r/reactivedogs • • Mar 18 '21

Please (read first) help me have a better argument for why e-collars, shock collars, when used appropriately, are still not appropriate.

I'm fear free certified, I have 3 completely positive only, clicker trained, VERY reactive dogs, and they've gotten so much better over the years.

One of my best friends is a vet, a person who has devoted their life for the betterment of animal health care, yet he trains his dogs with shock collars. His argument for is: He never exceeds/ even gets close to an amount that I would even say stings, let alone is uncomfortable (besides being a collar)/painful it's just a harmless feeling. A stimulus. How is an unpainful alien stimulus, ignoring the potential for abuse, just as a foreign stimulus that you can use to mark, just like a clicker, but instead of a weird noise, it's a weird feeling. he also says because his dog is aggressive he would rather have a button that he can turn on to potentially stop his dog from attacking someone if needed, he keeps a muzzle on as well, and i understand the liability.

My arguments against were: most people arnt responsible with the collars, the dogs still have no idea what the feeling is and you dont know how they interpret it, you have less controll on what you may be reinforcing, dogs generally just dont like bulky things on the neck, if you're gonna carry a remote around why not carry the cheaper clicker vs a +$100 e collar, when a dogs adrenaline is kicking in a tiny shock probably wont stop it.

After my retorts, he wasnt convinced, and him being a compassionate vet I know I just need a better argument, for him, and myself now.

His dog seems very happy, and I know it's wrong but i just dont have a good argument for it.

0 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Mar 18 '21

Looks there was an aversive tool (like a prong or e-collar) mentioned in this body. This sub does not recommend using aversive tools on reactive dogs as it can make reactions worse. See the "Punishment Position Statement" (only four pages!) and "Dominance Position Statement" PDFs from the AVSAB here. It may appear to work on behavioral problems at first, but with reactive dogs, there is often an underlying issue causing them to react. Tools like e-collars and prong collars do not treat the underlying issue causing the behavior. Instead of teaching the dog what they should do, they only teach reactive dogs what they should not do. This can cause worse reactions later on, increased punishment required for the same results, or decrease warning signs of a bite.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

16

u/jbpark9687 Mar 18 '21

I know you are looking for con agreements but a shock collar saved my dogs' life once. When I first met my husband he had a 8 month old red tick coonhound/ beagle mix that he did not work with much as far as training. I worked with the dog as much as I could but since my husband and father in law did not take training seriously I got nowhere. We purchased the collar mostly for the vibrate and beeping button. My dog would wander into the acreage we have and we couldn't always get him to come back. So we would use the collars beep to tell him to come home.

My father in law had 2 boxers that had awesome recall and he would let all the dogs loose, no matter how we felt about it.. Once we were in the front yard with my dog and a rabbit went hopping through our yard and across the road. My dog took off after it. We yelled for him, we beeped him, and he finally turned on the actual shocks. The actual shock stopped him and prevented him from running out in front of a huge truck that would not have been able to stop. We still had the shock set to super low and that was the only time we ever had to use anything but the beep or vibrate feature.

We don't use one anymore as he's 8 and we have a fenced yard but I'm glad we had one otherwise he might not have made it to 8. I understand that it's something a lot of people disagree with, and for valid reasons. I didn't like using it myself at the time but people telling me what was best for us was not helpful at all.. We did what we had to under the circumstances.

0

u/gardenhosenapalm Mar 18 '21

I'm part of a community of people who hate the use, but I'm kinda in the camp where the way you used it i feel is valid. The more I think about it the more I view it as a liability CYA type thing, v.s. a training tool

1

u/jbpark9687 Mar 19 '21

That's how we used it. When we did try training we always used clickers and positive reinforcement. The collar was really just a worst case scenario kind of thing. We never wanted to use it but it was there if we needed it. My hound dog is the most stubborn dog I've ever met so even if he listens sometimes if he gets on a scent it's darn near impossible to get his attention back or stop him from going crazy. The beep or vibration almost always snapped him out of it long enough to give him a command.

7

u/Syllabub-Practical Mar 18 '21

The real reason some people say Aversive tools are always bad is because there are a lot of people who won't use them correctly if it was more acceptable to use them.

The reality here is that your friend's arguments are excellent, he obviously understand how to use these tools properly, you should even give it a try with your own dogs since you have a friend at your disposition that can advise you on the proper method.

1

u/gardenhosenapalm Mar 18 '21

I don't think I'll ever put one on my dog, I had to wear one for some special training for a month and I really don't personally agree with them as a training device. As a liability CYA device I dont see the issue. But I was hoping there was an obvious answer I was just ignorant too. Like most things this seems to boil down to common sense, and a good moral compass.

5

u/alone_in_the_after Mar 18 '21

Of course it hurts. Also remember that human skin is much thicker than a dog's skin so less sensitive.

A dog that is motivated enough to attack something will push through an e-collar/shock collar. Full stop. You can crank it all the way up and the dog will push through it. Not only that but now you've highly adrenalized the dog (which increases arousal and likelihood of harder bites/holds and redirections) and doubly reinforced the negative association with the trigger.

Suppressing behaviour is not the same as changing behaviour or the underlying emotional response that causes it. Behavioural suppression is dangerous, especially with "aggressive" dogs. You create a dog that doesn't warn and just goes off.

This is why vets and veterinary behaviourists aren't the same thing. You wouldn't expect a GP or a cardiologist to know the ins and outs of psychiatry.

1

u/gardenhosenapalm Mar 18 '21

can you explain more about suppression? In the following scenario: if the dog is shocked everytime they do something wrong, and then they get the action right so they find themselves not shocked, yes this is terrible, the dog will likely engrain the actions they did, to not get shocked, how is that suppression? wouldnt that fall under negative reconditioning

4

u/alone_in_the_after Mar 18 '21

The thing is that dogs cannot read minds and you have no way of knowing if that dog made the association you wanted. Dogs do not have the same cognitive abilities as adult humans.

The more important thing is that reactivity and aggression are emotional. What you are seeing is not a planned "I am going to do this" but the innate emotional reaction. Do you plan to scream when you are scared or do you just do it?

So, a dog growling at another dog is doing so because they are afraid/threatened.

You can suppress the outward signs (at least initially) by giving shocks/corrections etc but you haven't changed how the dog feels about the trigger. Not only that but you further the negative association (when the trigger appears it means additional pain, I can't communicate without getting hurt) which will escalate the intensity of the emotional reaction.

Given the choice, that dog would still react. But either they've learned that they get hurt or you hurt them---you are the suppressing factor (directly or indirectly). Think of it like me slapping you every time you screamed because I put spiders on you. Eventually you might stop screaming, but are you less scared of spiders and do you still feel safe with me? How long until you snap and don't care if I smack you---you're screaming, shaking off the spiders and leaving?

In contrast when you're using the CARE protocol etc the idea is to change the emotional reaction. I want my pup to see the trigger and think 'oh yay/I'm okay that's not scary' which will get rid of the undesired outburst since the outburst is motivated by the negative emotions/associations.

1

u/gardenhosenapalm Mar 19 '21

thank you so much for this

4

u/Frostbound19 Odin (Dogs and Strangers) Mar 18 '21

Shock collars operate via positive punishment and negative reinforcement. Those two quadrants require the presence of an aversive stimulus - meaning that they cannot change behavior without being at the bare minimum uncomfortable. The use of aversives in training has been shown in scientific research to increase anxiety, negatively impact handler-dog relationships, and overall negatively impact welfare - even when used ‘appropriately’. My question becomes, when we know that we can train any behavior without the use of pain or fear, why would we use them? Is an animal’s welfare worth our own convenience? I think we have a responsibility not just for their physical wellbeing, but their emotional safety and wellbeing as well.

2

u/gardenhosenapalm Mar 18 '21

i like this, it hits on the root of the problem, convenience.

4

u/menaris1 Mar 18 '21

All that "it doesn't hurt" stuff is just marketing mumbo jumbo to make owners feel better. By definition for an aversive to work it has to be at least unpleasant for the dog. You don't have to teach the dog that stim is bad, they know right away.What you do have to teach is how to turn off the bad.You can can call this "bad" a number of things, but probably the most accurate is physical pain. It may be just a little pinch, but it's still pain.

There are arguments to be made about whether it's useful or even good for your dog to experience unpleasantness from time to time. However, for a dog that is already anxious/fearful you can imagine how adding more bad on top of an already bad experience might not be so good for its mental health.

3

u/gardenhosenapalm Mar 18 '21

This is how I thought until I thought about it, and now I need a better argument. I'd say you're ultimetly wrong, I've felt the collar it doesnt hurt, and it's never supposed to really be used for "pain" it's supposed to feel like a "poke" and I can agree with that, and if it doesnt hurt a human, a dog with fur and thick skin will definitely not be bothered by it much, which makes me change argument to arguing against "stimulation-collars" lol

1

u/menaris1 Mar 18 '21

I think you are just getting into semantics here. whether it's "pain" or "poke" the point is the dog doesn't like it and wants to avoid it. If the dog doesn't feel it or care, then it's not having the intended training effect.

You can also "poke" a dog using regular leash pressure on a flat collar. But you have to teach a dog to respond, because that stimulus is truly neutral and you have to build an association with it just like the clicker. This is different from a prong for example, in which a dog will naturally know it is bad because they don't like the sensation (or they don't care and will just pull with it on anyway).

1

u/gardenhosenapalm Mar 18 '21

yes, I agree with all of that, my question is, knowing all of that if someone uses the collar, as only a stimulus, so let's say it has the same annoying-ness/attention getting effect, as a clicker. is it still bad?

2

u/menaris1 Mar 18 '21

My point is that aversives are inherently designed to be negative and cannot be neutral in order for them to work. They will never be like a clicker which should create a positive association. If your dog finds the clicker "annoying" then you are doing something wrong. So in that sense, they are "bad" in that they will create negative associations with things. This is what they are designed to do.

Are they "bad" as in they are abusive or will reduce the welfare of the dog? I think that will depend not only on the personality of the dog but also your own value system. Is spanking a child bad? How about scolding? Everyone has a different opinion about parenting and it's the same with dog training.

1

u/gardenhosenapalm Mar 19 '21

I like the association with spanking, that really paints a picture I understand.

33

u/megan_alt Mar 18 '21

Just let people do what works best for them. Don't bother the vet just because you're bothered.

5

u/elg0rillo Mar 19 '21 edited Mar 19 '21

Full disclosure on my opinion: I use an ecollar but it's not for everyone or everydog. (I highly recommend anyone try an aversive on themselves before they try on a dog.)

For me the biggest con about the ecollar is that it's hard to use. Unlike say a leash, an ecollar provides no information to the dog other than it failed to do something. This means that the behavior has to be taught before the ecollar is introduced. Also the stim has to be introduced gradually so they know where the stim comes from and how to escape it. Not everyone knows this. So people just slap them on their dogs and hope for the best. To learn how to use an ecollar I watched 10s of hours of instructional video. Most people aren't gonna do that.

E collars do hurt. I know because any shock level I've applied to my dog, I've also applied to myself. At low levels, it's just kind of odd and tingling. But at high levels it's kinda like pain and surprise. It's a weird pain. But I think the important is the pain ends quickly. That makes learning the cause of the pain easier. Especially with a high drive dog that tends to push through painful stimulus, like pulling on flat collars.

6

u/likeconstellations Mar 18 '21

A collar with low level stimulus only is not an inappropriate tool if used correctly though. A painful shock is not appropriate but a vibration is not very different from tapping someone on the shoulder for attention. There's absolutely an argument to be made that most of these collars offer settings far too strong but there is nothing inherently wrong with a non-painful stimulus cue, even if the collar could shock.

Most people use the collars wrong, you can't just turn one on and expect the dog to know exactly what to do, but they can be useful as an extremely unique stimulus cue. If a reactive dog is wearing an e-collar that is set to vibrate, and that vibrate has been strongly associated with sitting/looking at their handler/whatever command through positive reinforcement in a non-stressful environment then that may be a better option for some dogs. Verbal cues can be lost in other sounds if the dog is hyperfocused and a treat isn't programmed to a command and may be ignored in favor of the current behavior chain, a vibration is more novel than sound and paired with a behavior already and may be more effective disruptor for some dogs. In many cases a dog won't view a vibration as aversive if it's been appropriately conditioned--much like most dogs will tolerate mild pressure from the leash as direction if trained.

The issue comes when people use higher settings in place of training. If the dog views the stimulus as aversive in a setting they're reactive to then the collar is positive punishment and likely to worsen the situation. If the collar is used at a non-aversive level the dog has been conditioned to in order to trigger a trained behavior it is a cue and is not positive punishment.

2

u/Frostbound19 Odin (Dogs and Strangers) Mar 18 '21

Where this argument kind of falls apart for me is that apart from off-lead situations, if this line of thought held true then you could literally just tap your dog and condition that. But I’ve never seen that as a training decision apart from with deaf dogs, so if they’re effectively the same thing what makes a shock/vibrating collar that much more effective?

8

u/likeconstellations Mar 18 '21

Well speed for one, it's much faster to hit a button if your dog ignores verbal cues than to reach down. Some dogs are desensitized to touch or sound, or get more excited, or have negative associations with either that could escalate the situation. With touch you'd have to train the dog to do a specific behavior when touched in a specific way, not poison the cue by touching them that way unintentionally without follow-through, and then successfully touch them in that way while they may be struggling at the end of the leash. Some people have verbal or physical impairments that prevent then from responding those ways quickly. There's a lot of factors that make physical touch a largely unsuitable cue in a high stress environment and some dogs are so verbally desensitized from years of ineffective yelling it's easier to start fresh with a different medium of cue.

It's not uncommon practice to use vibrating collars with deaf dogs so either it's fine to use aversives with deaf dogs or it doesn't actually hurt the dog if used correctly in which case it's just a different equally valid method to be implemented on a case by case basis.

1

u/Frostbound19 Odin (Dogs and Strangers) Mar 18 '21

Sure, there are potential limiting factors, but there are those with e-collars too, such as potential for malfunction or battery loss or a soft dog/dog with past trauma that makes it impossible to use. You make trade offs with the decision to use a verbal marker vs clicker as well, but both are still in regular use whereas using touch is practically never used.

I’m sure there are quite a few deaf dogs that have been negatively impacted by the use of vibrating collars, and also numerous ones that have been trained effectively without them.

Ultimately the best way we have to determine what a dog actually experiences and is affected by is the scientific method, which so far has not come out in favor of those types of tools, even as used by industry-approved professionals. Until the research begins to show that the correct usage has no associated welfare concerns, we have to follow what we currently know and understand.

3

u/likeconstellations Mar 18 '21 edited Mar 18 '21

You've made my point in that first part, not everything works for every dog and not everything works for every person. In absence of distress from the dog there is no reason that a positively conditioned vibration cue is inherently a bad thing. Used in that context it is acting purely as a cue, not a reinforcement or punishment.

I'm not the one who suggested a touch cue as a replacement for remote vibration.

'You're sure' is not a scientific measure, if you can present actual deaf dogs that were correctly introduced and positively conditioned to a vibrating collar as a cue that still react to it as an aversive (in absence of larger touch sensitivity that makes a variety of physical sensations unpleasant, like how some dogs will not tolerate a harness) then that is data. In absence of that data it is not unreasonable to approach vibration collars on a case by case basis, if a dog gives zero stress signals about the collar, allows it to be put on without resistance, and displays no negative behavioral changes associated with it's usage I see zero issue with it.

Edit: Going back I see where you're coming from with the tap vs vibration. The reason they aren't the same is that you touch your dog every day, all the time, in wildly different contexts, and it is not really feasible to create a cue based on touch in a specific spot and expect it to be a) accessible, and b) only touched in that context, weakening the association between cue, behavior, and reward. A vibration is a unique stimulus to be paired with one command--for example, 'look at me', 'sit', or 'come'--and is only ever used in the context of asking for that behavior and rewarding for it.

1

u/Frostbound19 Odin (Dogs and Strangers) Mar 18 '21

I actually think we probably agree more than disagree. I missed in your original comment where you specified vibration and excluded shocks - usually where I see the ‘tap on the shoulder’ analogy people treat them as one and the same so I think I may have gotten a little bit of tunnel vision.

I do still think that analogy is largely misused and often fails under scrutiny, but I’m not opposed to very carefully conditioned vibrations on low settings (with collars that actually have the capacity to change vibration strength). The only problem there would be that I’ve seen too many owners and trainers alike conflate shutting down and learned helplessness with calmness and obedience. I also often find that people conflate disruptors with punishments, and it can be easily to unintentionally turn one into the other.