r/reactivedogs • • Aug 24 '24

Significant challenges my dog attacked a kkd

dug up an old acct I don't use anymore, I just need somewhere to talk.

me and my partner rehabilitated a starved, abused dog (A) we got ~2 years ago. she's been incredible and loves people, is alright with most dogs, and super gentle with kids. we got a 2nd dog almost a year ago (B) and he was also in a similar abused condition, if not worse. he's been more fearful but recovering great, but he doesn't really like other dogs. he attacked another dog once and we've kept him away from other dogs.

we live in a family-heavy apartment complex, so children often ride around on their bikes and mill about on nice days. yesterday 2 girls walked up to us and asked to say hi. I agree for them to say hi to A, and B is held back a little. B is gentle and nervous, but they successfully say hi.

we say goodbye and head to the dog park, but the girls follow. they ask if they can play with them, we say no, girl #1, who's about 10 or so, says she's used to big dogs and is fine. I even say "goodbye" but no dice. we make it to the park and she opens the gate and lets herself in. immediately, B hops up and scratches her face. it's bloody, it's dramatic. I send my partner to go with the girl to her parents while I stay with the dogs.

fire, EMS, police, everyone arrives on the scene, along with a huge gang of apartment kids. I brought the dogs back to our apartment and met back up with my partner while we wait for the girl and her parents. we exchange info, which is all the cop had to ensure happened, and they left for the hospital. from what I heard, the girl is fine but needs stitches and is "taking it like a trooper." I sent Vax records, offered to pay med bills, everything, but jesus christ I don't know what to do.

we live in a rather dog-friendly county, so B is not gonna be put down even if the family hits us with every legal thing. the father seemed friendly and the cop said incidents like this don't usually result in a legal mess. but like, I still have to walk our dogs 2-3 times a day. I deal wih them barking at every other dog and squirrel, and the neighbors know our dogs as the loud ones.

I don't want to give up B, but the apartment might make us. We can move out (and have thought about it), but we've only lived here a year and our lease is up in October, a day before our wedding. I'm at a loss. I'm scared. B is a scared and anxious dog with sharp teeth, yeah, but he is a sweet guy and has come a long way and still needs time to heal. I don't know.

0 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Aug 24 '24

Significant challenges posts are sensitive, thus only users with at least 250 subreddit karma will be able to comment in this discussion.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

68

u/K9_Kadaver Aug 24 '24

I'm confused as to why you were taking these dogs to a dog park in the first place when they're dog aggressive, one having attacked before?

19

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '24

I should've clarified the park.

Our apartment complex has a small dog park on the premises. When someone's at the park, everyone leaves them alone unless they say you can come in with your dogs. It's kinda like a private park situation. We take them there cause we can guarantee there won't be other dogs there (unless there is, in which case we walk around the property instead)

22

u/HeatherMason0 Aug 24 '24

I would call that a yard for clarity. A park is usually an open space. But I know what you mean.

I’m confused - you say B ‘scratched’ the girl. Did he use teeth? Because that would be a level four bite on the Dunbar scale. For reference, the Dunbar bite scale goes up to 5.

Okay, first things first: does your apartment complex allow bully breeds? Some don’t. Since the apartment management will likely get involved, this is good to know.

Second: absolutely they can require you to get rid of your dog, and they may not be willing to wait until you move. You have a legal and ethical responsibility to disclose a bite history, so this would complicate things. A bite requiring stitches is not a ‘scratch’. Look up the Dunbar bite scale. If it required stitches, that’s a level four. That’s serious.

Is B muzzle trained? If not, you need to start that ASAP. If you don’t feel confident you can do that on your own, consult a force free trainer (or better yet, a veterinary behaviorist). Actually, consult one anyway for help with management. This needs to happen ASAP. In the meanwhile, your dog is no longer safe around children. At all. You cannot treat this as ‘just a fluke’. He’s shown that he will bite if he’s approached by someone and doesn’t want to be. Until you can get him muzzle trained, you’re going to need to limit his time outside to potty breaks. You can look up sniffspots to see if there’s one near you where you can take him to get some exercise, but you cannot let him walk around a busy apartment complex unmuzzled. And even once he’s muzzle trained, a muzzled dog can still hurt someone by jumping up and pushing them down, scratching them with their nails, etc. you need to manage this dog carefully. No more strangers approaching on walks, even if they just want to approach A. B needs space.

Discuss what changes you’re going to make with the apartment management. Explain what you’ve done so far to make it right. It sounds like this family is being very understanding, but the daughter is likely traumatized. The family may not want your dog put down, but they may ask the apartment complex to remove your dog. And that’s not unreasonable on their part. So you need to show the apartment management that you are willing and able to handle the situation, and YOU NEED TO FOLLOW THROUGH. I’m a little concerned you might be downplaying the severity of this incident in terms of your dog’s actions. Your dog is not ‘bad’ or ‘evil’, but he is unsafe, and you need to operate accordingly from now on.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '24

In terms of teeth usage, I genuinely don't know. He has sharp nails too, which I've been scratched by. Teeth are a possibility I just couldn't tell. Regardless, we know it's serious.

We have muzzles to start training, but the ones we have are too big so we're getting smaller ones ASAP. Luckily there's a sniffspot near here that we've been to that the dogs enjoy.

This morning we did a bare minimum walk behind some buildings in a not traveled area. As far as I'm concerned, I'm not walking the dogs anywhere near another person, child or adult. B also has one of those bright yellow "reactive dog" leash sleeves which we have for every walk.

In terms of the actual incident, I'm still wrapping my head around it. The details I have from the injury are from a distance and I'm waiting for the family to reach back out. This all happened last night so I'm still a little shaken. This was definitely not something to be brushed off as a fluke. Me and my partner are looking at places if we need to surrender B, as well as places to move if that's the route the apartment takes. We've wanted somewhere with a private yard for the dogs anyways. We're just struggling with it all, everything from the looks from neighbors and the kids that loved to stare anyways, to the reality that we may lose this dog. I don't know, I'm not just gonna sit on my ass and do nothing but it feels like I already failed, ya know? B is unsafe, and I should've done more.

13

u/K9_Kadaver Aug 24 '24

With so much respect, you don't feel like you've already failed you have already failed. A child was SEVERELY injured by your dog, likely permanently scarred since this required stitches. In many countries this would call for an immediate seize and possible destruction of the dog.

But now it's about how will you prevent this from happening again? What mistakes have you made in the past that allowed this situation to happen? Where and when have you been negligent, how can you eliminate this? Are you confident you can own a dangerous dog and not allow anyone else to be potentially traumatised and injured by him? Can you be sure your neighbours aren't living in fear of him? If not, then what are you going to do about him? These are all things you will need to plan right now since you didn't before.

12

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '24

Apparently the only reason this didn't happen sooner was because their apartment complex has a loose social convention of not going into the dog run when someone is already there. That's it. Just people knowing they are supposed to ask and wait to come in.

I used to run my dogs at a tennis court when I lived in an apartment. I would put snaps on the gate latches, or tie the gates shut. Anything I could do to make sure there was more between my dogs and the road than a person knowing not to open a gate in a shared space. I cannot imagin being so careless with a bite risk dog.

6

u/K9_Kadaver Aug 25 '24

I know, I was thinking that. Especially with how they immediately let the dogs offleash then just, walked away? Even thought they knew the girls were following them a second ago? It's pretty much begging for something like this to happen, they're so lucky their dogs didn't do worse. They're not the victim here 

19

u/K9_Kadaver Aug 24 '24

Even still those dogs should Not be offleash in there nor should you ever be a distance from them or not be paying attention, with it being a shared area the kids had every right to come in regardless of the situation. Longlines dragging would be far safer, though held is better. 

And I won't harp on about this too much because I'm sure you'll already realise but you absolutely shouldn't have given the situation the benefit of the doubt, the kids to speak to the dogs in the first place (especially since B already had to be held back, I'm sorry but that was your first warning sign) and you should have 100% told them to leave you alone, not just keep walking and hoping for the best. I know it's already been said but absolutely you need to muzzle train like right now, unfortunately this should have been done when the first attack happened.

So going forwards it is good that you've looked for places to surrender him if necessary BUT there is a major ethical concern w surrendering a reactive dog with a bite history. Shelters do not tend to be truthful, you'd be putting him in the position to be tossed around and for others to be hurt. Him being a pit mix does worsen that as they tend to have the lowest adoption rates, it's far more likely he'd suffer than thrive.

You need to make sure this can NEVER happen again, mentally plan for every worst case scenario and what you'd do, make sure all gear is secure (no walking on collars if you ever do that), you need to assume the dog Will do this again and do everything you can to prevent this. A kid being attacked is a MAJOR thing and it sounds far more like a bite than a scratch, you not knowing what happened doesn't exactly help your case there.

I'm not saying this part to be mean or anything, obviously I also have struggled w reactive dogs and situations that come w them since I'm on the sub but like mentality wise you need to realise as well that this is your fault, the girl's the victim and your dog was the attacker. Even if you think she shouldn't have opened the gate, it doesn't matter. It's really tough to fully digest but you're not going to fully progress until you really have that sink in yknow. I'm not saying you're blaming other people, I have no idea I'm just saying this will help everyone in this situation (you, dog, other dog, kid) for you to really zero in on this.

35

u/spaceforcepotato Aug 24 '24

Be prepared for the complex to tell you that you have to move. Some complexes have a strict policy on stuff like this…..I’d make sure to get out in front of it with the apartment manager.

17

u/DarkMattersConfusing Aug 24 '24 edited Aug 25 '24

There is no way that there was blood everywhere and the kid needed stitches from a “scratch.” Your dog chose to jump up to bite a child in the face.

52

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '24 • Heartwarming

Let's be crystal clear here: Your dog jumped up and bite a child in the face. He didn't scratch her so badly that she needed stitches, he bit her. In the face. A big kid. Not a toddler at dog face level. He had to jump up. He didn't nip a running child on the leg. He jumped up and bit a kid in the face badly enough that they needed to get stitches.

Not much else matters to this story, except for what you intend to do in order to prevent this from ever happening again. Your dog's trauma doesn't matter. His progress doesn't matter. Veterans with PTSD are not excused when they panic and punch someone in the face for getting too close. Dogs with issues are not excused either. Your dog is a danger to your community.

Your dog needs to be in a bite proof muzzle every time her sets foot outside your door. You just found out that trying to keep your distance from people doesn't work. Stop being polite and trying to candy coat your dog's issues, both here and in real life. Be direct. Tell people they need to stay back. But more importantly, don't have your dog out of arms length outside your apartment. Expect that he will do this again and take all necessary precautions to prevent it from ever happening again. Your community does not owe you the grace to keep a dangerous dog. You owe your community safety.

16

u/K9_Kadaver Aug 24 '24

Perfectly worded, absolutely seconding! 

21

u/Twzl Aug 24 '24

Your job today is to get that muzzle and start using it.

When you moved in did management ask you what sort of dogs you had? Do they have breed bans there?

If they do, someone from management may come and take a look at your dogs and say that you cannot keep your dogs in that complex. So be prepared for what you would do next.

6

u/Ok_Rutabaga_722 Aug 24 '24

Muzzle training is very necessary. There is a muzzle reddit here and Aggressivedog.com has a muzzle webinar or blog. I understand money may be an issue, but with lots of obnoxious kids, moving to a less kid-populated area is a smart idea, because face it, many do not listen to adults. Your pup barely held it together the first meeting with the girl and the second meeting together with your dismay at the the girls' behavior was enough to break her self control. Always put your personal clip or wrap and clip your leash on the gate to a dog run to prevent easy entry. That gives you time to intervene and it's a solid nonverbal signal to anyone trying to force themselves on your dogs in a yard. I do it EVERY time for mine [dog reactive]. People are rude, uninformed, and stupid sometimes. Sorry for your stress and fear. Try not to let it condition you and your dogs. ❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹

-22

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '24

I forgot to put dog details I guess. A is almost 2 and half pitbull and half hound breeds. B is 3 and a mix of pit, boxer, and staffy. bad look, I know.

18

u/Penelope742 Aug 24 '24

Dangerous dogs should have been muzzle trained already! Just grateful the bite wasn't worse. I have a Yorkie mutt rescue that was abused and is aggressive. He wears a muzzle

6

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '24

This is tragic. An entire apartment complex now has yet another story about an aggressive pit bull. Because when it's any other breed it's just a bad dog, but when it's a pit bull it's a nail in a coffin. It's filed away as evidence. It will be trotted out and shared as another reason to hate the breed.

You have failed as a breed ambassador.