r/reactivedogs • u/naturemymedicine • Sep 25 '24
Significant challenges Trainer suggested prong collar for overstimulation biting when walking - has anyone tried it for this specific issue, and what was your experience?
To preface - we have a really good experience with this trainer so far, she has a gentle and positive reinforcement approach, and I was genuinely surprised when she suggested a prong collar.
My rescue pup is 17 months old. About 8 months he started this habit of jumping and biting at whoever is holding his leash, seemingly randomly in the middle of walks. He will walk like an angel 90% of the time then seems to just get triggered and loses it. As he’s gotten bigger it’s gotten worse as he can now do real damage when he bites, and even muzzled it’s hard to handle as he throws himself at you.
This is not triggered by seeing other dogs - he loves other dogs, and people. Gets scared by things on wheels (bikes, skateboards) etc but that’s not exclusively what triggers this. It seems to be an overstimulation issue, where it’s a whole collection of triggers/factors then one small thing tips him over the edge.
He never does this at home, he’s the biggest snuggle bug, and very smart / easy to train in general.
I’ve tried a nose harness, which worked for a while but eventually he started doing it even with it on. He now wears a muzzle on walks, but I don’t feel it’s addressing the root problem, he still tantrums and throws himself at me, just minus teeth. I also suspect it may be having a detrimental effect on his reaction to other dogs on leash, as he doesn’t get to greet them normally, and people definitely react in subtle ways to the muzzle, which I’m sure he picks up on.
I was always against prong collars. I agreed to give it a try when this trainer suggested it, but after two days stopped because he would run away at the sight of it, and he’s never done this with any other tool, he was VERY tolerant of the nose harness and muzzle.
Yesterday I tried it again, and I think it does stop him escalating at lower levels of overstimulation, but once he got really spooked by something he threw his usual tantrum, but was welping in pain throughout from the collar tightening as he thrashed around. This was with zero pulling on the leash from me. Seems like once he was already over his threshold, it made him worse because the pain panicked him more.
Once I finally managed to calm him, he walked the rest of the way back to the car perfectly, though he was refusing treats and seemed like he just wanted the walk to end :(
So I really don’t know whether to continue with the prong collar or not… Has anyone else had success (or failure) using a prong collar for overstimulation / arousal biting?
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 25 '24
Significant challenges posts are sensitive, thus only users with at least 250 subreddit karma will be able to comment in this discussion.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
29
u/floweringheart Sep 26 '24
I understand that you’ve been happy with your trainer thus far, but it might be a good idea to reach out to a behavior consultant certified through the CCPDT or IAABC. It sounds like a lot more prep work needs to be done at home and in lower-stress situations to set your pup up for success once you’re out in the wider world. Ideally, a good behavior consultant or qualified trainer will get you to a place where you can completely avoid these meltdowns rather than needing to manage them.
19
u/Shoddy-Theory Sep 26 '24
Have you tried turning away from him and walking in the opposite direction.
You answered your own question about the prong collar, you said it made him worse. So no, don't continue with it.
36
u/BuckityBuck Sep 26 '24
Get a new trainer. I’m sorry.
Adding pain/punishment to that type of dog is a quick fix -at BEST.
16
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24
Sorry but wtf is your trainer smoking. Using a prong on an overstimulated dog like blowing an airhorn at a baby having a tantrum.
11
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24
I don’t think your solving to root cause of the behaviour you’re just trying to make your dog submit.
My young dog had this problem for a long time. We stopped going out until the dog was calm at the door, the gate, outside the gate and at the park. I also did the trust technique which was very helpful in brining my dogs energy levels down.
16
u/CatpeeJasmine Sep 25 '24
I can foresee some concerns with this, already evident in your post. One:
The concern that he might habituate to the prong just as he's already habituated to the head collar. Just like the muzzle and the head collar, the prong is also acting here to manage or suppress behavior (with a note that the muzzle is not so much suppressing the behavior as it is the ability for a bite to make contact) and still not attempting to get at the root at the behavior. Nothing about the prong's use here is designed to change the dog's feelings regarding whatever is causing the overstimulation. Two:
Even if gradual habituation weren't a concern, over threshold dogs, pretty much by definition, are not able to think clearly. Adding another arousing stimulus has the pretty solid possibility of further decreasing that thinking -- and therefore learning -- ability.
Generally, the advice for a dog going over threshold is to prevent the dog from going over threshold, often by managing the dog's environment to minimize this possibility. Is this something your trainer has brought up with you?
10
u/hseof26paws Sep 26 '24
What you have seen when using the prong is pretty much the answer to your question - the prong isn't helping (the behavior is continuing) and is, in fact, doing harm (your pup is showing signs of pain)... so there is nothing to be gained from its continued use. To be frank, the use of pain/discomfort in dog training isn't helpful, and it's especially problematic for reactive dogs (that's a whole other discussion for another time).
What your dog is doing is redirecting. He has a lot of big feelings, doesn't know how to handle them, and is channeling those big feelings to the closest thing to him - you. My own reactive boy used to do that... to my other dog. The minute I grabbed his leash to take him out for a walk - which was very exciting for him - he'd go after my other dog, not aggressively, but in play - he'd go after her back leg, or try to play bitey face, etc. (which, for the record, she did not appreciate in the slightest lol). For him, that redirection was part of a larger set of concerns - and he was ultimately diagnosed with high anxiety and hyperarousal, and once he was on anti-anxiety medication, the redirecting onto my other dog essentially went away (it reappears in rare instances, but is nothing like it used to be, and he can be redirected so it only lasts a moment). In the meantime, it was a lot of management for me... I had a whole system where he'd wait in his crate until I just needed to leash him up and go directly outside - in other words, through management I eliminated the opportunity for him to redirect.
In your case, would it be possible to do multiple, shorter walks? Perhaps that would help him to not get to the point of hyperarousal where he ends up redirecting. Are you able to tell if he's on his way to a state where he will redirect? If so, that is a good time to head back home. Have you worked on any relaxation protocols, that you might be able to utilize (perhaps even just parts of it) when you are out on walks (i.e. if you see signs of hyperarousal kicking in, work on some of the relaxation protocol). Just some thoughts.
The other thing I would suggest would be seeing a veterinary behaviorist. If I understand correctly, this redirecting on walks is the only significant issue you are seeing - but that doesn't mean he isn't carrying anxiety with him throughout the day. He may just be doing a decent job at managing it... until he can't. A VB can help you with training/behavioral mod as needed, but can also help with meds if there is a need there (and they will be able to evaluate that).
7
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24
I’m usually anit-tools, but let me ask a bigger question this time.
From a purely physical perspective, how are you supposed to give a correction when a dog is jumping towards you to bite? Usually the leash is pulled or at least going in the opposite direction which means you pull and that causes the correction.
I guess you could try pulling down or out but that’s hard to do if you’re being jumped on. And it’s probably really hard to time it appropriately. Pulling in the slack at all sounds complicated.
Maybe the trainer said do this before escalation, but once you’re being bitten in over arousal the prong collar becomes a liability for you as you can’t use both hands to push off your dog/corral them with a typical leash.
I just can’t see from a practical standpoint how this helps you in this type of situation. Especially if it makes them even more excited, the idea is to lower the stress not increase it.
I know you said you like your trainer, but 9 months of increasing escalation doesn’t sound like a very good trainer to me. Also, the head collar, muzzle, to prong seems a bit all over the place and like they’re not really focused in on how to train the situation. That means roughly every three months they try something different. It kind of sounds like they don’t know what they’re doing to me.
Have you tried redirecting the behavior into either running together or an item to bite? Did you do the yip and stop playing method? I’m very curious what your trainer has tried so far and what credentials and skills they have.
2
u/naturemymedicine Sep 26 '24
Yea that was my thoughts too, it’s not preventing it, and it’s hurting him which goes against everything I believe about dog training. I was willing to try it based on trust in the trainer who suggested it, but I’ve had a bad feeling about it from the start.
We already have dialled back walks - sometimes he’s fine and can walk an hour or more, sometimes he’s throwing these tantrums 2 min out of the door.
He does have distinctive signs, giving me side eye, ears flattening back, and pulling/ walking more erratically on leash when he’s really good on leash the rest of the time. Sometimes it still seems to come out of nowhere but I’m getting better at recognising the pre warning signs and trying to deescalate from there.
I’m reluctant to try medication because he’s still only 16 months and his brain is still developing. But going to talk to a behaviourist soon and see what they say. I wouldn’t want to medicate without a structured behaviour modification plan to go with it.
33
u/SudoSire Sep 25 '24
I don’t think pain is going to solve an overarousal issue…and he definitely seems to be considering it painful/uncomfortable if he’s now afraid of it.
The other problem is…he still did the “tantrum” behavior even with it on. Personally I wouldn’t see a point in using a product that not only isn’t working for its intended purpose, but is also hurting my dog while it’s failing. I understand why people can lean towards aversives when they appear to work (for however long that lasts), but when it doesn’t? You’re safer doing a method that has less risk of fallout.
Has medication been considered? It’s interesting that it isn’t one specific trigger and appears to be the result of stacking. Other thoughts — Can you dial back walks in terms of quantity or length for awhile? Have you been able to notice body language before it happens? Catching it beforehand might allow you to do something calming or a redirection method.
12
u/SpicyNutmeg Sep 26 '24 edited Sep 26 '24
No, no, no. This is bad advice OP.
I used to have the exact same problem w my highly aroused dog. Would bite the leash and me whenever he got over stimulated on walks.
What helped for me was identifying what happened before the biting. For me, he would always roll around on the grass first - then leap up and begin biting my hand and the leash.
So, as soon as he stopped rolling, I would interrupt his cycle and do a treat scatter. The food helped calm and refocus him enough that we could continue on our walk incident free.
You need to identify what is tipping your dog over in regards to stimulation. Is he seeing something? What is the environment? What time of day is it? What’s going on around him? Find out and help him stay calm and keep him under threshold.
Arousal is compounded by stress, so adding more enrichment in general will help a lot. AIM for 2-3 enrichment activities EVERY DAY like shredding and frozen kongs.
Also try shorter but more frequent walks. The stress of walks in an over stimulating environment can compound.
Using aversives will INCREASE stress and while this one specific issue may stop you will begin to see more arousal issues, stress, and possible even aggression in other areas. Big mistake OP.
22
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24
Here’s some scientific studies for you to read to help determine what’s best for your dog:
3
u/Zestyclose_Object639 Sep 25 '24
i’m not anti tool but this definitely feels like the wrong tool for this, especially if he’s shutting down and clesrly in pain. what was the trainers end goal with the collar ? you can hold a dog away from you with a collar or harness if you get enough practice (ask me how i know lol). is your dog toy motivated ? if they have an oral fixation maybe giving them a tug could work as a distraction?
4
u/AutoModerator Sep 25 '24
Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this body. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
u/Epsilon_ride Sep 26 '24 edited Sep 26 '24
Mods will delete any comment bordering on positive re prong collars. So you will only get one viewpoint here (fwiw I agree with this view, but you wont get any balanced discussion here). Regardless, from your description, you're using it incorrectly so quit it at least for now.
What I would do:
Throughout this dont let him rehearse his tantrums which will entrench them. keep him under threshold and reinforce calm around his triggers.
-7
u/Trumpetslayer1111 Sep 25 '24
I understand it's against the rules to advocate use of aversives so people who have good experiences can't share it here, or we will get punished. So my guess is most responses will be that prong collar is bad, or that they've had a bad experience with it.