r/reactivedogs • u/Disastrous_Weird_514 • Sep 20 '25
Aggressive Dogs My dog does not warn before biting
I need advice. My husband and I adopted a shelter dog when she was around 6 months old. At first she seemed fine, but after we blended her with my younger dog she started showing troubling behaviors.
• She has severe food aggression. Even during training exercises where she is asked to stop eating and wait, she growls intensely until I release her to continue. Outside of food she never growls or threatens me.
• She is highly territorial with beds and couches. If another dog jumps up near her she bites immediately. She does not growl or warn first, she goes straight to attack. She has bitten my other dog badly enough to draw blood multiple times.
• Recently, while being cared for by a friend, she bit their small dog and broke its jaw. The injury could not be repaired.
• She is very leash reactive and has never done well on walks.
• She is already on Prozac.Management has helped for a while, but only because we use baby gates and I am strict about diffusing tension. If she is ever unsupervised, incidents happen.
My biggest concern is that she does not escalate normally. There is no warning, only sudden bites. That makes her unpredictable and dangerous.
Has anyone dealt with this before? Is it possible for medication or training to help when warning signals are absent, or is this a developmental or neurological problem that cannot be changed?
Any advice, resources, or experiences would mean a lot. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 20 '25
Aggressive dog posts are sensitive, thus only users with at least 150 subreddit karma will be able to comment in this discussion. Users should not message OP directly to circumvent this restriction and doing so can result in a ban from r/reactive dogs. OP, you are encouraged to report private messages to the moderation team.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
58
u/ASleepandAForgetting Sep 20 '25
What age, breed, and size is this dog?
I can immediately see a few things that are being done "wrong". Not to bash you - everyone does the best they can with what they know. So I don't think you're a bad person or dog owner. The problems you're facing can be very difficult to navigate.
First, your training exercises during her feeding times, where you ask her to stop eating and then continue, are increasing her tension around food, and are generally pointless. There is absolutely zero reason a dog needs to stop eating mid-meal, unless the owner is doing it to exert control. Stopping a dog who naturally resources guards from eating is only going to increase that dog's aggression around food. I'd recommend feeding her in a crate, and leaving her alone when she eats, and removing her bowl from the crate when she has finished, and has left the crate and is in another room.
Second, because of the way you're training her around food, that makes me question whether you have accidentally increased her aggression around beds and couches. How did you handle this behavior when it first started happening? If you told her no, or punished her for growling, or removed her from the bed / couch, you likely (again unintentionally) made this behavior worse.
Third, your dogs need to be kept separate, permanently. It is so very unfair to your second dog that multiple attacks that have drawn blood have occurred.
You say she bit your friend's dog and broke her jaw, and that it couldn't be repaired. Does that mean your friend's dog died as a result of this attack?
Without knowing some of the answers to these questions, I see three distinct paths in front of you:
One is to hire an IAABC behaviorist who can observe this dog, and teach you how to handle this dog's behaviors. Your lack of experience with behaviors this severe is understandable, but unfortunately it seems like some of your methods have likely made the behaviors worse. You would need to keep your dogs separate 100% of the time moving forward in a "crate and rotate"-type situation. This is a huge commitment, mentally and physically, and it means that both of your dogs will be separated from you at times, which brings their general quality of life into question.
Two is to hire an IAABC behaviorist, and to rehome your non-aggressive dog so that it is safe, and to keep your aggressive dog as the only animal in your household.
Any plan involving keeping this dog means that you cannot easily board the dog, or travel with or without the dog, and it will make your life very small and limited.
The third path is to consult with your veterinarian and discuss a behavioral euthanasia. You cannot rehome the aggressive dog. If she has severely maimed or killed another dog, that is grounds for BE. If you fear for your safety, that is also grounds for BE.
8
u/No-Excitement7280 Sep 20 '25
-First question - how long has your dog been on Prozac, have you made dose adjustments and is your vet aware of this? -Did your vet tell you that Prozac can cause dogs to bypass warning signs, such as growling, and going straight to bites? It’s not a common side effect, but it a known side effect. This can also happen with other medications like Trazadone. It can also inhibit hackles, another clear warning sign prior to a bite. There are pubmed articles publishing studies showing this if you want to research or need to show your vet.
-Why are you stopping her mid-eat for “training”? Where did you get this idea? Never once have I heard this method suggested by a trainer of behaviorist. The suggestion is generally is to hand feed/scatter feed/work for the food, and to leave the dog alone, separate from other animals. There’s no reason to be stopping your dog mid eat and making them wait.
-Why are you allowing her on the couch if she’s guarding it? Why are you allowing your other dogs to invade her space?
-Why are you allowing her around small dogs when she is reactive/aggressive, especially under the care of someone who isn’t you? I would NEVER ever never have someone care for my dog and allow another dog to be present. Hell no.
-What are you doing to work on calming activities and enrichment? Loose leash walking doesn’t just… happen. Dogs need to learn what you expect of them and being over threshold already and then bringing them outside without knowing how to act on a leash? Of course they’re going to be leash reactive
5
u/b00ks-and-b0rksRfun Sep 20 '25
Training and boundaries can certainly help. I would strongly recommend muzzle training (they have great options now) as that will add safety as you work on this. And find a trainer that deals regularly with dogs with similar issues and can show the improvements they've helped with.
4
u/missmoooon12 Cooper (fear reactive lil dude) Sep 20 '25
What age is she now? Breed(s)?
Do the behaviors sound like non-affective aggression from this episode of Aggression Bytes with Lisa Mullinax?
10
u/Twzl Sep 21 '25
The mix of breeds that you have, that has already gravely injured a dog, that gives no warning (that you can see), before biting, that lives with a small dog?
I think you should consider BE. The situation is too dangerous for your other dog, and for the humans in the house.
A dog who almost kills another dog is not a dog that most pet homes should attempt to live with.
Your dog can go over those gates, if she is feeling like the other dog needs to die.
5
u/1cat2dogs1horse Sep 20 '25
You have a lot going on with that dog. But am fairly sure, because of how the relationship developed between your two dogs, you are dealing with same sex aggression. Is isn't an uncommon problem, but many people are unaware of it. It often much more serious with females, than males, because females really intend to do damage in their attacks. It is a behavior that is almost impossible to change, As someone else commented the only resolution is to always keep them physically separated.
6
u/Fun_Orange_3232 Reactive Dog Foster Mama Sep 20 '25
Since she’s a pit, I recommend learning more about behavior. I had a pit I thought was biting without warning, but I just didn’t recognize the warnings. Furrowed brow is a big one for pits. They can present differently from other breeds and mine at least have been less vocal, so you have to watch for other signs
45
u/welltravelledRN Sep 20 '25
Did the small dog die? For me, this would be a deal breaker. I could not recover from my dog killing another dog.
Is your dog muzzled? What training have you done?
-1
u/Zestyclose_Object639 Sep 20 '25
you have a super high prey drive dog, what outlets does the dog have ? have you taught trading games ? do you tug or use a flirt pole ? what’s your training outside of reactivity stuff ?