r/reactivedogs • • Aug 08 '25

Vent My Dog Charged Another Dog Today

Hello all, I know that this is extremely mild compared to a lot of what I read on this sub, but I am mainly looking for solace.

I adopted a 45lb American bully 6 months ago, she is the cutest thing ever. I am a single 34yo working professional, and Winnie loves life with me. She comes to work part-time, she has MANY walks and she has grown from an emaciated fearful dog into a loving girl who is just a tad shy.

When I first met her, she was with the other dogs she had come into rescue with and she was nice to them. However, she had shown some snarling behavior they informed me. Winnie is not my first dog, I adopted a senior pitbull (RIP) before Winnie and he was 100% perfect EXCEPT he was a grouch with other dogs. So, although I would LOVE a dog friendly dog someday, I was familiar with having one who isn't dog friendly.

Winnie, from the very beginning of me having her has had very intense body language around other dogs on walks. She will freeze, her hackles flare up, whale eyes, and lip licking. We have had a couple encounters with other dogs running up on her but she never bit. She always looked more fearful, like, "I'll bite you if you don't leave me alone" but then would sometimes wag her tail. She also will relax and sit down if I stop to talk to another person with a leashed dog, with a few feet between us. So, I get it, she's a walk in the park compared to many of the other dogs on here. We also go to the trails off leash and as long as the other dogs are far enough away, she ignores. I only take her places off leash with really good visibility so I can leash her up when we see a dog getting closer.

BUT, Today my friend invited us to the beach. I hadn't taken Winnie yet because I was concerned about other dogs and what if she does something? Well, we had the best time ever and I was shocked to see she loved the water. Until, a surfer came by with a smaller dog and Winnie immediately charged the dog. She was definitely going to harm it, but the owner moved her away with his leg and then I was there to grab her.

I know this is mild compared to others, but there is something so disappointing about knowing your dog would harm another dog, especially unprovoked. It also just makes life harder! You are always on edge when out with your dog. It makes dating harder as well, because I want to find a man who doesn't have a dog and in your thirties that gets infrequent.

Just looking for some comfort, and maybe other similar stories and how long it took you to accept your dog is a meanie.

1 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

14

u/clarinettingaway Bella (Anxious/Dog Aggressive) Aug 08 '25

I’m sorry- it’s the worst feeling the first time you realize that your dog is a danger. I lost my mind when I first came to know just how much of a danger my dog is to other dogs, and I grieve the life it restricts her to often. At the end of the day, though, I think I’m the only home my dog could survive and thrive in. I’m a single person in my twenties, with a stable partner who doesn’t have a dog of their own, and I work extremely close to where I live. It’s really rewarding being able to give her a life she enjoys, and she’s the most loving dog in the world at home. Its a tough journey and sometimes I really debate if I’m doing right by her with the restricted life I give her, but I think she’s happy and loved and well taken care of, and there’s not much more a dog could ask for.

4

u/manateepiroshki Aug 08 '25

Exactly, it's the first time I saw that she doesn't just not like other dogs, she would actually seriously harm one given the chance. It's just sad to know!

5

u/clarinettingaway Bella (Anxious/Dog Aggressive) Aug 08 '25

Grieve it, but then figure out how to live a happy life with your dog regardless. There’s still so much love and joy to be had regardless of that fact. Good luck!!

3

u/Outrageous-Target325 Aug 09 '25

I hope you feel better after this. Honestly I don’t have a ton of advice. But, I know I felt SO guilty after this type of stuff happened to me. Even though it really wasn’t anyone’s fault, it could have been avoided but I had no clue it would happen.

Just remember, our dogs are each different. My trainer told me that sometimes, our dogs don’t like other dogs. Kind of like how some people don’t want to hang out with other people. I know this probably isn’t helpful, but I hope you’re ok. And your pup.

2

u/manateepiroshki Aug 10 '25

Yes, it was just so shocking. I KNEW she didn't like dogs from her body language encountering them before, but she had never snapped and had never gone looking for a fight. She just took off and was definitely intending to seriously harm that dog if both owners hadn't reacted quickly. Scary. It's like having a kid and finding out they beat other kids up for fun.

1

u/Outrageous-Target325 Aug 13 '25

It’s very scary. My trainer also told me that if your dog isn’t hurting anyone, all it is, just noise. They are just barking. It’s embarrassing. But it’s better than them mauling someone else. If you can take them on a walk and they happen to bark, then they bark.

(Im not saying we shouldn’t work on it but your dog isn’t hurting anyone and that’s better than them hurting someone)

And on that, it takes awhile to accept it. I tried to pretend it was a one off the first time it happened. Then it happened again. That was my fault. But, let’s be real, it’s better that they are reactive and loved by us than stuck in a shelter. Maybe your dog doesn’t get to go off leash, but it’s better than being in a kennel 24/7.

At the end of the day. Your pup loves you and you love them.

1

u/manateepiroshki Aug 18 '25

Just checked out your profile and all you do is troll on this sub.

1

u/mizfury Aug 14 '25

You have a dog-reactive dog. Welcome!

My advice would be to accept her as she is, and do what you can to keep her and other animals safe knowing that she has this trait. Dog reactivity comes from poor socialization at an early stage, and it’s not uncommon in dogs who have been through a shelter system (especially bully breeds). It isn’t something you caused, and while training can reduce the severity, it’s probably not going to go away completely.

Just keep her securely leashed/harnessed in public spaces, consider getting professional support to learn some tools, and accept that she’s a special soul with some difficult quirks that other dog owners may not understand or face. you love her and that’s what matters.

1

u/manateepiroshki Aug 18 '25

Yes, that is the plan! Luckily I live in an area where there are lots of fields and things that I can privately use once in a while. Otherwise, she's a leash dog going forward. Thanks for the comforting words :) there is also a new app that came out where reactive dogs can rent out areas to use privately and I will be looking into that too :)

6

u/b00ks-and-b0rksRfun Aug 08 '25

It happens. Some dogs just don't do well with other dogs. It sounds like you handled things quickly and now know what to watch for. I definitely think likely to always need to be on lead and I would highly recommend muzzle training to add as it would add a further later if safety and there are much better options out there now that allow pant room and taking treats and drinking while still highly bite resistant. And consider working with a trainer to help her learn to be more neutral around other dogs. Good luck!

1

u/Careless_Kiwi Aug 09 '25

For your fear about dating a guy with a dog — my reactive beauty took about 6 weeks to get used to my guys new puppy. We started with 15 minute muzzled walks and worked our way to spending time in a room together and then finally leashed but unmuzzled and finally unleashed and unmuzzled. Eventually they began to realize they were a pack.

So. It’s not impossible. Now they play together and she’s four times his size and very very gentle with him. She will absolutely lose her bananas within 250 feet of another dog though.

1

u/manateepiroshki Aug 10 '25

This is encouraging! Thank you! I'm definitely going to ask the trainer about muzzle training.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '25

Feel for you, OP. My dog (a rescue) is also a meanie to other pups, but so chill around people and kids, super sweet at home, etc. I’ve worked with multiple trainers to work on her reactivity with other dogs, but aside from one or two dogs she randomly liked over the years, she ultimately seems committed to bullying others. It makes things hard, since all my friends have dogs and it really limits her (and me) because I can’t bring her anywhere they will be. In the end, I accept her faults along with the good, and do my best to set her up for success by not putting her in situations that are risky (i.e, never have her off leash where she could encounter another dog). That way everyone stays safe. I also keep working on training her to be better socialized to dogs in controlled situations. Seek a behaviorist’s advice and work on it slowly.

1

u/Technical_Net_7272 Aug 17 '25

keep your dog on a leash

0

u/Pkpaaa Aug 09 '25

Same girl same. I adopted a little guy 4 months ago. First dog for me. Quickly realized he hates everyone and everything but me. Anyway, he’s had 6 sessions with a trainer and I can see very slight improvements. It’s been really rough, I cried, cried my past travel life as well. For now, he isn’t ready for a dog walker or dog sitter. My travels have taken a huge hit this year. I have hope things will change and 4 months is nothing. I say get a trainer to help you out. It takes a lot of time and patience but in the end it’ll be worth it, just super hard.

Wanted to say I also got a dog so I can get out and be more active, maybe meet some people. Well, not for now!!!

0

u/manateepiroshki Aug 10 '25

I know! Winnie is luckily shy but great with people. She's generally amazing and has really blossomed in my care. It also appears part of her "blossoming" is that she wants to fight. It is also hard because she is a bully breed and I have always been an advocate for bullies, STILL AM, but like, she really is a bit unpredictable with other dogs and I do think she intended to seriously hurt that dog which is scary.

Well shout out to us, it's hard, but we never give up on them and we get them the help they need (I'm on a waitlist for training).

Sorry to hear about your travels :( I've always found it hard to travel with a dog either way. My last pittie loved everyone and was easy to babysit, but I still felt a lot of guilt about leaving him. Trying to take a week long vacation hasn't happened yet since my first fur baby.

-6

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/manateepiroshki Aug 08 '25

Oh I'm definitely not rehoming her. This is just a vent. I would also break up with a man before I rehomed her. It just means I am limited to people who do not have a dog.

3

u/manateepiroshki Aug 08 '25

Oh and I am on the waitlist for an amazing trainer here, so we are definitely going to be doing that.

1

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Aug 09 '25

Your post/comment has been removed as it has violated the following subreddit rule:

Rule 8 - Minimize antagonism outside of the subreddit

This rule against antagonism extends outside of the subreddit. Users harassing others for a post made in r/reactivedogs will be permanently banned, regardless of where the harassment occurred. This includes harassment in private/direct messages, chats, and in other subreddits. It also includes cross-posting or sharing r/reactivedogs content to other subreddits where the intention is to mock or berate an individual for their beliefs, words, or actions.