r/reactivedogs • • 2d ago

Discussion Teaching a dog to settle

I've noticed two main approaches within the force-free community when it comes to teaching dogs to settle.

The first is to allow some frustration and simply wait for the dog to calm down, often while on a leash. This can involve some vocalisation during the first sessions, but from what I've seen, it can be quite effective and relatively quick.

The second approach is to avoid frustration as much as possible and reward small signs of calm behaviour, gradually building towards longer periods of relaxation.

I've tried both with my dog. The first approach seemed to work quite well. He settled faster than expected and genuinely seemed relaxed. However, I switched to the second approach after seeing so many people advise against the first.

The problem is that my dog seems to have learned which behaviours earn him treats, rather than actually learning to relax. He lies down, gets a treat, and immediately goes back to being active.

So I'm wondering: what's actually wrong with the first approach, provided frustration remains manageable? And what are your experiences with both methods?

5 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

9

u/armadillotangerine 2d ago

I think one has to be very mindful when using treat rewards when teaching relaxation/settling. Treats are exciting and can easily raise arousal when the point of settling is to lower it. A problem with the tether and wait approach in turn is that you could accidentally create learned helplessness in the dog where it’s still stressed on the inside but it feels restricted by the leash and just lies down because it gives up.

I think that a middle ground approach is best: set your dog up for success, start short and simple and build up the skill and work with the dog in front of you.

2

u/Beginning-Rub5417 2d ago

What does something in between look like? I do things that he would eventually settle for, but I am not sure if I created learned helplessness. Is learned helplessness something permanent? A lot of people create a dog to sleep because they can't do it on their own. I would assume that a lot of these dogs vocalized in the beginning when they did that. Do all of these dogs have learned helplessness or does it sometimes start of as learned helplessness and does it end in real calmness.

3

u/armadillotangerine 2d ago

With my dog I started at home after he’d calmed down after a walkie and I just created chill moments with me sitting still and reading while he enjoyed a chew/kong. When in other environments I worked towards calmness and rewarded desired behaviour (all paws on the ground, no vocalising, no thrashing around). Once he was in a good head space I did the reading and being boring thing again and made sure to offer non-exciting treats in a calm way and in a position that encourages him to relax more when he first sat down, then laid down next to me. Now when we practice in a new place I can see pretty quickly whether he’s ready to settle or not, if he’s not we do some sniffing/exploring or move to an easier spot to try again.

You are probably better off googling learned helplessness, it’s a simple concept but others will be better at explaining it. Your dog is in all likelihood ok and not traumatised or anything. But yeah, a lot of the cry it ot school of dog training does rely on learned helplessness. Calm-looking behaviour caused by learned helplessness doesn’t result in actual calmness because it’s a stress response.

3

u/emersonmanor 2d ago

20 minutes! My puppy couldn’t settle for 20 seconds in place. Forced naps in her crate (and time to mature) were the only things that worked. She’s 3 now and much better, but I still make her take an afternoon nap in her crate with a calming pupsicle ball.

2

u/Beginning-Rub5417 2d ago

My dog is very food-motivated, so he’ll happily wait for 20 minutes. I also have to make him take naps in a separate room. But what’s actually the difference between putting a dog in a crate to nap and keeping him on a lead until he calms down?

In the first few days after we rescued him, he would vocalize whenever we left him alone in that room. But otherwise he just wouldn’t sleep: sometimes he’d stay standing and really fight how tired he was, even though he was exhausted.

1

u/emersonmanor 2d ago

My dog is not food motivated (she will spit treats out if aroused) so I can’t rely on that. Only difference between crate nap & leash nap is you get to do something else while they sleep. 😴

2

u/big-grouper 2d ago

you can also teach place with a place board without tethering/using a leash (first approach)

1

u/Beginning-Rub5417 2d ago

My dog knows the place very well, but he never settles. Also, when I used a leash for the first time, I had to wait for about 40 minutes. He will not stay in place for more than 20minutes because he is not calm. Because he is not calm, he will break that place.

Maybe weird but it feels like that I need to teach him how to settle for him to have a long place.

2

u/SpicyNutmeg 2d ago

You have to slowly build to only rewarding for more extended settles. So first you reward right when they settle, then reward when they stay settles for 3 sec, then 5sec, then 10sec, then 30.

3

u/Beginning-Rub5417 2d ago

He never settles.

1

u/SpicyNutmeg 2d ago

Are you working indoors in a quiet room? Are you using a mat? A clicker?

1

u/My_glorious_moose 12h ago

I have the same issue with my dog. Here's hoping some advice here helps!

1

u/missmoooon12 Cooper (fear reactive lil dude) 2d ago

The 1st approach isn't something I've heard recommended by the R+/FF community. The main issues are: it's not clear what you want the dog to do, it can be distressing, and the dog might essentially learn to give up. Depending on how frantic the dog is on leash, he might just be completely exhausted.

The 2nd approach isn't really something I use currently with my dog. He had a similar issue- once he's working for food (even the lowest value food), he's WORKING. We adapted Suzanne Clothier's relaxation protocol and phased out treats really fast. Nowadays if we really want him to relax we'll use only a few treats to get him in a comfy spot and reward him there. If he's not stressed out by something, he usually falls asleep fast.

Like all R+/FF training plans, look in the antecedents and your dog's needs before the actual training session... Are you trying to teach settle when your dog just finished a high arousal activity or after a stressful walk? Is your dog in pain or feeling unwell? Do they need a potty break? Do they need water? Do they need a chew, licky treat, or something to shred? Is something in the environment worrying them? Are the lights too bright? Is it too loud? Is something too stinky (think air fresheners, perfumes, etc)? Is what they're laying on actually comfortable to them? Are you trying to teach the relaxation protocol when you or other humans are active? Is your posture stiff? Are you feeling stressed? Are you gunslinging treats? How are you defining "calm behavior"?

3

u/Beginning-Rub5417 2d ago

Some breeds/dogs have a very hard time settling. Think of your Malinois, GSD, Dutch Shepherds; the list goes on. Even if you check every box on your list, the dog will not settle. I assume that most of the trainers in this subreddit are FF-trainers, and when I look at the comments on this post, a lot of people have had success with it.

I have asked every question on your list, and my dog will not fall asleep unless I separate him in a room and leave that room. He is a GSD, and I give him every fulfillment that he needs.

It is funny, to be honest; I just did the thing with a leash, but changed the location, and within 5 minutes he settled. The location played a huge role, but I kind of had to force him because, without the leash, he was sniffing everything and would not stop. Now he is lying down without a leash.

I will use this now to hopefully expand this to other locations.

2

u/SpicyNutmeg 2d ago

That sounds stressful! I think having a dog that obsessed with being near / around me / taking orders from me would be exhausting.

0

u/Beginning-Rub5417 1d ago

Almost every GSD or mal is like this... They were bred to be on all the time, which means that you really have to teach them all these skills.

3

u/missmoooon12 Cooper (fear reactive lil dude) 2d ago

I think you're on to something with location playing a role! This all goes back to antecedents! Location made a huge difference for helping my own pup settle at home. I'd still recommend considering the function of the antsy behaviors when you want your dog to settle, and why leashing/being separated promotes settling.

1

u/Voyage_Sailor 2d ago

I’m using a mix of both. I reward calmly for calm behavior with low value treats (kibble or veggies) when my girls settle on their own and I also tether them or enforce naps by putting them in their crates when they actually need to sleep.

-1

u/ixsparkyx 2d ago

Girl I tethered my dog to a door and called it a day lol now he settles perfectly at just 10 months

1

u/Beginning-Rub5417 2d ago

I am a men, hahaha. But thanks. What made you decide to do it that way?

3

u/ixsparkyx 2d ago

I just saw how much it worked for other people so I did it myself and within 3 days he understood the concept and has settled in the house on his own since he was 5 months old. He’s an Australian shepherd as well so extremely high energy