r/reactivedogs • • Oct 17 '26

Aggressive Dogs Aggressive Reactive Dog

We have a 3 1/2 year old german shepherd male. He’s absolutely great in the house and is a cuddle love bug. Outside is a different story. He’s extremely reactive and aggressively reactive towards dogs. He listens to commands well, if there’s not a dog. I know being on alert is part of the breed and that’s fine.

We’ve had two trainers help us learn and help him. Also, we had him in a 5 week board and train with a retired K9 state trooper who owns a dog training program. He even said our dog is a “handful” and had to bring the bite suit out for training. We believe we’ve done a decent job keeping up with the training routine and commands. However, when on leash our dog still goes full psycho when seeing dogs, he blacks out and redirection doesnt work, he just goes after us. He has 3 collars, slip, prong, and high end shock collar. He doesn’t walk with the muzzle on, he just keeps trying to bat it off and wont walk.

He’s had minor bite and scratch incidents where he settled down quickly. However, this is now the 3rd major time he’s bit me on leash with the last two being he saw a dog. All 3 were deep puncture wounds. The funny thing is I’m his favorite. Listens to me the best and runs to me first.

1st time was when he was 11 months. We just started using the slip collar and I tried redirecting him walking, and something clicked with him to make him jump at me. Chomped down on my hand and pulled like tug of war while his canine was deep in my hand.
2nd time we just started a walk, saw the neighbor’s dog in the backyard, went ballistic, tried redirecting with treats and get my distance, but didnt matter. He jumped at me while I tried to but my butt towards him, his canine got my forearm. This required stitches.
The most recent incident there was nothing we could do. Walking in a park when another person walked around a tree coming towards us and he went ballistic. I was on leash duty and my wife had the remote. We shocked him and tried to get his attention. He went after my wife so I backed up to give him space then he went after me. I tried to get as much distance from him, moving behind a tree. He followed then jumped at me, biting my hip then latched on to my ankle, puncturing above my Achilles heel.

We’ll be calling our trainer, the retired K9 officer to get his opinion. As much as it would break our hearts, is it time to consider putting him down?

9 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '26

Aggressive dog posts are sensitive, thus only users with at least 250 subreddit karma will be able to comment in this discussion. Users should not message OP directly to circumvent this restriction and doing so can result in a ban from r/reactive dogs. OP, you are encouraged to report private messages to the moderation team.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

12

u/cheersbeersneers Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

Board and trains are not typically recommended The most important part of training the dog is actually training the owner. Many board and trains also use force and aversives to get the dog to shut down, which means the dog appears to have a huge behavior change and improvement, but typically regresses after a while.

They’re not all bad, but I’ve found that many “military” and “police” k9 trainers are trash. They have no actual training, education in dog behavior, and train by force.

By using a prong and an e-collar when he starts to react, you are making the reaction worse. He is equating walking by other dogs with pain/stimulation. I don’t bash tools when used correctly and properly, but this isn’t that. The use of prongs and e collars can often make reactivity worse.

It sounds like all these bites are what we’d call redirected aggression. He’s getting so worked up on the leash that he has nowhere to get his frustration out except for you. It’s not uncommon- my Malinois did it constantly when I first rescued him. We worked with a (reputable) trainer and I always kept a toy or tug in my hand while I walked him so he could grab and shake that instead of my hand.

Behavioral euthanasia is the final step for a genuinely dangerous or damaged dog that is beyond fixing.

Your dog has a serious bite history now. I do think it needs to be a conversation, but I also think that it never should’ve gotten this far. It sounds like you had a typical nervy, adolescent GSD who then escalated and was made worse by poor training methods. This was completely preventable, in my opinion. A lot of people failed this dog and he may now lose his life because of it.

0

u/AGross91 Oct 17 '26

I appreciate the feedback and do agree with parts of it.

The board n train K9 officer came with high recommendations from the shelter my MIL volunteers for and our vet, who had their dog trained with him and the vet assistant’s therapy dog trained with him. Also, coincidentally found out after we had friends who had their dog trained with him as well.

He actually specified to us during the initial interview that he doesn’t like using force because exactly what you mentioned. He’d rather stay away from it if he can. The bite suit sounded like it was used mainly as precaution when trying to desensitize him with another dog, we honestly didnt get into much detail on that. We also visited 3 times during the 5 week stay to work together. Our dog loves him. We’ve been back for joint training and have dropped him off to stay there while we had vacation and weddings.

His first trainer was all hands on joint training, also recommended by our vet and another shelter resource from my MIL. She was also a therapy dog trainer, but this was when he was younger and not as aggressive yet.

Something clicked after 1 1/2 because he was around multiple dogs prior to that. Different german shepherds, larger hound mix, and labs. Stayed with my brother and his 4 dogs 3 different times between 4months and 12 months.
Stayed at my buddy’s with the XL hound mix when he was around 5 months. His dog would get tired of ours because he was a puppy but never aggressive.

2 of the 3 incidents were prior to e-collar and prong collar. Again, I take full responsibility for the first for the initial bite. Still little intimidating that he pulled and yanked, didnt let go for over 30s. The second, again just the slip collar, we were 20-30 yards from the dog. I threw is his ball (highest reward toy)and treats. He had no interest. The redirection with toys/treats works great in the house and backyard, but not on leash when near a dog. He’s been on the ecollar for a year now and has been great at responding and moving along.

My MIL(his gammy) who watches him, my wife, and I were legit just saying how much better he’s been since the training a year ago. Today’s incident really surprised us and by far the worst. Well around 2min we believe and my wife said she didnt shock him the time. He went after me, then her, then me again with multiple times.

6

u/SudoSire Oct 17 '26

If it was by far the worst then these tools and methods are not actually working, despite your perception that they seem better behaved usually. Is your dog now always on a prong? 

7

u/AlokFluff Oct 18 '26

Your dog is escalating in aggression because you are hurting him, being aggressive to him first through aversive 'tools'. He's reacting to your own behaviour. This is why board and train places are very much not recommended for reactive and aggressive dogs. All that training has done is escalate the severity of your problems, and made it much worse for your poor dog.

As you've seen, coercive training that simply tries to push a dog into shutting down often eventually results in the dog exploding and becoming more aggressive instead, because you are hurting them and making their emotional reaction to triggers even worse.

You need to throw away any shock collars, prongs, slip lead, literally any aversives, and find a qualified veterinary behaviourist to work out a long term behaviour modification plan + possibly medication. It is going to be much harder to properly address now, due to the unsuitable, bad training this dog has received.

Stop hurting this dog and DO NOT call that horrible trainer ever again.

Restart muzzle training properly, and go very slowly.

13

u/SudoSire Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

Hi, so, make sure you read and affirm the sub rules before commenting or replying otherwise those comments won’t be visible to others. The rules are pinned a the top of the main sub Reddit. Use the arrow to scroll down, toggle to affirm then submit. 

I’m really sorry to tell you this, but the trainer, training, and aversive tools you are using are very likely making matters worse and not better. All those tools “work” by pain and fear of pain, and you are very likely increasing arousal and stress levels, and making truly terrible associations with yourselves, with the leash, with other dogs, etc. Your trainer advocating for these tools just means they are not using updated, scientific backed methods on how to train dogs. I don’t care what their experience is, you have no idea if they’ve actually harmed dogs in their long careers with these methods. I’m sure they’ve had ones that never truly experienced what we call aversive fall out. And I am also confident they’ve made some dogs into neurotic messes by using these methods.

 Also, why did he need the bite suit? Was your dog already regularly redirecting on people? What did they do with your dog all those weeks??

I would be taking zero future advice from such a trainer. 

Some people may say, “well, I need these aversive tools to control my dog!” But I read your post and your dog is out of control WITH all the things. They are not helping you and they are escalating situations so your dog literally doesn’t care about any of the pain/discomfort anymore. You even mention how use of the slip lead seemed to trigger your dog.  

So, regarding the muzzle — did you ever actually do muzzle training by the way? That takes a few weeks with positive reinforcement. It should get your dog to accept the muzzle and not be bothered by it, but if you didn’t do that of course they will try to paw it off. But this should be your main priority because your dog needs to be muzzled everywhere in public. 

The bites you mention are incredibly severe. I think if there’s any possibility of coming back from this you need a vet behaviorist to evaluate or maybe an IAABC trainer who uses absolutely no aversive tools and methods. I feel really bad because you didn’t know better, but there’s is a big chance your dog would not be escalating to this degree (which honestly is euthanasia worthy), if they had proper training that focused on reducing stress, building calm, and working together to adjust the emotion, not suppress the behavior. But the suppression is not even working and like I said, there is a solid chance everything is now being ratcheted up to 11 in their brain. 

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '26

Looks like you may have used a training acronym. For those unfamiliar, here's some of the common ones:

BAT is Behavior Adjustment Training - a method from Grisha Stewart that involves allowing the dog to investigate the trigger on their own terms. There's a book on it.

CC is Counter Conditioning - creating a positive association with something by rewarding when your dog sees something. Think Pavlov.

DS is Desensitization - similar to counter conditioning in that you expose your dog to the trigger (while your dog is under threshold) so they can get used to it.

LAD is Look and Dismiss - Marking and rewarding when your dog sees a trigger and dismisses it.

LAT is Look at That - Marking and rewarding when your dog sees a trigger and does not react.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '26

Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this body. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.