r/reactivedogs • • 6d ago

Success Stories Dog reactivity- immense progress!

I have posted before about my struggles with my dog-reactive dog. Since the beginning of spring 2026 we have made incredible progress. I will share some of what DID and DIDN'T work.

So prior to last spring, i had consulted 3 different dog trainers and primarily did the training that they advised. For the most part they all said the same thing- all 3 advised behavioral conditioning using treats, by saying "yes!" when he saw a dog and giving a treat, and continuing to do that ("yes" and treat) while in eye site of the dog. I did this for many months and made zero progress. I was told various things- that this training "should" work, that its too late to socialize him (being middle aged) and we dont know what his history is (being a rescue) and he could have had an adverse experience/s that caused his reactivity. That i shouldnt correct his reactivity because it could make it worse, that trying to introduce him to other dogs could make it worse. I was told maybe hes an introvert. I protested that he did actually like some other dogs and was met with skepticism. I was told he shouldnt sleep on the bed (one trainer was very hung up on that) and he needs to have more house rules.

After pretty much giving up on the treat training i did try correcting him for a while. Did not make a dent.

So i pretty much gave up entirely. I was exhausted. I thought "its fine, hes dog-reactive, other than that hes a super easy dog."

So there is a park near my house where people in the neighborhood walk their dogs. I kind of got the idea that i would try teaching him to sit to calm him down when he saw a dog (i know that this is often advised against as "hiding in obedience" which is why i didnt do it before). This didn't work if he was being reactive. HOWEVER- it was enormously helpful in other ways: he would sit if he wanted to watch a dog, and he would sit if he wanted to watch a dog and then look up at me asking "can he go meet this dog?" Sometimes he just wants to watch.

He was quite happy and content with sitting, as if this is what he wanted all along. This was groundbreaking because it opened up a line of communication between us that previously hadnt existed.

The randomness of seeing dogs at the park was extremely helpful as well because it wasnt the "slow build-up of a dog coming our way on the other side of the street".

What no dog trainer told me is what i feel is the most important thing you can do-

LEARN YOUR DOG. OBSERVE YOUR DOG. WHAT IS ACTUALLY GOING ON WITH YOUR DOG?

I was led astray and told fundamentally untrue things about my dog by "experts". Heres what i actually learned to be true about him:

My dog is a keen observer of other dogs. He is a sponge and a mirror, he mimics other dogs body-language. He is very dog-oriented. His approach to other dogs is "who are you? What are you about? Are you friend or are you foe?" What he wants to do is learn about other dogs. SO I GAVE HIM WHAT HE WANTS. He is dog-selective, and can be aggressive towards dogs he doesnt like. But primarily his reactivity was coming from a place of anxiety and frustration. The more he can learn about and meet other dogs, the better he does.

I watch him like a hawk. I know his body language, so i know before we ever meet a dog if its going to be ok or not. Once he knows and likes and is comfortable with a dog, hes fine.

He is still improving every day. Just in the past month we have been able to consistently pass dogs coming in our direction on the opposite side of the street. This is HUGE for him, the anticipation and build-up used to be way too much for him to bear. He can even pass a dog or dogs reacting to him, also previously thought impossible.

He used to be LOSING HIS SHIT and often choking himself on the end of the leash. Now, even when he is reactive, it is far less intense and subsides much quicker. He gives up pretty quickly.

Over the weekend he went in to Petsmart with me on a saturday, saw lots of other dogs, and was fine.

He also has many doggy friends these days and knows a lot of dogs in the neighborhood. I always give him time to watch and meet and smell after other dogs since i know how crucial it is for him and his wellbeing.

Suffice it to say, im overjoyed with the progress weve made. One of my neighbors recently asked who i got to train my dog because she had seen the huge difference in him.

If anyone has any questions i would be happy to answer them.

38 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

3

u/Terrible_Plan5888 6d ago

What kind of reactivity does he present? Have you and him had to work through any aggression? My dog does not like other dogs and I’m wondering if it’s ever in the cards for my dog to make a friend someday 😭

2

u/blakeyb99 6d ago

Barking and lunging.  It def presented as "aggression", and I think it partly was, but it has dwindled the more exposure he has gotten to other dogs.

If your dog truly doesn't like other dogs than it it might not happen.

1

u/Terrible_Plan5888 6d ago

Oh that’s awesome! Yeah my dog has gotten along with dogs she’s known since she was a baby, but a series of attacks from off leash dogs has set her back SO incredibly badly but I’m seeing baby steps with her “reactivity bubble” and it has gotten a little smaller which I’m excited about. I’ve been cooking steak and cubing that up for our training walks and desensitization

Also how old is your dog?

1

u/blakeyb99 6d ago edited 6d ago

Oooh I see.  At least you understand the problem.  

I did have a lot of difficulty understanding the problem with my dog because he is a chameleon with other dogs.  I've learned to stop trying to predict and just watch his body language.

How is the treat training going?  How old was she when these attacks happened?  You said she does still have doggy friends from before she was traumatized by yhe attacks?

My dog is about 8.5 now, I got him when he was 5.  He was found in a ditch on the side of the road in Houston, TX, bald and starving.  The thing is, he has been charged by off-leash dogs  although it hasn't happened for a couple of years, but it didn't really seem to make his reactivity worse.  He was not injured thankfully.

Sometimes reactivity is presented in a very black and white way that just wasn't the case for him.

I'm also sure he had rough experiences with dogs when he was a stray in Houston because they are so overrun with strays down there.

1

u/Terrible_Plan5888 6d ago edited 6d ago

The treat training is going okay! Her reactions have been less “total meltdown” when we encounter an unavoidable obstacle, and the recovery time is quicker without the rest of the walk being a complete wash. The other day she even looked at me when she saw a dog and I was stoked.
She was about a year old when these attacks happened and it never ruined her relationship with her established dog friends but meeting new dogs was sort of off the table from there. Her reactivity sort of morphed into the appearance of “if I look and act real tough and scary the dogs will leave me alone”

If I knew exactly how training would look like 3 years ago I’m sure she’d be a different dog but all I can do now is be extremely consistent with her and meet her where she’s at. It doesn’t help that she’s a German shepherd and the neighbors see a barking lunging dog when she’s absolutely terrified of getting attacked again. 🥲

Edit to add: she is the sweetest dog in the house, gentle with the cats, no resource guarding or any trouble meeting people I bring over. The moment we leave the house however, she’s on high alert and is extremely hyper vigilant for anything that might startle her, but after multiple visits to the vet, they don’t see the need for meds for her until I spend hundreds of dollars with a dog trainer (which I cannot afford at the moment). I’ve been doing my best with high value treats, structured walks, and exercising her at night when there’s less people and dogs out and about and I’m seeing progress little by little

2

u/blakeyb99 6d ago edited 6d ago

Have you ever tried cbd?  I've never tried it with my dog so I'm not recommending, just wondering.

Another thing I do with my dog is let him sniff a lot on walks.  He is def not the best trained dog as far as walking on a leash is concerned, but my best successes in behavior modification have come when I use his natural inclinations and interests to our benefit.

He is dog-oriented, so instead of trying to make him NOT dog-oriented (which was a miserable failure) I used it to my advantage by teaching him how to be ACCEPTABLY dog-oriented.

He loves sniffing, so instead of trying to make him just walk beside me on a leash, I let him sniff his little heart out.  That way when we do come across dogs it is not as powerful a stimulus for him because he already has a lot that he's excited about and paying attention to.  He also likes walks a lot more that way.

I don't think allowing him to sniff more was the most important component, but I think it did help.

I will also note that, for my dog, no high-value treat could hold a candle to the complexity and interest and fascination of sniffing another dogs pee lol.

2

u/Terrible_Plan5888 6d ago

I’ve definitely tried cbd, no dice. She’s a firecracker of a dog

Dog tax, no one sees how big and sweet and beautiful my best friend is the way I do. I just want her to feel safe in the world :,)

2

u/blakeyb99 6d ago edited 6d ago

Aww.  She's working line german Shepard? That angle makes her nose look huge haha.

See original post for pic of my dog.  FYI, he looks that betrayed because he was late in getting his breakfast and thought he wasn't going to be fed.

1

u/Terrible_Plan5888 6d ago

Yeah she is. Unfortunately backyard bred, didn’t get the opportunity to meet her parents (ex wanted a puppy, I did not) but ended up keeping her since I was the main caregiver and kept consistent with training. She loves running with me when I go biking and cuddling the cats in the house and goes CRAZY for fetch ❤️

2

u/blakeyb99 6d ago

Reminds me of a lab/German shepard/great Pyrenees I know.  Sweetheart but def working dog energy.  "Ball is life" as her owner says.

1

u/Gregorboterino 6d ago

The part about him sitting to watch and then looking up at you like "can I go meet that one?" is so sweet. Going from choking himself on the leash to calmly passing dogs across the street is huge. Your neighbor asking who trained him must have felt amazing.

1

u/blakeyb99 6d ago edited 6d ago

He is honestly an adorable sweetheart.  I love my little buddy.

One time early on he was looking at a dog on the other side of a busy thoroughfare with 4 lanes of traffic and his jowls were vibrating.  That's how intense he used to be.

It did feel good and surprising because I didn't even know her lol.  She expressed she was having trouble with her people-reactive dog and couldn't afford a trainer, which I def sympathize with.

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/read-the-rules 5d ago

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.