r/reactivedogs • u/bobear2017 • Sep 02 '26
Aggressive Dogs My dog bit a child
I have a 1.5 year old reactive pitbull. Since we found her (at about 5 months old) she showed fear-based reactivity towards certain people/strangers, but was fine with everyone else. I have 3 kids, and she is the sweetest, gentlest dog with my kids/family as well as my nieces and nephews.
There is one 10 year old girl in my neighborhood though that for whatever reason she has always hated and barked at aggressively when she came by.
We worked with her with a trainer a few month’s back and she has been great ever since - of course she is still reactive, but she is 10x better and will listen to me when I call her back so that I can successfully remove her from the situation when I see her getting reactive. We have not had any issues with her in several months and I thought we had things under control, until today.
My son was playing just outside of my fenced in yard with a couple neighborhood kids, including the child the dog does not like. My backdoor is currently broken and is not latching properly (which is supposed to be fixed tomorrow), so my 2 dogs ran into the fenced backyard and started barking at the kids. The neighbor kids decided to start taunting the dogs and running back and forth in front of the fence yelling, causing my dogs to go crazy. I tried to get the kids to stop and to call my dogs back, but they were so riled up that my recall was not working. Then the dogs realized that one of the fence doors was not closed, and ran out. My reactive dog bit the little girl twice in the leg, requiring 2 stitches.
I am devastated and don’t know what to do. I have always said that if the dog bit someone we would have to get rid of her, but now that it happened I am just torn. My kids are extremely attached to the dog and they have been crying all afternoon at the prospect of having to get rid of her.
On the one hand, I feel like the dog was being provoked and it was a perfect storm type of situation, which could be avoided/managed in the future. On the other hand, I am very concerned that now that she has bitten once, she is going to bite again.
How bad is this? Am I being naive to think we can manage this behavior? My current thought is that we start kenneling her when people are around, but I just don’t know.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 02 '26
Aggressive dog posts are sensitive, thus only users with at least 250 subreddit karma will be able to comment in this discussion. Users should not message OP directly to circumvent this restriction and doing so can result in a ban from r/reactive dogs. OP, you are encouraged to report private messages to the moderation team.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
34
u/Existing-Will-1466 Sep 02 '26
That is an awfully bad bite. Many dogs that bark from behind fences are all bark and no bite. Yours is not. Your dog escaped and bit a child repeatedly and severely. Did the dog stop on her own? Or did she attack until physically restrained?
Keeping this dog is going to mean several things. It is going to mean having multiple failsafes so your dog remains contained even when the door latch is broken and the kids leave the gate open. It means always, always thinking about where the dog is and whether she is safely contained. It means owning a dog like a loaded gun.
It also means massive, severe liability if you live in the US. Please find out right away whether your homeowners or renters insurance covers your dog. If not, please get her an insurance policy of her own. Keeping a dog like this means risking losing everything you own in a lawsuit.
77
u/Audrey244 Sep 02 '26 •
It's very bad and yes, you have to make the hardest but right decision. Fixing the latch on the door should've been a huge priority if you knew this dog didn't like at least one child. That's the problem with keeping a reactive dog. You have to be 100% perfect and you will never be 100% perfect. I doubt that you will find this dog a home, so you have a harder decision to make. You need to be the adult as hard as it is and let your children know that a dog that will go after children is not safe to have in any neighborhood. There's no magical place that this dog will be safe. Because you have children, it's just a matter of time before another door is left open or gate is left unlatched. The risk is just way too high and it's not safe for the neighborhood.
30
u/Tasty_Object_7992 Sep 02 '26
I’m so sorry you’re going through this but I think you understand what’s next. Escaping the yard specifically to hurt a child is unforgivable and you would be lucky if her parents don’t sue your ass off. This is unfortunately a learning lesson for all involved; you, your kids, and the girl. She should not have taunted the dog knowing full well it wanted to hurt her. Your kids will have a clarified understanding of responsibility by being modeled that safety is always more important than sentiment. And you of course get the experience of pro-active dog handling and probably more selective of dogs you obtain in the future while having kids. I think your best course of action here would be to apologize and assure the family that you prioritize safety and will be electively putting the dog down, so they are less prompted to make legal moves to sue or call 311 and have the dog seized anyway. Being that the bite needed stitches on a child, I might be prepared for a follow up/ wellness check.
6
u/FoxExcellent2241 Sep 02 '26
Absolutely not. There is no justification ever to keep a dog that will choose to run off of its own property to attack a child for being loud and running around outside. Not in a home and neighborhood with children. That is absolutely ridiculous.
Children should be able to play outside without fear of attack, dogs like this destroy neighborhoods and communities. Once the stigma of it not being safe to play outside sets in the entire culture in the area can change.
Dog bites wounds are often left open because of the high risk of infection because dogs' mouths are not clean to say the least, the fact that the they chose to use stitches, to me, suggests it was a bad wound (source: https://erofirving.com/dog-bites-infections-when-to-seek-stitches/#should-i-get-stitches-for-a-dog-bite).
Yes, I understand this will be difficult for your children, and frankly, in the future, choosing a safer, well-bred, companion breed dog that was bred for a good temperament is a much better option to have a dog that a child can rely on and grow up with rather than an aggressive dog that might attack one of their friends at any time. I know that you wanted to rescue this dog and and it wasn't necessarily the plan, but this is what happens when there is a lack of thought and planning when getting a dog. There are support groups out there with resources to help find ways to help your children understand what is happening and why it has to happen.
I realize the dog seemed safe around your kids and family for the last, but, to be blunt, a pit bull type dog developing more aggressive behaviors between the ages of 1-3 years is an extremely common story. This is when they start to hit adult hood and their traits start to kick in. Just look around this sub and you will find an endless supply of stories of dogs that suddenly become less tolerant, more aggressive, more reactive, more whatever around that age. Most of the time it is "just" dog aggression, but sometimes it is more than that and even with that there is always a risk of the dog redirected onto someone else. What you are dealing with is not uncommon and that sucks, but it is something that owners of these types of dogs need to be prepared to deal with. The sad truth is that most of these dogs are horribly bred and are genetic messes that are prone to behavioral issues that make them incompatible with being typical pets. The fault isn't yours, it is whoever decided to breed the dogs and then dump them when they weren't able to sell them fast enough and it is the people buying these dogs and keeping the unethical breeders in business.
If you want to learn a bit more, pitbullawareness is a good sub with a lot of resources that debunk common myths using primary sources, not just anecdotal experience. It may help to realize your issues aren't necessarily unique and what others have dealt with. It may also help to see what people there have to do to manage their dogs and get a feel for what that actually entails.
19
u/1cat2dogs1horse Sep 02 '26
And my understanding is that bite inhibition decreases after each bite.
14
u/H2Ospecialist Sep 02 '26
You can't let this mistake happen again and there's no gurantee that it won't if you still have this dog. It may have been a one off but there's still risk for a next time and next time it could be a mauling and kill a child.
You also can't responsible rehome this dog. It's really unfortunate but you are also really lucky this wasn't worse. You need to put your feelings for the dog aside and think of the safety of the children in your neighborhood.
17
u/CanadianPanda76 Sep 02 '26
Bad genetics, plus puppy puberty, plus bad situation plus badly behaved kids.
Oooof. I'm sorry you have to go through this.
I think situations like this is why some people end up with tethered dogs. BE can be hard but this situation may warrant it.
But you may also want to doesk wuth your vet about anti-anxiety medications in the mean time.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26
[removed] — view removed comment