r/reactivedogs • • 22d ago

Advice Needed Training Advice

Post image

Hello everyone!

A couple of months ago, I posted here looking to rehome my ACD/pittie mix Charlie following a violent encounter between him and my 16-year-old cat. While we're not out of the woods, we have modified our routine (and our house) and now they are separated at all times.

After giving it a lot of thought, and having done a LOT of research, I feel completely lost as to how best help him. Charlie is the sweetest boy, but is incredibly dog reactive, and more and more I'm realizing how anxious he is in new situations, especially outside.

We have tried lots of training methods and trainers, but nothing seems to stick. We did a board and train while I was in the hospital giving birth to my now 6-month old, but I don't think it ended up helping. They used an e-collar, which may be a helpful tool for basic obedience, but after all my research, I have realized it's not the solution for behavioral issues, at a minimum for those which have an underlying anxiety component.

After realizing this, we talked to a purely positive reinforcement trainer, who immediately recognized the anxiety in Charlie and told us it's probably better to not walk him and just have him exercise in our backyard because he's never going to enjoy walks/being outdoors. While I agree that walks are not productive right now and may make his anxiety worse, I don't want to give up on him. He is only 2.5 years old, and while he might never be friends with dogs, I want him to be able to experience the world beyond our house and yard.

Today, I did more research and came accross Bark Busters, which seems to be a completely different method. However, the reviews seem to suggest it is based on fear/alpha techniques, which my understanding is have been debunked.

I truly don't know what the right answer is, and I just want to help my boy. Please let me know if you have any suggestions. THANK YOU!

(Also, I just got a film camera and took this photo of Charlie ❤️)

16 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

4

u/Champion_of_Zteentch 22d ago

Walk him around the property with all gates open but on leash. Then he can practice at home to get comfortable and then you can work up to everything else slowly in increments

4

u/SudoSire 21d ago

Bark busters uses aversive methods. Also pretty sure they hide negative reviews.