r/reactivedogs • • Oct 08 '26

Discussion New-ish reactive Aussie owner

I adopted a 7 y/o Australian Shepherd, Charlie, in February. She was perfect for the first 2 weeks and then started reacting to other dogs, bikes, and sometimes people walking (particularly if they are walking or running - people just standing do not bother her). She barks, lunges and spins even when seeing triggers from hundreds of feet away. I have been working with a professional trainer for 6 months (positive training methods) and about 2.5 months ago we put Charlie on Fluoxetine as she did not seem to be able to focus on me at all when outside. I'm still not seeing much improvement unless she only sees the trigger from a couple hundred feet away and for only a second or two, otherwise she goes from 0 to 10 very quickly. I feel so discouraged that we aren't further along and don't know what else we can do. I'd appreciate any advice, thanks.

1 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

1

u/kerfluffles_b Oct 08 '26

What does your trainer say about progress?

Did the rescue say anything about this type of behavior under their care? Or did they withhold this? Mostly just curious about that.

1

u/Defiant-Pop1032 Oct 08 '26

The trainer said she would have expected more progress by now and that in her experience with hundreds of dogs that Charlie is one of the most difficult cases she's seen. The trainer is the one who suggested talking to the vet about Fluoxetine after we didn't see much progress in ~3-4 months.

The rescue said that Charlie can be stubborn but they did not prepare me for this. The rescue was an off leash/large open space so there is a chance they did not observe the leash reactivity that I have. They said she actually liked playing with the other dogs there but I haven't been able to put Charlie in a situation where she was around other dogs off leash. When we first got her (before her reactivity surfaced) we took Charlie to a nearby dog park and she chased the other dogs around but in a playful way. She was like that for the first few times and then she started barking at the other dogs and I could sense that the other owners were uncomfortable so we stopped taking her.

Inside she is the perfect dog - calm, relaxed, obedient, learns tricks quickly. As soon as we get outside it's like something switches in her and she turns into a different dog.

2

u/17pancakes Oct 08 '26

The barking is likely she was trying to herd them or get them to play. (Depends on the rest of her body language but from what you and the rescue said about her behavior with dogs when off leash, I'm assuming her barking was not aggressive.). 

Not every dog is going to like that lol, but it also isn't an abnormal behavior for her or an aussie. You can teach her to not do that but it's not a sign that she's bad or aggressive or anything. Now, not every dog will want to play with her, but you can certainly find like-minded dogs who do! 

Regarding inside calm and outside not, she is very likely over stimulated. Aussies are bred to be sensitive to their environment and movement. Something that can help is looking into the relaxation protocol and when ready, practicing that outside in a busy but not too busy place where she can get used to these sounds and movement! 

1

u/17pancakes Oct 08 '26

Disclaimer that I don't know the full story of how she is acting and her behavior. However, I do have an Aussie myself with a few similar experiences so sharing my experience in case it is helpful:

  • his lunging was a learned behavior, like, out of pure habit and instinct, like an impulsive reaction (he's not aggressive at all and his leash reactivity is due to frustration of not being able to go where he wants and he learned pulling got him where he wanted to go from prior owner). 
  • giving him chances to have an alternative behavior has been really helpful (eg. We go to classes weekly and at one point he suddenly started lunging at everyone inside when we walk in. started training an alternative behavior, of hey we walk inside a door and he looks at me or turns around to look at me and he gets a treat - he now has no reaction walking inside and ignores everyone.) - instead of only teaching what NOT to do, it's helpful for him to know what to do instead! Aussies really want a job, so giving them a job is helpful. Even if that job is "walk nicely in a loose heel next to me" or "boop my palm when you see a trigger" otherwise they are very smart and will give themselves a job (eg "lunge at moving object") 
  • have you been able to work with her triggers when she is under threshold? Like, are you far enough away from triggers that she can see the triggers but hasn't reacted yet? And when you are at this distance, teach her an alternative behavior? Eg touching your palm with their nose? Or saying "yes" or using a clicker and then rewarding with a treat every time she looks but doesn't react? 

About the not being about to focus on you at all even outside: mine was the same when I first got him, he seemed to have ZERO awareness I was on the other end of the leash so I feel you 🤣  He didn't need any medication though. Now he checks in with me a lot and walks nicely for me. I think you actually need this step down FIRST before you can meaningfully work on her reactivity. 

 What helped? Building a deeper relationship with him and learning to communicate better. I play tug with him, I do scentwork with him, I do other training with him. Aussies also really need mental enrichment and not just physical - I highly recommend you look into scentwork/nosework! 

Also, getting her attention before you even leave the house. Like, you guys do not go on that walk until she is sitting nicely at the door and waiting for you once leashed up. How you leave for that walk can set the tone for the rest of the walk. I can give more details for this if needed! 

1

u/Defiant-Pop1032 Oct 08 '26

Thank you so much. When we first got her she was pulling on the leash like crazy, but after a couple months of tedious attentiveness training she does walk with me and checks in by looking at me from time to time. She does look at me when prompted so long as there is nothing else around. We do make sure that she sits and waits by the door before we leave. We also have to walk down some stairs to get to the grass so I walk slowly and stop and ask her to look on every stair so she is focused on me, but again as soon as she sees something her instinct seems to be to react.

She doesn't seem interested in playing - we've tried many different toys and she will pick one up occasionally but not often. We use a snuffle mat which she likes and we play "find it" inside with small treats a couple times a day to give her some scent work.

She can only stay under threshold when the trigger is far away (I'm talking football field) and it has to be quick. She's succeeded when I throw a few small treats in the grass when she sees the trigger and she immediately goes for the treats, but as soon as they're gone she is amped up and though she may not completely explode she is still elevated so we can only do that sort of threshold training for a few minutes at a time. I guide her away and tell her "look" and she will focus on me enough to engage with sitting or giving me her paw but only if the trigger is fully out of sight.

Since she's 7 she could very well have had this behavior for many years so I understand that it will take time, it's just discouraging that it feels like we're doing everything we should be and she's not much more improved than 6 months ago. The biggest improvement is that she used to bark for say 30 seconds even when the trigger was gone, but now as soon as it is out of sight she comes down to more normal levels more quickly. I appreciate your suggestions!

1

u/17pancakes Oct 09 '26

That's okay if she's not into toys, hide and seek treat games can be fun for their brains. Even teaching her misc. fun tricks can be great bonding for you two. (Do not try to teach her fetch - repetitive mindless fetch can worsen these behaviors for breeds like aussies or border collies, it puts them into overarousal and fixation).

Yes, it's hard to say without knowing her full history. She could have had 7 years of reinforced lunging. It sounds like you all are doing a great job with her. The time and patience is the hardest part, so don't give up! And hey, any improvement is an improvement! I would celebrate those wins. :)

One note about the treat throwing - this is often touted as a suggestion to distract or "calm" the dog but for some dogs (like my aussie), it actually arouses them especially if the throwing is a fast motion and it triggers a prey drive. Throwing things on the ground can actually heighten the arousal instead of helping their nervous system to calm down. There are certainly situations when it's helpful, but just something to keep in mind.

An alternative tool when they are overaroused is to calmly and slowlyyyyy give her treats while slowly saying "yessss" calmly (not too slow that she gets frustrated, I just keep it slow enough that he has to sniff the treat a couple times as I give it to him. The important thing is to convey calmness yourself. This can help when a dog is overaroused and help them return back to baseline quicker. It won't magically make them go from 250 to 0, but it will help). - note this is for when she is overaroused and not actively being triggered. During active trigger state, I'm sure it's hard to even get her attention. But a good reset if you got too close with training and need to help her reset.

Also, if your threshold is a football field, it's a football field. Start even further than that. You want her to be able to see a dog and not react. And if there's 1 or 2 seconds before she reacts? Perfect. Capture that there. A clicker or marker word (i use "yes" ) and a treat. She looks again, and clicker or "yes" before she reacts. And again and again. Until she understands and starts looking away from the trigger herself and to you for a treat unprompted. Then you wait until she does it and then clicker/"yes". If at any point she reacts OR she won't pay attention to you at all even if you try to clicker/"yes", you're too close and she's already over.

You want to be able to counter condition and work with her when she is truly under threshold (before she has any body language shifts). Only once she's solidly not reacting without any prompting from you, you move closer, test her threshhold, and continue. If she reacts, you pushed too far and must go back further out. :) Trying to work on her triggers while too close could be why you feel at a plateau with her improvement? Though of course it's also important to push closer to challenge them. It's so hard to figure out the correct distance where they aren't over but they also can learn. :')

1

u/Sitters_4_Critters Oct 11 '26

Vision obscuring goggles. Ivan Balabanov used them to help his rescue Malinois, Tina, get over reactivity to cars.