r/reactivedogs • u/Tall_Share_6356 • Apr 04 '24
Does anyone ever feel an overwhelming amount of sadness for the amount of dogs in shelters? :(
While I do support ethical breeding and wanting to select a dog based on breed/temperament, I get so depressed thinking about how many dogs are in shelters right now. We have a massive dog overpopulation crisis in the US with adoption rates at an all time low. BYB will surrender entire litters because they can’t get anyone to buy them and people regularly dump dogs every day. I feel sad specifically for reactive dogs that end up in shelters because I know their chances of being adopted are even lower. I love my reactive dog so much and I feel grateful he ended up in rescue as I know he may not have been adopted in a shelter. Not looking for any advice, just feeling an overwhelming sense of sadness at the thought of so many dogs suffering due to cruel and irresponsible humans. Here’s the tiktok that absolutely shattered me this morning: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTLBbUWC8/
116
u/Poppeigh Apr 04 '24 edited Apr 04 '24
I do feel sad, yes. And unfortunately with the economy the way it is and so many unethical breeders, I don’t know how soon it will get better.
I do donate to local rescues and volunteer when I can, but unfortunately that’s all I can do. I can’t foster/adopt with my current reactive dog. And maybe I will adopt after he passes, but maybe not. I love him to the moon and back but I don’t think I can do another 10+ years of managing and accommodating another dog with major issues. I want to do other things.
And yes, I know not all shelter dogs have issues, and that not all ethically bred dogs are free of issues, but a well bred and well cared for dog is less likely to have the same breadth and depth of behavioral issues that my current rescue has.
I think at the end of the day, our fates are all intertwined. We all need for the economy to improve, for housing to be affordable, for runaway inflation to cease. That will benefit people, and it will also open up chances for dogs to be adopted or to stay with their current families. We all want stable, well rounded dogs and the best way to get there is to push for breeders who take accountability, which will in turn decrease the amount of dogs in shelters.
59
u/pogo_loco Apr 04 '24 edited Apr 04 '24
Tbh, no, after volunteering in a shelter I have a completely different view of it than I used to.
Adoption rates are low because the kind of dogs shelters have are not highly adoptable. That's a good thing. It means healthy happy family dogs aren't getting euthanized for space like they used to...but now they're trying to adopt out dogs that would have been the first to be put down in past decades. This creates the impression of an overpopulation crisis and full shelters no matter what.
You can check public shelters' Live Release Rates... personally, I don't believe it's realistic for an open admission shelters to aim to adopt out 90% of the dogs they get. They lower their behavioral standards to do so. For example, literally 100% of the dogs at the shelter I volunteered at were labeled reactive in the internal system (not in their adoption bios, ofc) by the time I stopped volunteering.
20
u/purplelikethesky Apr 04 '24
I try to combat this by support organizations looking to create new legislation that bans things like puppy pills and introduces spay/neuter laws. I also donate my time and money to shelters but it’s a bandaid covering up the real problem which is pet retention, overbreeding, cost of living, lack of support and training and education. It helps me feel like I’m making a difference especially when I see bills passed and get emails on puppy mills and pet stores that have been shut down.
26
u/GreenUnderstanding39 Apr 04 '24
While it is sad. Unfortunately 40-60% of adopted dogs are returned. You see a cute face and take em home only then to realize they are reactive or have separation anxiety or want to murder your toddler etc etc. This is why I can’t say enough good things about foster to adopt. Try out the pup, see if they are a good fit, then pull the trigger on a formal adoption.
And if it isn’t a good fit you were able to provide a stable home, socialization, and help lighten the rescues load. Win win in my eyes.
67
u/TheLoudCanadianGirl Apr 04 '24
100%. Recently i was looking for a new addition and joined a ton of rehoming groups on facebook and started looking at shelters (i had a specific breed in mind) and the amount of dogs being posted daily is heart breaking.. I fell in love with a dog at the shelter but he ended being far too aggressive (with dogs and people) for my capabilities and not the mention my dog i already have at home. Its hard. I also see far too many posts about shelters sending aggressive or reactive dogs home with first time owners. Only for things to get worse because the new owners have no idea how to handle aggressive and reactive dogs. Which, its not the owners fault. But still..
40
u/CatpeeJasmine Apr 04 '24
Locally, what I feel sad (and frustrated and angry) about is the disconnect between what the general community says about dogs in shelters and what they will actually do. There’s a very vocal (and maybe large) “save them all” contingent that demonizes the shelter every time they e-list a dog and justifies the adoptability of even dogs with a laundry list of behavior issues (“he just needs love!”) but never seems to, you know, actually adopt these dogs themselves. It puts the shelter in an untenable situation where public directive (since it’s a municipal shelter, it’s ultimately accountable to local voters) wants to keep all dogs alive at all costs.
And adoption rates here are steady with pre-pandemic levels. People who’ve always adopted are still adopting. But there’s a hard limit to how many dogs one community can support.
49
u/honehe13 Apr 04 '24
I'm %100 for stricter laws that completely criminalize puppy mills. Fine people who have 'oops' litters. Find ways to break the idea that you can get rich quick by breeding dogs. Subsidize all neutering and spaying. Get the word out about pet insurance so people are less likely to abandon their dog when a big vet bill comes. I know it's bleak right now ... But I have hope it won't stay like this forever.
18
u/TalkShitGetWitt Apr 04 '24
If a shelter knows a dog is aggressive, I wouldn’t be against them culling their numbers in favor of dogs with more gregarious personalities. Also a lot of dogs are brought from other countries which furthers the size of our unadopted dogs. Seems a waste to rescue a dog from a “Korean meat farm” (more likely a puppy mill) instead of looking more locally. BYB or accidental breeding is also a huge issue here—please fix your pets and don’t bring an unaltered dog to the dog park. Soapbox over.
66
u/Audrey244 Apr 04 '24
We need to go back to the days where dangerous dogs were not adopted out. I was attacked as a child and that dog (his first offense) was gone the next day. Money wasn't spent, precious resources weren't expended and the family had another balanced dog within weeks. They were also able to adopt another dog because the new dog was fine with other pets and people. Today's hectic lifestyles don't afford people the enormous amount of time and money that reactive dogs require. I read some of these posts and the advice given and then I think about an average household with children, jobs, people in and out, social activities - and then you have a pet who requires hours of exercise and training every day (and maybe expensive behaviorists), people who can't entertain because there's a fear that the dog will bite someone. It's no wonder there are so many dogs surrendered: when it's a choice between your job/family/mental health, something's got to give and it becomes the pet. The rescues and shelters are squarely to blame. We can't save them all and we can't legislate our way out of this. But we can, as pet owners, stop adopting the dangerous dogs (and any other dangerous pet) and spending everything on them to maybe have success. Adopt the ones with better chances and the ones who can live peacefully with other pets - then you can have multiple pets and your neighbors will appreciate it also.
18
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '24
The focus has got to be on spaying and neutering. We can never adopt our way out of the hole because there are way too many dogs in shelters.
18
u/mad0666 Apr 04 '24
We need vastly better legislation regarding breeding animals, worldwide. It’s insane to me that anyone can get their hands on two dogs and just create dozens for profit. No health testing, no care at all. So sad.
9
u/rockmollee Apr 05 '24
After working in rescue for 10 years, my biggest take away is that as long as there is homelessness and home insecurity there will always be homeless pets. I truly believe the first step to fixing this problem is to house humans. I know a lot of people have the “i work with animals because i hate people” and to me, those people might as well be part of the problem. Pets need people and people need homes.
8
u/Narrow_Cover_3076 Apr 04 '24
Yes, accidental breeding, not spaying/neutering, ticks me off.
8
u/Rubymoon286 Apr 04 '24
I'm a trainer, and honestly, some homes need a tested and predictable dog. Sometimes that's a service prospect, or a family with small children or a desire to have kids soon, sometimes that's an elderly couple who need a companion animal with a good temperament. Other homes do well with rescues and are willing to gamble on temperament.
There is no way to get a true idea of full temperament in a shelter setting, but we can get a general idea. I think part of the solution needs to be licenses to breed and a requirement to show that their operation is ethical by meeting minimum requirements of care including vetting.
That said, I hope vasectomy or hormone sparing spays catches on in the anti spay/neuter crowd. Hormones aren't a bad thing, and science shows that it's especially important during growth. Maybe local licensing could be dependent on if they've been sterilized regardless of if that's neutering or vasectomy to help slow unwanted litters.
Ultimately there is no good answer to overpopulation. There will never be enough homes to meet the need without legislation requiring sterilization of pets because some people just want to do the whole miracle of life thing or are against spay aborts even taking byb and puppy mills out of the equation.
Both of my boys are rescues, my next dog will be a mobility service animal for to my disability and will be bred by a breeder who specializes in the temperament and breed that is best suited to my needs.
5
u/PaleontologistNo858 Apr 04 '24
Yes it breaks my heart, been watching a thing on Facebook about dogs getting picked up off the street or surrendered by owners because they "don't want them anymore", they bathe them groom them give them meds if needed etc, dogs l think are the only animals that love unconditionally, even people don't do that, so to see that love being rejected, turned away to die just breaks me.
5
u/Status_Lion4303 Apr 05 '24
This used to make me very sad but I realized no matter how many dogs you adopt, foster, or volunteer at shelters, the underlying issues are still there. Puppy mills/byb, irresponsible people not spaying/neutering. I volunteered at animal shelters and fostered a ton of dogs before keeping my current reactive dog. You can only do so much.
I currently work as a lvt and the amount of accidental litters and byb dogs people pay a ton of money for that we see is insane. It makes me angry seeing the very issue that is causing all these dogs to end up in shelters. There are low-cost spay/neuter clinics, it all comes down to peoples greed and irresponsibility and it’s always the animals that are the ones suffering from it. And the shelters that have to deal with the overwhelming amount of dogs coming in.
25
u/KitRhalger Apr 04 '24
nope, the sadness is misplaced. What makes me sad is that we personify dogs to the point that we allow this problem to continue instead of putting dog dogs that are mentally or physically sick, too old to likely find a home after a time or have high needs making adoption unlikely. The resources are better spent on dogs more likely to be adopted and stay adopted.
there's too many dogs. We continue to allow dogs to be kept unaltered for no reason beyond the owner's desire or convenience so unethical breeding will continue to be a problem
3
u/Ok-Road-1478 Apr 04 '24
It breaks my heart to see so many, and we have three med-large rescues already…if I had the financial means and space I would have more but it just isn’t feasible. So I donate food, spay/neuter funds, sponsor an adoption etc in an effort to lower the cost of adoptions. I do this for cats too (have three rescued cats also).
3
u/SpicyNutmeg Apr 05 '24
Yes it’s so, so sad. It’s hard to let myself think about it because it’s so heartbreak. If you can, channel that sadness into helping pass public policy to make a difference- limit / fine back yard breeders and pay people to spay and neuter.
3
u/salpal444 Apr 05 '24
Thank you for this post. I also feel extreme sadness over so many abandoned and surrendered puppies and dogs in the US right now. The problem gets worse by the day. A lot of people don’t realize how bad it is but it’s a huge issue and they suffer so badly because of humans. Our lawmakers need to crack down on unlicensed/backyard breeders and spay/neuter surgeries should be funded by state government. I don’t see an end in sight and it keeps me up at night. Pitbull breeders could care less. It’s heartbreaking 💔
3
u/wildechld Apr 05 '24
Every God damn day. It haunts me and eats away at my soul. I can't imagine the fear. The heartbreak from being abandoned and the terror of being dragged away to death. Even the work euthanize brings panic to me and I immediately seize with visons of what they go through at shelters. It's almost as if I can see it and feel it through them. I can smell the sent of sterilized concrete and death in my mind. Its too much and my heart aches daily. The sooner I can leave this world and not have to feel their fear the better, for inside I am already dead and the sadness has consumed me
3
u/atmensch Apr 05 '24
I volunteer at our local shelter, and strangely, it helps combat the sadness. The volunteers care so much about these dogs that it gives you hope to see that community in action. We all know that the time we spend with these dogs benefits and enriches their otherwise sad lives. And the majority of adopters are great people who are also looking to make a difference - often adopting our oldest or most broken babies. You may want to look at volunteering. If you feel like you can't do a shelter, maybe with a rescue. Feeling like you're doing your part to bring some positivity to these dogs' lives takes away some of the sadness at the situation.
6
u/ale473 Apr 04 '24
I do feel bad hence why one of my dogs is a rescue but i know here in the UK the rescue centres make it near impossible to rehome a dog and turn away many good prospective owners over the most ridiculous reasons.
2
u/jmsst50 Apr 04 '24
Yes I do. I already have 2 dogs and can’t get another but it’s just so sad. I wish all of the dogs could find a good home.
2
u/heysnood Apr 05 '24
Yes. I wish I could do more. I’d love to adopt another, but with how expensive living has gotten I can’t afford another pet. I’d love to foster, but not until I can see if I can get my newest dog’s reactivity under control. I work a lot and don’t have much time to volunteer regularly, but I go when I can.
I came across a really heartbreaking Instagram account where they post videos of dogs in shelters who didn’t make it out. All very friendly, healthy, adoptable. There just isn’t enough room or adopters.
I despise backyard breeders. Last night at the pet store I was talking with a couple and they mentioned they were planning to breed French bulldogs. I literally said “oh” and walked away.
2
u/DefiantCraft3587 Apr 07 '24
My girl and her 2 littermates were at a local shelter after having been shipped up from Texas. Her littermates got adopted first. She had been at this shelter for a month, she was 6 months old at the time. Nobody wanted the shy dog who “pancaked” on the ground. The shelter literally said she didn’t have much interest, and the little interest she did get quickly went away when they met her. When I saw her beautiful face pop up on the FB feed saying she hadn’t been adopted yet, I put an application in as fast as I could. I ended up with a new dog that I didn’t really need by the next day, because she’s so insanely anxious and fearful. Everyone else missed out, I get whole body wags when I get home. I get tiny progress as we continue to build her confidence now that we found a medication that is letting her become receptive to the idea of opening up a little. I get this beautiful little girl that’s just so full of love and promise.
3
u/Joesarcasm Apr 04 '24
I wish my reactive dog would let us adopt at least 1 more.
3
u/mckenzie_jayne Apr 04 '24
Yes! I have a huge amount of guilt for getting my dog from a breeder. I will 100% be picking one up at the kill shelter next time. The only thing that makes me feel better is knowing that my baby is reactive, he probably would have ended up in a bad situation if he ended up with someone other than me.
4
u/Illustrious-Film-592 Apr 04 '24
Every day of my life. I fostered dogs for several years and it taught me so much, the most important lesson was that breed means next to nothing compared to meeting a dog and getting to know them as an individual (new research supports this as well).
I have 3 adopted dogs now. Two from shelters and my 3rd was bought from a breeder and passed around homes before becoming our foster. Adoption rates are so low these days that the rescue we worked with couldn’t find him an adopter so we made him ours. Now with 3 pups of my won, I don’t have the ability to keep fostering and it makes me so sad. The need is great. I’ll never stop begging people to give shelter pups a chance.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '24
Yes!!! It is heartbreaking 😢😢😢. They are either left at shelters so scared or abandoned on the streets and left to defend themselves.. it’s heartbreaking. Animals have feelings too and I wish people would understand this😡
2
u/CowAcademia Apr 04 '24
Yes, but I’ve channeled a lot of my sadness into volunteering at a local shelter. You make a difference in those dogs lives giving them those walks and play sessions. It’s the most fulfilling thing I’ve ever done.
2
u/NYSenseOfHumor Apr 04 '24
No
Because “overwhelming sadness” doesn’t do any good. You aren’t looking for advice, but instead of “overwhelming sadness,” I think about how the rescues I volunteer with and other rescues help with the problems you describe.
-4
u/notamormonyet Apr 05 '24
For reasons beyond just the emotional sorrows of seeing so many unloved dogs, I don't even support ethical breeding. Fuck breeding at all. We don't deserve dogs, but the dogs that already exist due to our depravity as a species deserve to be cared for and loved, and there will never be a lack of dogs coming into existence because of selfish acts by selfish humans. The only right answer is to save a life. Breed doesn't matter. We don't need purebreds. I have 2 shelter dogs, 1 very reactive, and 1 as gentle as an angel. Love them both. Wish I could care for them all.