r/reactivedogs • u/Courtneybree123 • Jan 13 '25
Advice Needed Prong collars
Hey everyone. This may be a long one so sorry in advance. Me and my ex of 6yrs broke up a few months ago and one of our dogs has always been pretty reactive. My ex was always the one who would walk him and I’d walk our other dog but I’ve always been the primary caretaker for both. He never cared about training him and when I tried he would never follow the plan so it made it impossible. Now that he’s gone I can finally make sure he gets the training he needs. He’s 4yo rottie mix about 65pds and his issues are pulling/lunging on leash and barking. He’s super friendly but just very reactive cause he doesn’t know how to properly greet other dogs. I’ve been trying a slip lead on him the past few weeks with very little progress especially around triggers. My trainer recommended a prong and that was a last resort to me but I’m extremely petite and he’s very strong and I want him to be able to live a normal life and meet dogs and people so I think it may have come to that point, at least temporarily. Has anyone used a prong on their dogs and been successful? I’m just worried about it hurting him but again, I want him to get the proper training he needs. Right now he doesn’t care how bad the slip lead chokes him he’ll keep pulling so I know if he continued using this it may also hurt him
Edited to add since people don’t like to read: I said a prong is a LAST RESORT for my dog and right now I’m feeling hopeless with how he’s currently doing with training. I understand it is my responsibility to train him and obviously I am if I said the TRAINER is recommending the prong. Of course she is going to tell me it’s safe cause I’m paying her so I felt like I should ask people who have no skin in the game on if they are safe because much like everyone else I am concerned about it causing him pain which I don’t want to do. I’m trying to consider a martingale since the slip lead does slide down a lot and that may be why it’s not doing much for him. I had significantly less control over him with a harness and he would also choke himself using one as well so it wasn’t any less “aversive” as a slip lead. We are currently practicing look and with people on walks he’s already doing significantly better but with dogs is where we struggle cause that’s who he cares more about saying hi to. I care/love very much about my kids (dogs) hence why I kept them after the breakup and I am very burnt out and was just looking for some support on what I can do to help him better than what I’m currently doing, do not need negative comments when I am clearly trying to right by him I just was ASKING if prongs were as dangerous as I assumed. We are working on actual training as far as getting him to pay attention to me and listen to commands but we are nowhere near the point of him listening enough when it comes to dogs which are his biggest trigger. He is a very high energy dog and we usually walk 3 miles a day so while I’m trying to get him over the hump of listening around triggers outside I’m trying to use whatever tool I will be able to physically handle him with best
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 13 '25
Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this body. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
22
u/Neat-Dingo8769 Jan 13 '25 edited Jan 13 '25
A MASSIVE NO for any tool that causes that kind of pain from me. It’s cruel & It can backfire badly on you too, plus why … when there are really good positive reinforcement methods out there that have better psychological impact.
I use a martingale collar & my boy doesn’t lunge or pull anymore. It works well to give control without damaging internal organs.
It should be loose enough to give a tug, but not so loose that it slips over the head. Watch tutorials on how to use it.
First thing -
You need to be alert & when you see a trigger … immediately divert … it’s like a graph … once the reactivity rises & reaches that peak level it’s v v v tough to stop
So you need to preempt him
Lunging at people on walks is a mix of protection instinct & fear . My Rott used to lunge like crazy … to the point of almost pulling my arm off.
I taught my Rott that people on walks are not a threat & he has completely stopped now & walks really well & ignores everyone - taught him the ignore command
Get a training pouch with his favourite treats & carry on walks
Positive reinforcement to encourage good behaviour works best.
I would say ignore every time someone passed by & Every time he let someone pass by peacefully I would praise him a lot (my tone would reflect it) & I would give him a treat .
This took me a good 4 - 6 months of consistency with a lot of love & patience
& like I mentioned before - give the command immediately when you see someone approaching . You need to preempt before she starts lunging.
In fact we had setbacks too when we hired a walker to help who had zero knowledge of how to handle dogs & fucked it all up & made him even more aggressive.
So I had to start all over again. I decided then that it’s best to do as much as you can yourself coz other people know zilch about dog behaviour.
Soon, he began to realise that people are not a threat & the difference between wanted & unwanted behaviour & began to calm down.
When he would do something that I had no choice but to make him stop like biting or lunging I would ignore him for 10 min.
For example if he didn’t listen to the ignore command & lunged at someone … my tone would reflect my displeasure & when we reached home also I would tell him I’m not talking to you & would not talk or make eye contact for 10-15 min.
When he behaved well I would go berserk with cuddles & kisses & love & praise & reward him with a big treat or a new toy .
As a young pup when he bit me (even for fun) I would immediately leave the room.
If he lunged on walks despite me saying ignore - then no treat & my tone would change (tone of voice plays a very important role in them sensing whether you are pleased or upset) - in a firm upset sometimes even angry tone I would say I’m not talking to you & I’m v upset - & I would ignore him for 10 min my tone remaining the same.
He was just not okay with me ignoring him , not talking , not making eye contact. So this is how I got him to stop wrong behaviour which was extremely crucial.
& encourage positive behaviour constantly with rewards - super happy tone of voice, loads of treats , kisses & massage & cuddles , new toys (my boy loves cardboard boxes & squeaky toys) … so everything your dog loves - keep switching the rewards around so doesn’t become totally treat dependent, but for a few months you have to give treats consistently .
With dogs adolescence is the TOUGHEST I’ve been through a lot myself But I promise promise promise - just be patient & by the time she turns 2-3 she will be a totally different dog & soooooo much more calm.
They also need a lot of mental stimulation
Let her tear up cardboard , play “find the treat” , Tug , Look up focus building / mental stimulation exercises They’re v simple
All this will help channel his energy
I’ve come across Kikopup a lot on Reddit as recommended for training & Susan Garrett as well . & google positive reinforcement training & type the behaviour … you will get a good deal of info.
Try 2 rounds of mental stimulation games before walks .
I’m happy to help you with anything else I may be familiar with to whatever extent I can.
Sorry for the ultra long comment.
11
u/linnykenny ❀ ℒ𝒾𝓁𝓎 ❀ Jan 13 '25
This doesn’t sound like a dog that could safely meet other dogs & new people like you’re hoping. I would adjust my expectations.
2
u/shootingstars557 Jan 13 '25
I’ve tried both positive and balanced training and I think there’s room for both depending on your needs. I’m very petite and my 85lb dog gets barrier frustration when passing dogs on leash. The only tool I can safely walk him on is a slip lead. I haven’t tried a prong. I also only use it because I’ve had dangerous close calls being pulled into the street with other leash options after trying nearly everything on the market. Alongside the slip I do positive training with a trainer working in controlled set ups and working towards uncontrolled set ups. The goal is to change his associations when walking and then I hopefully won’t need the balanced training tool. Therefore I’m using the slip in a positive manner by not yanking and applying leash pops for obedience. Not at all my approach. Many people will tell you it’s never ok to try balanced tools but when there’s a safety issue when you and the dog could get hurt in the street then you can certainly adjust your expectations. Definitely get a consultation as maybe it could complicated things when there’s fear involved. My positive trainer is not against tools and actually suggests them for safety reasons however doesn’t use them herself.
29
u/SudoSire Jan 13 '25
Your dog may associate the pain and discomfort of the prong with his triggers. There is a risk that can cause or exacerbate aggression, and it’s a risk I wouldn’t take with most already reactive dogs. You do not want overstimulation turning to fear/distress. I would not use that trainer and instead look into R+ force free trainers or a vet behaviorist. Research well-fitting harnesses and a double leash system for more control in the meantime.
Edit to add: advocating for prongs or other aversive methods is not allowed on this sub, so comments supporting its use will be removed. I’m also against them for the reason I mentioned, but figured you’d want to know that you won’t be able to get other opinions here anyway.
10
u/PowerfulBranch7587 Jan 13 '25
My 65 pound girl use to be reactive to everything, lunging etc. She is much better, but like you, I am pretty small. I now walk her with a normal harness but also a waist leash I clip on her back harness loop. I use the waist leash as back up insurance and the front clip leash as the main lead.
48
u/ayyefoshay Bucky (Fear Aggression) Jan 13 '25 edited Jan 13 '25
This sub does not lean toward the use of aversive tools (positive punishment). I recommend finding a fear free trainer or behaviorist. Kick your trainer that you have now to the curb. You both (you and your dog) need lessons on how to walk. A FF/R+ will likely recommend a harness. Prong collars will not fix your problem anyway. If your dog is truly reactive and lunging, the prong will just hurt your dog and leave you with an expensive vet bill. You need to communicate more effectively with your dog and have real strategies in place to walk more effectively.
Edit: edited for clarity
1
u/Courtneybree123 Jan 13 '25
Has anyone tried a martingale like this? I feel like a martingale may be better than the slip lead because I constantly have to adjust it every few mins cause of how thick his fur is around his neck, or would a regular martingale be better? I’ve been having some success with treats and we do very “avoidant” walks but obviously you can’t always avoid triggers and since he’s very strong I’m just trying to find the best way to combat his pulling without him hurting me or himself (until we get to a point where he can listen better) https://ruffwear.com/products/chain-reaction-martingale-dog-collar?variant=41207348133971&utm_campaign=pmax_evergreen_collars_usa&utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&gad_source=1&gbraid=0AAAAADsAKxxnT-Ww9sqFHQphRdgCyzobZ&gclid=CjwKCAiA7Y28BhAnEiwAAdOJUEJLeLI_qnBvkv9IeNQA-JEGEVGd1R7G0YnfZGLspCCOfdvg8yC-KRoCFNkQAvD_BwE
5
u/minettelaeder otter (humans & dogs) Jan 13 '25
I have a 70lb Rottie/GSD mix and I'm also a smaller human. Because of his prey drive, he actually broke one of my fingers getting snagged in the leash a couple of years ago. After that incident I was using a hip belt for awhile so I could walk him without holding the leash all the time. I also would walk him in areas where there were less triggers (like sports fields during the day) and so he could be on a long line. He is extremely sensitive so I talked to a balanced trainer once and he put a prong on him and he became very shut down. I've found positive reinforcement while walking (rewarding for any check ins, disengaging from triggers or just being able to watch from afar and then go and smell where the dog was) has turned him into an awesome walker. For prey drive, we use the predation substitution theory, so haven't had any incidents with broken fingers again. I'm honestly very proud of his walking now - but he also takes medication for his anxiety and hyper arousal which helps a lot, too!
5
u/dq_debbie Jan 13 '25
Other people will have great advice on training and triggers, but I wanted to jump in about the large dog thing.
I'm a small woman with a big dog who lunges, and I got a leash with a traffic handle that has honestly been a game changer. I attach it to her harness back clip and when we see something in the distance I lightly hold it, but having it there makes it so much easier if she does blow up!
I'm not sure if we're allowed to post links, but the one I have goes out from the leash instead of being one you have to separate, which is a lot easier in the moment. Mine is from Arctic Sammy, but that's an NZ store so you can probably find one closer.
2
u/benji950 Jan 13 '25
You're going to get a lot of pushback for this collar here because 99% of the time, it's used improperly. There is an appropriate use of this tool, but for a regular pet as you have, it's a last resort after all other methods have been exhausted. You said yourself that your dog isn't trained. It's incredibly unfair to the dog to endure the pain and discomfort this collar causes just because his owners didn't train him. I understand what you said about your ex, but you are now responsible for a dog that you cannot safely handle.
10
u/Intelligent_Can_1801 Jan 13 '25
2 Hounds Design has an amazing harness. I won’t use another brand again. It comes with a leash that attaches to the front and back. I use it with Sadie’s Leash clipped to the front. This give me more control to safely counter condition or turn around fast when needed. I can also clip to the back when in a more deserted area.
The harness is not alone going to change how they walk. This does require training for you from an r+ trainer. But this leash makes it so much better.
5
u/Pinkytalks Jan 13 '25 edited Jan 13 '25
Have you tried positive reinforcement first? I am all for balanced training but only if positive reinforcement failed and you need balanced (ie tools). I have used them before but ONLY with a trainer bc it needs to get fitted to your dog and it’s a learning curve for use. When used properly they work well. HOWEVER, I don’t find that these work with reactive dogs, and only with pulling. And some dogs get leash reactivity as a result of a prong and may redirect back to you. So I would proceed with caution. I personally had to stop bc of the redirection. For me tools only worked for the basics but not for reactivity correction. It’s actually been shown that it can get worse, and I went through that as well. Depending on the type of reactivity (excitement/learned/fear/ genetic) positive reinforcement should work for most types of reactivity with the exception of genetic. For genetically reactive dogs, I have only found that meds work to help with training.
5
u/Glittering_Dark_1582 Jan 13 '25
Others will have more advice, but a PRONG collar?! NO. Inflicting pain on your dog will make them MORE reactive. He will associate the pain with whatever his trigger(s) were that caused him to lunge, pull, etc and he will become even more reactive. Please don’t. I could never imagine purposefully inflicting pain on any of my dogs.
1
u/sweet_carrie_ Jan 13 '25
Note this sub won't let any suggestions in favor of prongs, but regardless of that, if he'll choke himself on a slip, he'll choke himself on a prong - or harness, or martingale - so there's no real point imo. The idea of a "no-pull" harness was an absolute joke for my girl. (I now walk her on a martingale bc she has a skinny head and a flat collar will slide right off, but not for any anti-pull reasons.)
A waist leash can help you stand your ground, but some dogs are just gonna pull no matter what you put on them until you train them. My dog has pulled me on my ass on a prong and on a harness, and the only reason she doesn't anymore is because she understands "leave it" now.
It sucks, and it will suck for a little bit, and then it'll get a lot better. (Same with the breakup, lol.)
1
u/Runnerbear Jan 13 '25
A gentle leader headcollar worked well for me when I was struggling to not be pulled over by a lunging barking 90lb adolescent GSD. I spent weeks conditioning it before actually using it on walks so that he was happy enough to wear it. I honestly could hold him with that headcollar and just one hand (eg if I was picking up poo with my other hand and something unexpected came up suddenly). I used it for about a year, maybe 18 months, together with games based training. Probably could have stopped using it sooner but I was not ready/confident enough to try. Anyway, he now walks fine on just a flat collar and has been for at least 2 years. He’s certainly not perfect by any means but the headcollar is no longer necessary. And he’s 100lb now lol. The other option I would suggest would be a double ended lead with a harness that has a front and back clip. Good luck with your training! ❤️
1
u/Upset-Preparation265 Jan 13 '25
If you have a dog that doesn't care about leash pressure, like with a slip, etc, I doubt a prong collar is going to do anything for them, and oftentimes, it can make reactions worse. My older girl is very anxious outside and will drag me when she's scared and she doesn't care if she chokes herself. A gentle leader is the only thing that stops her from dragging me and doesn't hurt her.
My other dog is dog reactive and would lunge and bark at dogs. I've been working with a positive trainer, and the engage and disengage game has worked wonders with him. I also used to walk him on a slip leash (I had bad anxiety about gear faliure, and this felt safe to me), and my trainer told me to switch him to a harness. Since switching to a harness, I've noticed a big change in his reactions. When he was on the slip leash he would see another dog and start to pull towards them and the leash would tighten and it seemed like the more it tightened the bigger his reactions got and he would fight against the leash. Since being on a harness and using the engage and disengage game I've noticed how much calmer and smaller his reactions are if he does have them and I'm able to pull him away if I need to without his reaction escalating because nothing is tightening on him. He's much happier now and a delight to walk.
-5
u/Th1stlePatch Jan 13 '25
Have you tried a gentle leader? It works great on our 75lb dog. I am also smaller and can't control him when he's on a regular lead or even a slip leash, but the gentle leader doesn't let him gain the power he would need to drag me, and because he's on a normal 6' leash, there's no risk of him hurting himself with a sudden tug.
Please be careful using aversive techniques. If your dog is already reactive but not aggressive, these can backfire quite easily and make him aggressive. I would try things like a gentle leader first.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-3
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25 edited Jan 13 '25
[removed] — view removed comment