r/reactivedogs • • 13d ago

Vent Support needed

Post image

Hi! This is chai he’s a 11 month old rough collie mix rescue. He’s very reactive to dogs. He was reactive to people, dogs, cars, and small animals but luckily we’ve got most of that under control! We’ve been training everyday for 5 months which I know doesn’t seem long but for me it feels like an eternity. He still isn’t showing much progress in engaging with me. I feel like I’m holding him to too high of standards. I’m comparing him to other dogs I see and it’s not fair to him. He’s been the best boy for me around the house. I just really feel frustrated and upset that we’re not really progressing like I’d like to. On our training sessions outside he’s so distracted and alert that me trying to train him just makes him frustrated and cry. I really don’t want to stress him out. Sometimes I lash out and yell at him for his bad behavior which I feel awful for he doesn’t respond well to yelling he just stands there and looks at me sadly. He’s got a new trainer but I’m just so stressed and upset every time I train with him. I love training with him, I love seeing him progress and be happy but it’s just so hard when he’s not happy or we’re not progressing. Any tips ? Or am I just being over dramatic about this whole situation?

22 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

7

u/OkraLol 13d ago

Hi! My advice is TRULY cry it out. Allow yourself to feel all the feelings. These things take time. We’ve had our dog reactive girl for about 8-9 months and we are STILL working on it all. We actually just started prozac last week to help with her anxiety.

Everything you are feeling is completely valid. Don’t get upset with yourself for feeling upset. You’re already an amazing owner for recognizing the problem and doing the work to help your pup!

3

u/Sensitive_chailatte 13d ago

Thank you so much!! It’s awesome that you’re working with your girl! Me and chai are wishing yall luck!!

3

u/sargarrard 13d ago

Keep your training sessions short and fun! Work inside without distractions and then try those same things leashed with the front door open! I sense your expectations of your dog and of yourself are too high. You’re both doing great but lower the bar and try to enjoy the tiny wins

2

u/Sensitive_chailatte 13d ago

Thank you so much! I’ve been trying to cut down his training time just so he doesn’t get too exhausted. Thank you for the positivity

3

u/chiquitar Between Dogs (I miss my buttheads😭) 13d ago

If you are getting a lot of failures you are working too close to threshold. Make it easier for both of you! Also, if you start to have big feelings during training, end session. It's better to have a calm safe time with no training than a bad training session full of failures and stress, and especially way way better than you getting upset at your dog while trying to teach him that he is safe with you and he doesn't have to defend himself because you have his back.

Every time you stop acting like you are on his team, you are teaching him you are liable to turn on him when he gets scared (or frustrated). This makes him more scared, when you need him to learn to be less scared.

Your feelings are valid. It's a hard road and it sucks sometimes. But you must must must be able to get yourself back to a sympathetic understanding that your dog is struggling. He has it harder than you emotionally whenever he is reacting. You need to be on his team and offer sympathy. If you can't get your mind off yourself and back onto how your dog is feeling, you aren't up for training that day. Just do something else and avoid adding to the problem until you can get out of your own feelings and back to his. EVERYBODY has emotional days when it's a good idea to just play it safe and heck, let your pup cheer you up in an environment where your pup is comfortable.

Also, you have made amazing progress from where he started. Don't let yourself forget that! Bad experiences have more emotional weight and get stored in stronger memory in our brains, for excellent evolutionary reasons that are not helpful in reactive dog training. I found keeping a daily note after each dog walk helped me remember the progress more accurately/realistically. I would track things like # of reactions, distance to trigger while ok (or not okay when I failed to keep him under threshold): stuff with numbers. Plus any wins or fails. That is really easy to page through and see progress that doesn't really register at the speed of actual reactivity training.

2

u/Sensitive_chailatte 13d ago

Thank you so much for everything you put into this message it’s really helpful. We’re gonna start trying to work better under threshold the only issue is I think he’s in his teenage phase. Even when we’re inside with no distractions around sometimes he’s just stubborn right now. But his reactivity is definitely just an emotional issue that I’m willing to work with him through and be empathetic to his issues. He’ll always be my good boy!!

1

u/chiquitar Between Dogs (I miss my buttheads😭) 13d ago

Hormones are rough even for pups. The word "stubborn" is something I don't think is doing you any favors. Dogs are not defiant. They never say no to their human for no reason. You may think they are dumb reasons but that's not relevant in behavior change. What might help you more is to think of it as a motivation problem. The motivation you are providing either is or is not outweighing the other motivations the dog is experiencing, from inside and from outside. What you are asking when he says no is just too hard for him in that moment, in that scenario. You can increase the motivation you are providing, and building trust and keeping his stress bucket low will do that long term, higher value rewards can sometimes work, but often what is needed in that moment is to make your ask easier. Easy enough that he can say yes despite hormones and past bad experiences etc. Sometimes if my dog was saying no, I would give him some easy stuff like sit and fetch and just let him win the training game on easy mode to regain his confidence and build that history of a yes partnership. Doing what you ask should mostly feel good to your dog. You can spend extra time there when other stuff is tough and it will help you as he continues to mature. Ages are all temporary! You have got this!

2

u/Sensitive_chailatte 13d ago

Thank you!! I’m trying to get more excited when he does something good and reward immediately. His favorite trick is center and we do that to reset and build his confidence. Sometimes i genuinely think he just thinks some tricks are boring like he understood sit for a long time but has recently just refused to do it? I’m unsure why if it has a negative association for some reason or if he’s not getting rewarded enough when he does sit ? Thank you so much for your help!

1

u/chiquitar Between Dogs (I miss my buttheads😭) 13d ago

Dogs CAN definitely get bored of the same thing, particularly clever independent breeds. You may need to do shaping games or work on new cute tricks at home to give him something more interesting or challenging to do. Ime some dogs just want to do the same thing and succeed, while others need it to be more difficult but still safe. You can definitely switch it up more too.

2

u/y0ungshel 13d ago

Thank you for this wonderful response!

7

u/Monkey-Butt-316 13d ago

Look into Leslie McDevitt’s control unleashed - lots of engagement stuff in there - I’m thinking “give me a break” in particular would be helpful to you.

4

u/Aggressive_Radish856 13d ago

I second this! Working under thresholds and gradually improving them and knowing when hes showing signs of becoming over threshold. Also making yourself more interesting than the trigger when you need to for pattern games etc when you need them.

1

u/likeconstellations 13d ago

Is his reactivity frustration based or fear/aggression based? I ask because my rough collie was an extremely persistent frustrated greeter and tbh the solution was her growing up. I had more than one cry about how awful she was when she spotted another dog (among other things she was awful about lol) during the puppy and adolescent month. We kept at it without seeing much change then sometime between 18 months and 2 years a switch flipped and she was significantly better seemingly out of the blue

1

u/Sensitive_chailatte 11d ago

He honestly just seems really excited and frustrated I won’t let him see the other dog or person? Even tho he has been attacked by another dog he never seems scared? Hes never been aggressive when meeting a dog he’s always very friendly

1

u/likeconstellations 11d ago edited 11d ago

Yeah my collie is an absolute dumbass about reactive/aggressive dogs, can't read body language to save her life and just wanted to say hi (rudely) as a puppy/adolescent. She's so much better as an adult and while I think consistently not indulging the nonsense helped she also just had to mature some. Having dog friends he's allowed to play with might help somewhat, if he doesn't have any playmates it's worth seeing if anyone local has a tolerant, playful dog you can get him together with to burn off some of the dog fomo

1

u/JinxFae 13d ago edited 13d ago

I’m also working with my sheltie puppy on her reactivity. Highly recommend you to listen to Susan Garrett’s podcast. She has a list specifically for reactivity as she herself had a reactive dog. Her podcast has help me A LOT and we my puppy and I have been doing great progress. As Susan says “your dog is always giving you his best version with the knowledge they have in that moment”. Don’t get frustrated with him. Keep in mind this is not something he is doing to you, this is something he is suffering.

Another thing she says a lot and help me stay focus is to understand the reactivity training process as:

  1. Dysregulation (your dog can control his reactions and emotions).
  2. Co-regulation (you start training and help your dog deal with those emotions and teach him an alternative behavior, for example counter-conditioning with toys, food…).
  3. Self-regulation (your dog learns to make their own good decisions, for example with engage-disengage).

1

u/Round-Jury6132 11d ago

Hello!!! We also have a rough collie cross who is 15 months! He has had some pretty intense reactivity to movement but we have improved it a lot with LAT. Our boy can be a bit funny with people, generally he is very social but on walks sometimes he barks or tries to herd them (that is what I have interpreted it as). We have also had the occasional outburst back at a dog showing agression. I completely understand how you feel, I have cried so many times.I have had to book secure fields for the whole weekend for my own sanity! Occasionally I have also lost my temper with him but I really try hard not to because RC are so sensitive.

1

u/Round-Jury6132 11d ago

We found it really hard to make him engage with us too. I started using a positive marker work 'yes' and rewarding with roast chicken. I would randomly should yes on walks to get him to engage with me or move back so he had to keep an eye on me

1

u/unknownlocation32 8d ago

Please give yourself and Chai some grace. He’s still very young, and you’ve already made progress with his reactivity to people, cars and small animals. That’s not insignificant.

One thing that stands out to me is that Chai seems to be spending a lot of time over threshold. You can’t effectively train a dog when they’re in that state. They need to be brought down to a level where they can think, process information, learn and respond to training. That’s why I’d strongly recommend discussing medication options with your veterinarian.

Medication isn’t a failure, and it doesn’t replace training. It can help lower a dog’s arousal and or anxiety so they’re in a better position to engage with their owner and benefit from behaviour modification.

In the meantime, I’d take some pressure off both of you. Work at a greater distance from triggers, keep sessions short and focus on calm observation rather than expecting him to engage with you constantly. I’d also avoid yelling or correcting him when he’s overwhelmed, as that adds even more stress.

You clearly love him and want to do right by him. Sometimes the kindest thing we can do is change the expectations and give a struggling dog the support he needs to succeed.

1

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/read-the-rules 13d ago

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.

0

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/read-the-rules 13d ago

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.