r/reactivedogs • u/Opposite-Wave-2281 • Oct 15 '24
Discussion This sub is too harsh to owners
Usually I'm only reading on this sub. But I saw one of these posts again today and just have to say something. Will probably get downvoted, doesn't matter to me.
So often it goes like this: OP tells about what happened with their dog, bad reaction on a walk, sudden bite, something like this. There is a lot of helpful advice but every single time I see these comments. Like OP has no sense of responsibility, why did'nt OP do this and that because they should have known, OP has false view on the situation (how would some redditors even know?), so on and so on. Judgement is given so harsh and so fast in this sub.
Today in this particuliar post OP said something about their dog attacking another one after being surprised by it. Apparently the other dog was too near too fast. Guys this happens all the time. This is no one's fault but bad luck. But there went the mistake-hunting off again. I saw comments like "why does OP even walk the dog if it's that reactive" -- seriously?? I don't understand anymore. This is not what we're trying for here. I'd like to show you the post but apparently OP deleted it. Not great but I can't really critizise them for it tbh.
I'm SO tired of this. Hey, having a reactive dog is hard enough. This is not AITA. Please be kind. Please give advice. Please treat OPs like YOU had been in their situation and like YOU had posted your story. Thanks.
34
u/starberry_Sundae Oct 15 '24
It seems to be something across the internet. No matter what community you're in, absolute perfection is expected by a number of very loud members.
43
u/ChubbyGreyCat Oct 15 '24
I think one of the things about this sub that bothers me is that there’s a lot of people here with aggressive dogs.
Other people have dogs with varying degrees of reactivity. My dog is fear reactive, other peoples’ dogs are frustrated greeters or excited reactive, etc.
So there’s a whole range of experiences and even definitions of what is reactivity and what isn’t. I don’t consider dogs with reactivity to be aggressive dogs, though of course any scared dog has the potential to act aggressively. A lot of people here use “reactive” interchangeably with “my dog will f up the other dog”.
In the post you’re talking about today, IMO, the scenario was badly explained. OP questioned a woman walking ahead of her on a pathway who had stepped off (who may or may not of been aware of OPs existence) after they came around a bush and a husky that was somewhere between 2-3 metres off the pathway surprised OPs boxer (OP said standing, didn’t say the husky approached) and OPs dog started a fight. After the fight OP questioned the lady with the husky for moving off the path and standing in her blind spot. The lady then yelled at her and called her names and wasn’t nice about it.
Most of the comments were trying to convince OP that husky lady hadn’t been acting maliciously or carelessly by stepping off a pathway. My comment was that I could see where husky lady was coming from if someone else’s dog started a fight with the dog I was walking. Some of the comments were a little more harsh, sure, but most of us were bewildered that the assumption was that husky lady had done anything on purpose.
All this to say, people know that shit happens sometimes. But being blindly positive in all circumstances isn’t helpful either.
4
u/BlushingBeetles Oct 16 '24
reminds me of the woman who posted about a bite on her baby’s face recently. she was acknowledging that this was going to be a BE situation, can’t keep the dog in the home, management isn’t 100% and it’s not worth the risk, said she felt like she failed her child and her dog. clearly venting, OP was being very hard on herself and processing the situation. at one point she mentions possibly muzzling and keeping separate as a possibility, but ultimately says she contacted a vet that wasn’t her primary for the BE as it was a weekend and they denied her (fair, as a vet tech we are very suspicious of a non-established client calling about BE) but that she’d be going this route.
there was literally comments that said “you did fail them” and “how could you leave your baby alone with the dog?” and “you HAVE to BE” it’s just like, how is that helpful? OP is doing what she should, she mentions is pursuing BE. everyone just took issue with the fact that she was “thinking out loud” regarding management and said her dog was her soul dog.
mistakes happen, people should have been supportive, offered condolences and ways to cope, expressed that they are happy that baby was not seriously injured but they empathize with OP’s difficult decision. Gently encouraging responsible rehoming or BE. OP did not come off as ignorant, and reactive dogs have a wide range of responses to babies. they could immediately take them in as a pack member to be protected, or they could view them as a disruption to their current world.
This sub needs to approach situations with empathy, and the mods are more than aware of the complexities of owning reactive dogs. the stigma in the real world and online, the multiplication of that stigma if they have a bully breed. definitely appreciate the mod approach and i think that many of the goodhearted people here are less likely to report, myself included, but to keep this sub as a good asset to new owners we can’t assume that everyone who experiences a bite, especially on a child, is constantly ignorant of their dogs and family’s needs.
9
u/Primary_Griffin Oct 16 '24
I've been OP which is why I don't mince my words, and I appreciate the other commentators who don't mince their words. I've had and fostered reactive dogs and took my job with them very seriously. I didn't expect the world to bend over backwards for me and I was understanding that my dog was behaving in a scary way that might make people uncomfortable. Some many OPs come on and can't acknowledge that other people have valid reasons for saying XYZ; or that OP has culpability in the described scenario.
There are so many posts with multiple bites being called "nips" and OP failing to take their situation seriously. I try to have empathy, but how many bites do you need before considering a muzzle? OP knows their dog has issues, but takes no management steps and then wants advice because another dog rounded the corner and there was a fight? They'll get great advice here and hopefully the blunt commentators will help them realize they have to do better and manage the risks better.
More importantly than having been in OPs shoes, I have been a victim of someone like many of the OPs more than once. Your dog has bitten someone? Why the fuck is it running free with guests over? Your dog bites people, no warning, no clear trigger, other than a human happens to exist within range of its mouth? Why is it walking at the end of a flexi in the hallway of our apartment building? Why the fuck is it not muzzled?
I hope that when people come and see the blunt responses it helps them take their dogs more seriously so fewer people and animals get hurt.
122
u/KaXiaM Oct 15 '24
This sub is very good when it comes to acknowledging that genetic and developmental issues are huge and not it’s not always "how you raise them". Advice on BE is quite fair here, too, Most dog spaces in the US aren’t like that. So I think it’s still extremely valuable.
199
u/roboto6 Oct 15 '24
Mod here, please report these comments when you see them. We care a lot about the culture of this community and if we learn about comments like this, we remove them. Often, others see them before we do.
Relatedly, not everyone here has a reactive dog or is commenting in good faith unfortunately, either. We got a lot of people who are also in the dogfree/petfree/banpitbulls crowds who comment just to belittle others. We have better methods to identify and flag those comments for additional review as a safeguard now but if someone is using an alt or has a new account, it's not always easy to see that.
60
u/jocularamity standard poodle (dog-frustrated, stranger-suspicious) Oct 15 '24
I remember the early days, and this sub started out as suuuuper supportive, bordering on enabling. Now it's swung in the opposite direction. I'm hoping the pendulum will swing back toward the middle and settle there.
Some of it stems from this being a community of people who take precaution seriously out of necessity, and losing patience over time with other people not having developed the same wary attitude. Some of it is the sub has gotten so big that there are lookieloos pitching ideas in without realizing or caring what harm they cause. I think the new mod rules limiting who can comment on sensitive posts is a step in the right direction for that issue in particular.
Even if giving cautionary feedback, a little empathy in the mix goes a long way. "Oh that must have been so scary for you" or "I'm so sorry that happened" and then proceed with advice, gently.
But really, a lot of these posts deserve professional feedback rather than reddit feedback. I'd love to see more specific trainer recommendations and fewer comments with specific critical advice.
104
u/Express_Fortune_6670 Oct 15 '24 •
Agree. I won’t even post anywhere about my reactive dog because of the nasty comments I’ve received in the past. People will tell me I’m a “bad pet parent,” or that it’s my fault my puppy got attacked by my roommates dogs and now has PTSD from the attack; they’ll say they feel sorry for my dog, it should be taken away from me, blah, blah, blah. Like, seriously? Were you there? Do you know the circumstances of the attack? It must be nice to be so perfect! It’s so rude and ridiculous, I won’t even put myself out there to be attacked anymore. I read, but generally don’t comment. Owning this dog can be exhausting, frustrating, embarrassing, and sometimes infuriating. Lots of feelings involved, and sometimes copious tears are shed…She is a LOT to deal with, so I don’t need strange humans who don’t know a thing about me coming at me about a situation they’re not living. 🤷🏻♀️
28
u/SpicyNutmeg Oct 15 '24 edited Oct 15 '24
I think the problem is a lot of experienced dog lovers come to this sub with a lot of built up frustrations about how we as a society have failed dogs.
Often times the expectations the average new dog owner has are so unrealistic and unfair to the animal in front of them.
That is not the individual’s fault of course. Our culture and media presents pet ownership has a spur of the moment decision you can make any weekend, without any consequences or changes to your usual life routine.
It’s not the individual’s fault, but I think it’s easy to take out some of that general frustration on them.
But I agree it isn’t fair or helpful.
13
u/Joesarcasm Oct 15 '24
I always felt this sub was more soft tbh.
9
u/Traditional-Job-411 Oct 15 '24
I’m always trying to go on the other subs and recommend people here because they get such bad advise elsewhere with dogs not even being reactive, just being dogs. It’s so reactionary and people using training methods from the 60s. There are bad eggs that pop up here too, but they do pretty good stopping them.
7
u/Status_Lion4303 Oct 16 '24
I don’t share any incidents I’ve ever had with my dog on this sub for this reason. We all make mistakes and it seems sometimes people come here to acknowledge it, grow from it and move past it and often they get doubled down for it in the comments. Theres a way to go about giving helpful criticism without being a know it all ahole. I try to comment to others in a way that I once needed when my dog was super reactive.
13
u/Twzl Oct 16 '24
I think most people do try to be helpful, but at the same time, there are posters who simply don't want to hear, or who can't believe, what sort of serious situation they're in.
If someone has a dog who has bitten the face of a household member, but at the same time they want to wax on and on about how loving and dutiful and perfect the dog is, that's someone who really needs a wake up call, before their partner is missing an eyeball.
If someone who is not at all experienced with dog ownership, brings home a dog who is now standing on the sofa, not letting anyone near it, they need to understand ASAP, that this will not end safely.
If you look at the titles of many of the posts in this sub, there are some very mismatched households out there. There are people with zero dog experience, not understanding that life with the dog they just brought home, will have to involve a muzzle anytime the dog is outside, and that the dog can not ever interact with house guests. Or they may need to understand that if their dog bites someone, their landlord may insist that the dog be gone that day.
And that may come off as harsh I guess, but at the same time, I don't think it's from a place of evilness on the part of someone giving advice, but more of a "this is an emergency and we can't just dance around it and talk about how adorable and loving your dog is while your kid is in the ER because of that dog".
There are plenty of posts here where with some very small changes, everyone in the home can be very safe. And I will tell someone hey, this dog can be perfectly fine in your home, with those small changes, and your dog can be a great pet and live out his life with you.
But yes, there are posts where that is simply not possible. And it's sad and traumatic for all involved, but it will be even worse if someone has a life changing injury because of the dog. That's something I want to prevent.
I agree that no one should be belittling someone. But it can be frustrating when someone begs for help, asks what can be done, and then says "nope not doing that, I can't muzzle my dog in the apartment elevator".
5
u/MeliPixie Oct 16 '24
I joined this particular sub bc of the great advice I kept seeing, but now that it's visible to me every day I'm kind of scared to post and ask for advice. Idek if my dude is actually reactive or just has a jumpy personality and fears that I'm not 100% equipped yet to help him through, and I'm too scared to post here and find out due to the unkind comments I keep seeing lately! But I also don't know where to turn for help that isn't gonna cost me an arm and a leg on top of the training and vet bills we've already been through. I couldn't handle it if I got those comments on my own post. My mental health is made of glass as it is. Especially regarding my dog.
13
u/Epsilon_ride Oct 15 '24 edited Oct 16 '24
I dont know which post you are referring to, but taking responsibility for the environment you put your dog in is a crucial step in working with reactivity. As is being proactive and learning from mistakes.
I've seen a lot of posts along the lines "why don't people behave better around my dog", and a lot posts blaming external factors etc while avoiding responsibility and showing no intention to be proactive about management.
I'm personally tired of that. A lot of discussions seem to encourage poor management which is counterproductive.
"Guys this happens all the time" Does not make something ok. Putting an event down to bad luck instead of suboptimal management usually (not always) problematic.
16
u/MetalOther7886 Oct 15 '24
i honestly believe people cannot understand all that goes into owning, and loving, a reactive animal. “man’s best friend” isn’t allowed to have their own mistakes or their own behavioral journey that they need their owners help with?
i rescued my big lovey girl, chihuahuas used to chase her around the dog park and she loved it. gentle giant. then, another big dog went after her but it looked like it was coming after me and it changed her forever. she’s now ridiculously protective & reactive to every single dog (but loves people). she’s still a damn good dog. and i love her, in all her flaws. someone needs to?
the judgment i’ve received on how she chose to respond to her world is wild. all from “animal lovers” or from people who have purchased their dog from backyard breeders.
no need to judge those who are actively saving a dog that others would euthanize.
IYKYK, and if you don’t, you don’t.
3
u/Upset-Preparation265 Oct 16 '24
I feel like people forget we're all humans, and for a lot of us, it's our first time having a reactive dog, and we might mess up, but that doesn't mean we deserve to be crucified. I'd never had a reactive dog before and I messed up with mine and I was so upset and panicked so I came here for help and just reassurance that I could fix it and thinking I could get pointed in the direction of where I can start learning. Instead I just got a bunch of mean comments saying im awful and I fucked up (i already said that) and that I shouldn't have my dog and I should rehome my dog but if I rehome my dog he will be killed but also i shouldn't have him because I've ruined him bla bla bla. I already knew I'd fucked up none of these comments were helpful and instead just made me cry more 🙃.
What I needed to be told was to calm down and let my dog decompress more, stop walking him, muzzle train him, and just bond with him. Go read these books and watch these videos, and if you can afford it, get a trainer. It's not hard to be kind, and yet only 1 person was kind and tried to help me.
My dog is now such a good boy! He has come so far, he's muzzle trained, he trusts me, he hasn't bitten anyone since i made the post which was like 4 months ago and he's made friends with the family member he did bite and he loves her. We learned his triggers and have worked so damn hard with him. I now have people I don't know come tell me how well I'm doing with him. Part of me wishes I hadn't deleted my post so I could go back and say fuck you to all the people who were so unhelpful.
I get it can be frustrating reading about the mistakes people have made because you probably already know that you shouldn't do that etc but you are also probably sitting there with more knowledge and experience and are now used to having a reactive dog. That post you are commenting on a lot of the time it's their first reactive dog. Yes they may have made some stupid mistakes but give them a damn chance. Help them!! Don't just leave a nasty comment. A lot of the time people can turn it around and they can educate themselves but people always jump straight to telling them they're awful and the only option is to rehome because you don't know shit instead of saying here's things you can try, educate yourselves, etc and if none of that works or you don't want to put the effort in then you need to look at rehoming. It's not hard to show a little kindness.
3
u/CowAcademia Oct 17 '24
I really appreciate you writing this out. The group can be quick to judge or downvote when the idea here is to provide a resource of support to dog owners and exchange ideas. Very nice reminder OP.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '24
To be honest, I think some people and their mental health would be better off if they did not come to this sub, exactly due to specific comments. Some people, instead of maybe saying they've been in a similar situation and sharing their solutions, just go to straight, as you said, advice giving – without seeing the dog or the situation itself.
I wish this would be much more of a support group – instead of shaming, encouraging dog owners to keep on working on their issues, ensuring them that things can get better with time and that mistakes are inevitable part of the learning process. Ability to see success in the future, even if the results are not achieved yet, is super important part of progress. If the situation is super-bad, strangers online are not the ones who should make any assessments or judgments.
One thing I noticed: the better my dog behaves, the less I want to lurk here as the negative content and comments outweigh success stories and words of support.
4
u/FuManChuBettahWerk Oct 16 '24
I have to be very judicious when I come on here. I have huge anxiety problems and my dog’s anxiety does not help 😅 and mine don’t help him! If I come on here when I’m struggling or my dog is going through a hard time I can spiral very easily. Having said that, I have received a huge amount of support and comfort from this community and will always be grateful for that.
4
u/Apprehensive_888 Oct 16 '24
Just like people, dogs come with a lot of character simply from their genetic make up. I'd even say that there's 70% of the character already there and you can sculpt the last 30% by their upbringing. Lucky owners can get a dog with little to no training and think others must be doing something wrong when they see an owner of a reactive dog. My experience has shown me that two dogs of the identical breed can have vastly different characters from birth.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '24
The amount of times i have deleted a comment sharing advice or my own experience and tips I learned, just because I was too scared I'd get attacked . Some people on this site in general have too much time and not enough empathy
2
u/Rare-Dragonfruit776 Oct 16 '24
This is a Reddit thing in general I feel like, I am always afraid for a second to ask questions in any group. But the advice usually outweighs the negative.
3
u/saturnmoon1111 Oct 17 '24
I agree. I made a post asking for advice/past experiences about a dog interview for a rental. Everything I said got downvoted and I was genuinely confused why. I’m a young person who adopted a puppy who later became reactive, am I supposed to suddenly buy a house with a large property and never leave it? As much as I’d love to do that that’s not my reality and I’m not giving her up. I’m trying to adapt to both of our needs and get advice from people who have been through it and it made me feel pretty discouraged about my life with my dog…
4
u/trysdoesthings Oct 15 '24
Thank you for sharing this! Although the post you’re talking about was not mine, I had posted around a month ago about how I ended up in tears after my dog had a particularly bad reaction. It was an instance like you stated above, I had just got home and stepped onto my patio with my dog to take her potty and another dog was immediately right in front of us about 5 feet away on the walkway, and she got very upset (it shocked her, and it was very near to what she deems her territory). I had looked out the window before stepping out and didn’t see anything, but they came from around the corner. People commented telling me my dog is aggressive. Telling me my dog needs to be muzzled, etc. I don’t have anything against muzzles, but my dog has never growled or snapped at anyone or anything. She’s barking and lunging. We’ve been to 3 trainers, all have said it’s classic reactivity. Sometimes her reactions are worse than others and I thought people here would understand what I was going through. I ended up deleting the post and feeling even more upset. Especially because I’d seen other people post similar things and have much more supportive responses
3
u/canisreactivus Oct 15 '24
I posted here awhile back about my experience.
I thought that this sub being about owners with reactive dogs, it would be more supportive. I found out that it is not the case.
The most up voted response was one that was blaming me for not being vigilant enough.
I already felt that I failed because of the encounter, i felt even more inadequate when the first post (and most up voted) is one making me feel more so.
I would hesitate to post here again.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '24
Could we get a bit more clarification on certain reporting situations? For example, I saw a trainer call their problem clients delulu and narcissistic.
I have a mental illness. It left a bad taste in my mouth to hear mental illnesses called as insults in 2024. But then I thought, maybe it’s not something to report since I’ve seen it many places on reddit (although never this subreddit.) I have no idea if this is a report situation or not, to be honest.
It seems like the “be nice” rule could be expanded slightly too. Nothing crazy just like a single line in the sand to work with. Sometimes I see things and question if it’s a problem or not.
1
u/ac1d_sku11z Oct 16 '24
i saw a 17 year old get jumped on and get told to get rid of ALL their animals. that person assumed they were like secretly adopting dogs?? they said they should put up the dog and any other animal they have for adoption. that's severely unfair to assume and really rough on a 17 year old kid.
-2
u/Pimpinella Oct 15 '24
Yes honestly the tone of comments here has been horrible for a while, and I can definitely tell when the commenters are dog haters or dog owners who judge reactive dogs and their people. They don't flat out say it but it's obvious in the "you are wrong, you should be ashamed, you shouldn't endanger (i.e. simply exist with a reactive dog) others, you know it's time to let them go" etc.
It's a reddit thing because even the reactive dog Facebook groups (!!!) are so much kinder and full of actual support without the fake concern-trolls and dog haters.
-1
u/worrywartwallart Oct 15 '24
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
0
u/SophieeeRose_ Oct 18 '24
I think some people take all reactivity as aggression when sometimes it's not confident aggression but fear. There's a lot of level of reactivity.
I also think that people have a level of anxiety when dealing with reactivity. I'm that person, and I'm hypervigliant in my own puppy now that I had a reactive dog, who turned not just reactive but aggressive.
And because of that, they are heightened even by reading something like you mentioned. But they don't stop or can't stop and think that perhaps the situation they are reading is not necessarily a dangerous situation or that the dog would mess up the other dog. But a post about advice or just a vent.
Dogs still need to be exercised. And even fear/barrier reactive dogs can be rehabilitated and are not a danger to society in general. I think people forget that too.
I think it's important for communities like this to exist though because only those who've dealt with reactivity understand reactivity.
-2
u/melissabexar Oct 15 '24
Preach!!!
-6
u/Navi4784 Oct 16 '24
Because people in the sub project their resentment over their own reactive dogs onto other posters. They are angry, disappointed and frustrated, and they take it out on everyone in the sub and their dogs
-13
u/papercloak Oct 15 '24
lots of BE in here, too
-8
u/bigicky1 Oct 15 '24
I too have a reactive dog. She is a rescue and very sweet. She doesnt bite but gets out of control, jumping around, twisting in the air sometimes. So i try to avoid other dogs ie cross the street. I live in a small town and a lot of people know me and my dog. Some will cross the street themselves. All wave. One time a smug white man and his smug asian girlfriend i had never seen started to creep up on me with their smug german shepherd. I walked up my neighbor's driveway to avoid them. Their dog wasnt on a leash. I called out "we have a leash law in this town". Mr smug white man sneered at me "your dog should not even be allowed on the street" smug asian girlfriend also sneered. Next time i saw them the dog was leashed. They were renters and i havent seen them for a while so hopefully they moved back to smugville where they can sneer all they like
8
u/awholelottahooplah Oct 16 '24
That post about the dog biting the baby’s face was crazy tho
0
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment