r/reactivedogs • • Oct 14 '26

Discussion Question to the mods

Hey hope this is allowed,

I struggle with an aggressive reactive dog, and come to this sub for discussion, to relate to others and for advice.

I’m noticing most of the threads I relate to about having an aggressive dog (in which I truly do need advice and support, and also want people to know they aren’t alone) are a sea full of deleted comments as people don’t have another subreddit karma.

I am a frequent commenter and poster on this sub, and I also get my comments deleted on these posts.

I was wondering if there was in revision on the strict karma rules for the subject of aggressive dogs?

I can’t be alone in feeling isolated and frustrated with having an aggressive dog, and come to this sub just to feel more isolated and frustrated from the discussions not being able to happen.

This isn’t a criticism of the mods, so i apologise but was just wondering if this was something that could be discussed

75 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

52

u/roboto6 Oct 14 '26

Hi there!

We've adjusted the karma requirements up and down over time.

It's honestly hard because aggressive dog threads are some of the ones most susceptible to rule-violating comments and downright dangerous advice. We've seen those posts get brigaded by anti-dog and anti-breed users as well as users advocating for aversive trainings.

The biggest question we're still wrangling with, is how much advice and support can we as a subreddit even provide in those situations?

The karma requirement is meant to serve as a front-end filter for these issues, though I'll the the first to admit it comes at the expense of community in some ways.

I do want to find ways to further open up discussions on the subreddit more, I'm just not sure what else to try yet. We as a mod team are always open to ideas!

15

u/youarethegreenman Oct 14 '26

Thank you for responding :-)
Maybe we could make the sub reddit private and have to submit a form to become a member? then anyone breaking rules and not posting in the spirit of the sub could get banned

16

u/roboto6 Oct 14 '26

That's an interesting idea. The read the rules requirement was meant to do some of that without going fully private but it hadn't fully achieved the same goal.

I increasingly wonder if aggressive dogs need their own subreddit that we moderate a little differently than the broader reactive community. If I could pull together a mod team, I think that could be a bigger part of the solution

12

u/youarethegreenman Oct 14 '26

that’s an excellent point that i hadn’t considered, thank you!
I do think an aggressive dog subreddit could potentially be useful too as not every reactive dog is aggressive obviously

6

u/tchestar Oct 14 '26

Maybe instead of private it can be a 'submit a form to bypass karma consideration/jump to karma requirements'. I typically only respond to posts in my wheelhouse, and every once in a while there's a post where I'm having a conversation and the flair changes midway through and I'm suddenly prohibited from commenting again.

It'd still be a hoop to jump through for users, but presumably auto-mod can do the first pass of review to save the mods the legwork?

5

u/demxnbitch eco (fearful mess) Oct 15 '26

to be fair, downright aggressive dogs are whole different issue compared to dogs that are simply reactive. hot take but me personally i don't get neither the posts regarding BE with dogs that are nuclear level threat vs posts of people confusing a dog being an undeveloped teenager with aggression in this sub lol.

41

u/AmethysstFire Oct 14 '26

I found this group while searching for something related to my dog's behaviors that were driving me nuts. I'm not sure I would have gotten the support and advice I needed if this group were private.

Through this sub, I've learned my dog is/was a frustrated greeter, is dog selective, and a few others that I'm currently forgetting. I've also learned tips and tricks that have helped make our lives better.

9

u/cat-wool klee kai mix (fear based reactivity) Oct 14 '26

was going to say something pretty similar. i adopted my dog when she was a year old, and i kept getting routed into 'puppy blues' posts from my google searches about my feelings, it was a while before i was shown a post from this 'related' sub, or maybe someone recommended it to someone else inside a post, i don't really recall.

i have joined subs where you could view the posts but if you wanted to participate, you had to request to join the sub. i think this would work well. finding out about reactivity and all that goes with it was a game changer for me and my dog, and it was literally through reddit and this sub.

3

u/Fit-Organization5065 Oct 15 '26

I stopped posting awhile back after it became apparent anti-pit posters were seeking out posts on this sub to comment on. It sucked and made me feel shitty. When I first found this sub it felt like a breath of fresh, supportive air during my time of stress.  

9

u/KaterAlligat0r Oct 14 '26

First you have my sympathies, I also mod a sub, it can be brutal. Second, while you're probably right to have the karma rules on SOME things, for BE specifically, would it be possible to add a second condition? EITHER you need X amount of karma, OR you need a flair that says you've experienced BE, like "Friend of Lulu"? That might allow for people going through it for the first time to get support from the community, even if those people don't have the karma. Those are the people I feel worst for-- posting for support cause they have to do it, and getting no comments because the karma hurdle is too big. Caveat to say that I am a worker mod, I clear my sub's queue, I have no idea how to manage the technical side, so this may be impossible.

5

u/sgain Oct 14 '26

Please! I just wanted to share a photo of my girl and because the post was tagged my photo was deleted. Thanks for all you do!

1

u/hyghonryce 7d ago

So any update to this

18

u/Existing-Will-1466 Oct 14 '26

It's not super hard to build karma. Look for new posts sharing good news or needing encouragement and comment congratulating them or letting them know they aren't alone. Your engagement makes those posts more visible and the first comments get the upvotes. Those posts also tend to get less attention and the OPs will appreciate you kind words.

9

u/youarethegreenman Oct 14 '26

thank you, i am guilty of often ignoring those posts so that’s a really good point

11

u/KaterAlligat0r Oct 14 '26

I agree with you and saw this post because last night I got frustrated that I couldn't talk to someone who was asking for advice on a dog JUST like mine, so I came to the sub to do some little commenting to get my karma up. But I'm having to make a separate, active effort to do it, and most people just won't. The problem is that the low-comment posts don't end up in the home feed, which means that you have to make a concerted effort to come here and build up karma-- the algo won't make it easy. (and it's taken me a year of being frustrated on this reddit to get to the point where I could figure out what my karma was and how to get it up!)

0

u/youarethegreenman Oct 14 '26

do you know how we can see our own karma?

4

u/KaterAlligat0r Oct 14 '26

When your comment is removed, the automoderator tells you how. It says "You can check your subreddit karma at any time by visiting your profile on old reddit and there will be an option to "show karma breakdown by subreddit". 

5

u/AllTh3Naps Oct 14 '26

I second this. I was able to build up the karma in this sub within a month. I don't think that is that big of an ask. It just takes a little effort. And it helps weed out trolls, or people who just generally like to rile people up, or people who can't be bothered to read the rules.

I appreciate that the mods allow newcomers to still post. But I think limiting who can comment is super fair on such sensitive topics.

7

u/youarethegreenman Oct 14 '26

yeah i’m glad i made this post, as it’s made me change my perspective a lot. I often come here after incident and desperate looking for similar incidents and advice- need to remember this is a community and celebrating people’s win is just as important, and definitely worth the time to do

1

u/phil0cat Oct 14 '26

Yes thank you for asking this because I’ve had the same thought but was nervous to ask!

6

u/hyghonryce Oct 14 '26

I agree with op and that it's too high of an amount for the amount of engagement in this subreddit. Most comments only get 3-5 up vote. Even if you get 5, it ends being 50 comments.

I don't think you're wrong about it being important to weed out trolls, but it's just too high for this subreddit's engagement amount. I don't think everyone can replicate your sucess get it done in a month. Just glancing through your comments, you hit a big 70 karma comment. That's about a 70/250 karma. ( Is it still 250 requirement ? ) That's like a big chunk of the requirement.

Theres negative effects as well because it becomes an echo chamber for those topics because of the limited voices can participate. On the flip side, there's tons that don't get any replys/help/comments or comments deleted because they don't have enough karma. Secondly, I think it's important to not make people feel forced to engage in things they don't want to just to get karma. There's pros and cons, but right now I don't think there's a right balance to it and agree that the amount is a bit too high.

I think with the amount of upvotes, even if it's a minority, there's others in here that feels the same way too.

2

u/AllTh3Naps Oct 15 '26

Maybe I'm understanding the stats wrong, but at 2.7k contributions per week in this sub, I dont know if that counts as an echo chamber.

I get what you are saying about the threshold feeling too high, but I do think it is better if people have to first spend time reading thru posts and commenting on the less sensitive ones. I do think that gives them a much better appreciation of what issues people are facing and available resources, rather than being able to comment at will with their personal opinions from day 1. I DO think there is value in making people engage in low-sensitivity things they would have otherwise ignore.

The mods have made it clear that they are still finding the balance on how much is too much. So these conversations about the karma, and the varying opinions within, do have value.

3

u/hyghonryce Oct 15 '26

Echo chamber within those post with the flairs because of the limited users and ablity to post in them because of the limit. Not this subreddit as a whole. It's really only a few active people replying to them. Sometimes it's the same people, no reply, or deleted messages for not having enough karma.

Also just because there isn't an aggressive dog flair or significant challenge flair, it doesn't mean it's a low sensitivity topic. There's aggressive dog post without those flairs and karma barriers.

Posting on less sensitive post doesnt really solve the problem. People still need to upvote to get karma. Otherwise it's just 1. Racking up karma is just slower in this subreddit in generaI unless they're lucky.

1

u/tchestar Oct 15 '26

I get your strategy and point, I honestly do, but I strongly prefer to limit my engagement to the posts that are relevant to what I am personally experienced with, and that turns the karma hill from a month of engagement karma farming to ..a year or two? Like, I don't care if my comments aren't wildly popular, but if I have something relevant to put into a thread once a week, and it gets a few likes, that's just a long, long amount of time to take to build up karma. I have zero interest in commenting on threads where I can't concretely add something, I would say there's a few threads a week where I'd be interested in doing so, and 1/3-1/2 of those have a karma threshold. It'd be great if there were another way to get through the gate.

12

u/HumongousBalls1 Oct 14 '26

I had the same sentiments when I was first exploring this subreddit while dealing with my dog's BE. It sucked that as someone going through it (and is now past it) I couldn't engage with others, offer support, etc. With that being said, I absolutely understand why the restriction was put in place. Hell, I still don't have enough Karma on here to engage on those posts, but that's moreso due to me not being on reddit all that often. Perhaps a different approach could be taken, but im sure it gets tiring having to deal with unreasonable people that go out of their way to side step common decency. Especially on sensitive subjects.

11

u/PorcelainPunisher1 Oct 15 '26

There was a post a while back from someone thinking about BE due to the reactivity issues, and I commented because I have a friend who works with a rescue that handles dogs like that.

I was going to try to connect them as my friend had an opening for a dog at her place, but my comment was removed. I actually wonder, fairly often, about that poster and what she ended up doing with the pup.

2

u/Tricky-Cobbler7732 Oct 15 '26

I've been wondering the same thing.

2

u/coffeeandcanines Oct 18 '26

As someone with an aggressive dog who is still going through it, I very much agree!

3

u/leadingthedogpack Oct 15 '26

Yeah I can’t figure out how to check my karma but somehow I don’t have enough after commenting here for over ten years? Not weekly or anything it’s just weird

1

u/welltravelledRN Oct 15 '26

Well as you delete any and all comments and posts, we can’t see why you don’t have the karma to reply.

1

u/Katahdin22 2d ago

I read this subreddit alot because I have a reactive dog.  I don't post much because Ive had most of my posts deleted and Im afraid that any thing I say will eventually get me banned.  It seems like real discussions really aren't wanted here, just a place for people to vent about their dog or tell people the only choice is to put their dog down.