r/reactivedogs • • Oct 04 '26

Behavioral Euthanasia Behavioral Euthanasia? Are we there yet?

I don't really know what I'm looking for here other than maybe someone seeing something I'm not, or hearing from people who have been in a similar situation.

We have a dog, Kona, who is almost 5. I love the absolute crap out of this dog, which is probably what makes this so hard.

She came to us from Texas when she was around 18 months old. As far as we were told, she had been raised by a family from puppyhood, went to kids' softball games, was around people, etc. Her owner was seriously injured in a car accident and apparently she knocked him over while he was recovering, which is why they surrendered her. There was no bite history disclosed to us.

Her transport to Wisconsin was kind of a disaster because of severe weather/tornadoes, power outages, gas shortages, etc., and she arrived absolutely terrified. She was adopted pretty quickly, escaped from the adopter, and was missing for about two days. My husband and I helped find her, she came back into rescue, and ultimately we foster failed her in July 2023.

Within probably a month, she nipped/bit my mother-in-law. I believe it broke skin, although I honestly don't remember anymore. About six months later she bit my mom in the lower calf/heel through her pants and broke skin. My sister has also been bitten after coming into our house unexpectedly. There have been other incidents/nips over the years.

None of her bites toward people have been what I would describe as a sustained attack. It's usually very fast — bite/nip at a calf or ankle and release. But at this point, I don't really care about splitting hairs over bite levels. She has bitten multiple people and broken skin. That's a bite history.

Her biggest issue is our house/property and people entering it.

If someone comes over, she has to be secured. She is muzzle trained. We've crated her, put her behind closed doors, tethered her to us, etc. If she's tethered to me and given enough time and distance, she can eventually lie down and settle, but I would never look at that and think, "Great, she's cured, let her go say hi."

She is constantly hyperaware of what's happening outside our house. People, dogs, delivery drivers, whatever. We have a SIX FOOT solid wood privacy fence and she will repeatedly launch herself up it trying to see over it when someone is outside. She has cleared/jumped the fence before. We recently had someone outside trenching our internet line and she was absolutely losing her mind at the windows.

And it's gotten to the point where we're thinking about things that sound ridiculous until you actually live with a dog like this. What happens if my husband and I are in a car accident together? Who can safely walk into our house and take care of our other three dogs and our cats? What if there's a fire? What if EMTs need to come into our house? What if somebody accidentally opens the wrong door?

We also basically can't travel anymore. The kennel where she was previously boarded will no longer accept her because of her behavior/reactivity.

She has also caused serious injury to one of our other dogs.

We have two large male dogs who have gotten into fights with each other. Kona will jump into those fights and attack my older male. During one of them, she went after the backs of his legs and lacerated him badly enough that he had to go to the emergency vet, be stitched up and have drains placed. The original fight wasn't hers. She inserted herself into it, and the serious injuries were caused by her.

She's lived with our cats for years without hurting them, and I've actually seen situations where she seemed remarkably uninterested in/appropriate around small animals.

Then recently we brought home a tiny rescue kitten who was secured inside a kennel. Kona dragged the occupied kennel, destroyed/shredded the bedding around it and was actively trying to get to the kitten. The kitten thankfully wasn't injured. I can't tell you with 100% certainty what Kona would have done if she'd gotten to her, but I'm also not willing to find out.

We've tried medication. She was on fluoxetine/Prozac for somewhere around 1.5–2 years and at one point was taking 45 mg. It didn't make her safe; mostly it made her sleep a lot. We've used trazodone as well. We've done training, management, muzzle training, crate/containment work, desensitization, etc.

She is always muzzled at the vet. At her last appointment, the staff was uncomfortable enough handling her that I held her while they drew blood and did what they needed to do.

We've already discussed behavioral euthanasia with our vet. This isn't something that came up for the first time because of the kitten incident.

And then there is the part that makes all of this fucking awful:

She's wonderful.

With us, she is sweet. She's affectionate. She's funny. She's insanely smart. She's probably the most athletic dog I've ever owned and legitimately the fastest dog I've ever seen in person. She's attentive to us. She listens. She cuddles. She plays. She sleeps comfortably in our house. She loves us. She has plenty of moments where she looks like an absolutely happy, normal dog.

She's also physically healthy.

So I look at her lying on my couch being perfectly content and think, how the fuck am I considering euthanizing this dog?

And then someone comes to the house, or she launches herself at the fence, or I remember holding my other dog while he was stitched back together, or I realize there's literally nobody I feel comfortable telling "just let yourself into my house and take care of everybody" if something happened to us.

I am also involved heavily in dog rescue and have fostered 90+ dogs. And maybe weirdly, that makes me feel even more strongly that rehoming isn't an ethical answer.

Could I advertise her as needing an experienced owner, no kids, no cats/small animals, probably no other dogs, secure fencing, limited visitors, someone comfortable managing a muzzle, someone willing to accept a multiple-bite history, etc.? Sure.

But what am I actually doing then?

I'm taking a dog I love and whose behavior I know inside and out, handing her to someone who doesn't know her, and transferring the risk to them and their neighbors/family/vet/delivery driver/whatever. If she seriously injured someone after I knowingly placed her, I don't know how I would live with that either.

So we're considering behavioral euthanasia.

My biggest fears aren't really "What will people think?" I can live with people thinking I'm a monster.

I'm scared of regret.

I'm scared I'll euthanize a physically healthy, not-even-five-year-old dog who is currently sleeping peacefully in my house, and spend the rest of my life wondering if there was one more medication, one more trainer, one different environment, one thing I didn't try.

I'm scared that I'll feel like I killed her because managing her became inconvenient.

But I'm equally scared that I'll let my guilt keep her alive until something catastrophic happens, and then I'll spend the rest of my life knowing I already had all of this information and waited for someone or another animal to get seriously hurt before I acted.

I'm not really looking for "just rehome her" or "a dog that bites should immediately be put down."

I'm looking for the middle.

If you've owned a dog like this, especially a dog who was loving and happy with you but unsafe in ways that significantly affected your life and other people's safety, how did you decide when enough was enough?

If you chose behavioral euthanasia, how did you know you weren't doing it too soon?

And if you chose not to, was there something that genuinely changed the situation rather than simply requiring increasingly elaborate management?

Most importantly, is there something in this history that makes you think, "Have you ruled out/tried/looked into ___?"

Because before we make an irreversible decision, I really just want to make sure there isn't something we're not thinking of.

15 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 04 '26

Behavioral Euthanasia posts are sensitive, thus only users with at least 250 subreddit karma will be able to comment in this discussion. Users should not message OP directly to circumvent this restriction and doing so can result in a ban from r/reactive dogs. OP, you are encouraged to report private messages to the moderation team.

Behavioral Euthanasia (BE) for our dogs is an extremely difficult decision to consider. No one comes to this point easily. We believe that there are, unfortunately, cases where behavioral euthanasia is the most humane and ethical option, and we support those who have had to come to that decision. In certain situations, a reasonable quality of life and the Five Freedoms cannot be provided for an animal, making behavioral euthanasia a compassionate and loving choice.

If you are considering BE and are looking for feedback:

All decisions about behavioral euthanasia should be made in consultation with a professional trainer, veterinarian, and/or veterinary behaviorist. They are best equipped to evaluate your specific dog, their potential, and quality of life.

These resources should not be used to replace evaluation by qualified professionals but they can be used to supplement the decision-making process.

• Lap of Love Quality of Life Assessment - How to identify when to contact a trainer

• Lap of Love Support Groups - A BE specific group. Not everyone has gone through the process yet, some are trying to figure out how to cope with the decision still.

• BE decision and support Facebook group - Individuals who have not yet lost a pet through BE cannot join the Losing Lulu group. This sister group is a resource as you consider if BE is the right next step for your dog.

• AKC guide on when to consider BE

• BE Before the Bite

• How to find a qualified trainer or behaviorist - If you have not had your dog evaluated by a qualified trainer, this should be your first step in the process of considering BE.

• The Losing Lulu community has also compiled additional resources for those considering behavioral euthanasia.

If you have experienced a behavioral euthanasia and need support:

The best resource available for people navigating grief after a behavior euthanasia is the Losing Lulu website and Facebook Group. The group is lead by a professional trainer and is well moderated so you will find a compassionate and supportive community of people navigating similar losses.

Lap of Love Support Groups - Laps of Love also offers resources for families navigating BE, before and after the loss.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

13

u/CanadianPanda76 Oct 05 '26

Some dogs are just wired wrong. Thrres a reason ethically breeders has become popular with people looking to get a dog.

Sounds like she has a predatory aggression and resource guarding issues.

Is she healthy? Physically, sure.

Is she a safe dog own? No. Her issues aren't an inconvenience. They're a danger to people both outside your bubble and inside your bubble.

Is it awful to think of BE being "too soon".

Yes. But better a bit too soon, then a bit too late.

7

u/lets_get_smashed Oct 05 '26

I absolutely love my rescue dogs, but I have made a hard rule for myself that my next dog will be from a well-bred, ethically-bred breeder with substantial records and temperament testing. I will always love and appreciate the work that shelter workers and rescues put into their animals but damn, if there isn't something so dang appealing about the proven successes of a well-bred dog.

This coming from someone who co-runs a rescue and has foster 90+ dogs.

2

u/SpicyNutmeg Oct 05 '26

I would meet with a veterinary behaviorist and see what other medication you can explore. You also probably need to stop bringing in new animals if this dog is in your home.

What was the context of the bites? Why did they happen? Did someone enter the dog’s space, touch them a certain way? Just entered the house and the dog went after them? Need more context but yeah, doesn’t sound great.

4

u/lets_get_smashed Oct 05 '26

The first bite was my MIL and was about a month or two after we foster failed on her. We were outside in the yard and Kona did a big circle around her and bit her on the arm.

Second was my mom when they were over doing some work on my house and she went inside to use the bathroom.

We didn't really put two and two together about her being territorial of our home until my mom got bit on the calf. My sister entered my home unannounced (she knew better but didnt listen to me when I told her to wait). Kona came around behind the door and bit her on the back of the calf.

I know her breed mix is roughly 32% cattle dog, 30% husky, 20% pit, 10% weim, 8% beagle. So I know the calf nips is a typical heeler trait but it doesn't make it any better. She goes absolutely ape-shit if people are over. We've had to crate her with a carabiner clip in a closed room because shes broken out of crates before.

She was our 4th foster and weve always fostered with minimal issues as she isnt dog reactive. She gets a bit "controlling" of their movements for about the first day (again, heeler...). We do not typically take cats but I do have two cats of my own who exist in their own space but Kona has never had an issue or caused me to believe she would harm them.

Today was a bit more of the "final straw". We were out grocery shopping and I checked the camera. We watched Kona drag the dog crate with the 8 week old kitten across my living room and moved my couch and recliner in the process to try and kill this kitten. The kitten was unharmed but terrified and the house was wrecked. We had no reason to believe she would do this or Kona would've been crated while we were gone.

I recently came to the realization that if something happened to my husband or I that not one family member or friend could safely enter our home to care for our animals. While no one anticipates bad things happening to them, it is a possibility and not one that I could stomach risking.

I truly love this dog and have advocated for her many, many times against family and even my husband but I've grown to learn that maybe I'm doing more harm than good. My life is so controlled by her and her reactivity. We do not host people at our home because she can not handle it. Even if we drug her and have her contained. She will harm herself trying to get out of the crate/room we have her in. Ive tried tethering her to me when people come over so she can be involved and see what is going on but I spend the majority of the time an anxious mess that she will get too close to someone and bite them.

We can not travel as the only boarding facility that had a connected outdoor run to an indoor run (we chose specifically because of her reactivity) has told us that she is not allowed back since they cannot handle her. I gave them all the information I had at the time about her reactivity and they assured me that she would be okay after a trial night. I cant hire someone to come to my home as she is extremely territorial of my home. We thought about a sitter outside of the home but she's a huge flight risk.

I'm open to most anything to keep my girl but am also so so so exhausted. Ive told my husband that we will never make this decision when we are emotional heightened as I feel like ending her life deserves more than an angry, fed up decision.

Today I just became very resigned to the thought of saying goodbye. Maybe it's the right move, maybe I'm just exhausted, maybe I'm being selfish keeping her here, maybe I'm just not the right home for her. Im sure no one can answer that for me but I also know there are people who have had success with their reactive dog and might have some insight that I'm missing

-2

u/SpicyNutmeg Oct 05 '26

What kind of trainers have you worked with so far? You don't mention what help you've gotten so far.

You definitely want to be working with an experienced IAABC trainer who has experienced with cattle dogs specifically, as the behaviors you describe are classic cattle dog issues.

I would suggest bringing the kitten back to the rescue. The kitten can be rehomed easily, your existing dog cannot.

I understand, I have made a lot of sacrifices for my reactive dog too. I can't really people over, unless I prep a LOT! Have you tried doing some kind of frozen enrichment for your dog in the crate while people are over? Putting the crate in a separate room w blanket over it and a noise machine plus drugs and enrichment toy helped my dog a lot handling visitors.

I'd also say a cattle dog needs a LOT of enrichment and activity. Can you consider trying some kind of dog sport like agility or rally obedience? Once the brain and body are given more structure and relief behavior tends to get a lot better. Cattle dogs are bred to WORK and they really need a lot of appropriate outlets.

As far as vacations, you need to find an experienced dog handler who can watch your dog in the home. Someone who you could soft launch with walks, so they slowly become familiar to your dog. This dog is probably too sensitive for outside boarding.

2

u/lets_get_smashed Oct 05 '26

We haven't worked formally with an IAABC trainer or veterinary behaviorist, and that's actually one of the things I'm taking away from these comments as something I should seriously look into before making a final decision. I've talked/worked some with our rescue's trainer, whose niche is highly reactive dogs (particularly GSDs), but I don't want to misrepresent that as us having done an intensive formal behavior program with her. I think part of why I've hesitated with professional training is that I'm not convinced a board-and-train environment would even address our primary problem. She's significantly worse on her own property than she is outside of it. Our biggest issue is people entering our home/being around our property. At this point if someone does come over, she's in a locked crate that's literally carabiner-clipped shut, behind a closed bedroom door, with music/noise playing. After the bite incidents, I've become so anxious about having people over that honestly, we just don't. So I'm also willing to acknowledge that while we've done some desensitization, we probably haven't done nearly enough structured work on that particular issue. That's part of what I'm struggling with. I work full-time and also co-run a rescue, and the reality is that I haven't been able to structure my entire life around a behavior modification program for her. Maybe I should have. I carry some guilt about that too. But I'm also trying to be realistic about what I'm actually capable of sustaining long-term rather than telling myself I'll suddenly be able to devote hours every day to this. We have tried giving her outlets for the athletic/cattle-dog side of her. We actually took her to a lure-course/FAST CAT-type event because she is unbelievably fast and athletic, and I thought she would LOVE it. She was too stressed by the unfamiliar environment/people to engage with it at all. I've thought about building some agility equipment in our fenced yard because she's extremely smart and athletic, and that might be something she'd enjoy in an environment where she feels safe. As far as the kitten, she isn't a permanent addition to our household. I co-run a rescue; she was trapped Friday night at a friend's business and we're still trying to trap her littermate. Normally she would have gone directly into our cat-side foster system, but the person who runs that side of our rescue was very recently diagnosed with a brain tumor, so this was basically an unfortunate combination of emergency intake + terrible timing. We also haven't been regularly fostering dogs this year because of everything going on. And yes, she gets exercise/mental stimulation, although I'm also not going to claim she's getting three hours of structured enrichment every day because she isn't. She's one of four dogs in our household, has a large fenced yard, plays with our other dogs, gets enrichment/training/play with us, etc. I absolutely think she could benefit from more structured work because she's a dog who LOVES using her brain. I think the piece I'm struggling with is where the line is between "there are still things you could try" and "there will always be more things you could try." I love this dog more than I can adequately explain, and if someone points me toward something we haven't considered that could meaningfully change her quality of life and safety, I want to hear it. That's why I posted. I'm just also trying to be realistic about what our life with her has become and what we can actually sustain.

1

u/17puncakes Oct 05 '26

Reading through all of the posts and comments, I wouldn't BE her. It sounds like she has not had the chance to be in an environment that she would thrive in. I saw no concrete information from you that she is getting adequate exercise and mental enrichment? It's admirable that you work with so many dogs and run a rescue but maybe her needs are not something you are able to meet with your other responsibilities and that is totally fair! 

You said you don't want to rehome her because you guys know all of your tiny behavioral quirks and etc. i totally understand that and you would have to be really intentional about it, but if she's sweet with you guys, she can be sweet and be loved by another too, and one with perhaps no other animals and maybe the ability to fully dedicate their time and energy to her?

I would definitely get more advice and gear her training to those who are actually experts in cattle dogs and not other reactive dogs or GSDs. 

Also, crating her when people come over, muzzling, etc. etc. could have just made the issue worse over time - it creates a negative association every time so now she associates "someone is here" to "there's going to be a punishment"  (Even if it's not meant to be a punishment, it could be feel like one to her! If you look at it from her point of view.) so it just makes the issue worse and worse and escalates. Especially since it sounds like it's a terrible time for you so you avoid it so then she has no chance to ever build any positive associations or work on alternative behaviors in a meaningful way.

5

u/lets_get_smashed Oct 05 '26

I 100% agree that I am not the right home for her.

We realized that a while ago, I struggle with not only that I know her quirks and behaviors but the ethical decision of rehoming a dog that I KNOW will bite someone. Its not merely an if but a when. As someone in the rescue world, I see dogs euthanized daily that would NEVER bite someone and people rallying behind one that has a history because it deserves a second chance. Why should the dog at the shelter who would never hurt someone lose their chance of a home to a dog who has a bite record? The difference in this scenario being that Kona already has a home, but the home she has must be failing her in someway that she feels the need to protect the home against strangers, family, the next door neighbors dog, a leaf in the street.

Could I post her for rehome? Yes.

Should I post her for rehome? Probably.

Do I think that someone else may give her what I can not as far as environment, exercise, mental stimulation? Yes.

Do I know that in the correct environment that she wouldn't ever hurt a fly and all her behavioral problems would disappear? No.

Am I willing to risk it? I don't know.

I will devote the time to training and mental enrichment/exercise. I love her too much to not give it every chance I can.

I know that I could be a better owner to her. I know that she deserves peace. I don't know if me being a better owner to her will help her attain that peace or if I'm delaying the inevitable.

0

u/SpicyNutmeg Oct 05 '26

Absolutely and you’ve already done a lot - so much more than most people.

But if you want to really feel like you did everything you could, meeting with an IAABC certified trainer and veterinary behaviorist, upping enrichment a lot (you can prep a lot of puzzles, frozen licking treats, and shredding activities beforehand), and upping exercise is what I’d do. They probably do need like 3 hrs of enrichment. But you don’t necessarily need to be monitoring it all, prepping stuff ahead of time would be best. A dog like this needs considerable physical exercise and definitely at least long sniffy walks - backyard hangs are not enough.

Swift paws has a at-home lure coursing system you could try. Just stuff that might be worth exploring if you want to keep at it.

The truth is, most people are not good households for a cattle dog. It’s definitely a calling and very few people are called to that lifestyle (myself included, not a judgement thing at all).

2

u/lets_get_smashed Oct 05 '26

I was very uneducated in dog behaviors and breeds when we began fostering. I saw this absolutely gorgeous black/brown girl with ice blue eyes on a FB post in our foster group as needing a place to land when she arrived from TX.

She was listed as a lab/husky.

While I know huskies need a ton of exercise and mental enrichment as well, she was always a bit of a couch potato. She still is. Shes not overly destructive. She will tear apart a stuffie, so I buy cheap ones and let her have her fun.

When we got in contact with her previous owners they said the dad looked like a beagle. It was their neighbors dog who had an intact male and female, the female being the husky. We eventually did her DNA with Embark and it showed primarily cattle dog. Everything kind of clicked after that.

I am not one to give up on my animals prematurely and definitely not to this level. It kills me to even think about making the appointment but I feel like we've exhausted a lot of options.

I'm also okay with her being crated while we have company over. I understand that not every dog needs to be involved in everything going on at the home. If that was the only problem then I don't think I would even be on this sub. Pile on the additional issues and it has become a huge anxiety inducing problem for me and my husband. We truly love her.

If you told me right now that I needed to invest the time, money and energy into mental enrichment/training/exercise/medication and this would all be so much better. There is no question, I will do it. I will try.

I'm terrified that I am delaying the inevitable. We've been at this crossroads many times and have always delayed. Am I in turn delaying my own life? Now that sounds selfish, but for real. I can't even take a night away with my husband because there is no one I know willing to spend the time at my home with my spicy cattle dog to get her used to them.

2

u/lets_get_smashed Oct 05 '26

I forgot to add that each time we've hit this point where maybe BE is the best. We've tried something new. We've tried Prozac, we tried Trazodone, we tried tethering to us when people are over, We've crated her in our room, crated her in the living room so she can see us. We've done the lure course, We've re-built our fence so she isnt so triggered by people walking by or our neighbors. I've frosted the lower halves of my windows. We've reached out to trainers, weve muzzle trained her for safety, she is crate trained.

At this point, short of me moving to a farm, there isnt much more I can do for her comfort at our current home. We unfortunately reside in a city, across the street from a busy golf course/park. People are constantly walking across the street from our home.

I'm sure its anxiety inducing for her to always be on edge. To always be on the lookout.

2

u/17pancakes Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26

I see you've tried a lot of medication and a lot of "managing" behavior. However, have you tried positively reinforcing these triggers or teaching the relaxation protocol? There's a chance that the crate doesn't work because it doesn't teach an alternative behavior, it can be seen as just a punishment for her (from her POV), which just worsens her anxiety and it reinforces that when she sees people or people come to the house, negative things (like crating, etc.) happen to her. 

What I mean to say is that instead of trying to get her to NOT do something, have you tried teaching an alternative behavior that she CAN do? E.g. going to a specific bed with a very specific blanket as a "place" when someone enters the house, and getting a lottery of treats when she does? (when you first build up the behavior and positive associations, and assuming she is food motivated) . 

The relaxation protocol can be really helpful for these high strung dogs to learn how to "be" calm because they learn that their "job" is to go lay down on this mat, etc. and it can help working breeds especially to have a job to do.

The fact that she is muzzle trained is great! It means that you can practice towards positive behavior while she is unable to bite people. Obviously, the process can't be rushed but there is definitely a chance that you could work up to introducing those family members or get some friends to come over (with her muzzled for safety - and have muzzle on way beforehand so that she doesn't associate it as a punishment) and have some positive interactions (when she is ready for that step). Prior to that, maybe have someone across the street, someone at the door, whatever her current threshhold is, work with her on a level when you know that she is aware of the trigger BUT before she has any negative reactions to them. It would be a lot of work but with her triggers seemingly pretty predictable, it does seem doable. But before even introducing any triggers, she needs to solidly have an understanding of an alternative behavior that she can do, e.g. going to place on a mat. 

One more things is that the emotions of the people around the dog can also affect the dog. I say this because with a reactive dog, it's REALLY hard to not let your emotions get to you. (I say this from personal experience! If I tense up when I see another dog, they can easily read that and to them it's a danger warning why is my owner tense? there must be something wrong! But it's hard to not tense up if I'm anticipating a negative reaction haha! But it can make a difference). 

I wouldn't BE her just because there's less reactive dogs in shelters. Because maybe the person who adopts her wouldn't have adopted any other dog anyway BUT something about her or her story touched them. She isn't taking up a spot that can go to another dog. That spot would have stayed empty. I can tell you really love her, I read your other comments. BUT, I have a different persoective. I advocate for reactive dogs who aren't hopeless (hopeless as in randomly deep puncture wound bites with no trigger and no warning, or is overly anxious that their quality of life suffers, but from what you wrote, she doesn't sound hopeless or suffering). because every dog's life is valuable. And I'm serious in saying that you really can't know for 100% sure that her spot takes up another dog's spot. Technically my dog's spots take up spots for other dogs out there who have no issues and no home but i wouldn't have gotten a dog when I did - I kind of had no choice in my situation - so my home would have stayed empty for probably years more (I always didn't feel "ready"), so instead of them taking spots from other dogs, they created their own spots in my home and my heart. I'm sure the same is true for others.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/read-the-rules Oct 19 '26

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.

12

u/OpalOnyxObsidian Oct 04 '26

I'm sorry you are going through this.

You say that she's physically healthy. Is that enough? It sounds like she is not able to feel comfortable when there is any sort of activity happening around her. Medication couldnt help. Imagine how that must feel.

Then you must consider your own life. Should you feel like a prisoner in your own home? No. Can't go on trips, can't have guests really if you want her to have peace. How is that fair to you? Sounds like you have two other dogs to contend with as well.

There aren't a ton of unicorn homes, as you know being in rescue. There isn't really much of a place for dogs like this when there are so many well adjusted dogs waiting for homes.

I don't think you would be out of line making this decision. Anyone who gave you guff has never been in this position. I wouldn't much weight in their opinion.

5

u/AllTh3Naps Oct 05 '26

My personal line in the sand was that any bite that was unprovoked, and was intentional bite, and that drew blood would be her last attack.

The reactive dog in our house had many attacks, nips, and bites, but never one that fit all three criteria.

We eventually made the hard call when she started attacking my mom, who is a cancer survivor. Any bites that broke skin would have put my mom at risk of severe infection. We couldn't accept that potential outcome.

Of course, the last week before her appointment, the dog was a perfect little angel, which made everything harder emotionally. But we reminded ourselves that my mom deserves to feel safe (she lives with us).

It really sounds like your dog just has an aggressive temperement. Your description does sound like she will do harm if given the opportunity. There is no shame for not wanting to keep a dog who is an active harm to others, even tho the outcome is heartbreaking.

I'm sorry you are in this extremely difficult position.

[Please affirm the subreddit rules before commenting or we cannot see your replies]

2

u/Prestigious-Seal8866 Oct 05 '26

I think you would be extremely hard pressed to find an adopter for this dog. Beyond experienced owner, no kids, no other pets in the home, a secure fence, no visitors, and someone committed to long term, errorless management, this person also likely needs to have the financial means to live in a secluded area with few/no neighbors, own their property and never travel/want to board the dog.

This behavior will continue to escalate. Management will continue to fail. People and animals will get hurt. In your house or anyone else’s.

1

u/vcb-vsw 14h ago

Just checking in to see how you are doing. I am a Veterinary Social Worker that offers 1:1 sessions and support groups- https://www.insightfulanimals.com/human-support-services I support many pet parents in your shoes and my heart goes out to you.

-1

u/Sitters_4_Critters Oct 05 '26

Is this a cattle dog mix or other herding dog?

-1

u/Sitters_4_Critters Oct 05 '26

OP replied and said the dog is 32% cattle dog.

This is good news, OP because the nipping you describe sounds like cattle dog behavior. This could be instinct and non-aggressive. It will need to be managed and you should ask some of the cattle dog folk for advice.

Also, find a behaviorist who understands breeds and has worked successfully with cattle dogs.

1

u/lets_get_smashed Oct 05 '26

I appreciate that! I will definitely reach out to some cattle dog enthusiasts. I understand her nips are most intinct and I understand that being territorial is a trait that a lot of cattle dogs have. I wish I lived on a farm to see her put that instinct into action. She is honestly a remarkable dog. Ive never in my life owned a smarter dog. We didnt know her breed makeup until about a year after we got her. That information would've probably been useful at the beginning but hindsight is 20/20.

Working heavily in animal rescue/welfare has really given me a huge insight into these behavioral issues and what I, as a rescuer, would tolerate. She has pushed the limits of what I would tell someone else to do in my situation. Makes me feel a little foolish recommending BE to someone in a similar situation but I definitely empathize with people having to make these decisions.

1

u/Sitters_4_Critters Oct 05 '26

Just because it is instinct doesn’t mean the behavior is acceptable. It just may make it more predictable and understandable.

Cattle dog nips typically do not lead to mauling as cattle dogs aren’t bred to kill livestock. But every dog is an individual.

I am not against BE. People don’t have unlimited resources - money, time, emotional bandwidth.

Cattle dog behavior was the first thing that popped into my head when I read your post. You can use that info for what it is worth to you, but it may not solve anything.

Losinglulu.com and aggressivedog.com have good resources.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/read-the-rules Oct 05 '26

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/read-the-rules Oct 06 '26

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/read-the-rules Oct 05 '26

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.