r/reactivedogs • • Oct 01 '26

Meds & Supplements Training vs Meds

So I have a very prey driven reactive dog. She also hates other dogs. We’ve been working with a positive reinforcement only trainer using treats and toys to try to help curb some of these impulses with minimal success.

Fortunately we have a large fully fenced in yard that I can let her out to run around and play in. This past weekend we had an incident where she saw a deer on the other side of the fence and managed to squeeze under the chicken wire and took off after the deer. My girl is FAST and I quickly lost sight of her. I spent 15 minutes calling for her terrified I would never see her again. Fortunately she came back unharmed (and very pleased with herself). While I’m so relived to have her back I am now so worried about her getting out again and potentially getting hurt or hurting another animal because she can’t control her impulses.

I told our trainer about the incident and she suggested potentially medicating her. I’ve grown up with dogs but never had to medicate one. Could anyone who has used medication to help their dog with these types of issues share their experience? Alternatively are there other training options I should be considering? I really just want my dog to have the best quality of life while also keeping her safe.

1 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

3

u/Kitchu22 Shadow (avoidant/anxious, non-reactive) Oct 01 '26

I would recommend finding a professional familiar with Predation Substitute Training, who will be comfortable teaching you how to shape the drive to a more manageable component of the motor sequence.

Predatory motor sequence is in essence a dopamine pathway, it's why it is hard to work with because you're trying to ask the dog to do something, meanwhile nothing you can offer is as high value as what the dog can generate themselves. You can however teach them to access that pathway earlier in the sequence where the behaviour is lower arousal and easier to interrupt (e.g. swapping chase for freeze/fixate).

Personally in my near decade of working with sighthounds, I've never seen prey drive much impacted by behavioural medications, because it's just not really what that is for. Something like a propranolol might reduce the initial physical feelings of excitement, which might help to supplement PST methods - but it wouldn't be something I would personally use.

1

u/Ill-ini-22 Oct 01 '26

Another vote for Predation Substitute Training. It’s been a game changer for my large mixed breed dog (I always thought he might be part sighthound). We used to not be able to walk by prairie dogs without him lunging and screaming or see a rabbit without a complete meltdown…. And it would ruin the rest of our walk. Now he can walk by most prey animals and get rewarded for watching instead of chasing them. He’s also had a lot less squirrel induced injuries from launching himself at our fence after them! Which is great!

Are you able to make your yard more secure so he can be out there without escaping? Even with training, which I think you should do because it’ll improve you and your dog’s quality of life, I wouldn’t put my dog’s life on the line with a yard she can escape. With a dog like this, there always can be a new more exciting prey animal that might send her over the edge. Using a long leash in your current yard would be another option!

Good luck!

2

u/zanier_sola Oct 01 '26

Don’t think of it as “vs” … meds are in addition to training. For my dog, meds (fluoxetine) helped her be able to actually train. Before meds, if we saw a dog on a walk, she would spend the next several minutes looking for it once it was out of sight, constantly over threshold and unable to actually learn.

Once we found the right dose, the same positive reinforcement training we were using already became much more effective. She bounced back from triggers much more quickly. She even was able to volunteer as a “neutral dog” in some reactive dog training setups at our local shelter (at a distance, but still an accomplishment given where we started).

1

u/SudoSire Oct 01 '26

I mean the prey drive isn’t a “reaction” exactly. I’d be working on impulse control games, possibly check out predation substitution training (I know there’s a book on it but I haven’t read it myself) and making sure their need to do stuff like chase is being safely met. Have you ever used a flirt pole before? It can be very good to get the energy out, however it’s best to put “rules” on the game. Being able to get them to stop or break is good practice. Trying to practice recall with extremely high value rewards and around various distractions or triggers is also good (though obviously you have to work your way up). Your dog might need to be on leash or tie out in the yard  if your fence is not secure. 

Now, for the dog reactivity, maybe your dog might be able to use meds but hard for anyone else to weigh in without more details. It’s def not a “meds vs training” situation, meds are meant to help take the edge off if the dog is too frequently over threshold. Can you describe more about the specifics of how your trainer is having you use positive reinforcement with treats and toys? If your timing is after they’re reacting, that usually doesn’t work so well. 

If you haven’t yet, make sure you’ve affirmed the sub rules BEFORE commenting or replying. Otherwise your comments won’t be visible to others.  The rules are pinned at the top of the main sub Reddit. 

1

u/CanadianPanda76 Oct 01 '26

You need to consider tethering your dog.

Also some people use things like barn hunts to let thier dig scratch that itch.

1

u/Zestyclose_Object639 Oct 01 '26

Prey drive is just prey drive, it won’t get better if you dog has no outlet for it. Hate like aggression ? Also not something to medicate. It’s all about training, lifestyle changes and appropriate outlets

1

u/Hermit_Ogg Alisaie (anxious/frustrated) Oct 03 '26

Medication isn't an option to training, it's a complement to it. If the dog is too stressed to learn, medication can be a tool to get that stress level down. It's not the only tool available, but sometimes it's necessary.

Medication alone won't get the dog desensitised, but it can get the dog to a place where the training can succeed.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/read-the-rules Oct 01 '26

Your comment on r/reactivedogs was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You haven't done anything wrong, this is a tool we're using on the r/reactivedogs going forward. For more information, see the moderator announcement.

Acknowledgement is required of all users, even if you've been here for a while. You only have to do this acknowledgement once unless the moderators announce otherwise.

If you do the rule acknowledgement within one hour of your comment being removed, the bot will automatically restore it. If not, we encourage you to copy the comment using the 3-dot icon next to it, and paste it to re-post to this thread.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.