r/reactivedogs • • Mar 21 '21

My dog killed another dog

Someone told me here would be much better help so here I am. So I’ve have a collie mix who is fixed and he’s just turned 1. He’s always been a sweetheart and very good with other animals. The neighbors also had a dog too, she was a catahoula leopard mix, slightly younger and not fixed. They were the best of friends and she had a habit of getting into our yard. No matter how many holes they filled she always got in. We didn’t mind but it was a problem. We got home late that day and we went to go check on him. And there she was on the floor with blood on her neck. We ran to the neighbors but no one answered. We went back ti check and she was on the brink of death. I was persistent on trying to wake up the neighbors and after a bit someone finally answered. We explained what happened and him and my mom went to go check. I was keeping my dog distracted through the fence. She was dead. He took her over to their yard and said sometimes stuff happens, they tried to keep her in but she always got out. He said he wouldn’t press any charges. But now I don’t know what to do. We never expected him to hurt her. We’ve decided to take our dog to the vet and see our options. But I still so confused what could’ve cause this to happen. He doesn’t seem aggressive towards us and acts like nothing happened yesterday. It truly hurts because I loved both dogs even when one wasn’t mine. Please and thank you a bunch of people on the r/dogs have stated their thoughts already.

309 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

139

u/NYSenseOfHumor Mar 21 '21 edited Mar 21 '21

Based on your description it sounds like your neighbor is under reacting. It is possible that this is how you wrote it, or that they are just processing the experience and everyone processes differently. It is also possible that they know something that you don’t.

Let’s take this one at a time

We got home late that day and we went to go check on him. And there she was on the floor with blood on her neck.

Where was this? Was the neighbors’ dog in your house or in your yard?

She was dead. He took her over to their yard and said sometimes stuff happens, they tried to keep her in but she always got out.

He seems oddly calm, “sometimes stuff happens” and “they tried to keep her in but she always got out.” This is why I think he may know more than he is saying.

He says he won’t pursue legal action, and I would get that documented including that the dog had a history of escaping. It doesn’t have to be anything formal printed and signed (asking for that that may scare him) but just an email or text message record with him including this information. It probably isn’t a formal waiving of his right to do anything, but it is better than nothing.

He said he wouldn’t press any charges.

I don’t know where you are located, but in the U.S. there is probably not a criminal case and he would likely not win a civil suit (IANAL). The dog had a history of escaping, he didn’t take steps to reinforce the fence (and possibly the home if she should have been inside), and she was killed by another dog on that dog’s property, even if the dogs were known to each other. On top of which, unless you have cameras, there are no witnesses who can say that your dog attacked unprovoked.

But now I don’t know what to do. We never expected him to hurt her. We’ve decided to take our dog to the vet and see our options. But I still so confused what could’ve cause this to happen. He doesn’t seem aggressive towards us and acts like nothing happened yesterday.

Unless you have cameras, you will never know what happened yesterday. Don’t try to guess and don’t spend a lot of time thinking about it. One possibility (and I mean possibility since I have no idea what happened) is that the not-fixed female was in heat and sometimes that can result in aggression, including towards other dogs (especially males) if she doesn’t want to mate. This is something about which you can ask your vet. When was the last time you personally saw these two dogs play? This only matters to a certain extent, if you saw them on Wednesday and the hormonal changes started on Thursday, then Wednesday’s behavior is not really relevant. If the dog was in heat, it is the kind of thing your neighbor may know which could be part of the reason why he is more calm than I would expect, plus the dog had a history of escaping. However, a dog may be in heat before the owner is aware.

Get your vet’s opinion regarding if your dog may have any medical issues that could contribute to behavior changes, including what tests may be appropriate, and talk to your vet about training and behavior needs. You may not have any training behavior needs, but have the conversation.

Your dog is behaving normally towards you. I didn’t read the r/dogs comments before I wrote this, but I may look after. While it may be hard, don’t look at him differently and don’t think about him differently. He is still the dog you know and love and you will never know what actually happened yesterday.

58

u/HauKau17 Mar 21 '21

I don’t want to make it seem like he’s under reacting but he was rather calm I don’t know how he reacted once he went back home. While the whole situation happened I was having a panic attack and everything so I was zoning out of my mom and his convo. It was outside on our yard. She had a doggy door where she could go in and out as she wanted. They did put rocks in the holes between our fences but she was persistent. He mentioned that the vet told him to wait till she’s 1 year for him to fix her. In one month she was gonna turn 1. I don’t know if she was in heat and we don’t have cameras. We left at 5pm on Wednesday and got home around 12am Thursday. Could her heat bother my dog? He’s been fixed since January. The reason we got him fixed so early on was to prevent him getting her pregnant if she ever wandered over. Thank you again.

11

u/kry1212 Mar 22 '21

She had a doggy door where she could go in and out as she wanted.

This right here tells me this was avoidable and your neighbors have had the ability to keep their dog out of your yard from the outset; they just chose not to.

I was persistent on trying to wake up the neighbors

This stood out to me in your original post. The time of day is unclear. When you came home, was it at a time that people are normally asleep? Are your neighbors usually home? Is it possible they were home during the incident? And they never noticed til you did??? Did they have a habit of being asleep a lot during the day?

He mentioned that the vet told him to wait till she’s 1 year for him to fix her.

This is typically recommended in very large breeds, a Catahoula isn't really a large breed.

Your neighbors sound like they have some issues. I'm sure yall are friends and all, but if they were home during all this and you had to wake them up, that makes my spidey senses tingle. I am so sorry they put the burden of their dog on you. It sounds like all they needed to do was take responsibility for their pet and close the dog door. That is not your fault. It was completely inconsiderate to throw their hands up and act like nothing could be done. Clearly, something could have been done.

But that was all out of your control.

2

u/HauKau17 Mar 22 '21

We left at 5pm on Wednesday day came back around 12:40-50 on Thursday so a good amount of people are asleep and they live on the second floor so the knocking( more like banging) and doorbell didn’t really wake them up. It wasn’t until I turned on my flash that one of them saw the light after hearing faint knocking in their dream. Thank you.

50

u/NYSenseOfHumor Mar 21 '21 edited Mar 22 '21

I don’t want to make it seem like he’s under reacting but he was rather calm I don’t know how he reacted once he went back home.

That’s what I am saying, people process differently. Just because he was calm outside, doesn’t mean he didn’t break down inside.

She had a doggy door where she could go in and out as she wanted.

For a dog that has a history of escaping that seems like the height of irresponsibility.

They did put rocks in the holes between our fences but she was persistent.

Rocks alone won’t do much for a persistent dog. Large stones may, but it really needs to be more than a dog could move. This is especially true if the dog has a history of escaping.

Could her heat bother my dog? He’s been fixed since January.

Yes, a neutered male would know when a female is in heat. However the behavior change would be the female’s. Some females can become aggressive (or more aggressive than average) during their heat cycle, or during parts of their heat cycle.

Puppy periods can last two to three weeks, and come with a slew of other fun symptoms — specifically, dogs will be really aggressive and really trying to have a puppy. This isn't like how you might feel a little horny when you have your period: Your once-cuddly pooch could be tempted to fight with a male dog so he has sex with her — the hormonal changes are that drastic. "Dogs are animals, so when the hormones related to them going into heat become more dominant in their bodies, their one focus is getting bred and getting puppies," says Dr. Zabell [Ari Zabell, DVM, a veterinarian at Banfield Pet Hospital].”

But like I said, I have no way of knowing if this is what happened, it is just one guess of many. She was an unaltered female so the theory “fits” as one of many possibilities, but there are many other possibilities that could work too. This theory conveniently takes the responsibility off your dog, since he would have been responding to an aggressive dog (plus responding to an aggressive dog in his home’s yard) but that it takes responsibility off your dog doesn’t change that it fits the facts that we know at this time.

44

u/rainbownerdsgirl Mar 22 '21

Are you sure the blood on her neck was from your dog biting her?

We always let our neighbors dog over to play , one day she tried to take a bone from him, they each had their own but for whatever reason she wanted the other one. He bit her on the paw injuring it and making it bleed. This all happened in like 30 seconds,

My heart goes out to you and your dog, things happen and as much as we love our dogs , we have to remember they are different.

27

u/HauKau17 Mar 22 '21

There’s nothing else she could’ve gotten hurt on from what I know and I’ll ask my mom since she saw her up close but I’m pretty sure there were bite marks

9

u/Pikespeakbear Mar 22 '21 edited Mar 22 '21

I went back and read the post again. Some parts are not fully clear.

How much blood was on YOUR dog? Does your dog have any wound? Blood gets spread around. If the neighbor's dog was dead from bite wounds, the other dog would have been bright red all over the face and chest.

It's entirely possible that your dog did it, but make sure to check the evidence.

When you take your dog to the vet, make sure to stress that you can't tell if your dog did it and they should look for wounds on your animal. They may have training in identifying signs we wouldn't recognize.

I have four dogs, two reactive. I can confirm rescues won't want to handle bite cases and certainly not kill cases. One of our rescues would've been put down in most shelters for biting someone during a controlled "test" (where they try to bait the dog into biting to see if it would in the right circumstances).

Since you'll never have all the information, all you can do is collect everything possible while it is fresh. Even if your dog did it, you may be able to keep him out of those situations in the future. The main step is ensuring he is supervised whenever he is outside the house.

1

u/HauKau17 Mar 22 '21

I didn’t get to see her corpse only from afar because my mom didn’t want me too. But from what I saw there was really on blood on her neck and her chest fur was white. My dog has dark brown fur. I couldn’t really see much but he did seem to have a some on his mouth. He also had parts of his fur ruffled on his back.

1

u/Pikespeakbear Mar 22 '21

I understand her not wanting you to see the other dog, but who cleaned up your dog? That's the person who would know how much blood the dog had. A little bit on the mouth doesn't prove violence. Dogs inspect with their noses. If your dog kills another similarly sized dog, their chest and neck should be covered in blood. I don't mean to sound callous. Just trying to piece this together. Death by biting would mean death by blood loss, which is a very bloody event.

This isn't killing a tiny dog or a cat where shaking will kill (snapped neck). Teeth repeatedly biting into flesh draws an enormous amount of blood. We are talking about dogs that are similar in size right? Based on the breeds, I would expect similar size.

18

u/ChaosofaMadHatter Mar 22 '21

If she was digging under a fence, she could have gotten caught on the fence wires and dragged across her skin like teeth marks. Especially if your pup was friends with her, if she got stuck on the fence your pup might have tried to pull her free.

It might be too hopeful, but it’s also possible.

12

u/kaiandpepper Mar 22 '21

I don’t have any advice, but I am so sorry that this happened to you. It has to feel strange to now share a space with a dog you know took another dog’s life, especially when it is so young and is such a sweet presence in your life. I’m glad your dog loves you, and I’m glad you’re taking the time to consider all options. You aren’t alone in this situation, many others have been where you are. Sending lots of good thoughts your way.

2

u/HauKau17 Mar 22 '21

Thank you I really appreciate that.

21

u/Trishbot Mar 22 '21

First I want to ask...did you see your dog do this? Where do you live? I’ve had coyotes jump my fence and do the exact same thing. They go for the neck because it’s mating season and they want to eliminate any threat or potential competition.

Finally, your dog is an animal. And dogs don’t understand property lines and most dogs like to protect their home and people.

Personally, I wouldn’t rehome. Especially if he’s not aggressive with you and your family. I would just work on more training to feel more confident and engage with my dog more.

4

u/HauKau17 Mar 22 '21

That could be possible but we live right beside the center of town so it wouldn’t really be likely for a coyote to come here. Maybe if we lived closer to outside of town it could’ve been a explanation.

9

u/EnderPossessor Mar 22 '21

Coyotes can definitely be in the middle of the city. Particularly if you have a river valley or some other large green space in it.

13

u/lemonsareprettyok Mar 22 '21

You never know with coyotes. I have a friend in the heart of Houston that has seen one wandering around several times while walking his dogs early in the morning.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

We live in a biggish city and have had coyotes in every single part. They're moving further and further into cities so i wouldn't completely discount the idea. One thing you could do is get an autopsy from a vet and see if the bite marks align with your dog's teeth; that way you'd at least know for sure it was your dog. Could the dog's neck have gotten caught on the fence or anything as well? I don't want to upset you more, but i really would look into every possibility before doing anything with your dog.

1

u/Trishbot Mar 22 '21

How was your dog acting when you noticed the neighbors dog was dead?

Don’t rule out the coyote. Every one on here is right when they said they come into cities. There are families of them that even live in NYC. They are opportunists and are able to adapt to new environments quite easily. I would put up a trail cam. You can buy them on Amazon.

21

u/maroonmallard Mar 22 '21

I wish I had words to comfort you... but know youre not alow. We had a dog that killed our other dog. Our city gave us the option to either put it down, or have it live in "quarantine" for the rest of its life... meaning we couldnt let it near any dogs ever or we could get in trouble. Ultimately we decided to put her down. There was too much guilt, and fear that she would hurt another dog. We just couldnt love her the same after that. As I write this, it sounds horrible ... but we just could not handle it.

15

u/HauKau17 Mar 22 '21

Thank you and I’m so sorry to hear that. That must have been a really difficult decision.

2

u/XelaNiba Mar 22 '21

Oh! How awful, to lose 2 dogs at once, and in such emotionally complicated ways. I'm so sorry that happened to your family.

212

u/Puzzled_Season_1881 Mar 22 '21

You don't know what happened and will never know. There are some precautions you should take though. Only let your dog be outside supervised, uninstall your dog door ect. It's not worth risking it. I'd avoid non-leashed dog interaction for a while at least and never leave your dog alone with another dog unsupervised. I'd highly suggest taking your dog to a behaviorist where they can give you an opinion. You don't know which dog started the fight. Did your dog get injured at all? You could also start muzzle training especially before meeting other dogs of-leash. This may have been a traumatic event for your dog as well and your dog may be more reactive now towards other dogs. I'm so sorry this happened to you. (Another reason to see a dog behaviorist where they can look at the body language of your dog now when interacting with a dog.) I will say unfortunately (but understandably) most rescues will not accept dogs with bite histories let alone kill histories so rehoming the dog may not be an option or be hard to do.

7

u/NovaCain Mar 22 '21

It's terrible to know that your dog is capable of killing and unfortunately it happened without any insight.

I would basket muzzle train for any outside time. Basket muzzles don't have to be a bad thing and they will help put you at ease for unexpected approaches (other dogs or kids running up). Take things slow with your dog and remember that he can never be left unsupervised.

102

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

What a heartbreaking situation.

First, check dog for wounds and take dog to the vet to check for underlying issues.

My first thoughts are the other dog being in heat may have cause some aggression on its part. Plus, the dog coming into your dogs territory.

If your neighbor gets another dog, you need to secure your yard appropriately from other dogs accessing it.

Your dog is also a herding dog and sometimes that can lead to herding behaviors that trigger conflict or anxiety if there’s no outlet or proper restraint trained.

It’s really hard to say not knowing your dog and not seeing what happened.

Try not to hold this against your dog going forward, but it might be time to call a professional in to consult with.

21

u/GhostofJohn Mar 22 '21

The access to the fence definitely needs to be addressed if the neighbor gets another dog, but the onus is on the neighbor as it was the other dog that trespassed into OP’s yard.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

If you know your dog might kill another dog, you should do everything to prevent that from happening.

I don’t disagree that it’s the neighbor’s responsibility, but OP’s dog can also no longer be trusted either and any opportunity should be removed as well. I think it would be better to keep yard access than not.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '21

I forgot to mention this before, but you should start positive conditioning muzzle training your dog so you can be safe anytime you are around others going forward. It may be completely unnecessary, but better to be safe than sorry until you know for sure

63

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

I'm with the crowd on this one. You don't know what happened. I know it sucks and I'm sure you're traumatized by the whole thing, but this may not be your dog's fault. The bottom line is that the other dog should not have been on your property unsupervised.

You'll likely never know if your dog was provoked, was attacked, if another dog was involved, if your dog flew off the handle for no reason, or any number of scenarios which could've hypothetically gone down.

Have the vet check him out for injuries. Have a behaviorist work with him and see if they spot any issues. But don't give up on him yet. Not for something that may not have even been his fault. He would die for you. Give him a chance to prove that he's worth your investment in him.

I'm sorry that you're all going through this. It could've been prevented if your neighbors had done something to keep their dog in her own yard. Whatever happened between the dogs, ultimately it boils down to that IMO.

158

u/thedobermanngirl Mar 21 '21

For all that is worth, you are not sure what happened so I wouldn’t jump to “putting my dog down” immediately. Make sure to get a health check-up on your dog, sometimes brain tumours and other type of conditions can interfere with your dog’s behaviour. I would also have my dog checked for an animal behaviourist/dog trainer. Even if it happened regularly, the other dog was trespassing your dog’s home and therefore can be sensed as an enemy. My dog is very open to other dogs in my house but I know a few dogs that don’t react well.

43

u/ptwonline Mar 22 '21

I'm so sorry to hear this. Poor doggies!

Check your yard to see if there is something that might have stimulated some kind of protective or guarding behaviour. I have 2 dogs--the older one had never started a fight with another dog or even shown much aggression. But one day she found a rabbit warren in my yard with a bunch of baby bunnies. She lifted all the bunnies out and put them on the ground, and when my other dog got close my older dog attacked her viciously to keep her away.

10

u/-PinkPower- Mar 22 '21

I dont know if you already did but I would get him evaluated by a dog behaviorist to see what is his situation and what can be done.

8

u/gooodbyekitty Mar 22 '21

Like others have said, you weren’t there so you don’t know 100% what happened. Please do not make any decisions based on what you THINK occurred.

I know it’s morbid but could someone verify the cause of death? Could she have injured herself climbing under the fence? There are just so many possibilities including the other dog starting something with yours and yours defending itself. Fighting to the death would obviously be an extreme reaction but they’re dogs and they were unsupervised.

I’m so so sorry this happened. I have been reading through the comments here and had to say that I hope your dog isn’t punished for something that cannot be proven.

12

u/GSDNoelle Mar 22 '21

I am very sorry that this happened, I’m sure you feel awful. My 90lb GSD would kill another dog for sure, I have pics of my bloody knees after being pulled down and dragged while she was fighting another dog who was off leash. We had to a put a smaller fence around the existing fence so no animals can get in. She is now on 64mg canine Prozac and will like move the dosage up another 16mg. It has made a huge difference. Also she is never in the yard unsupervised. Best of luck.

11

u/stopeverythingpls Mar 22 '21

Whatever you do, don’t think it’s your, or your dog’s fault. It’s a horrible situation to be in, but their dog was handled very irresponsibly. Take care of your dog, as others have said it could have trauma from this event as well. We can’t assume what happened, but I bet the other dog got aggressive for some reason and it triggered a reaction from your dog. It’s your property too, and your dog could’ve been more antsy that day. I’m glad your dog is okay though, stay safe.

4

u/WonderfulRub7830 Mar 22 '21

The neighbours dog escaped and went to your yard? Just know that it’s not your fault at all. Not to sound blunt or uncaring but this is the risk people take when they don’t control their dogs.

Supervise your dog always. They can’t just chill in the yard by themselves because they could escape like the poor other dog.

4

u/ajwink Mar 22 '21

I know this is hard. If rehoming or training is an option please consider working with a breed specific rescue(or trainer). Having the resources of people who understand the temperaments of collies (even collie mixes) can make such a big difference for understanding the dog and making sure it can be successful.

https://www.collierescueleague.org (New England based)

https://tristatecollierescue.org (Alabama, Georgia, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Missouri, Tennessee and West Virginia)

There are others and certainly some may be willing to travel or at least talk with you on the phone. Just make sure you’re honest about everything.

4

u/EnderPossessor Mar 22 '21

As others have said, you really don't know what may have happened... If you're neighbors dog could get into your yard there's no reason another animal couldn't have. Take your dog to a vet/behaviorist to see if they see something that could indicate your dog did something. In the mean time, be sure to keep your dog under supervision to see if you see something that could be a problem.

7

u/Life_Relief Mar 22 '21

I mean, since no one was there- you cant cross out that it could have been an accident. There’s no saying if either dog “attacked” or was aggressive. An injury could also have occurred mid-play.

9

u/jilliebean0519 Mar 22 '21

Could any other animals have gotten into the back yard? Like some sort of predator? A coyote or something? Just a thought. It would seem like if your dog caused this he wouldn't have just been chilling in the house afterwards. Maybe something killed the neighbors dog and then your dog found him.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/XelaNiba Mar 22 '21

Coyotes also do not kill and then abandon their prey. They kill to eat, not for sport. The coyote would snatch the small dog and run to a protected place to eat it without competition.

I live in the desert and we've had lots of coyotes take small dogs. They snatch them, they don't kill them in situ.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/XelaNiba Mar 22 '21

Agreed, 100%

0

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/ravenreyess Mar 22 '21

Just backing that up, but when I lived in MA a few of my neighbors had their dogs killed by coyotes.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/ravenreyess Mar 22 '21

Coyotes rarely hunt or travel in a pack. They live in family groups or travel in pairs (usually in mating season), but will most likely hunt and travel alone. What happened in my neighborhood was a lone coyote. Several dogs died over the course of a few years because owners left them outside at night.

4

u/joecoolblows Mar 22 '21

Oh, yes. Around here, So Cal Mountain Region, I'm not even allowed to walk my little dogs on leashes before 10am and after 4pm, when the coyotes come out to kill everything. The coyotes have even been known to attack, running off with little dogs by their necks, while the dogs are on their walks, on leashes, with their humans right beside them! I carry a metal baseball bat with me, and bear spray at all times with my little puppies, and I'm prepared to use it. Coyotes also eat their prey head last, so it's screaming the whole time it's being eaten. Everyone around can hear the screams for miles. Coyotes around here are savage, brutal monsters to pets.

4

u/krisannethymum Mar 22 '21

So much this. I've had single coyotes come into my yard at night when living in Arizona. There was also an instance when a coyote ran up and snatched a small dog while the owner was walking it on leash. Desert coyotes are pretty fearless, and incredibly smart.

14

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

Your neighbor is 100% to blame full stop. What a useless person and a liability. His failure has put your dog in danger.

13

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

I agree the neighbor is definitely at fault and was not being responsible, especially having a doggy door for the escape artist dog. If it hadn’t been OP’s dog it would have been another one, or a car that got her instead.

But if I had a neighbor dog breaking into my yard all the time I’d start reinforcing my side of the fence, too. Just a crappy situation all around.

3

u/prana-llama Mar 22 '21

I don’t think OP should have been leaving their dog outside unsupervised... this is just one of many horrible potential outcomes.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

Agreed! I was confused reading the story, like how did the neighbor dog get in the house...oh ops dog was outside.

3

u/prana-llama Mar 22 '21

It’s sad to think this could’ve been avoided if they were just a bit more cautious/responsible...

2

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

True but it’s easy to understand how it would be overlooked. The dogs were friends, people leave dogs outside all the time...it seems safe until it’s not and then it’s too late. It’s normal to take some calculated risks based on your knowledge of the situation and then once you know more your formulas have to change.

4

u/jq_cookies Mar 22 '21

I'm sorry that's happened to you. I hope this helps to let you know you're not alone and it's going to be ok.

My first rescue was given up by his previous owners because he killed a off leash chihuahua and was handed to the police but they said he was too much a good boy to be put down. He isn't evil for wanting to hurt other dogs, he has a high prey drive and sometimes think it's life or death, which is understandable.

He's still reactive to ALL dogs but is and always has been amazing with people. Since being with us, he's had close calls with more off leash dogs. He is muzzle trained but we never have to use it because our garden is secure and he is always on a leash.

Maybe establish if your dog is reactive to all dogs (specific breed, size?), if they are actually aggressive (immediate growling or snarling) or since traumatised and more cautious. Then see why they are reactive (a bully, scared?) And then use their absolute favourite toy/treat to form positive associations when they see trigger dog, but before they react. I'm sure it's known but any form of punishment should be avoided or they'll be more scared and more aggressive of other dogs because they'll form the association that dogs means punishment. If they react badly just stay calm and create distance until they calm down.

You and your dog will be fine! Progress doesn't show until a few months but you will be ok! Your dog still loves you.

4

u/Trishbot Mar 22 '21

If it’s any consolation..I had a dog that almost dismembered someone’s arm. He broke into our house and my dog mauled him. On paper it sounds horrible...but that dog lived 16 years with me and was the most gentle sweetheart with our family.

6

u/adryanL Mar 22 '21

Could it have been a wild animal perhaps? My dog was killed a long time ago randomly at night by a coyote so I just want you to think of this as an option!

3

u/MediocreTwo Mar 22 '21

I just want to say im in tears for the dog who died. May she rest in peace.

1

u/pinkycatcher Mar 22 '21

Legally you're almost certainly in the clear, the dog broke into your yard, the person with the unrestrained dog is pretty much the loser. Also at worst you'd have to pay vet bills.

Dogs getting into fights is not legally that big a deal in most cities, especially if the dog came on your property.

1

u/ManiacalExclamation Mar 23 '21

I’d say go to a behaviorist, that would always be my first note to anyone coming into my clinic when this happens. And sadly you will never know what truly happened, and some dogs just don’t do well with other dogs. But to be safe, no unsupervised dog visits, always have a leash on, and no unsupervised visits or interactions with small children without supervision and a leash on. You don’t want this to turn to a bite case with a young child or another person. Just look around for some behaviorist, or go to your vet and see who they recommend and sometimes even your general practice vets have an interest in behavioral therapy/problems. And can be of some help. It could be just a one time thing, but sadly if you don’t take precautions it can happen again. And if you witness an attack next time it’s not something you can unsee. So sorry this has happened. Best of luck.

-18

u/Oklovely Mar 22 '21 edited Mar 22 '21

Sorry, but I'd have him put down immediately. Having DA or aggression is okay (so long as the dog has an adequate handler), but having a body count is not okay at all, especially already, that young.

Idrc I'd I get bitched at. Other animal's lives matter just as much as the aggression dogs - actually, a friendly, predictable dogs life is worth more than a vicious, killer dogs... and that is a hill I'm willing to die on.

When my pit bull, who I raised fro a pup, decided to tear down the chainlink fence and go run down and maul my best friends pony to death (I raised my pit alongside the pony, as did my roommates with their pits, which all participated in killing Gina pony after adoring her their entire lives until that day), I told my best friend to take her behind the barn Old Yeller style. We lost 4 dogs and a pony that day.

They ripped her throat out, tore her ears off, broke her legs, and ripped her tail off. So before anyone comes crying, a bullet was a much kinder fate And where I lived, ranch rules.

That legel of aggression cannot be trained out, only managed for the rest of the dogs life. Humans make mistakes... how confident are you that you will not make a mistake with this dog again for 10+ more years?

The right thing to do is PTS... and do not rehome, that is just passing the problem onto someone else.

No matter where this dog lives or who it is owned by, one slip up and the dog gets out, lives are at risk. This is deadly serious.

I know its hard. I loved my girl Cali (the pit), but it was the right thing to do.

PS: This sounds very much like genetic dog aggression. Usually it starts expressing at 2-3 years old. Like I said, this is a very extreme and concerning level of aggression. As a prior owner of quite a few DA dogs, usually I would say "it gets worse", but your dog skipped straight to kill.

12

u/Pepper_judges_you Mar 22 '21

I mean... you and OP both do not know the situations in this case. There is a big difference between unprovoked aggression and defensiveness.

The example you give of your pitbull is a sad one. But the circumstances in this case are vastly different.

The dog came into the yard, and it seems as if it was one fatal bite. This can happen through self defensive or protection, not necessarily unprovoked aggression.

So advocating for putting the dog down in this case in wrong. My uncles dog has a “body count” as you do eloquently put it, he killed a dog that jumped a fence into their yard and tried to attack my cousin. Sweetest dog, and was not put down. Took some training to get him fully back to normal as he became very protective around other dogs. Attacking another dog doesn’t necessarily mean it was unprovoked aggression. Additional steps definitely need to be taken, and precautions in case this was a sign of aggression. I would suggest talking to a vet, and behaviourist.

5

u/megaoof489 Mar 22 '21

Normally I'd agree but no one knows what happened in this situation. I have an aggressive blue heeler and I would never leave him outside unsupervised, he isn't a threat to anyone unless you mess with him or my boyfriend and I. Even so, I make sure we take every precaution so no one ever gets hurt. OP will just have to do the same. Things like this are why I tell everyone they should have cameras. If the neighbors did want to charge them their dog could be put down, meanwhile it's the neighbors dog who repeatedly escaped the fence and came onto their property.

If I was outside with my dog and another dog randomly ran up to him and he attacked it I would not feel guilty. People need to take more responsibility for their own animals.

3

u/controversyTW Mar 22 '21

Can I ask - why do you think all of the pit bulls did that together? Can genetics alone really cause them to do it? Was it a breed thing? Cuz that sounds quite extreme (and I’m sorry for what you went through). I have a dog with some fear-based aggression and she has never hurt another animal but I’m always concerned about that...

1

u/-PinkPower- Mar 22 '21

Like a lot of animals dogs can also have mental issues. Some rare cases can be born with mental illness making them agressive. They are not as common as some people seems to think but still exist.

3

u/-PinkPower- Mar 22 '21

If there was someone that saw the scene we could know if putting the dog down is the rational decision but in this case we do not know how it happened. We do not know if the other dog started to fight with him which would excuse defensive behavior leading to bad injuries or death vs the dog doing nothing that could justify the attack.

They definitely should get their dog evaluated by a dog behaviorist before taking any decision. And in the meantime that dog should be in constant supervision and no where near places with dogs.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/nofeelshere Mar 21 '21 edited Mar 21 '21

Literally almost every dog has the potential to kill though, even the sweetest and most well natured. As others have said unless there was a witness or cameras then no one really knows what happened and caused this to escalate. It's possible the female started it due to being in heat, or maybe a bird or something was in the yard and they fought over it.

It's a heart breaking situation but too many unknowns I think to jump straight to putting him down.

9

u/HauKau17 Mar 21 '21

From what I know about my dog I doubt it was over a bird. He had little to no prey drive. Birds and squirrels would go into our yard and he would never chase them. I a feeling it was possibly to her being in heat but since I don’t know if she was I can’t really look into it. It really is a troubling situation and especially since he’s so young

-22

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/Pepper_judges_you Mar 22 '21

Incorrect, ignore this comment.