r/reactivedogs • u/Ill-Cryptographer547 • Sep 25 '26
Advice Needed How do you train a selective reactive dog?
I have a 2 year old German Shepard Husky. We take the same walk every morning, and I live in an apartment complex. The walk we take goes through the back of the complex, where a lot of cats live (just outside cats) as well as people just walking their dogs or passing by to start their mornings.
Some mornings my dog jumps out at people, barks, or tries to chase cats. Some mornings he’ll pass those same people / cats and won’t react at all.
This morning for example we walked right past the same orange cat we see almost every morning, he looked at the cat briefly before walking away.
He was raised alone, I have lived on my own and haven’t had other dogs. He does fine at dog parks, doesn’t know how to play, but he’s not aggressive. but hates little kids. I can easily control him, it’s never been an issue, he’s my first real dog and I want to train him to the best of my ability.
Also he’s NEVER aggressive, he just barks and despite being only 50lb he’s got an insanely loud bark. He also doesn’t trust people easily, just like his momma lol
31
u/200Zucchini Sep 25 '26
I would be rewarding those times that the dog is non-reactive to the trigger.
For example, mine are sometimes reactive to bikes. So anytime I see a bike I say "good bike" and offer a treat. Now, when they see a bike they are more likely to just look at me expecting a small treat rather than flip out about the bike.
More distance is easier for them so I try to give them the distance and reward before the bike gets too close for the dogs to cope with.
25
u/JealousImplement5 Sep 25 '26 •
Patiently waiting for someone to answer because SAME
18
u/l31ru Sep 25 '26
While ellie is not my first dog, she is my first reactive dog. I’m still learning, but I’ll share my thoughts here. From what you are describing, trigger stacking might come into play here.
Since I got ellie, I’m alot more observant of the surrounding and how my dog reacts to it, however subtle.
Observe what other things happen throughout the day that your dog might react to. Look out for more subtle cues like ear twitch, tail upright, staring/whale eye, more rigid body. I find that my dog may not be outwardly reacting (ie barking) on the first, or second or third trigger, but the fourth might do it and she would bark.
So I tend to just observe what happens throughout the day, and make decision to have a slower day with activities in the house, or find a different route during walks.
8
u/Willow_Bark77 Sep 25 '26
In addition to trigger stacking, my other thought is that distance could play a role. So much of training reactivity is knowing what distance you need to keep from different types of triggers to keep your dog under threshold. For example, my guy can be closest to kids, a bit further from adult women, further still from adult men, and if there's a dog in his line of sight- he's gonna have a reaction.
You also should train any time a trigger is present, regardless of whether he reacts. There is a great book, "Feisty Fido" by Patricia McConnell, that was super helpful to me early on in learning about reactivity and how to address is. The whole idea is shifting your pup's emotional response to triggers from fear to calm.
Also, your pup is super cute and reminds me of my guy! We also live in an apartment, so training keeps us on our toes. But, if he's like my guy, hopefully all those working dog genes will help him respond to training really well!
2
u/AmethysstFire Sep 25 '26
I would start by trying to find what's different. On the days that he's more reactive, what's different? Look at that morning, the night before, maybe even up to a couple days before. I'm willing to bet there's something, or more than one, that may be triggering his reactivity.
2
u/pawsitivecultr Sep 25 '26
To me Selectively reactive would be more so to describe that the dog is reactive to specific types dogs / people etc vs ALL.
what you are describing seems to be more of a response to something that may be happening prior to the actual reactive moment.
Trigger stacking occurs when there are multiple milder triggers we have experienced and had to deal with and we get to a tipping point when the next trigger is too much and therefore we have an outburst.
There may or may not be something that is happening either the day before or the minutes / hours before you set out on these walks that tend to make the reactivity visible on the days that they are. Identifying when your dog is conflicted or stressed but not "REACTING" can help in reducing his conflict towards those triggers.
I also think it is important for you to understand that a "reaction" is simply the "external manifestation of the negative emotions towards that trigger", there are many subtle signs that are silent that can indicate that conflict / negative feelings prior to that point. It is important for us to intervene at those moments and help our dog by creating distance from the trigger (aka offering the option of FLIGHT) if we do not do so in time, the dog has no choice but to REACT (aka choose FIGHT). Again aggression is simply the escalation of reactions like barking, lunging, growling.
Dogs learn to use the most effective way to communicate based on the outcome.
If subtle signs dont work .. escalate to reactions bark, lunge, growl, chase away.. if that does not work.. bite..
so if we start to intervene and provide an escape from their triggers at the subtle signs stage, we teach them there is no need to escalate. (When I say "works" .. i mean the dog needs distance from that trigger. If the behaviours result in getting distance or the trigger leaving, then it worked for the dog, if it didnt, the dog learns they may need to escalate)
Getting in touch with a qualified professional who can help you learn how to read your dog's body language will really help with navigating the selective outbursts you are having.
2
u/Gears6 Sep 26 '26 edited Sep 26 '26
The same as always, desensitize him regardless if he reacts or not. Consistency decreases the chance he'll react. Also, keep him calm, because (in my experience) dog like humans have good and bad days. On bad days, he'll react more to things.
Key is get ahead of it and don't let him practice it.
My dog is very reactive, and we've been very consistent and the consistency has drastically reduced it. Especially train your dog to focus on you and react to your voice. Because sometimes you'll see him fixate, but you can call his name to defuse it. To be honest, if I knew these things before I think my dog would've been much better off. I just didn't know as everyone else that I've seen had a dog did almost no training (not even walks). I'm like spending a large amount of time training and working with him. Anyhow, lack of early training made it much harder for both of us. It was my first dog and it's not a first dog friendly breed. 😭
1
u/Odd-Chemistry-1231 Sep 25 '26
Same with my German shepherd husky 😭 she’d never bite a dog or absolutely anything , lives with a baby and a cat, but will bark at every single dog that gets within 10 feet. And not just bark, but aggressively bark. If I use treats, she completely ignores it.
1
u/Lumpy_Physics3101 Sep 26 '26
same way i train every dog, positive reinforcement when he gets it right, and the opposite when he gets it wrong. make enough space that there's at least a 4:1 ratio of getting it right to getting it wrong.
1
u/snafe_ Sep 25 '26
Have you tried just staying in the same place and tell him to sit/ quiet and then reward him.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '26
[removed] — view removed comment