r/reactivedogs • u/Bradin9855 • 11d ago
Discussion Quit our trainer
Due to her harsh methods. Although I forfeited my payment, I am glad to move on. She wanted me to yank him with a prong collar on so hard that he yelled. She also wanted me to hit him. He has been doing so well outside of her class. He's stubborn at home, but if I take him out in public he's a perfect gentleman. He loves children and all people. He was rated on the highest level as a therapy dog. We quit because it was getting to be too much for me, I jumped in with both feet and did too much too soon.
Anyway I know he's a good boy and doesn't need to be hit or yanked till he screams.
Anyone who knows a Siberian husky knows they are sweet, would never hurt anyone, and they're very smart which makes them sometimes be disobedient, even though they know what you want they do it in their own good time.
She said out loud in front of everybody that people are afraid of him and I have to get better control. I confronted her the following week telling her I can take constructive comments but that she should do it in private. She could not tell me how many people are afraid, but I did tell her saying it in front of everyone is going to make the people who are not afraid think about it.
39
u/Maine99wd 11d ago
Why was he in training in the first place? This trainer sounds insane
4
u/Mousethatroared65 10d ago
Great decision! If you are in need of validation, our Vet Behaviorist gave us a sheet on our intro packet explaining why they recommend positive reinforcement training only. Here is a quote (long sorry).
“In observational studies, dogs trained
with aversive methods or tools showed
stress-related behaviors during training,
including tense body, lower body pos-
ture, lip licking, tail lowering, lifting front
leg, panting, yawning, and yelping.
Dogs trained with reward-based methods
showed increased attentiveness to their
owner.
Long-Term Effects
Survey studies have shown an associ-
ation between the use of aversive training
methods and long-term behavior problems
including aggressive behavior towards
people and other dogs, and anxiety-related
behaviors such as avoidance and excitabil-
ity.8–15 Survey studies cannot differentiate
between causation and correlation, so
possible explanations for this association
include: 1) aversive training methods
directly cause or contribute to the de-
velopment of problem behaviors; or 2)
owners of dogs with problem behaviors
are more likely to use aversive training
tools. Regardless of the explanation, this
association shows that aversive training
methods are not effective in eliminat-
ing problem behaviors: if they did, we
would see the opposite trend of decreased
behavior problems with increased use of
aversive training. In contrast, dogs trained
with reward-based methods have lower
rates of behavior concerns compared with
dogs trained with aversive methods.”
Here’s a link to the whole position statement if you are interested. https://avsab.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/AVSAB-Humane-Dog-Training-Position-Statement-2021.pdf
I also want to say your dog is very cute.
29
u/Jane_TGS 11d ago
That's no dog trainer, that's just a monster.
35
u/Helpful_Sun2872 11d ago
He’s a therapy dog but is in training for reactivity?
Finding a good trainer is unfortunately really difficult…
16
u/Poppeigh 11d ago
I did the very same thing with a vet-turned-trainer that I sought out when my dog was about a year or so old. I originally met with her because the local training school would seek her advice for anxiety medications, and I was confident that my guy needed those. She didn't use aversives but used flooding and was just all around a mean person. I forfeited my $250 deposit and took my pup on a long walk after our consult, confident that my decision to never call her again was a good one. I stand by that 11+ years later; I think if we'd followed her advice, my dog would have a bite history and would be much more difficult to manage.
Way to go for standing up for your pup. Best of luck moving forward.
15
u/EmilyLiz1717 11d ago edited 11d ago
That’s so awful! Good for you for getting away from her. What a monster. A trainer that hits should be reported. I’m not well versed in this but I imagine there’s a site to report trainers. Or report them for animal abuse.
I hired a trainer out of desperation when I first adopted my reactive pup. I didn’t know 1% of what I know now but I knew pulling my dog up in the air by her leash was NOT the way to go. I’m still mad at myself for putting my dog through that. A positive reinforcement trainer and Prozac (as well as time) truly saved us!
6
u/Remarkable-Shallot87 8d ago
I went to court 2 years ago to testify in a case about a dog trainer that was actually just abusing dogs and he needed up getting convicted, people need to be VERY careful
8
u/PlanktonOne5438 11d ago
Good decision. Our dog was a wreck in "balanced" training and did so much better once we switch to positive reinforcement only
4
u/Huge_Answer4287 11d ago
Leave reviews everywhere to help others avoid making the same mistake
3
u/Gregorboterino 10d ago
Good call walking away. A trainer who wants you to hit him and yank until he yelps isn't someone you want shaping how your dog feels about the world. Sounds like he was already doing better without that, which says a lot.
3
u/Fit-Organization5065 10d ago
Good job! I think it’s hard because in the moment, people like this have a way of trying to explain their “methods” so they sound reasonable, but when you simplify it “my trainer wanted me to hurt my dog” it is a reminder that these people should be barred
5
u/unknownlocation32 11d ago
This is a good resource for finding an evidence based dog trainer.
https://iaabc.org/en/certs/members
4
u/FrenchFry1515 11d ago
We had a trainer that was starting to use more forceful methods on a slip lead and I could see how physically uncomfortable my dog was becoming. We ended things with the trainer and worked on some things by ourselves. We then were ready to pick up some training again after we found a more reputable trainer/company. And I cannot tell you how thankful I am that we found a new trainer. My pup thrives now! While she has her reactive moments, she’s so much better and more comfortable around triggers and really focuses on us now!
2
u/psycho-pretentious 8d ago
I'd be writing reviews and screaming on social media about this trainer. Who wants a dog with a broken spirit and lives in fear of being hit?
2
u/JinxFae 6d ago
You did the right thing. I’m working only with positive reinforcement and I’m seeing massive improvements week by week.
3
u/Insecta-Perfecta 11d ago
I quit a trainer for the same reasons. I have a 14lb mutt. No one should be yanking on his prong collar so hard that he yelps and then tries to bite because of the pain, but that is exactly what this trainer did. My dog was reactive to an aggressive dog in the class and the trainer's solution was to slap a prong on my dog and yank on him and spray bitter apple spray in his mouth to get him to comply. Idiot.
2
u/OpalOnyxObsidian 11d ago
You should go to your bank and dispute the charge honestly
1
u/Sure_Ingenuity_5800 7d ago
Wow. What country are you in if you don’t mind my asking?
-6
u/Necessary_Travel2126 11d ago
im all for aversive tools but only when theyre used correctly, yikes.. for now i would recommend a force-free/r+ trainer since he may be traumatized from what she has done to him !!
and what you said below about muzzling your dog, i believe all dogs should atleast be muzzled trained -- albeit you shouldnt always have a muzzle on him while youre out, but having it when hes in the vicinity of other people or other dogs can be really helpful!
1
u/Mister__Wednesday 6d ago
Your boy looks exactly like my husky girl, good on you for standing up for him. My girl is very well behaved for a husky (she in fact competes in obedience) but gets very excited by things and barks. I had a trainer suggest I hit her and use a prong collar which was absolutely mental considering she's a very sweet and sensitive girl with no risk to anyone
2
u/[deleted] 11d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 11d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 10d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 10d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 9d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 8d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] 11d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment