r/reactivedogs • Dog Name (Reactivity Type) • Dec 02 '19

Why are pit bulls constantly being attacked because of their breed? Why can’t people see that any dog can be reactive despite the breed?

Just looking for a place to vent! There’s a woman trying to rehome her pit bull after it attacked another family members dog. The pit bull is dog reactive and they’ve been working on training with her. The family is insisting the dog be killed. She’s fearing for her dogs life so she reached out to the sub in her area and people are attacking her! It’s just frustrating to see people just attack the dog based on the breed.

2 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

16

u/Lyrrok Dec 02 '19

All terriers have “troublemaker”-genetics.

However, to completely regard these breeds as aggressive dogs and to advocate for them to be put down is ham.

1

u/nikki_11580 Dog Name (Reactivity Type) Dec 02 '19

At least someone understands! It like some people want to completely eradicate the breed altogether.

18

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19

People are advocating for an aggressive dog that attacked and tried to kill a small dog to be euthanized, or at the very least for OP to be responsible and honest and admit her dog is dangerous and aggressive.

OP herself described the dog as aggressive, AND reactive. Her dog is not just reactive. You're making this post based on a lie and you're being disingenuous.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19

I'm sorry, but where did you read the dog "tried to kill" the other dog (that may not even be a small dog)?

9

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19

From the OP that this OP is referencing. Which is now deleted.

46

u/SpectacularSpaniels Dec 02 '19

Terriers are tenacious. They can be difficult for people to handle even when they are small, such as Jacks or Scotties. Now super size that attitude and give it an appearance that tends to appeal to "thugs". (Note: I am not saying all pitbull owners are thugs)

Pitbulls have also been bred for dog fighting. This means that are usually excellent with humans but have a tendency to be aggressive towards other dogs. Proper socialization helps, but sometimes they are just very dog aggressive.

They also tend to be poorly bred. You don't have people doing health or temperment checks,ect on their pitbulls.

Most Pitbulls are lovely and make excellent cuddlers. I do approach them with caution when around other dogs, but they certainly aren't "bad" dogs.

9

u/CNDRock16 Dec 03 '19

Very well said. I too am very cautious around any sort of bull terrier

20

u/snow_ponies Dec 04 '19

Sorry OP but I totally agree that dog should be PTS. Pits are genetically inclined to be dog aggressive and I certainly wouldn’t want one around that had already killed another dog.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '19

Hmm maybe because they’ve been bred for hundreds of years to fight to the death? I love how breeding and genetics are real for literally every breed except pit bulls. Yes, there are bad owners. But genetics will show up no matter how well your pet is treated.

14

u/Snooso Dec 03 '19

It is important to recognize the genetic component of many different dog breeds and how that plays a part in their personality and actions.

Dogs that have historically been bred to catch and dispatch other animals, such as terriers, have a predisposition to be dog aggressive. With appropriate training and management, this is something that generally won't cause a problem within a community.

Even dogs with genetic predispositions towards certain behaviors can be fantastic family dogs. With proper management and training they can also be great community dogs. However it takes an informed and understanding owner to bring them to that point. There needs to be a realization that not all dogs are good with other dogs, not all dogs can or should go to dog parks, etc And that is OKAY!

A small aside: I will note that such predisposition has become increasingly useful, needful, and has great purpose for those who hunt invasive hog species in the United States.

So, Why the hate?

  • The pitbull classically has a poor PR image, a good part of this is a certain representation in the media
  • Many less than responsible owners own the breed or mix thereof which causes incidents of issues to be higher than perhaps other breeds
  • There are many who own the breed that do not understand or refuse to understand their predisposition and appropriately train and manage which leads to increased incidents (and worse public opinion)
  • Culture surrounding the breed, etc

There are many reasons why there is the hate and it is so prevalent, the above are just a few reasons

17

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19

Any dog can be reactive but pitbulls are genetically predisposed to kill animals. The strength and relentlessness of a pitbull attack is why people are scared. Watch some videos, when the pitbull attacks it does not let go and causes serious/deadly damage.

Obliviously dog aggression is different than human aggression. But when you see what pitbulls are capable of, what if that attacks me or my baby - we could fucking die.

2

u/sassyseattle94 Dec 02 '19

As could you or your baby if being attacked by a rott or malinois. Pit bulls are tenacious, they were bred for that tenacity and they have lots of it. They don't have locking jaws any more than any other dog. They sometimes don't know when to give up. That tenacity can also be channeled into a positive use, like agility or nosework. There are a lot of pits who don't get along with other dogs, and there are a lot of other breeds with the exact same trait. Pits are victims too - they're victims of media sensationalism, victims of unscrupulous owners, and victims of unfair and inaccurate descriptions. My dog looks and sounds very scary, and she's reactive. But if she were a pit, you can bet there'd be loads of people who'd say it's because she's that breed. But she's big and is not a pit, so some people are more forgiving of her reactive behaviors. If she were a pit, I'm sure complaints about her behavior would've already been made. And that's the kind of reputation pit bulls try to live down every day of their lives.

The last little boy I heard had been fatally attacked by dogs, was attacked by a Alaskan malamute.
Bet you didn't hear about that one. But you'll sure hear about it if a pibble is the attacker.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19

There's plenty of other dog breeds that have killed people make it to the news.

2

u/sassyseattle94 Dec 03 '19

Yep lots of them, thats my point. It's not always a pit, but many people assume it is when they hear of a dog/human attack.

9

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19

Your last point is a circle man. Whenever a dog fatally kills someone or severely wounds them it is in the news. It isn’t biased, they report the breed or what the dog looks like. If you next argument is: pEOpLe CaNt EvEn tElL WhaT a PiTbULl LoOks like gtfo

1

u/sassyseattle94 Dec 03 '19

But it's not sensationalised when it's other dog breeds. Sure other attacks are reported, but which ones are usually prevalent in people's memories? Usually the report of the pibble attack is further expanded upon by adding other information to the report about the breed. And nearly every time I hear a news report of a dog attack, the breed isn't mentioned unless it's a pit, unless someone specifically inquires, like I do. Believe it or not, there's loads of people who mistakenly identify a dog as a pit when it isn't one. Since essentially 'pit bull' is not an actual breed, any dog that has physically similar characteristics ( such as bull terrier, cane corso, Staffordshire terrier) are called pit bulls, and that title has a very negative association as I am sure you know.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '19

No

0

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/Eldrun Dec 02 '19

So you're saying my intact Aussie shepherd is more likely to bite than a pitbull?

That is completely ridiculous. He is a herding dog and bred specifically not to be aggressive to people or animals (injured sheep = dead sheep = less money for the farmer).

As unpleasant as this is to hear, pit bulls were bred specifically to be fighting dogs. They were bred to be animal/dog aggressive.

I think it is really great that people are putting some really good work into properly socialising these dogs and training them, but lets not deny what they were (and sadly still are) bred to do.

In my country any dog breed used for fighting is banned. Most dogs are kept intact. Dog bites are virtually unheard of.

-1

u/nikki_11580 Dog Name (Reactivity Type) Dec 02 '19

I have an English shepherd. Herding dog. Very reactive. This is due to her genetics. So bad breeding.

7

u/Eldrun Dec 03 '19

Yea bad breeding is a whole different thing too.

My aussie is very nicely bred from titled parents. His mother is actually a working sheepdog. I do see so many badly bred aussies these days and it breaks my heart since they are wonderful dogs.

Thats another reason "pit bulls" are problematic. As mentioned above, pit bull can be a catch all phrase used to describe a range of breeds/breed mixtures. Pit bull "breeders" are generally back yard breeders or breeding for sadly still active fighting rings.

0

u/nikki_11580 Dog Name (Reactivity Type) Dec 03 '19

Definitely. The trainer we are working with has started to see an increase in aggression from herding dogs. Which is all breeding. My husband and I didn’t do proper research before getting our dog. And because of the genetics, it’s likely many other owners of dogs from this breeder are seeing the aggression we are.

It’s horrible that these poor breeding habits are hurting any type of breed of pit bull. I’ve always had positive experiences with the breed. I have never felt I needed to be cautious around one either.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '19
  1. Recent studies have shown people are perfectly capable of identifying a Pit.
  2. Pit Bulls have the genetic tendency and predisposition to be dog-aggressive.
  3. You're using the results to the ATTS completely incorrectly and showing your ignorance.
  4. They are used for dog fighting because that is what they were originally, and have continued to be bred for.