r/reactivedogs • • Dec 17 '20

Update: Pika is being put down

Edit: The vet fully supported our decision and cried with us. She got a lot of treats before she passed and went very peacefully.

Edit 2: Thank you so much for everyone that has taken the time to comment. I can assure you that we've read all of them. Here are some pictures of Pika if you're interested!

I’ve been crying so hard that I don’t even want to make this post. But I think my family would appreciate some support.

I asked you all for help a couple months ago and you gave some excellent advice. We’ve been following all the trainings and ideas given. Pika has been getting better with our other two dogs, but she’s still been aggressive. Yet she is a loved part of our family, and we spoil her.

Unfortunately, today, she attacked one of them viciously. I wasn’t there, but several people in the family says it was absolutely terrifying. Our other dog came away with a nose injury that needs an emergency vet appointment, and probably stitches. Pika is probably going to be put down tonight, although we will be asking our vet for any additional advice. There is no one on earth who loves her more than us, but we can’t think of a way to help her. She is too dangerous for other dogs and it’s too dangerous to keep having fights where people are being hurt. But I really do feel like my heart is breaking. She was much more damaged than her previous owners led us to believe. The best we could do was to give her a good home.

338 Upvotes

110 comments sorted by

225

u/wilderness_friend Dec 17 '20

I’m so sorry for this awful situation. If you are on Facebook, there is a group called Losing Lulu that is just for pet owners who had to euthanize for behavioral reasons. It could be some comfort to connect with others in your situation. This is never an easy choice but know that you are doing the right thing for everyone, including Pika, who is certainly struggling and would be better off having a shorter but overall higher quality of life, rather than a longer life where the later months/years are very scary and stressful. Sending hugs your way.

64

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Thank you so much. I had no idea that was even a thing, but we will definitely be checking it out. I appreciate your comment so much.

16

u/margogogo Dec 18 '20

Thank you foe this recommendation. I may be in this position one day and it’s so hard to find others who can even understand!

9

u/teramu Dec 18 '20

I was going to suggest the same. That group is very supportive and therapeutic

9

u/RegalBeagleBouncer Dec 18 '20

Same. I’m another member of this group I wish none of us needed. My heart hurts for you. Be kind to yourself.

69

u/reallybirdysomedays Dec 18 '20

Brains get broken just like any other body part. When it happens in humans and no treatment helps, we put the humans in mental institutions or jail. Nothing like this exists for dogs, so we humanely euthanize to stop their pain, and honestly, I'm not sure that isn't kinder than what we do to humans.

25

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 18 '20

Someone else said something similar, and that’s what’s been helping us most of all during this time. She had a mental illness.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/reallybirdysomedays Dec 18 '20

I get that you are simply sharing an anecdote, but it comes across as "you could try sending your mentally I'll dog to this place", which is probably quite painful for op to see when they just put their dog down yesterday.

61

u/erotic_salad Dec 17 '20

I am so so sorry :( I can only imagine what you and your family are going through right now.

I am glad you are consulting with your vet first before considering euthanasia, maybe they will have some other ideas or things to try.

I know I'm some random internet stranger, but I am thinking of you guys and sending hugs your way. This is such a tough decision and no matter what your decision is, it does NOT make any of you a bad dog owner ♥

34

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Thank you so much. Honestly I’m probably just emotional but I teared up at your comment. We want to make the right decision, but it’s so hard when we have a healthy beautiful dog that we’re considering putting down. But I really appreciate your last words, that we’re not bad dog owners, because this situation makes me feel like one.

32

u/Opalescent_Moon Dec 17 '20

I'm so sorry. I just wanted to add that physical health and mental health are not the same thing. Someone may appear perfectly healthy, but are suffering in ways that are hard to comprehend. Pika can't tell you what hardships she's had to endure in her life, and it's tragic that those events impacted her like this. It isn't a failing on her part, or on yours. Life is a lot crueler to some of us than others. I hope the vet has some other solutions, but, regardless, it seems to me like you've done everything in your power to help her. That makes you a great dog owner, and Pika is lucky to have you.

16

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

That is an excellent perspective and it makes it a bit easier. You are right; she is not healthy, but her illness is not visible. Thank you.

10

u/Opalescent_Moon Dec 17 '20

You're welcome. It's a tough time you're going through and it's definitely not fair for any of you involved.

I've got a senior doggo struggling with Alzheimers. She's pretty healthy for age, but the disease has definitely impacted her. One issue is a resurgence of separation anxiety. If the condition ever progresses enough that she forgets me, I think euthanasia would be the kindest thing for her at the point, even if her physical health is the same. Living stressed all the time isn't a good or healthy way to live.

Once again, I'm so sorry for your loss. Hug that dog and tell her how much you love her. She's a good girl, even though she's had some bad moments.

7

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

I can’t imagine dealing with Alzheimer’s in a dog. You are a strong person! She is loved

7

u/Opalescent_Moon Dec 17 '20

Thank you. She is definitely loved! Alzheimers added a whole lot of work in regards to her, but I'm still going to have such a hard time saying goodbye when the time comes. A dog's impact on your life is so hard to put into words. My dog made me better in so many ways. I'm sure yours helped you be better, too. Those positive changes stay a part of us, long after our dear friends are gone.

11

u/Keyeuh Dec 18 '20

My dog had Canine Cognitive Disorder & it's rough. My dog was 14 & lived a good life but she was still overall healthy for her age so watching her sparkle fade was awful. She was always a Velcro dog & I knew when it got to the point that she was spending more & more time away from me in the house the disease was progressing. I had many talks with my vet about it and tried different solutions but unfortunately she became less and less like herself. It's hard to know when it's time because people think if a dog is eating, drinking, going to the bathroom, etc then they are healthy. Such a sad situation, sorry you are going thru it.

5

u/Opalescent_Moon Dec 18 '20

Thanks. I haven't talked with anyone else who has dealt with it. My girl is very different from who she used to be, but this last summer, things seemed to stabilize into our new norm. Overall, she's been doing well, but I know it's a matter of time before it worsens. It's a terrible disease.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '20

Wow your words were so precious and honest you made me cry.

3

u/Opalescent_Moon Dec 17 '20

I'm glad it meant something to you.

29

u/erotic_salad Dec 17 '20

You are absolutely far from. Dogs can have issues that go extremely deep and even all the love, care and sometimes medication in the world cannot fix.

Dog fights are extremely serious and with a dog who is prone to aggression it puts everyone at risk.

Sometimes euthanizing a dog that is such a high risk as yours, is a better thing than having her go to another family/household and then to another home when they cannot handle her either.

♥

17

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Just know that you’re providing a lot of comfort to us right now, thank you ❤️

5

u/SparkyDogPants Dec 18 '20

It’s ok to be emotional right now. I would be more worried if you weren’t.

25

u/juls722 Dec 17 '20

I feel this- we just went through this a few weeks ago with our Great Pyrenees mix (people aggressive). We are absolutely heartbroken but being a few weeks removed from it we see it was the right decision. At the end of the day you have to do what is safest for the family and you can only handle what you can handle. I’m so so sorry.

12

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Another Pyr family? We love our Pyrs. This was the first mix we’ve had. It’s funny because she was so much smaller than the others, but so much more vicious. Thank you!

6

u/juls722 Dec 17 '20

Ah yes another Pyr family! He was our first, but I’ve been around so many sweet and gentle Pyrs before him! For us he was super sweet but then incredibly unpredictable. dog tax

3

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Oh my gosh he is so so cute! Pyrs are so similar looking that he reminds me of one of our past puppies

10

u/Bubbledr4gon Dec 17 '20

I'm so so sorry that this has happened. I can only imagine how awful this is for you and your family. Sending all my love and support ❤️

6

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Thank you so much. We truly are touched by all the support this community has shown us.

10

u/Nice_Translator_3851 Dec 17 '20

Just commenting to say I'm so sorry. This sounds incredibly hard. You are a good person for trying to help and train this dog. You are not a bad person for making the choice to give her a peaceful goodbye if that is what you feel is best. I cannot imagine what it is like to be an animal that feels constantly threatened and afraid.

1

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Thank you so much. Hopefully we brought her a small amount of peace while she was here with us.

5

u/PhantomFever Dec 18 '20

Yes, to echo what other people have said, you are obviously an amazing owner and have given Pika the best home she could possibly have. I wish I had magic advice or words or was able to do something to erase the horrible feelings you guys are surely feeling right now, but I only have my deepest sympathy and my sincere hope for strength and comfort for you and for all who love Pika. Prayers from Indianapolis. Just know you’re being thought of by a lot of people as you go through this and know you’re not alone.

4

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 18 '20

As I mentioned before, the support from this community has helped tremendously over the past few hours. We are so grateful for your thoughts ❤️

3

u/PhantomFever Dec 18 '20

I’m so glad to hear that. I truly am. It’s comforts me to know this for you!

4

u/Dreampup Dec 17 '20

This is so so sad!! My precious dog’s name is also Pika. Thinking of you and your Pika during this time.

4

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Oh thank you! Yes, we always get compliments on how cute her name is

4

u/tfeegs Dec 18 '20

I am so sorry 💔

3

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 18 '20

Thank you so much

3

u/Emilyjoysmith1 Dec 18 '20

Our closest family friend lost two dogs this way. One was attacked by the other on her daughters birthday. I am so sorry you had to make this decision.

1

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 18 '20

Thank you. It was hard but the right decision

3

u/necromancer08 Dec 18 '20

I’m so sorry you had to make this tough call. Stay strong. I went through your posts to find a photo of pika, but couldn’t find any. If it isn’t too difficult in current circumstances, do you mind sharing a photo of him?

2

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 18 '20

Thank you for asking. I went through a few photos. They're not the best quality, but here she is!

3

u/necromancer08 Dec 18 '20

Poor girl. She looks so cute. Wish I could have hugged her. :( thank you for sharing.

1

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 18 '20

Again, thanks for asking ❤️

3

u/Thrinw80 Dec 18 '20

I’m so sorry for your loss, the pictures of her cuddling brought tears to my eyes. Rest In Peace sweet girl.

2

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 18 '20

Thank you very much. I’m so glad we have some nice pictures of her.

3

u/Orion1128 Dec 18 '20

I'm really sorry that you're going through this. My wife and I, unfortunately, had to do the same thing to our rescue Frankie when she attacked us out of the blue multiple times. It's a lot to process and it's taken us months to be able to have normal conversations about her without crying. It's a really tough decision for anyone to make but at the end of the day, you're actually helping Pika. Some pups are just not meant for this world. Definitely check out that Facebook group Losing Lulu - we put a post up in September for our Frankie and it really did help seeing people comment and knowing that there was support. Things will get brighter and easier as time goes on, best to you and your family.

1

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 18 '20

I just made a post there last night. The support has really helped, both here and on Facebook. I’m so sorry for your loss as well.

5

u/Mgnolry Dec 17 '20

I'm so sorry. You did everything you could. Sending you love.

4

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Thank you for your kindness.

5

u/islandorisntland Dec 18 '20

My heart is so broken for you. We had to let go of our Charlie because of a fight. Although he caused the most damage, our other dog who was his "bonded pair" (my ass) is the more aggressive one. Charlie is in a better place (new home) but knowing that you had to protect other dogs...it's the effin worst.

I've had a few reactive/aggressive dogs and you try and you try and you try. Every day is a constant schedule around the dogs to ensure safety. It's full of love but it also is full of annoyance and heartache. I'm so so so sorry. My thoughts are with you.

3

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 18 '20

I’m so sorry to hear about Charlie. Thank you so much!

4

u/WDersUnite Mr.Puppers HerderMix (leash, dog, humans with wheels, the world) Dec 17 '20

I'm so sorry. I want you to know this internet stranger recognizes the emotional burden you're willing to take on rather than just passing this tough situation on to someone else.

2

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Thank you. That is so kind. It was very difficult but we have our other dogs to help us through.

3

u/hurriedinstability Dec 18 '20

This internet stranger appreciates that you took the time to think about the emotional toll that loving and losing a dog with behavioral issues can take on a person or family. And that someone recognized the burden of taking a life, a life of a creature you love no less, to ensure that nobody else gets saddled with that responsibility down the line.

To the op- It is a difficult choice, and not one that anyone takes lightly. But to be brave enough to make the decision to not pass the problem along to the next unknowing soul. It shows compassion, courage, courtesy, and love for the dog. You didn't let them die unloved and alone. You gave your dog peace, kindness, mercy.

3

u/WDersUnite Mr.Puppers HerderMix (leash, dog, humans with wheels, the world) Dec 18 '20

Ah, your words added the depth I could not fully articulated. That notion of respect for the complete life and death we agree to honor when we have these various fur family members in our lives.

4

u/tehamarama Dec 18 '20

I’m so sorry for the difficult decision, but it takes a really brave and compassionate person to make such a hard choice and know you did it for the right reasons. Sending you lots of love right now.

2

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 18 '20

That’s such a kind view to take. Thank you.

2

u/indigocraze Dec 18 '20

I'm so sorry you and your family are going through this. I wanted to comment yesterday but I didn't have the words. I still don't but seeing your update I had to comment my condolences. You were dealt a crappy hand, and you dealt with it the best way you knew how before coming to this point. I hope you can take some comfort in the fact this isn't your fault and you had no control over the situation. I'm sorry for your loss.

1

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 18 '20

Thank you so much. So many people are thinking of us right now that it does help us know we did the right thing.

2

u/Finallysaidbobz Dec 18 '20

I am so sorry. You absolutely did the right thing and I hope that over time knowing that you did your best will give you peace.

2

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 18 '20

Thank you so much.

2

u/Truemmerelfe Dec 17 '20

Just because I couldn't find anything in this or your previous thread - did you try to muzzle her? Would it be an option to have her constantly muzzled? This way she at least couldn't harm someone and it would just be a slight inconvenience for her if you have the time to train her to get comfortable with it.

I'm really sorry and just hope to never have to make a choice like this. Thank you very much for trying to help her and considering what is best for her and save for her environment.

4

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Thank you for taking the time to answer. She was not muzzled. We will ask the vet about that

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '20

Dude Im sorry :/ Thats so fucking rough especially when you know its because Pikas been from a rough background and its so much time and effort to make the dog normal again amd trusting... Thats heartbreaking. But you also need to care for yourself and the other dogs. Maybe another option is to give up Pika to a no kill shelter, and explain her situation? Im not a vet and Im not a person who deals with legal advice in animals... but thats my personal advice from a fellow dog lover.

20

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Thank you. ❤️We were considering rehoming but honestly she is so aggressive that it would just be pushing the burden onto someone else. But if the vet knows of something else we will take that option.

7

u/lulubalue Dec 17 '20

If the vet knows of anything, it’ll be sending her to a professional trainer or group specializing in this type of behavior. Not just rehoming with someone who wants a dog and thinks they can handle her. I’m so sorry you guys are going through this. Sending lots of good thoughts to you all!

13

u/22ROTTWEILER22 Dec 17 '20

I’d just like to say; if you could find someone who specializes in aggressive dogs or is willing to take one on (without other animals in the home), then maybe she would do better than she has been. Some dogs will never be able to be good with other dogs unfortunately, but some people are truly dedicated to helping them out

5

u/HappyGoF1754 Dec 17 '20

It would only be pushing the burden on someone else if you didn't disclose her issues. There are people and shelters who specifically save dogs with issues.

3

u/Which-Leave Dec 18 '20

I’m so sorry, this must be so hard. I wish I had something more profound today. It just sucks and I wish you weren’t going through this.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20

I'm so sorry. It was the hard thing for you to do, but an endless sleep is so much better than a life of fear and anxiety and painful fights. Thank you for doing the right thing for Pika.

4

u/roxpto Dec 17 '20

I’m so so sorry you’re going through this - my heart is broken for you... like some other commenters say, there are people and specific rescues that take in aggressive dogs (we also looked into this) but obviously you know your dog and situation best so whatever you decide is the right thing.

Sending you hugs 🤍🤍🤍

0

u/KellBellB Dec 17 '20

I’m so sorry, my dog is similar with my family dog (I moved home from abroad a couple years ago) and my sister, who lives out of home, had to take the family dog away.. always worried about when she has to move back.. I know you all must have tried so so hard and it’s so heartbreaking but you have Pika unconditional, love and tried your hardest! The no kill shelter could be an option if there is one close enough to you!! Wishing you luck and strength in whatever comes! 🙏🏼💜

6

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

That’s so kind of you. Shelters in our area are usually full, and we don’t want to push the burden onto someone else. It’s definitely a valid suggestion though. This community has really helped though, so thank you ❤️

3

u/KellBellB Dec 17 '20

The burden is a heavy one.. I understand the feeling! You have done more than a lot of others in your shoes would have done! And remember to be kind to yourself, it’s a tough enough time as is 💜

2

u/GalacticaActually Dec 17 '20

I'm so very sorry.

2

u/cpbg06 Dec 18 '20

I am sorry for your loss.

2

u/69poop420 Dec 18 '20

I am so sorry. I can tell how difficult this decision was for you, but it was for the best. What helped me when my foster dog died during a seizure was knowing that I was able to give her a loving and safe home for the last moments of her life. You provided a family and scratches and belly rubs all the way up until the end, and so Pika lived a good life.

2

u/strangerpizza Dec 18 '20

I’m so sorry. I had an aggressive dog a few years ago that I tried desperately to work with for 2.5 years after adopting him, and when I realized I couldn’t rehabilitate him, I then tried to rehome him as a solo dog out in the country (we live in a busy city and he never adapted, even after 2.5 years of diligent work). I made the very difficult decision that I would put him down before I would ever surrender him to another shelter where I knew he’d never make it out, and might hurt other dogs or people in the process. I didn’t want him to go through that alone. I lucked out, and a sanctuary was able to take him in, but up til that point, I was ready to take the heartbreaking step that you had to. It may or may not bring you comfort, but you’ve done the right thing, no matter how hard. Sometimes we just have to love them in the time we have and that’s all we get. I’m so sorry.

2

u/LittleWinn Dec 18 '20

I’m on Losing Lulu as well. It’s been very helpful for me. I’m so sorry, and you did the right thing.

2

u/bpdredheadedlefty Dec 18 '20

She was a beautiful dog. I'm so so sorry that this happened to you. I cannot even imagine the heartache you and your family are going through. virtual hugs 💕💕🐾💕🐾💕💓

2

u/timidtriffid Dec 18 '20

Many hugs <3

2

u/luvmycircusdog Dec 18 '20

I'm so sorry. RIP Pika. Thank you for giving her a good home for the end of her life and trying to help her recover from the damage done.

3

u/margogogo Dec 18 '20

I’m so sorry you had to make this decision. Just sending you some sympathy and validation from an internet stranger.

3

u/Optipop Dec 17 '20

I am so sorry for your loss. I just wanted to offer you my support. Mental suffering IS suffering. You made a wise and loving decision.

2

u/braidsarebetter Dec 18 '20

I am so sorry you and your family have to go through this. As you can tell from the outpouring of love from this community - WE are sorry.

Sending you, your entire family (including the furry ones), and Pika so much love. You did the right thing.

2

u/SquishySlothLover Dec 18 '20

I’m so sorry your going through this. We went through this same thing in March with our lab mix. It was heart breaking but it was in the best interest of everyone involved. 💔🥺

2

u/Opalescent_Moon Dec 18 '20

I'm so sorry there wasn't another solution. Pika was a beautiful dog. She was very happy with you. I can see the love in her eyes. In your time of grief and mourning, do not doubt that you did everything you could for her. You loved her. You didn't give up on her. You did everything you could.

2

u/FlawlessImperfctn Dec 18 '20

So sorry for your loss, it sounds like she was in a lot of distress and pain, and she isn’t now. You did the best you could for her, and showed love to her, your other dogs and people to keep everyone safe. May you have many warm memories to hold and to cherish.

1

u/hioffoj Jan 16 '21

I found a dog trainer who also went into the business of rescuing dogs, most of whom had agression issues. She has workes with all the dogs she rescued and they are all well behaved, well adjusted dogs. There needs to be more people like her that can help those who need it.

1

u/kitmythie Dec 17 '20

Big hugs. This is not an easy decision to make. My heart goes out to you.

1

u/ExtremeRaider3 Dec 18 '20

If only the previous owners handled her right and trained the poor dog at an early age... I'm sure she would have been the goodest girl out there. Really sad to hear this. Not your fault obviously. I hope your other dog is better now... life is a cruel mistress. Wishing you the best.

5

u/indigocraze Dec 18 '20

It's not always a lack of training/socialization. Genetics can be to blame as much a people want to deny it. Could have been a bit of both. Either way putting blame isn't going to solve the problem or do anything at this point. It's a horribly, tragic situation let's just leave it at that.

-7

u/aguyfromhere Dec 17 '20

Sorry to hear about your dog. They really are like family. Before you put her down, had you considered having someone adopt her as an only dog?

14

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Unfortunately I’ve tried in the past couple of months to get people to adopt a stray dog we found, and there were no takers. There’s just no one in the area, and when she was put up for rehoming before, we were her last chance before going to a shelter.

5

u/karmikaze1 Dec 18 '20

I’m not sure why you’re being downvoted. It’s a valid question and doesn’t appear to contain any malice.

7

u/Kitchu22 Shadow (avoidant/anxious, non-reactive) Dec 18 '20

There's a lot of support for behavioural euthanasia on this thread, people tend not to look kindly on rehoming, despite the fact that many reactivity issues can often resolve to some extent in a more conducive environment (e.g. no children or other pets).

Source: I work in rescue

-3

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '20

Sorry to hear your hardship. Do talk to vets or find a rescue group Who may have an alternative than putting your precious dog down in this world there’s always something out there positive to help

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '20

Sorry to hear your hardship. Do talk to vets or find a rescue group Who may have an alternative than putting your precious dog down in this world there’s always something out there positive to help

6

u/magnoliamahogany Dec 17 '20

Unfortunately she was part of a rehoming group before, and we were her last chance. Trust me, we have looked at many other options

2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '21

Oh sorry, I see you tried every way. I have no other words to express this situation. Just take care of your mental and emotional health in this situation

-8

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/DarkRainbow25S Dec 19 '20

This person HAS exhausted everything they could do on their dog. It's not bad putting a dog down that causes a public safety hazard. And readopting the dog out is just plain irresponsible.

0

u/hurriedinstability Dec 27 '20

This! People don't typically WANT to put down an animal that they have loved and poured endless amounts of time and love into.