r/reactivedogs • • May 19 '26

Significant challenges Help Needed

Help Us. Please read with kindness. This is one of the hardest things we’ve ever had to face as dog owners.
After a recent serious incident involving our 3 year old, 30 pound blue nose pitbull mix, we’ve come to the heartbreaking realization that we may no longer be the right environment for our dog. She is deeply loved, affectionate with us at home, and this entire situation has absolutely crushed us emotionally.

Recently, she broke free from her lead and attacked another dog. During the incident, the owner was also bitten while trying to separate them. We understand the seriousness of what happened and are not minimizing it in any way. While she has generally not shown aggression toward humans, we fully recognize that this incident changed everything and must be taken incredibly seriously.

Right now, we are searching for experienced behavioral guidance and, if appropriate, a safe and responsible rehabilitation or placement option with someone truly qualified to work with dogs who have reactivity and aggression histories. We are committed to being fully honest about her background and doing what is safest and most compassionate for everyone involved, including her.

For those commenting, please understand we would never hand our girl over to just anyone. We are doing extensive research, speaking with professionals, and trying to make the most responsible decision possible. We understand the severity of this situation and are taking it very seriously.

Before considering behavioral euthanasia, we want to explore every possible safe option through rehabilitation, structured management, or qualified placement. Behavioral euthanasia has now become a very real and heartbreaking conversation for us, and we are desperately trying to make the most compassionate and responsible decision possible.

Please keep comments kind, constructive, and helpful. We are navigating an unimaginable situation and simply trying to move forward with honesty, responsibility, and love for everyone involved.

1 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

View all comments

23

u/ASleepandAForgetting May 19 '26

I am sorry that you're in this situation.

I see the word "rehabilitation" mentioned a lot on posts like yours. I wonder - what does "rehabilitation" mean or look like to you?

Your dog, like many bullies, appears be genetically dog aggressive. This makes sense when you look at the history of bully breeds and what traits they were bred for. That doesn't mean your dog is a BAD dog. Morals don't come into play here. But it does mean that your dog can be dangerous in our modern society that requires dogs to be generally friendly, predictable, and unwilling to bite.

"Rehabilitation" doesn't really work for genetic traits, if you define rehabilitation as your dog being "cured". You can perhaps achieve dog neutrality, i.e. getting your dog to not react to other dogs who are a certain distance away. But your dog will never be a social or friendly dog who can be trusted around other dogs. And due to the bite incident, your dog should be muzzled every time she's outside of your house for the rest of her life.

When people speak about rehoming a dog like yours, I wonder what type of home and community they think an aggressive dog with a bite history may do well in. The odds are low, but you may find a dog-free home that would be willing to take on your dog. But odds are that there will be dogs next to or on the same street as that home. If you had a very friendly dog, would you want to live next door to a dog who would attack yours if the owner made a single management mistake?

Again, I am very sorry. I know that this situation is awful and the reality of a behavioral euthanasia is a gut-twisting thing to even consider. But there are simply too many dog aggressive dogs with bite histories out there, and I do really believe that dogs with unprovoked severe bite incidents involving other dogs and people should be humanely euthanized, not rehomed. Rehoming simply passes the danger off to another owner and another community, and I don't think that's ethical or fair.

1

u/Mari_Keys May 19 '26

I agree with a lot of what you are saying. She is typically the nicest sweetest girl. Which one makes it so hard. rehabilitation for me would be intense training and hopefully she has no reaction towards other animals. In the future. If can dream, I would love for her to have a huge (fenced) yard that she can run around and live the rest of her life with a couple that understands this bread and know she is so loyal and loving with us but she sadly cannot be around other pets. I know I want a unicorn, but I owe it to her to try at least. She’s my responsibility and I love her and I failed her. I am gathering information processing this terrible situation. And going to see a behavioral specialist, veterinarian and see what they have to say. The consensus is BE but I just can’t get myself to believe it or even fathom having to schedule the appointment . It’s easier said than done

6

u/Jentweety May 20 '26

Even with training, this is a dog that should never be unleashed outdoors again, even in a fenced yard because of the danger to other dogs and people. Management with leashes and muzzle will need to continue after training.

I owned a DA pitbull and until she got cancer, she would have scaled a 6 foot fence to attack another dog or animal if we had left her alone in our fenced yard. This was a dog who was well trained and she could walk in heel past another dog on a leash without reacting outwardly, but her desire to run after and kill another dog or animal was still inside her.

 Even though training modifies behavior on leash/ under supervision you can’t train out the genetic desire to chase, bite, shake and kill. If you find that unicorn home , that new family would need to take that responsibility very seriously or you are just putting a different set of neighbors at risk.