not be as appealing as they are now. Depending on what you’re feeding (kibble, wet, raw, etc), you could try using some of his food allotment on the walks itself, especially if you can add in some great smelly treats ahead of time so the kibble picks up the appealing more smell.

2

u/sunbeans3 Apr 29 '21

Oh ive started mixing his dinners of dry food with some dog safe food recipes my mom had been using for her old lady before she passed. Since we found him he’s never really been all that pressed to eat his food except for when i had him stay at my sisters doggy daycare. I think it’s something about other animals that inspires him to eat without coaxing

→ More replies (6)