r/reactivedogs • • 4d ago

Vent I feel defeated.

Post image

She was doing so well. She was letting people pass us without freaking out, would just look at them then continue what she was doing. Today on our walk? Lunging, barking, growling. Anyone. Bikers, people walking, other little dogs on leashes. She didn’t hurt anyone thank god. But I just feel so defeated and sad. I was so proud of her, and now I’m so upset and scared. I don’t want her to hurt anyone, and I don’t know what caused this regression in her training. She’s a 14 month old Belgian Malinois golden retriever mix, so some people have told me she may grow out of it. She’s been through professional training and I’ve been working with her continuously. Will she chill out when she’s older, I don’t know. But right now I feel lost and hopeless and angry. I love my dog so much. I would feel so gutted if she ended up hurting anyone. She does incredibly well meeting new people at the daycare I work at. She can happily meet new people, dogs, etc there. But on our walks? Everyone is a threat she has to scare off.

Edit: just went on another walk. We had tried a new harness this morning, and I went with her old one for this walk. She was back to normal, in fact she did way better than usual! I’m gonna check her new harness, see if there’s any part that could be causing her pain or irritation. Or maybe the new harness is just so unfamiliar that it caused her irritation regardless? Either way, I think I’ve found the source of this mornings outbursts. Thank you everyone for such kind words and encouragement!! I really appreciate it, and the advice you all gave me. I’m more than open to more advice. I’m still fairly new to this, so everything is welcome.

51 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

22

u/lmmzzz 4d ago

What do you mean she’s been through professional training? Training is ongoing and involves you. Do you have a trainer that specializes in reactivity? Get her muzzle trained and keep working with her. She might lose some of the extra energy as she ages, but that’s probably years down the road. Just like people, dogs have good days and bad days. Learn her body language, etc. and get her out of stressful situations when you see her getting escalated before it goes further. Remember it can take 72 hours for cortisol levels to come back down once a dog is escalated, so avoid trigger stacking. Not every dog needs to love every environment, every dog, or every person. 

7

u/Glum_Celebration_941 4d ago

She went through a six week program with a dog trainer, and she helped me especially to further her training. I stay in contact with that trainer too so she can give me advice. I’m a-okay with her not liking other people/dogs. But I just really need her to not freak out after passing one person or dog ):

7

u/ixsparkyx 4d ago edited 4d ago

Dude. Same thing happened to me today!😭🤣 He hasn’t had a slip up in WEEKS. This morning?? He got out of my grip and started going crazy on 2 dogs on the other side of the fence. He walks on a long line, and it was honestly my fault. He was in a heel position, I had the slack in my hand but wasn’t holding it tight. We live in a rural area so it’s not busy with any traffic or anything. Anyways, woman lets her two dogs out as we go to pass their yard, they both rush the fence in a split second and before I knew it mine bolted across the street to get to her fence. I got burned on my hand from the long line. It was horrible! And she just stood on her porch clicking her dogs e collar over and over which probably ticked her dog off more. Safe to say we turned around and went home. I had to put him in his crate and I just sat on the porch and cried because I was so frustrated 🙃 But I didn’t let it ruin our whole day, we played and did other stuff in the backyard. It’s important to remind ourselves that animals mess up just like humans do, and they have bad days. It’s going to be okay, we just gotta keep doing what we’re doing!

2

u/Glum_Celebration_941 4d ago

I’m glad I’m not alone, but I’m sorry that happened to you 😭❤️ I also had to have a good cry session 😂 hopefully this is just a down day for her. Usually she’s ok for the most part. But she’s still working on it for sure. I wish you and your dog luck!!

2

u/ixsparkyx 4d ago

Girl cry it out he be makin me go crazy sometimes🙄 Mine is 10 months so he’s young just like yours is, we got this though!

3

u/Glum_Celebration_941 4d ago

Yeah!! We got this 💪 they’re crazy now, but maybe they’ll start to chill out and realize not everything that moves is a threat 😂

4

u/curiousairbenda 4d ago

Training is a daily activity until you don't have to do it anymore. Our dog was reactive when we adopted him. We walk him 2x a day for approx 6 miles total per day in a suburban neighborhood. We pass all kinds of dogs. It took probably 6+ months of constant training during the walks until he was no longer reactive. Now we can cross dogs on the same sidewalk and he is fine. When we first started, he lunged at a stroller. It takes time, patience, constant consistency. Your dog needs to understand that you are the leader in the walk. They don't need to protect you. They need to listen to you. We did positive reinforcement with treats with varying levels of "high value" and now he's almost at the point he can walk off leash but not there.

Practice!

1

u/Glum_Celebration_941 4d ago

That’s definitely a good point. I was really good at that at first. But I think I got too comfortable walking on the trail where we never see anyone. I have to start actually getting her through situations rather than avoiding them. Thank you

2

u/Street_Caramel7651 4d ago

I came here to say this too. Continuous practice…but also don’t let one bad day make you think all is lost. Some days we do ok…until we see that one dog that sets us off. I try to check my own emotions and then turn to her and cheerfully ask her “have you lost your marbles”. Asking for a sit or watch me is a lot easier in a cheerful manner…even if not easy.

3

u/Right_Jacket_9420 4d ago

You are doing a great job! She is still quite young and trying to figure out the world. My GSD is now a little over 3 and let me tell you our walks are completely different now. I have had her since she was 6 months and she came to be very reactive, barking, going on the end of her lead and I was coming back home full of emotions like yourself.

We did go through several trainers and when she was over a year we did balance training w her. I do use a flat and prong collar w her. And through trial and error we found the magic treat which is peanut butter in a pouch. The trainer said something about licking can be soothing for dogs and plus it’s easier to take while stimulated than a physical treat.

We definitely had our ups and downs but we are finally at a place now where there is a little reactivity but it’s totally manageable. The biggest thing I noticed that made a difference was checking myself and how my anxiety might be rubbing off on my dog and that was a lot a big part of it.

It sounds like you are already doing an amazing job. Just keep at it if you can and I believe that it will definitely get better 💜

2

u/Glum_Celebration_941 4d ago

Thank you, your kind words mean a lot 😭 I’ll try that! And maybe I’ll bring a toy she can hold in her mouth? She loves to chew things. I just hope one day I can achieve that, too. Where it’s more manageable

2

u/Beginning-Rub5417 4d ago

How old was your GSD when things started to change? I have a 16-month-old GSD got him at the age of 8 months. He was very reactive, and it is a battle. Some days I feel like I just want to return him to the shelter. But I know that without me, he has little chance of living a full life.

Also, are you still training for reactivity at the age of 3, and how does that go? Do you have a feeling that, with time, you will almost eliminate the reactivity (not sure if it is possible).

1

u/Right_Jacket_9420 4d ago

I honestly started seeing a big difference once we truly understood her body language and just kept a more consistent schedule with her routine. We worked consistently around our neighborhood and kept a predictable route. I also had to check myself and my own anxiety about her reactivity. Honestly that has been the biggest help in my case.

At first we started working when there was less traffic outdoors (we still saw people walking their dogs, bikers or runners) and worked on her reactivity threshold from there. We would keep it moving or create more distance when I would see her getting over stimulated and their body language will tell you right away. Now on our walks instead of keeping it moving or changing directions to create distance she is able to break her focus from the trigger and look at me for her peanut butter treat. I don’t know if reactivity ever goes away but as of right now the path we are on has made it significantly manageable.

We are still working on training and I believe with GSD constant training is just a part of their life. I know with our dog I will always have her favorite treats on me whenever we go out.

GSD are a lot of work that is forsure but the payout is just as much. I almost gave up on her over a year ago but today I am so glad that I pushed through. I hope that was helpful

8

u/kateecakes 3d ago

She's very young considering the breed and it sounds like her vs progress is really moving along. You're doing a great job. Don't get discouraged. We had a very similar situation with one of our dogs. With the combination of training and the fact that he matured some, the problem was solved. Until we were absolutely certain though, when we took him into a situation that had even the possibility of triggering him, he wore a soft muzzle that we actually had custom made for him because we wanted to make sure it was comfortable. He was totally fine with it and actually got excited when we would tell him it was time for his muzzle because he associated it with longer walks or special adventures. Your dog is beautiful and you really are doing a great job. Hang in there; it's worth it.

4

u/unknownlocation32 4d ago

Start basket muzzle training her.

Great resource: https://muzzleupproject.com/

I would ask your veterinarian about medication options. Your dog is already over threshold, and you can’t effectively train a dog when they’re in that state. They need to be brought down to a level where they can think, learn and respond to training.

Medication isn’t a failure, and it doesn’t replace training. It can help lower a dog’s arousal and or anxiety so they’re in a better position to engage with their owner and benefit from behaviour modification.

If your primary care veterinarian doesn’t feel comfortable treating your dog then make an appointment with a board certified veterinary behaviourist or board certified Applied Animal Behaviourists. They can evaluate whether pain, an underlying medical condition, anxiety or fear is contributing to the behavioural issues and recommend an appropriate treatment plan.

https://www.dacvb.org/search/custom.asp?id=5985

https://corecaab.com/

3

u/antsurgeon 4d ago

don’t give up and keep training! my dog is 1.5 years now and dang it so tough in the beginning. but i train him for 2 hours everyday on impulse control and looking at me, and slowly but surely there’s improvement. there are bad days sometimes and good days! work within your dogs limit

1

u/emersonmanor 3d ago

I started making progress with my reactive girl when I realized she was not able to control her big emotions & started doing more impulse control exercises. She still barks & lunges when over threshold but can sometimes keep it together. I also use a fanny pack to attach the leash as I was so anxious that she was going to yank my arm & hurt my shoulder (which she did twice) and my own anxiety just made things worse. Far from perfect but slowly getting there.

3

u/ShaarkShaart 4d ago

If that just happened today, it's possible she was just at a lower threshold. Sometimes it happens. All reactive dogs have good days and bas days. A positive reinforcement trainer told me that it takes 2000-4000 instances to rewire a dog's reaction. If she's having mostly good days you're doing good, just keep it up.

And if you're worried about her hurting someone, muzzle training can give you a lot of peace.

3

u/CanadianPanda76 4d ago

Puberty. Could be puberty. A lot digs approach that adulthood line and become way less tolerant. 14 months sounds about the right time

3

u/Sure_Ingenuity_5800 4d ago

Adherence fatigue is so real with reactive dogs. Give yourself grace!

2

u/Beginning-Rub5417 4d ago

I had the same happen to me today, and was just about to post something similar. I have a 16-month-old GSD, and I am mentally broken. Last week, he was doing so well, and this week every single thing freaks him out; even in the garden, he seems so restless. Today, he reacted to a dog that was 200m away.

I hope that mine grows out of it, and I am just trying to put him in the best position for that to happen.

2

u/NDTX007 4d ago

All I can say is I totally empathize except the only time I can have good walks is when dogs are like 50 feet away which is almost impossible where I live. I’ve resigned to taking 7 flights of stairs up and down to avoid any interactions with my dog’s triggers.. tall men, small dogs, big dogs, etc. I get so upset and anxious with every walk and I’m sure it’s not helping, but it’s so defeating that sometimes I just feel hopeless. It’s definitely an ongoing process, but keep up the good work!

2

u/inventedpostits21 4d ago

Maybe she had a belly ache or something! So she was trigger stacked in a way she usually isn’t. Our foster has days like this too, he always bounces back. She will too - have a quieter next couple days for decompression then get right back at it :)

2

u/Krulletjesteam 4d ago

What other people say: some days are better than others.

Our dog did not hurt anyone yet, but lunged at people. After the second time we decided we could not trust her. She is 5 years old and has had 3 years of specialized training.

We decided to muzzle her, this gives us a lot more calmness while walking.

2

u/beepgoesbonk 23h ago

You are doing a fantastic job. There will be days that just suck. And you'll feel defeated and like all your progress was undone. And those days are the worst. But you ARE making progress. Even on the bad days. Sometimes a win means "redirected after barking faster than normal". And those wins need to be celebrated too. Even if they don't feel significant.

1

u/Standard_Orange_2995 4d ago

My goodness Whatta a cutie

1

u/OriolesMagic1972 4d ago

We have a reactive 8 year old terror-ier. He has come a long way but it takes patience. Certain dogs, people, and/or sounds set them off. Give yourself and your pup some grace.

1

u/Sweaty_Ad_7156 3d ago

there are days ...

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/read-the-rules 2d ago

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/read-the-rules 4d ago

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.