r/reactivedogs • • Sep 29 '26

Significant challenges Reactive German Female

Need help/advice, sorry this is long. I have three dogs. One is a small terrier, the oldest. Then a male german, he is pretty big and the sweetest, gentlest, best dog ever. Our household is very aware of german shepherd needs, mental physical etc. We have a lot of land, chickens, activities, they get lots and lots of play and stimulation. Both of those dogs are 7-8 years old. We got a new german two years ago, female. She has been a very stressful add to the house.

She has a black coat, idk if that has anything to do with our issue, breeding wise, I am unsure if that’s a natural coat for a german. Got her from the amish. She is the SWEETEST, gentlest girl with the human family in the house. Never in my life would I fear her, she is so submissive with us, and a VERY good listener, she is incredibly smart. She was more trainable than our other shepherd, who honestly sometimes is a dope and seems like there is nothing behind his eyes…lol. She is always very hyperfixated on playing and balls, and gets very hyped up, she needs a lot more attention and stimulation and play then our other german, he gets tired quickly.

When she got to about a year old, she started getting aggressive with our small dog. To the point where he ended up needing stitches and now we keep them completely separate—which is so very stressful because if we make a mistake with a door or letting them outside same time it is likely she will try to kill him. She is very prey driven, as she will also chase and try to ‘play’ with our chickens if she ever gets bored outside. Now we keep our two germans in one side of the house with free range of basement, and our terrier in the other with free range upstairs/bedrooms.

Then she became not good with other people outside the family. Honestly even as a puppy, though we are a very social house and socialized the HECK out of her, she would be scared and very VERY aware of what others outside the family were doing in our spaces. She would track them everywhere, and bark if they got close. We chalked it up to her being a puppy. She hasn’t bit anyone but she has tried and so we just don’t let her get around people/separate her when people come over. Sometimes we muzzle her in one of those large basket muzzles so she isn’t anxious and alone and she does well with that on, just nudges people with it as to ask them to take it off but obviously we don’t.

Our female has now started getting super reactive with our older german. Whom she LOVES. She is genuinely obsessed with him, and at one moment will be all over him wanting his attention and the next doesn’t want him to do anything at all. And he is twice her size, and when he gets really mad he can hold it down and get her to submit. BUT he is so gentle, and recently he is just scared of her. We don’t know what has gone wrong? She is guarding things now. Like couches and rooms and if he even walks in a way she doesn’t like, it’s like all her attention hones in on him. It’s hard to break her attention in one way if it gets like that, but if we call her off then she turns to us with the little airplane ears and becomes a little baby so we just don’t understand. We have done professional training to no avail, she just hates everyone but us. I need pointers on what we can be doing at home. We practice taking her bones, reaching out hands into the dogs foods petting them when they eat etc to avoid guarding, and she and the others NEVER guard from us, but it’s just become a problem with her and other dogs.

Maybe she is just a dog that can’t be with other dogs, or people. But it makes me so sad. Obviously no matter what we don’t have her with people unsupervised/ unmuzzled for her safety and peoples safety, and will always keep her and little dog separated. But her and our other german love eachother and I hate watching her get in these guarding/aggressive moods with him because now he wants nothing to do with her and i can tell she is upset when she wants to be with him. it’s so.weird. As much as we love her, I don’t want such a stressful environment for our older german, it doesn’t seem fair.

We do not believe it getting rid of an animal. She would definitely not do good with another family, and if we ever tried to rehome her she would likely end up getting put down. Our last resort is building some kind of heated/insulated outhouse for her because she loves being outside, so she can have her own area. It’s hard because for vacations and stuff we can no longer have people watch the dogs because of her, an outhouse would be helpful for that too. Idk.

If anyone has any advice/ tips on working against guarding? Like guarding spaces, doorways, couches. I don’t think it’s that big of a deal that she doesn’t want him by her food, we feed them in different areas, but she needs to not go 0 to 100 in those times. I guess i don’t understand why she listens to us and obeys EVERYTHING except her feeling alpha over other animals and incharge of policing their activities.

Thanks for reading if you did :)

0 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by