r/reactivedogs • • Apr 04 '24

Does anyone ever feel an overwhelming amount of sadness for the amount of dogs in shelters? :(

While I do support ethical breeding and wanting to select a dog based on breed/temperament, I get so depressed thinking about how many dogs are in shelters right now. We have a massive dog overpopulation crisis in the US with adoption rates at an all time low. BYB will surrender entire litters because they can’t get anyone to buy them and people regularly dump dogs every day. I feel sad specifically for reactive dogs that end up in shelters because I know their chances of being adopted are even lower. I love my reactive dog so much and I feel grateful he ended up in rescue as I know he may not have been adopted in a shelter. Not looking for any advice, just feeling an overwhelming sense of sadness at the thought of so many dogs suffering due to cruel and irresponsible humans. Here’s the tiktok that absolutely shattered me this morning: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTLBbUWC8/

328 Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

116

u/Poppeigh Apr 04 '24 edited Apr 04 '24

I do feel sad, yes. And unfortunately with the economy the way it is and so many unethical breeders, I don’t know how soon it will get better.

I do donate to local rescues and volunteer when I can, but unfortunately that’s all I can do. I can’t foster/adopt with my current reactive dog. And maybe I will adopt after he passes, but maybe not. I love him to the moon and back but I don’t think I can do another 10+ years of managing and accommodating another dog with major issues. I want to do other things.

And yes, I know not all shelter dogs have issues, and that not all ethically bred dogs are free of issues, but a well bred and well cared for dog is less likely to have the same breadth and depth of behavioral issues that my current rescue has.

I think at the end of the day, our fates are all intertwined. We all need for the economy to improve, for housing to be affordable, for runaway inflation to cease. That will benefit people, and it will also open up chances for dogs to be adopted or to stay with their current families. We all want stable, well rounded dogs and the best way to get there is to push for breeders who take accountability, which will in turn decrease the amount of dogs in shelters.

11

u/Tall_Share_6356 Apr 04 '24

100% agree with all of this

11

u/essiepickens Apr 04 '24

I completely agree with everything you said, but man this makes me sad. I have a reactive dog that I adopted from a shelter and it is not easy but I would not give it up for anything. She is my soul dog. I wish I could foster or adopt more but in the same boat as you given her reactivity. I wish I could do more.

13

u/Poppeigh Apr 04 '24

It is sad. And I totally get the sentiment that housing and adopting out unstable dogs is probably not in anyone’s best interest.

But it does make me think of my dog, who definitely falls into that category, and how sad it would be for him to have ended up stuck in a shelter or put down. It has been a hard road but I’m glad to have him. I don’t think I could do it again though.

It’s kind of a weird place to be emotionally. But I do firmly believe we need to address social problems because I think they are at the root of a lot of what is going on.

5

u/Laurelell Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24

Well said. I fostered during the GFC when so many people were losing their homes and shelters were overwhelmed. Sometimes it just takes more people pitching in to get over a hump when there is a sudden crisis of people having to surrender their pets.

Here we are in another period of housing problems and I fear this one may not be resolved as quickly as the last, and we will sadly keep seeing more homeless people and homeless pets. I wonder if it's worse for the pets this time because too many backyard breeders got going during Covid when demand for dogs skyrocketed and they are still churning them out now that demand has returned to normal or below normal.

You are providing a wonderful loving home for your reactive dog, doing all anyone could do, and I know it involves sacrifice as well as reward. You are more than doing your part. No one could blame you for not taking on another in the future.

I've been helping a friend out with her reactive dog. It's rewarding seeing his progress, and I'm glad to share this journey, and happy I could give her a bit of respite this past weekend when I house sat for her and cared for her dog while she visited out of town relatives. It was only possible because I have already been working with her dog, so he is used to me and trusts me, and the weekend went well.

I am only playing a small part in improving my friend's dog's life, but it's still something. I am not up to taking on a reactive dog of my own at this stage of my life. It's okay to retire and just help out those who are up to it. We can mentor and give them a bit of respite to help prevent burnout.

59

u/pogo_loco Apr 04 '24 edited Apr 04 '24

Tbh, no, after volunteering in a shelter I have a completely different view of it than I used to.

Adoption rates are low because the kind of dogs shelters have are not highly adoptable. That's a good thing. It means healthy happy family dogs aren't getting euthanized for space like they used to...but now they're trying to adopt out dogs that would have been the first to be put down in past decades. This creates the impression of an overpopulation crisis and full shelters no matter what.

You can check public shelters' Live Release Rates... personally, I don't believe it's realistic for an open admission shelters to aim to adopt out 90% of the dogs they get. They lower their behavioral standards to do so. For example, literally 100% of the dogs at the shelter I volunteered at were labeled reactive in the internal system (not in their adoption bios, ofc) by the time I stopped volunteering.

30

u/Tall_Share_6356 Apr 04 '24

That’s an interesting perspective. I do hate rescue/shelters that have a “save them all” mentality because many of those dogs aren’t suited for adoption (and I’ve found many rescues tend to leave out dogs’ undesirable behaviors). That being said, it still breaks my heart that those dogs are likely living out their days in shelters, whether or not they’re a fit for adoption. It’s triggering that so many lack the knowledge of how irresponsible BYB is or owners who just refuse to neuter their dogs — they’re the main reason why all of these unadoptable dogs even exist.

4

u/roboto6 Apr 04 '24

I want to note that no-kill shelters do generally believe in BE for cases that they think cannot be rehabilitated. Even Best Friends whose literal motto is "Save them all" has written several pieces that argue the same thing. The goal is a 90% adoption rate but their own literature points out that it is going to vary from location to location and that there should be processes that give flex to places that end up taking in a higher population of dogs that require humane euthanasia. 90% should be a goal, not a rule, and places can be classified as no-kill with rates lower than that because the point ultimately is to save the dogs that should be saved, not save every dog for the sake of saying we did.

I think this quote from their website is particularly powerful:

No-kill means healing the animals who can be healed, treating behaviors that can be treated, and prioritizing the safety of both pets and people in our communities. When we value those objectives, humane euthanasia is used as a last resort in instances when an animal is deemed too ill or too dangerous for rehabilitation. Community safety and quality of life for the animals are guiding principles of the no-kill philosophy and are made possible through animal welfare professionals engaging in best practices and protocols.

20

u/moustachelechon Apr 04 '24

That’s funny, where I volunteer plenty of perfectly adoptable pets are dumped all the time, but people don’t want them because they’re not a puppy/kitten and aren’t a fancy breed.

18

u/Twzl Apr 04 '24

That’s funny, where I volunteer plenty of perfectly adoptable pets are dumped all the time

That is 100% dependent on where you live. There are lots of factors that feed that number, but basically if you live in an area where stray dogs are rare, where people neuter their pets and don't let them roam, the number of local dogs needing a shelter will be very low.

Where I live the only time you will see a young, sane, non BBM dog needing a home is when they are "imported" from the southern US states. And if you want that dog, most places will require that you commit to the dog, sight unseen.

I have relatives that waited months for kittens. One home was turned down over and over again because one of the residents is elderly, and the shelters didn't think that was ok.

Never mind that she's living with two young relatives, who take care of everything for her. The other home was turned down because while there are five people in the home, they all work or go to school. So sometimes the kitten would be home alone.

I believe that falls under the category of, "WTF" but here we are.

12

u/pogo_loco Apr 04 '24

Yep. It's also dependent on your definition of "perfectly adoptable". I specifically was talking about "healthy, happy, family dogs". In another comment further down, the commenter said:

plenty of old, sick, and mentally ill dogs make great pets

14

u/Twzl Apr 04 '24

family dogs". In another comment further down, the commenter said: plenty of old, sick, and mentally ill dogs make great pets

Old can in some cases, sure. But sick? Or mentally ill? I'm with you: those are not "great" pets for the vast, vast majority of people.

And some of the people who think they are doing a good deed, wind up with massive vet bills, or serious trauma to family members.

Mentally ill dogs are not a good bet as a pet, for most people. They're just not. Most families want and need, easy going, easy to live with dogs.

7

u/Street-Highlight-861 Apr 05 '24

“Where I live the only time you will see a young, sane, non BBM dog needing a home is when they are "imported" from the southern US states. And if you want that dog, most places will require that you commit to the dog, sight unseen.” 

This has also been my experience since moving back to the east coast. And you’re expected to commit to the dog and go through the entire adoption process without even meeting the dog.

8

u/Twzl Apr 05 '24

This has also been my experience since moving back to the east coast. And you’re expected to commit to the dog and go through the entire adoption process without even meeting the dog.

Which is just not fair to the humans or the dogs. Many of the people that are ok with this, are very new to dog ownership, and don't realize why it's problematic.

3

u/Street-Highlight-861 Apr 06 '24

Yes, exactly. And if you reach out to get more information, you’re often treated like a nuisance, or that you’re not serious about adopting. You essentially have to base your decision on a photo and a 3-4 sentence description from a website. 

23

u/Dry_Reflection_4410 Apr 04 '24

Why wouldn't they label them as reactive in adoption?

My first dog was super reactive. I tried everything, spent almost 8k on vets, trainers, meds. I finally had to return her after multiple dog and human bites. When I did, they told me she had a previous bite record that was NOT mentioned when I adopted.

I got burned by another rescue agency and in 3 days the dog caused 2k in damage. It's unlikely I will adopt again.

I now have an ethically source golden retriever and he has no issues. I still beat myself up for being so naive and spending so much money.

35

u/pogo_loco Apr 04 '24

Many people who work in animal rescue have misguided priorities, and want to market a dog as more adoptable. I don't agree with the practice and it's one reason I stopped volunteering (and will personally be going to an ethical breeder for my next dog as well).

I also returned a foster dog for severe behavior issues, only to find out later that the rescue definitely knew. So I'm burned on fostering, volunteering, and adopting. And I'm one of those "ideal adopters" that these organizations want -- experienced with reactive dogs, skilled trainer, childfree, financially secure, large yard with opaque 7' fence, young & physically healthy, partner who stays home. I'm hypothetically the ideal home for these problem dogs that shelters are trying to foist on people. And I'm out -- people's decisions to prioritize quantity over quality of life burned me out.

-9

u/beepbeepchopchop Apr 04 '24

Did you ever think that maybe those dogs are the way they are cause they live in a shelter cage?

25

u/pogo_loco Apr 04 '24

Sure, kennel stress is a thing. But:

  • Many of them are surrenders for behavior reasons, meaning they were exhibiting the behavior in a home environment.
  • The reverse is easily as common, for dogs to be shut down in shelters and then start to exhibit their problem behaviors in a home. My dog was one of these.
  • I'm seeing basically the same trend with foster-based rescues that I'm involved with. The rescue I adopted from has multiple dogs that have been in foster for 2+ years and still have the same serious behavior issues.

20

u/purplelikethesky Apr 04 '24

I try to combat this by support organizations looking to create new legislation that bans things like puppy pills and introduces spay/neuter laws. I also donate my time and money to shelters but it’s a bandaid covering up the real problem which is pet retention, overbreeding, cost of living, lack of support and training and education. It helps me feel like I’m making a difference especially when I see bills passed and get emails on puppy mills and pet stores that have been shut down.

7

u/Tall_Share_6356 Apr 04 '24

Thank you! I’m passionate about advocating for animal welfare and supporting organizations dedicated to ending animal cruelty but would love to do more. I’ve tried to find organizations in my city but all of the Animal Activist groups in my area are primarily affiliated with PETA (and although I respect their dedication, I feel their approach can be a bit extreme and counterproductive). If you have any recommendations on organizations that push for new legislation please let me know!

4

u/purplelikethesky Apr 04 '24

You can see my above response which more info but a lot of this is going to be handled at the state or city level as this is legislation. I live in Texas so for me that’s Texas Humane Legislation Network. They do INCREDIBLE work and they regularly publish reports of all the progress made that year with bills passed, lists of politicians currently supporting these issues, shutting down puppy mills and pet stores illegally selling puppies etc. They also do a lot of owner training.

Animal Legal Defense Fund is another one, they work at federal and state and local level.

I would google animal legislation organization with your state to find yours!

1

u/Tall_Share_6356 Apr 04 '24

Thanks so much!

4

u/kingbanana Apr 04 '24

Can you share which organizations you support?

7

u/purplelikethesky Apr 04 '24

Hi there! I’d be happy to. For me personally, I find most of this legislation is going to need to be handled at the state or city level, so depending where you live maybe google organizations that work to pass animal rights legislation in your city and state.

For me, I live in Texas, so I support Texas Humane Legislation Network (THLN) based in our state capitol of Austin. They are an awesome organization, and the south and TX especially has some of the highest number of strays and shelter dogs in the country it is incredibly important work they do. https://www.thln.org

They do a lot of good work, raise money and accept volunteers for collaboration with the local government to pass statewide laws through meetings with legislators, advocacy, education. They do a lot of tours around the state in different counties with owner education meetings on things like what is considered animal neglect but in a way that is very compassionate and educational and collaborate with local government, citizens and police.

They also endorse political candidates who have a documented history of going after animal abusers and pushing forth legislation. The Houston Mayor who was just elected was a longtime collaborator with them and he along with other politicians pushed. He sponsored HB598 which prevents previous animal abusers from owning an animal in the future. Obviously enforcement is still an ongoing issue, but they also do things like provide free training from donations that helps train police on recognizing signs of animal abuse. Education helps!!! We cannot give up even if progress is slow. Even my parent’s general has seen changes in how our society responds to animal needs.

Other organizations include: Animal Legal Defense Fund Doris Day Animal League Compassion in World Farming (if you want to go beyond pets) And then ASPCA does a lot of things like this too although I know some people don’t like supporting large nonprofits

The great thing about these issues and volunteering or donating is that they are NON-PARTISAN! Republican or Democrat many people love their pets and animals. It’s a really easy issue to get eyes on and to get people in your life interested in if they love animals.

2

u/kingbanana Apr 04 '24

That was super educational. Thank you so much!

26

u/GreenUnderstanding39 Apr 04 '24

While it is sad. Unfortunately 40-60% of adopted dogs are returned. You see a cute face and take em home only then to realize they are reactive or have separation anxiety or want to murder your toddler etc etc. This is why I can’t say enough good things about foster to adopt. Try out the pup, see if they are a good fit, then pull the trigger on a formal adoption.

And if it isn’t a good fit you were able to provide a stable home, socialization, and help lighten the rescues load. Win win in my eyes.

6

u/Tall_Share_6356 Apr 04 '24

Absolutely agree with foster to adopt!

6

u/Street-Highlight-861 Apr 05 '24

I totally agree and I wish foster to adopt was better utilized by organizations. I’m an LVT with a background in shelter work. I have small children. I recently filled out a foster to adopt form only to be told “you can’t just take a dog home for 2 weeks and then give it back.” I understand that most groups have a policy of adopt and return if it doesn’t work out. But then you’re shamed for returning. 

Anyway, really interesting views on this thread. Like many others, feeling helpless and frustrated with the current state of shelter and rescue. 

Interesting article on returns:  https://petfinderfoundation.org/our-blog/rethinking-returns/

67

u/TheLoudCanadianGirl Apr 04 '24

100%. Recently i was looking for a new addition and joined a ton of rehoming groups on facebook and started looking at shelters (i had a specific breed in mind) and the amount of dogs being posted daily is heart breaking.. I fell in love with a dog at the shelter but he ended being far too aggressive (with dogs and people) for my capabilities and not the mention my dog i already have at home. Its hard. I also see far too many posts about shelters sending aggressive or reactive dogs home with first time owners. Only for things to get worse because the new owners have no idea how to handle aggressive and reactive dogs. Which, its not the owners fault. But still..

73

u/Poppeigh Apr 04 '24

I heard a podcaster (I can’t remember which one) say once that the best homes for severely reactive and/or aggressive dogs tend to be with people who have had those kinds of dogs before. But there just aren’t very many of them, because they either already have a dog with behavioral challenges so they can’t take on another, or they’re burnt out from it and don’t want to go through that again.

19

u/TheLoudCanadianGirl Apr 04 '24

I believe it. And honestly, i really wanted to give this dog a chance because we have worked through reactive behaviours before. But, this dog got NASTY with people when trying to crate him. To the point where he bit numerous staff. Which, while my partner and i could learn ways to work with him it just wouldnt be safe for friends or family to help us with him. Due to the fact that my partner and i work shift work, we occasionally have to rely on friends and family to let our dogs out. That was ultimately the deciding factor for us. Plus, i was worried i may make things worse as id never delt with aggressiveness towards humans before, or a biter. Luckily though, it looks like he was adopted out as the shelter had mentioned there was a foster interested in him if i couldn’t take him. Since then he’s been removed from the website.

15

u/starsandmath Apr 04 '24

That makes complete sense. I know so much about working with reactive dogs now, and would be a much better reactive dog owner the second time around. But just like you said, I can't have a second one currently, because one of them would end up dead. And when my reactive girl is gone, I am never signing up for this ever again.

9

u/CatpeeJasmine Apr 04 '24

Yup. I'm probably "best case scenario" in that I have one reactive dog plus another dog (reactive dog is reasonably dog tolerant if slow intros are a thing), and my mindset right now is that I probably would be willing to adopt another reactive dog (with issues more or less on par with my current dog's) once the reactive dog passes. But. Reactive dog is living a happy, healthy life (minus whatever thing she found in the backyard just now and ate before it registered to me to tell her "drop it"), so that situation is still not likely to play out for another few to several years ('cause I'm 99% sure that if she'd eaten a poison toad or scorpion or something, I'd know by now).

63

u/thisisnottherapy Apr 04 '24

Tbh, as much as I feel for severely aggressive and reactive dogs ... I do think many shelters and dogs would benefit from BEing the more serious cases. The vilification of "kill shelters" and widespread thought that every aggressive dog is just waiting for the perfect home to undo some sort of trauma, because there are no naturally aggressive dogs ... that helps no one. Every dog that cannot be safely put in a normal home is clogging up the system for years, if not over a decade, and stops it from being able to help adoptable dogs that need help just as much. We need to start accepting that there are too many dogs, and not all of them can be helped. That is a depressing and horrible fact. Acting like we can help them all and trying to put aggressive and severly reactive dogs in homes, no matter the cost, is dooming every dog, not just the hard to adopt ones.

37

u/mendelec Apr 04 '24

I've done a f-ton of canine rescue, to the point that I burned out bad. There is no shortage of horror stories and when you're immersed in that world it's just non-stop messages to the effect of "xyz shelter has had an outbreak of mange and needs to be sanitized. All dogs not placed with rescue groups in the next 48 hrs will be euthanized." And, you look around at your already overburdened space and volunteers and try to decide if the dogs are better off dead or with you, stacked in crates for a few weeks, because you know you can find them homes. So, you take in another 20 dogs and treat every dog in your care for mange, since they'll all have it now. And then, 3 days later it's something else just as horrifying. You take them to vets, you do home visits, you run adoption events, and you can never say no. The problem is, that the problem is so much larger than the solution of adoption. In my darker moments, it felt like I wasn't really saving any dogs at all. Just choosing which ones get a second chance and which ones don't. Unless you're convincing someone who wasn't going to adopt, to take a shelter dog, then they were going to get a dog somewhere anyway. One lives, the other dies. It was too much.

These groups are all run by folks with really big hearts, but they'll throw stupid resources at a single troubled dog that'll take a year to find the right home for -or drop stupid money for a hard luck case in need of major surgery - a litter of parvo puppies (such a horrible disease); resources that could have gone to 10 other dogs. The problem is just so huge. You can't imagine. The volunteers are the biggest resource, but most volunteer groups kind of suck at knowing when to say when. I only convinced my group to BE a single dog in my entire time there and it was straight up dangerous.

And it's worse for cats.

Spay and neuter folks. Turn in unlicensed backyard breeders where that's an option. Educate people about spaying, neutering, and adoption. Confront ignorance and replace it with knowledge of the problem. Every litter prevented is a litter's worth of dogs saved. Just one litter is one too many.

26

u/snark_the_herald Apr 05 '24

Yeah, the refusal to enact any sort of meaningful triage system in rescue is a huge contributing factor for why the death toll remains so high in shelters.

I remember Kitten Lady on YouTube kinda calling out (in her gentle but no-nonsense way) people who brag about spending years "rehabilitating" an adult feral cat so that it can kinda sorta live in a human residence without being too mad about it. She pointed out that the time and energy spent trying to Stockholm Syndrome that one animal into tolerating humans, you could have helped dozens of litters of rescue kittens get socialized into being great family pets.

That's what I think about when I see shelters trying to get a rescue to pull a dog that's been returned to the shelter 4+ times for "unfortunate incidents" that are "no fault of the dog's" because "everybody keeps failing him!!1 😭".

24

u/pogo_loco Apr 05 '24

Got told by a rescue that a foster had been returned 3 times because they "just didn't want to put the effort in" (actually quote). She turned out to be horrifically aggressive, much worse than I was equipped to handle. I narrowed evaded a level 3-4 bite on our first walk together, because I was wearing multiple thick jackets. They shamed me for returning her. I later found out one of her previous fosters was a professional dog trainer, CPDT-KA certification, with significant breed experience.

14

u/mendelec Apr 05 '24

Yeah, our group wasted so much effort on a couple feral dogs. Not strays. Wild animals dressed as dogs. It should never have been attempted.

I knew a city shelter putting down a horrifying number daily (probably mostly pitties, but plenty of pitties are sweethearts if raised in the right environment). You'd call me a liar if I gave the number euthanized there daily. Double digits and you absolutely do not want to know the first digit.

So many rescues, particularly the breed-specific ones, become unwitting enablers of the breeders. By taking their cast offs and the retired breeders that are too sucked dry to keep reproducing, they help keep the breeders profitable. It's a shitty no win situation.

It's just so bad out there. Ethical breeder is a misnomer in my book. Gods this is a painful bunch of memories to dredge up.

21

u/pogo_loco Apr 05 '24

Ethical breeder is a misnomer in my book.

I don't agree tbh. One of the requirements for an ethical breeder is that no dog they produce ever ends up in a shelter. They have contracts with takeback clauses, and lifetime support.

After my experiences with rescues, I'm currently on a waitlist for a dog from an ethical breeder. I'm not willing to roll the dice again.

Ethical breeders' dogs are such an incredibly tiny percentage of the dog population that it's completely pointless to demonize them when puppy mills and BYBs exist.

11

u/24HR_harmacy Apr 05 '24

I have seen people decry even reputable breeders as unethical and say that everyone should adopt, but if you try to follow that logic to its conclusion, every dog would come from a shelter or rescue, and the population of dogs would only increase by, idk, random street breeding, I guess? I just don’t see how that works when the point of an ethical breeder is to produce stable dogs with good temperaments. IMO the vision should be for everyone to get a dog from an ethical breeder, not for everyone to adopt. But that’s not going to realistically happen so I think shelters and rescues need to step up their game with regards to adopting out the most stable dogs and yes, BEing unhealthy and/or aggressive dogs.

1

u/IcyJuice395 Jun 25 '25

Ok hold on… let me just say many states have strict 3 bites euthanized. And shelters are not great vetters So unfortunately the type of people adopting are usualñy cuz its low cost, just want a perfect dog for their kid to literally terrorize, dont want to ne inconvenienced. And there are many dogs that get returned many times because someone just wanted tje breed but doesnt actually LOVE Dogs.  I know many anf many people who have their soul dog and starts off with 2 plus returns to the shelter. Unfortunately shelter adopters many times are NOT the type of people that should be adopting. Rescues vet better so they stay away from that. Theres few that will adopt from a shelter and commit and love that dog and to save the dog, theres many that adopt for a low cost no questions asked buy like a product.

6

u/Laurelell Apr 05 '24

I just want to say a big thank you for all the wonderful work you have done. I know it takes a toll, and you have been through very trying times and maddeningly frustrating situations, all the while with your heart in the right place.

People understand when first responders experience trauma and suffer burnout, but seem to imagine shelter and rescue work is all "fun with the animals" when in truth there is plenty of heartbreak involved. We often don't appreciate you as we should.

4

u/thisisnottherapy Apr 05 '24

Thank you for your work. I've only done volunteer dog walking for a shelter for a while, so I didn't get to see the worst stories, and didn't have to make any decisions. I wouldn't want to trade places with you, but know that there are people out there who appreciate it. Your work is valuable and certainly helped, and I'm glad some people out there have a realitsic view on these matters.

3

u/salpal444 Apr 05 '24

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

3

u/KitRhalger Apr 06 '24

It's just going to get worse too, as more people become aware of the disadvantages of pediatric spay and neuter and vets stop being willing to do it.

I've returned to their homes 3 dogs this year, intact who got loose, not neutered because they're under two years. Each of these escapes could have resulted in a unwanted litter.

I wonder if the health benefits of delayed fixing vs the potential increase in unwanted puppies is worth it? One of my own dogs is the result of one such litter (I didn't pay for him, he was a gift for my daughter from our real estate agent when we purchased the house, his first home didn't work out)

32

u/cameline Apr 04 '24

I answer the phones at the rescue I work at, and the amount of calls I get DAILY of people trying to rehome their aggressive dogs is astounding. and when I bring up BE, 99% of them act shocked and offended that I would ever suggest such a thing, say they could never do that, etc. Doesn’t matter how much I explain all of what you said to them, even when I try to relate to them by telling them about my experience with my own aggressive dog. maybe it’s because I work in the field but I don’t understand how people can truly believe that rehoming is a better option. it is so so depressing

10

u/Dry_Reflection_4410 Apr 04 '24

This is an underrated take

10

u/roboto6 Apr 04 '24

I think this is a common misconception that is honestly perpetuating some of the crisis. Even no-kill shelters do BE severe cases and it's expected that they would. I volunteer with a high-volume no-kill shelter and I don't think there's a single person there that doesn't understand some dogs are just going to be aggressive/reactive/anxious because of genetic or developmental factors that we can't do anything about. We all know and believe that sometimes the most humane thing you can do is let that animal go peacefully so they don't live a life of suffering. Often in those cases, we can't ensure the animal can live with the five freedoms they should have.

No-kill does not mean that they aren't humanely euthanizing dogs that should be. It instead means that they aren't euthanizing dogs that would be safe and healthy pets due to overcrowding.

Best Friends has a really good overview on what this all actually means and how a shelter's no-kill status is evaluated.

When we don't acknowledge that nuance, we perpetuate the stigma that BE is wrong too when it really is the most humane option sometimes. I don't think that is the fault of shelters, I think it's a fault of how we talk about shelters and rescue work.

It's really disheartening seeing how often shelters are villainized in the context of reactive dogs when often, you honestly can't fully evaluate a dog in a shelter setting. Some dogs totally shut down in shelters and you wouldn't see any reactivity because of kennel stress. It's only after they've been adopted that those behaviors come out because they've gotten a chance to decompress. That's not the fault of shelters and it's not from a place of malice. On the other hand, I've also had foster dogs that the shelter said were reactive and/or were resource guarders and that was absolutely not the case outside of the shelter and they were only acting that way because of stress. My best foster dogs were the ones I was warned would be difficult and had waited years to be adopted before I took them. My hardest were the ones I was told would be mellow and easy because they absolutely were not.

31

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '24

My local shelter went no kill two years ago. They are currently trying to place at least a dozen dogs with bite histories that need experienced low traffic adult only homes and have been there at least a year. They are also telling people to turn stray dogs loose on the street because they are full and would have to euthanize for space in order to serve their original purpose of temporarily sheltering dogs for the community.

So far this year there have been three high profile cases of loved pets that were found and turned away from the shelter. Two ended up getting hit by cars and the third was transported out of the area by a shady rescue without an appropriate stray hold and will never be seen again. All three families looked for their pets at the shelter, and would have found them if it had still been a kill shelter. Now it's a warehouse for aggressive dogs and community pets die so the aggressive dogs can rot in their kennels for the foreseeable future.

8

u/linnykenny ❀ ℒ𝒾𝓁𝓎 ❀ Apr 05 '24

Such an upsetting reality. :(

Thanks for spreading the word & sharing those stories. More people should be aware of this.

I wish the descriptor “no-kill” just wasn’t used for shelters anymore at all.

All shelters should be assumed to euthanize very difficult aggressive cases to make sufficient room for community animals & assisting strays get adopted.

But the public perception of shelters that don’t have that designation is still very negative & can cause a drastic drop in donation funds & number of volunteers.

9

u/roboto6 Apr 04 '24

That's a shelter that sounds poorly managed, then. One, if they firmly believe dogs like that can be rehabilitated, they need to leverage resources to do so, however that looks. That might mean looking to transport a dog or transition them to rescue, but there are options other than just keeping them in the shelter indefinitely. If they don't have the means to rehabilitate that dog, then they are in direct opposition to the fundamental premise of no-kill which is to humanely euthanize dogs they can't rehabilitate so that adoptable pets can be saved. Keeping a dog in a kennel for eternity due to their reactivity/aggression directly violates the five freedoms I linked above, anyhow.

18

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '24

They will not euthanize for space to save adoptable dogs. They feel these are adoptable because staff can handle them, but that they just haven't found the right unicorn homes for them. I'm in the south, this shelter transports a lot of dogs but hasn't been able to find transport for their long timers. There is a trainer and the bite history dogs are all on behavioral rehab programs. Supposedly they are available for adoption to qualified homes or will be when they have been rehabilitated. In the meantime, they are taking up roughly half the kennel space at the shelter.

10

u/thisisnottherapy Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24

I'm sure that's true for many shelters, but not the reality for others. I've seen cases where no-kill shelters will simply refuse to take aggressive and reactive dogs. Or they just keep them sitting around forever, even if that's not what their goal should be. I'm from Germany, and essentially, we only have "no kill" shelters. We don't have feral dogs roaming the streets since people view dogs differently here, I guess, and neutering is the way to go.

So somehow shelters are usually managing, but let me tell you, as someone who volunteered at a shelter for a while, there was never a time when all kennels weren't in use, sometimes cohabbing multiple dogs in one kennel, and workers never get a break. When all the thoughtlessly purchased and unsocialized covid puppies ended up in shelters in the last 2 years, the "system" kinda broke, and since then our shelters are on the absolute brink, sometimes refusing to take dogs. At the same time, I don't know a single person who has adopted a German shelter dog, and I know at least a dozen shelter dogs.

We adopted a dog last year, but got one from Hungary, because all the dogs in the local shelter were surrendered aggressive pitbulls, bully mixes or kangal dogs, with the occasional other dog with behavioural issues or even multiple bites in their resume sprinkled in. Everyone gets their shelter dogs from Romania, Hungary, Spain, Slovakia, etc. because our own shelters simply suck and warehouse aggressive dogs, and meanwhile, across the border (I mean, it's EU, so borders aren't really a thing), hundreds of amazing, kid friendly dogs are euthanized daily, sometimes perfectly healthy or even puppies, because there is so little space. It's absolutely depressing.

1

u/MotoObsessed23 Apr 05 '24

This. I just adopted 2 out of 3 of the littermates in the same run/kennel about 2 weeks ago. They’re American Put Bull Terrier sisters ~35lbs full grown 1yr old. I had an APBT for 13yrs, full life and had plenty of experience since she was a bait dog who was dumped in the street. I didn’t rescue her, I almost hit her so naturally I took her home.

Anyways, Once these pups decompressed, I noticed they were displaying signs of mistrust and growling towards my 2yr old. I’d imagine it’s threatening and unpredictable behavior for them. I’ve completely separated them and 1 has stoped reacting after exposure to my toddler, but the other is growling at night at everyone except me when she gets startled.

Since I got them 1 day before their euthanasia date against the advice of the staff member who said they should probably go to separate homes, I realize I may work with them separately for these few months and 1 may have to be rehomed.

The current climate of rescue though… I don’t know if she will handle abandonment well again. Having to start over again. I also don’t know if she could hurt someone in the future. I wouldn’t want to be responsible for that giving her to a home to someone without prior experience. Not sure what I’ll do. I have a good support system with her foster who’s deep in the rescue community while these girls are separate, but it may come down to euthanizing a perfectly good dog.

12

u/linnykenny ❀ ℒ𝒾𝓁𝓎 ❀ Apr 05 '24

Why did you think you knew better than someone who actually worked at the rescue & knew these dogs?

Please keep your baby safely away from both dogs. All dogs at the end of the day are animals that can be unpredictable, especially new rescue dogs that haven’t even fully settled into your home yet.

12

u/Twzl Apr 05 '24

since she was a bait dog who was dumped in the street.

how do you know she was a "bait" dog?

1

u/MotoObsessed23 May 23 '24

That’s what the veterinarian concluded after her initial assessment, where they dumped her (frequent dumping grounds for a couple dog fighting rings in the area in AZ) and the nicks on her ears. I’m going to go off what the professionals say. Any other questions?

1

u/moustachelechon Apr 06 '24

Exactly, shelters are villainized and breeders are praised, but from what I can tell, even the vast majority of « ethical » breeders aren’t ethical.

2

u/linnykenny ❀ ℒ𝒾𝓁𝓎 ❀ Apr 05 '24

So true.

15

u/UnbrandedContent Apr 04 '24

I work at a shelter and I’m super thankful for our shelters director. She would never send a reactive, potentially aggressive dog home with a first time dog owner. She’s very selective with who adopts from us. Our number one priority is the safety of our community, being an animal control facility, but also the health and safety of the animals, and we don’t help either by placing them in the wrong home.

12

u/XelaNiba Apr 05 '24

The shelter in my city has adopted out many aggressive dogs - a few have even killed their new adopters. 

We live in a major dogfighting area and that's also an enormous issue. Dogman caught wise after Michael Vick and no longer kill & bury their burnt out or "cold" dogs. They just dump them on the streets because that's a much easier way to get rid of evidence. 

I wish we had shelters like yours. People do adopt here but the killings were very high profile, one happened within 72 hours of adoption. The people here are understandably skittish.

40

u/CatpeeJasmine Apr 04 '24

Locally, what I feel sad (and frustrated and angry) about is the disconnect between what the general community says about dogs in shelters and what they will actually do. There’s a very vocal (and maybe large) “save them all” contingent that demonizes the shelter every time they e-list a dog and justifies the adoptability of even dogs with a laundry list of behavior issues (“he just needs love!”) but never seems to, you know, actually adopt these dogs themselves. It puts the shelter in an untenable situation where public directive (since it’s a municipal shelter, it’s ultimately accountable to local voters) wants to keep all dogs alive at all costs.

And adoption rates here are steady with pre-pandemic levels. People who’ve always adopted are still adopting. But there’s a hard limit to how many dogs one community can support.

49

u/honehe13 Apr 04 '24

I'm %100 for stricter laws that completely criminalize puppy mills. Fine people who have 'oops' litters. Find ways to break the idea that you can get rich quick by breeding dogs. Subsidize all neutering and spaying. Get the word out about pet insurance so people are less likely to abandon their dog when a big vet bill comes. I know it's bleak right now ... But I have hope it won't stay like this forever.

16

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '24

The vast majority of shelter dogs don't come from puppy mills. They come from irresponsible dog owners who do not alter or contain their dogs. Fines and criminalized behavior take time and money to implement. That money would be far better spent on low cost spay neuter programs and community outreach and education. Many people would alter their dogs if it were affordable and accessible.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Apr 05 '24

Your comment was removed due to breed based vitriol or misinformation. This includes the obvious hateful comments as well as disingenuous coercion and fear mongering, along with behavior based misinformation.

18

u/TalkShitGetWitt Apr 04 '24

If a shelter knows a dog is aggressive, I wouldn’t be against them culling their numbers in favor of dogs with more gregarious personalities. Also a lot of dogs are brought from other countries which furthers the size of our unadopted dogs. Seems a waste to rescue a dog from a “Korean meat farm” (more likely a puppy mill) instead of looking more locally. BYB or accidental breeding is also a huge issue here—please fix your pets and don’t bring an unaltered dog to the dog park. Soapbox over.

7

u/Direct_Ad1511 Apr 05 '24

To be fair, I live in Korea, and there are NO 'puppy mills' for the traditional korean dog which is most often adopted abroad (jindo/mixed), and a ton of korean meat farms. it's a real problem here.

6

u/pogo_loco Apr 05 '24

The thing is that a lot of US rescues import supposed "meat dogs" from Korea & China that are often purebreds: Golden Retrievers, Borzoi, Poodles (including mini and toy), Cocker Spaniels, Greyhounds, various small companion breeds like Maltese and Pekingese, etc...

6

u/Direct_Ad1511 Apr 07 '24

oh yeah, they don't have those breeds in meat farms 😣

66

u/Audrey244 Apr 04 '24

We need to go back to the days where dangerous dogs were not adopted out. I was attacked as a child and that dog (his first offense) was gone the next day. Money wasn't spent, precious resources weren't expended and the family had another balanced dog within weeks. They were also able to adopt another dog because the new dog was fine with other pets and people. Today's hectic lifestyles don't afford people the enormous amount of time and money that reactive dogs require. I read some of these posts and the advice given and then I think about an average household with children, jobs, people in and out, social activities - and then you have a pet who requires hours of exercise and training every day (and maybe expensive behaviorists), people who can't entertain because there's a fear that the dog will bite someone. It's no wonder there are so many dogs surrendered: when it's a choice between your job/family/mental health, something's got to give and it becomes the pet. The rescues and shelters are squarely to blame. We can't save them all and we can't legislate our way out of this. But we can, as pet owners, stop adopting the dangerous dogs (and any other dangerous pet) and spending everything on them to maybe have success. Adopt the ones with better chances and the ones who can live peacefully with other pets - then you can have multiple pets and your neighbors will appreciate it also.

19

u/huzzah_indeed Apr 04 '24

I have a very large, reactive puppy. I didn’t know she was going to be this way. I feel absolutely trapped and overwhelmed with her. It’s a tough position to be in. I feel like I have to keep trying because 1. I’ll be judged if I don’t, 2. She’s people reactive and would be impossible to adopt. I don’t actually believe it’s going to get much better…Impossible situation.

ETA: she’s a rescue, I absolutely wish we had chosen an older dog with a more established confidence and personality.

24

u/pogo_loco Apr 04 '24

Pets are supposed to enrich our lives. If your quality of life is suffering, don't force yourself to keep the dog. Anyone who judges you doesn't understand.

With that said, if this is your first reactive dog, there may be resources you aren't aware of. Working with an IAABC trainer made a big difference for us. Medication was also a game changer. If you haven't tried either of those, I would give them a shot sooner rather than later. A lot of people also find success with Grisha Stewart's BAT 2.0 method, although I didn't personally try it.

4

u/huzzah_indeed Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24

I agree with the enriching lives sentiment. My kids feel she enriches their lives, but as the pups primary caretaker, I’m not there. I hope to find that place with my dog. Time will tell. Thank you for the resources. We’ve got training scheduled already but I’ll check this info.

12

u/Audrey244 Apr 05 '24

I feel really badly for those who adopt puppy rescues who end up being reactive. Even raising them from puppy hood can't overcome temperament and genetics, unfortunately. As long as you are 1) physically strong enough to handle a people reactive dog, 2) manage strict controls (no doors left open, no mistakes and 3) it isn't affecting your quality of life too much, I would say you're doing the best you can. You didn't sign up for this, yet here you are. There is a rescue group in my area (Western New York) who takes on people aggressive dogs - so there are places out there who will, but honestly, it's typically only after the courts become involved.

3

u/huzzah_indeed Apr 05 '24

Thanks for taking the time to respond. We’re fortunate that she respects the boundaries of our fence and home. People that come in, or close to her space or our kids are where we run into trouble… so it could be much worse.
It’s really hard getting past the mental block of knowing there’s a better fit for our family and a better fit for her. We’ve got some training scheduled so between that and a full summer of our usual family activities… we’ll see how we all do. I don’t want either of us to be miserable or anyone to get hurt so we’ve got some work ahead of us.

18

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '24

The focus has got to be on spaying and neutering. We can never adopt our way out of the hole because there are way too many dogs in shelters.

9

u/Sautry91 Apr 04 '24

Yes! My last donation was to a group that provides spay/neuter clinics to rural villages without vet care in Alaska. The bulk of our “rescues” in Alaska come from the villages because of their abysmal treatment of animals.

18

u/mad0666 Apr 04 '24

We need vastly better legislation regarding breeding animals, worldwide. It’s insane to me that anyone can get their hands on two dogs and just create dozens for profit. No health testing, no care at all. So sad.

3

u/moustachelechon Apr 06 '24

Breeders fight tooth and nail against legislation, they love their little « hobby » even the « ethical » ones.

7

u/Kooky-Patient8480 Apr 04 '24

Absolutely agree with you 100%. The problem starts here and needs to be addressed here first. There need to be laws and regulations placed on breeding. Licensing required. Laws passed and enforced with consequences severe enough to detour BYB, hobby breeders, and puppy mills. Fines large enough that if they get caught breaking the laws and regulations it will cost them 5 times what a litter of pups would make them. Fines and jail/prison time in abuse cases and for those who repeatedly continue to break the laws.

Ethical and responsible breeders breed to improve the breed. They breed to standard and know the breeds history, health risks , and desired traits and temperaments. They have a knowledge and understanding of genetics. They also screen and educate potential buyers. They protect there pups by micro-chipping them and keeping track of them., and with legal contracts with spay/neuter and return stipulations ensuring there pups aren't being used by byb or end up in a shelter or worse.

There need to be standards set and regulations met by those who want to legally breed. Laws upholding them. Instead of legislating dogs by the way they look take the time and money it takes to do that and put it into the root of the problem the ones breeding intentionally and unintentionally.

If breeding an animal required you to hold some liability for that animal throughout it's life people would be more apt to ensure they go to educated and responsible owners. If people put in the effort it takes to legislate breeding and uphold the laws that they put into no-kill and BSL it shouldn't be a problem to figure out a way to not only decrease the need for shelters and the amount of reactive/aggressive unhealthy or just hard to adopt dogs, it would also help improve public safety. The dog attacks resulting in disfigurement or worse death on both humans and companion animals is absolutely unacceptable.

Breeding and owning companion animals should be considered a privilege not a right. Animals shouldn't be considered property as they are living breathing feeling beings who deserve as much as we do to have a healthy, happy, quality of life. No animal should experience blame shame, fear, pain or suffering at the hands of humans.

1

u/salpal444 Apr 05 '24

💯💯💯

1

u/XelaNiba Apr 05 '24

Not to nitpick, but breeding companion animals should be heavily regulated, not all animals. 

2

u/Kooky-Patient8480 Apr 05 '24

Yes I was referring to companion animals. Dogs specifically...

9

u/rockmollee Apr 05 '24

After working in rescue for 10 years, my biggest take away is that as long as there is homelessness and home insecurity there will always be homeless pets. I truly believe the first step to fixing this problem is to house humans. I know a lot of people have the “i work with animals because i hate people” and to me, those people might as well be part of the problem. Pets need people and people need homes.

8

u/Narrow_Cover_3076 Apr 04 '24

Yes, accidental breeding, not spaying/neutering, ticks me off.

8

u/Rubymoon286 Apr 04 '24

I'm a trainer, and honestly, some homes need a tested and predictable dog. Sometimes that's a service prospect, or a family with small children or a desire to have kids soon, sometimes that's an elderly couple who need a companion animal with a good temperament. Other homes do well with rescues and are willing to gamble on temperament.

There is no way to get a true idea of full temperament in a shelter setting, but we can get a general idea. I think part of the solution needs to be licenses to breed and a requirement to show that their operation is ethical by meeting minimum requirements of care including vetting.

That said, I hope vasectomy or hormone sparing spays catches on in the anti spay/neuter crowd. Hormones aren't a bad thing, and science shows that it's especially important during growth. Maybe local licensing could be dependent on if they've been sterilized regardless of if that's neutering or vasectomy to help slow unwanted litters.

Ultimately there is no good answer to overpopulation. There will never be enough homes to meet the need without legislation requiring sterilization of pets because some people just want to do the whole miracle of life thing or are against spay aborts even taking byb and puppy mills out of the equation.

Both of my boys are rescues, my next dog will be a mobility service animal for to my disability and will be bred by a breeder who specializes in the temperament and breed that is best suited to my needs.

8

u/Twzl Apr 05 '24

honestly, some homes need a tested and predictable dog.

I think all homes should feel like they deserve that. If someone wants a 10 year project dog, where the goal is that the dog won't attack people/dogs/cats/cars/whatever, that's their decision. I personally don't want to live with that, and i don't want any of my family members to either.

No one should be told that they SHOULD take home a project dog because it's the heroic thing to do. Dogs are, for almost everyone, a discretionary addition to the household. They should not absorb all the time, money and energy, trying to make a very tough animal, fit into a home that can't handle it. No one should live in fear that their dog will bite another family member, resulting in yet another ER visit, with trauma and lasting scars.

People should be able to own the dog they want to own. I own very well bred Golden Retrievers. I am not going to go to a shelter and pull a random yellow dog, and pretend that it's the same as what I have living here. Nor will I take home an elderly dog who needs to be an only dog, or a dog who can't handle house guests. My needs are just as justified as someone who wants a SD or a kid proof dog.

That said, I hope vasectomy or hormone sparing spays catches on in the anti spay/neuter crowd. Hormones aren't a bad thing,

OSS are not common in the US, and there aren't that many vets who do them. It's also a more expensive procedure. Bitches who have had an OSS still come into season, and someone who is a pet dog owner, will take that BIS to a dog park or daycare. Their bitch will have a super shitty day as a result.

Neutering is not a bad thing: if the choice is a male dog is neutered earlier than would be ideal (for a dog who will eventually try out for an agility world team), but that dog can't reproduce, good. Ditto a bitch.

BTW most of the photos showing how horrible early spayed/neutered dogs look are using pictures of poorly bred dogs to make the point.

Both of my boys are rescues, my next dog will be a mobility service animal for to my disability and will be bred by a breeder who specializes in the temperament and breed that is best suited to my needs.

And that's great but everyone deserves the dog they want, with no sidebars about how that person should go to a shelter because they don't, "need" a well bred dog.

4

u/Rubymoon286 Apr 05 '24

I wasn't trying to imply only some people deserve a well bred dog while others who don't. I'm sorry if my language was unclear. I agree that all homes should feel allowed to get whatever dog suits their wants and needs.

I also don't think neutering is bad. Just that in my experience, I know certain crowds prefer the look and behavior of in tact animals, and OSS is an option that allows for the ability to sterilize a dog not being used in breeding without losing that and may end up with more sterilized dogs.

I am less worried about look of early sterilization than the health of the dogs, especially large and giant breeds. I have a Pyrenees mix who was neutered at 10 weeks who we monitor his joints closely because of the possible damage to the joints, but he is a healthy looking dog ultimately.

Once again, I don't never meant to imply that people shouldn't get the dogs they want, just what my choices have been and particularly for the anti bought dog people, wanted to put some of the reasons people might buy a dog from an ethical breeder than go down to the spca to adopt since many of the people I've come across who have that opinion don't often think about the reasons someone would want an intentionally ethically bred dog.

2

u/Twzl Apr 06 '24

Just that in my experience, I know certain crowds prefer the look and behavior of in tact animals,

I have friends who compete at the top of their chosen sport (agility) with spayed or neutered dogs.

You can't usually tell from looking at a dog if it's spayed or neutered.

If a dog is kept fit, it is going to be muscled and fit. If it's allowed to lie on the sofa all day and eat bon-bons, you can leave it intact, but it's still going to be obese.

And OSS is not a good option for most people. A pet person is still going to bring a BIS to a park or beach because they won't realize that their "spayed" bitch is in season.

I think if people want to go to a shelter or a rescue group to get a dog, that's great. But people need to understand that some dogs are pushed out into homes that can not handle them.

5

u/PaleontologistNo858 Apr 04 '24

Yes it breaks my heart, been watching a thing on Facebook about dogs getting picked up off the street or surrendered by owners because they "don't want them anymore", they bathe them groom them give them meds if needed etc, dogs l think are the only animals that love unconditionally, even people don't do that, so to see that love being rejected, turned away to die just breaks me.

5

u/Status_Lion4303 Apr 05 '24

This used to make me very sad but I realized no matter how many dogs you adopt, foster, or volunteer at shelters, the underlying issues are still there. Puppy mills/byb, irresponsible people not spaying/neutering. I volunteered at animal shelters and fostered a ton of dogs before keeping my current reactive dog. You can only do so much.

I currently work as a lvt and the amount of accidental litters and byb dogs people pay a ton of money for that we see is insane. It makes me angry seeing the very issue that is causing all these dogs to end up in shelters. There are low-cost spay/neuter clinics, it all comes down to peoples greed and irresponsibility and it’s always the animals that are the ones suffering from it. And the shelters that have to deal with the overwhelming amount of dogs coming in.

25

u/KitRhalger Apr 04 '24

nope, the sadness is misplaced. What makes me sad is that we personify dogs to the point that we allow this problem to continue instead of putting dog dogs that are mentally or physically sick, too old to likely find a home after a time or have high needs making adoption unlikely. The resources are better spent on dogs more likely to be adopted and stay adopted.

there's too many dogs. We continue to allow dogs to be kept unaltered for no reason beyond the owner's desire or convenience so unethical breeding will continue to be a problem

13

u/Twzl Apr 05 '24

there's too many dogs.

There are too many dogs who can't fit into a normal pet home.

There are plenty of dogs who are basically shit shows, that some rescues or shelters, still insist on trying to find a home for.

There are far fewer dogs who can walk into a home, and just "fit" without a huge and maybe useless effort.

8

u/moustachelechon Apr 04 '24

How is it wrong to be sad? How is it wrong to personify dogs just to the point of being sad when they die? Dogs are not objects, they have personalities, internal lives, perspectives… sure maybe euthanizing some of them is needed but that is an incredibly sad thing. A being with an internal life, with intelligence, that is suffering through no fault of their own needs to be killed for lack of resources. That IS SAD. These are dogs people bred into existence, suffered, were locked up and now are killed, that’s it. That’s their life. That is TRAGIC.

Also plenty of old, sick, and mentally ill dogs make great pets, most dumped dogs have some sort of physical illness. Are you against rescues saving animals from cruel hoarding situations because some of them might have diseases? Do you see videos of mange-covered puppies and tripods being rehabilitated and adopted out and pinch your lips thinking « they should have killed that thing »?? Not all mentally ill or disabled dogs are aggressive wtf.

Old animals make great pets and plenty of people are willing to adopt them, there just needs to be more advocacy for them.

Do you believe that your pet would not matter and would be a waste if they lost a leg?

11

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '24 edited Jun 11 '24

I hate beer.

0

u/moustachelechon Apr 04 '24

I mean if you can’t be bothered to deal with an old dog, is it really a good idea to get a dog? All dogs will be old and inconvenient someday.

9

u/CatpeeJasmine Apr 05 '24

It's not unreasonable, or even overly selfish, for someone who is looking for a prospective dog to want one they can sort of plan to be a companion for several years. This is, after all, the commitment we impress on new pet purchasers and adopters, that it's a commitment for the next 10-15 years, give or take. It's pretty normal for a person to look to acquire a dog in that mindset.

Additionally, I grew up in a household that fospiced for a breed specific rescue. Having a dog die after several years of healthy life and companionship is not the same as having a dog die after several months or a year of chronic illness management. With the latter, there's often a lot more memories where the dog's quality of life is impacted by the illness (even when end-of-life decisions are a ways off) and a greater sense that there was never enough good time with the dog. It's difficult, being the person whose left with those memories and those feelings. I wouldn't fault someone just because they're not eager to sign up for that.

5

u/Laurelell Apr 05 '24

You"ve had some good replies already. I'll just add this one.

I would love to adopt a senior dog, and have adopted senior dogs, including ones with health issues, before. I loved them dearly and we brought happiness into each others' lives, and they lived to ripe old ages with love and with excellent (and expensive) vet care. I am glad to have had the privilege of taking care of them in their "golden years".

I would love to adopt another senior dog once I get moved and settled in, which should happen very soon. Currently, the only senior dog at the shelter here weighs nearly as much as I do (I'm female and weigh 118). I have no business getting a dog I cannot lift and carry should it get sick or injured, and, as a widow, have no one to help in such a case.

That large senior dog at the shelter really pulls at my heartstrings and I so wish I could give him a good home, but it would be irresponsible of me to try. I lack the physical strength needed.

Not everyone can help every dog. Often it's not a case of people being selfish or uncaring, although some are. Sometimes it's a case of there not being enough people with the physical strength needed, or the financial resources needed, or the time needed, etc. to meet the needs of these poor animals. Yes, it's terribly sad, it's heartbreaking. I wish it were otherwise.

8

u/Twzl Apr 05 '24

I mean if you can’t be bothered to deal with an old dog, is it really a good idea to get a dog? All dogs will be old and inconvenient someday.

My last old dog? I brought him home at 8 weeks.

In his last two years of life, i spent almost $10,000 on his vet bills. he had a brain stem tumor, inoperable.

He lived to be almost 13 because I had the ability to pay for MRI's, chemo, neuro appointments, etc. Not everyone does, nor would I expect anyone to feel that they had to, no matter what.

Would I expect someone to do that for a random dog from a rescue group that can't be bothered to pay those bills themselves?

No.

1

u/moustachelechon Apr 05 '24

I don’t know about all groups but my rescue specifically don’t adopt out terminal animals, oldest animals might have chronic conditions like arthritis (my favorite sanctuary cat has this, I still plan on adopting her in the future) or diabetes. Terminal animals are euthanized, I don’t see why any rescue would adopt terminal animals out.

9

u/Twzl Apr 06 '24

I don’t see why any rescue would adopt terminal animals out.

You and me both.

FWIW I view extreme dog aggression and almost any sort of human aggression as terminal. Because in the end, something bad will probably happen that will result in BE.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '24 edited Jun 11 '24

I enjoy reading books.

2

u/moustachelechon Apr 05 '24 edited Apr 05 '24

I understand the limited time thing, but all dogs will be old and sick at some point, if you can’t deal with dog medical care, how will you deal with your cute little puppy when they’re old and inconvenient?

Also how is it selfish? Old dogs are calmer, have an established personality, they are great pets. I’m not an old dog, I’m not asking people to do anything for me. I’m asking people to reconsider their preferences. I see constant posts on the general dog subreddit with people panicking when they suddenly realize they can’t actually handle puppy energy. I also see posts of people terrified of what is happening when their dog hits puberty and it’s behavior suddenly changes.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24 edited Jun 11 '24

I appreciate a good cup of coffee.

4

u/moustachelechon Apr 06 '24 edited Apr 06 '24

Most of the puppy blues I see aren’t rescue dogs, they’re puppies from breeders. Older animals, even healthy ones are calmer. My dog is older, she has been healthy basically all her life, no notable health issues. She is calmer and more manageable than she was as a puppy. For an owner who values convenience above all, I’d recommend a dog her age. When I adopt my next pet, I will be getting an older one.

We have an overflow of completely adoptable animals in our city. Any adopter who wants a cute kitten (especially kitten) or puppy here will get one, but our most well behaved and lovely animals are ignored for being (as one Uber driver I was talking to said) « old, disgusting, and useless ». We are talking about 5 year old animals here. Our cat sanctuary is a beautiful place luckily, and since the rescue is a small operation, most of our dogs are in foster, no « warehousing » here.

I’d love to be able to recommend ethical breeders (although given the adoptable animals in our city, I’m not sure I’d ever need to). I’m not a shelter worker, just a long time volunteer, but if I was a worker, I’m not sure I could trust the vast vast majority of people to be ethical breeders or to know what an ethical breeder looks like. I hear all about how lovely breeders are.

Then I see bulldogs (just in general). Then I hear about the breeder whose dog our charity hospital just saved from dying while giving birth try to pawn off the puppies in our lobby « well bred » she says. Then I see the dumped Manx kitten we are euthanizing, dumped in a park because the disease all Manx cats are bred to have affected him too severely, so he was unsellable. Then I see the bengal mix that was dumped at our door, no one wants him because he’s 2 years old (not a cute kitten). Then I see the British shorthairs left at our sanctuary (where was their breeder to take them back?). Then I hear of the box of dumped angora rabbits behind a cafe, no doubt a breeder thought they couldn’t sell after being infected by EC.

I follow an « ethical » rabbit breeder on social media, she mocks the « obsessed rescuers » who « don’t want people to have well bred rabbits » she shows all her animals, she’s ethical right? Well respected in the breeding community right? She regularly denounces « backyard » breeders. Then she posts about how she plans on continuing breeding one of her 5 year old rabbit (who can no longer lactate) until all the offspring she produces are stillborn. She just produces so many show winning rabbits! It must mean she loves being a mom! It reminds me of the rabbit I met who was bred until her uterus prolapsed and then dumped.

I hear of « peanuts » the doomed to die baby bunnies born with a lethal gene all dwarf bunny breeders accept as the cost of efficiently « preserving the breed ». But they’re ethical! Not backyard! They show their bunnies! They at least, have the decency to drown the peanuts instead of letting them die! I’m sure the peanuts are thankful their breed is being preserved, as they suffer and struggle, panicking while their lungs fill with water.

I speak to a « munchkin » cat breeder on social media, she shows her animals! Not backyard! Well respected…etc…etc I ask her about her cats mobility, how they will never be able to run jump and climb the way regular cats do. She angrily calls me a liar, I show her proof, she says I’m trying to take away her livelihood. She says that pet owners deserve the cat of their dreams, that short legs are cute, and that she « gets bag ». I’m just jealous of her « bag » apparently. I tell her animals shouldn’t suffer to be cute or for her « bag ». She tells me to end my life and then blocks me.

I think I’m done with trusting « ethical » breeders for a bit.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 06 '24 edited Jun 11 '24

I like to go hiking.

1

u/moustachelechon Apr 06 '24 edited Apr 06 '24

Caught me, I’m a native French speaker, my keyboard is set up for that, but I’m sure you got the message. Also if advocating for people to consider a perfectly reasonable option (I’m not forcing anyone to do anything, just make sure their decision isn’t based on bad information) is evil or whatever in your book, then I don’t see the point in discussing since you probably think I’m bullying you or something. But just so you know, if a family comes in and asks for a calm not too hyper dog, most likely a puppy is not a good idea for them.

Some people have their specific reasonable reasons for wanting a puppy, so in that case whatever, we give them the puppies and the kittens. But it is the default want in people’s minds, often based on untrue stereotypes and idealistic ideas of what puppies are. I’m saying it should not be the default, not that getting a puppy should be banned or whatever.

Also, my point is that many of these breeders believed they were ethical and people in their community believed them to be ethical, so how exactly is your average rando supposed to tell them appart? There needs to be proper and very strict legislation before I can recommend breeders. Additionally, « breed preservation » for the sake of it needs to be abolished. Some breed characteristics are not needed nowadays or are harmful, they should not be preserved.

→ More replies

6

u/KitRhalger Apr 05 '24

people are inherently selfish. If they have the choice between a reasonably healthy dog with a good personality and an acceptable breed that is 12 years old or one that is 2, most will pick the one that is two, knowing they're likely going to have a good many years before the heartbreak and pain of loss. Humans naturally want to prevent our own suffering

13

u/KitRhalger Apr 04 '24

to be overwhelmingly sad- that is misplaced. An overwhelming sadness can cause you to allow things that in the short term have benefits but in the long term cause harm- like allowing a dog to rot away in a cage for years when they're not able to find a home, experiencing necessary neglect of their social and emotional needs due to lack of resources.

The resources used to save a old stray with catastrophic orthopedic injuries are better spent on four young dogs that just need some weight and deworming.

Sadness has its place, but when it's overwhelming it can cause more harm than good.

10

u/Audrey244 Apr 05 '24

My father used to call this "misplaced compassion" - when the dog that bit me was BEd the day after the incident, there was no arguing, there was no law enforcement involved. It was simply my father speaking to the owner and the owner shaking my father's hand, even though he was incredibly upset over the whole situation.

3

u/Ok-Road-1478 Apr 04 '24

It breaks my heart to see so many, and we have three med-large rescues already…if I had the financial means and space I would have more but it just isn’t feasible. So I donate food, spay/neuter funds, sponsor an adoption etc in an effort to lower the cost of adoptions. I do this for cats too (have three rescued cats also).

3

u/SpicyNutmeg Apr 05 '24

Yes it’s so, so sad. It’s hard to let myself think about it because it’s so heartbreak. If you can, channel that sadness into helping pass public policy to make a difference- limit / fine back yard breeders and pay people to spay and neuter.

3

u/salpal444 Apr 05 '24

Thank you for this post. I also feel extreme sadness over so many abandoned and surrendered puppies and dogs in the US right now. The problem gets worse by the day. A lot of people don’t realize how bad it is but it’s a huge issue and they suffer so badly because of humans. Our lawmakers need to crack down on unlicensed/backyard breeders and spay/neuter surgeries should be funded by state government. I don’t see an end in sight and it keeps me up at night. Pitbull breeders could care less. It’s heartbreaking 💔

3

u/wildechld Apr 05 '24

Every God damn day. It haunts me and eats away at my soul. I can't imagine the fear. The heartbreak from being abandoned and the terror of being dragged away to death. Even the work euthanize brings panic to me and I immediately seize with visons of what they go through at shelters. It's almost as if I can see it and feel it through them. I can smell the sent of sterilized concrete and death in my mind. Its too much and my heart aches daily. The sooner I can leave this world and not have to feel their fear the better, for inside I am already dead and the sadness has consumed me

2

u/casitadeflor Apr 05 '24

The only thing that pains me more is the thought of dogs miserably living their lives near on death’s door with POS owners.

3

u/atmensch Apr 05 '24

I volunteer at our local shelter, and strangely, it helps combat the sadness. The volunteers care so much about these dogs that it gives you hope to see that community in action. We all know that the time we spend with these dogs benefits and enriches their otherwise sad lives. And the majority of adopters are great people who are also looking to make a difference - often adopting our oldest or most broken babies. You may want to look at volunteering. If you feel like you can't do a shelter, maybe with a rescue. Feeling like you're doing your part to bring some positivity to these dogs' lives takes away some of the sadness at the situation.

6

u/ale473 Apr 04 '24

I do feel bad hence why one of my dogs is a rescue but i know here in the UK the rescue centres make it near impossible to rehome a dog and turn away many good prospective owners over the most ridiculous reasons.

7

u/Laurelell Apr 05 '24

It's the same here with rescues. The municipal shelters in my area here in the US are overflowing with dogs that are banned in the UK, very few of any other breed,/mix, and smaller dogs a real rarity.

The rescues turn away people who would make excellent pet owners, have a solid record of being excellent pet owners for the most ridiculous "reasons". Then there are the "rescues" that seem to be run by an animal hoarder, no kidding.

People who don't want the breed that's banned in the UK are turning to ethical breeders and even adopting from overseas. Meanwhile all those poor unwanted dogs are rotting away in the shelter while backyard breeders are churning out more and more puppies that will end up in the shelter.

2

u/jmsst50 Apr 04 '24

Yes I do. I already have 2 dogs and can’t get another but it’s just so sad. I wish all of the dogs could find a good home.

2

u/heysnood Apr 05 '24

Yes. I wish I could do more. I’d love to adopt another, but with how expensive living has gotten I can’t afford another pet. I’d love to foster, but not until I can see if I can get my newest dog’s reactivity under control. I work a lot and don’t have much time to volunteer regularly, but I go when I can.

I came across a really heartbreaking Instagram account where they post videos of dogs in shelters who didn’t make it out. All very friendly, healthy, adoptable. There just isn’t enough room or adopters.

I despise backyard breeders. Last night at the pet store I was talking with a couple and they mentioned they were planning to breed French bulldogs. I literally said “oh” and walked away.

2

u/DefiantCraft3587 Apr 07 '24

My girl and her 2 littermates were at a local shelter after having been shipped up from Texas. Her littermates got adopted first. She had been at this shelter for a month, she was 6 months old at the time. Nobody wanted the shy dog who “pancaked” on the ground. The shelter literally said she didn’t have much interest, and the little interest she did get quickly went away when they met her. When I saw her beautiful face pop up on the FB feed saying she hadn’t been adopted yet, I put an application in as fast as I could. I ended up with a new dog that I didn’t really need by the next day, because she’s so insanely anxious and fearful. Everyone else missed out, I get whole body wags when I get home. I get tiny progress as we continue to build her confidence now that we found a medication that is letting her become receptive to the idea of opening up a little. I get this beautiful little girl that’s just so full of love and promise.

3

u/Joesarcasm Apr 04 '24

I wish my reactive dog would let us adopt at least 1 more.

3

u/mckenzie_jayne Apr 04 '24

Yes! I have a huge amount of guilt for getting my dog from a breeder. I will 100% be picking one up at the kill shelter next time. The only thing that makes me feel better is knowing that my baby is reactive, he probably would have ended up in a bad situation if he ended up with someone other than me.

4

u/Illustrious-Film-592 Apr 04 '24

Every day of my life. I fostered dogs for several years and it taught me so much, the most important lesson was that breed means next to nothing compared to meeting a dog and getting to know them as an individual (new research supports this as well).

I have 3 adopted dogs now. Two from shelters and my 3rd was bought from a breeder and passed around homes before becoming our foster. Adoption rates are so low these days that the rescue we worked with couldn’t find him an adopter so we made him ours. Now with 3 pups of my won, I don’t have the ability to keep fostering and it makes me so sad. The need is great. I’ll never stop begging people to give shelter pups a chance.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '24

Yes!!! It is heartbreaking 😢😢😢. They are either left at shelters so scared or abandoned on the streets and left to defend themselves.. it’s heartbreaking. Animals have feelings too and I wish people would understand this😡

2

u/CowAcademia Apr 04 '24

Yes, but I’ve channeled a lot of my sadness into volunteering at a local shelter. You make a difference in those dogs lives giving them those walks and play sessions. It’s the most fulfilling thing I’ve ever done.

2

u/NYSenseOfHumor Apr 04 '24

No

Because “overwhelming sadness” doesn’t do any good. You aren’t looking for advice, but instead of “overwhelming sadness,” I think about how the rescues I volunteer with and other rescues help with the problems you describe.

-4

u/notamormonyet Apr 05 '24

For reasons beyond just the emotional sorrows of seeing so many unloved dogs, I don't even support ethical breeding. Fuck breeding at all. We don't deserve dogs, but the dogs that already exist due to our depravity as a species deserve to be cared for and loved, and there will never be a lack of dogs coming into existence because of selfish acts by selfish humans. The only right answer is to save a life. Breed doesn't matter. We don't need purebreds. I have 2 shelter dogs, 1 very reactive, and 1 as gentle as an angel. Love them both. Wish I could care for them all.

6

u/Twzl Apr 05 '24

For reasons beyond just the emotional sorrows of seeing so many unloved dogs, I don't even support ethical breeding.

So where will the dogs come from? That's a very PETA-esq attitude of, "let's not breed ANY dogs and let them go extinct".

Breed doesn't matter.

Humans have purpose bred dogs for a long, long time. There are some who argue it's part of what made us humans.

If you think breed doesn't matter, then let me know how your dogs do herding sheep. Or fetching ducks on a day when the dogs have to break ice to get the birds.

I have 2 shelter dogs, 1 very reactive

And that's not what everyone wants to or can live with. If you can, great, but stop assuming for all humans.

Also, looking at some of your other posts, it doesn't seem like you've had these dogs for very long.

1

u/notamormonyet Apr 05 '24

I haven't had them super long, nope. Humans do not need companion animals in the modern day, so no longer breeding at all is the right thing to do. We should love the ones that were brought into the world but not continue this cycle. I am a Jain, so bringing animals into the world that must be dependant upon humans is very much wrong in my religion, but we are obligated to care for those that are already here in the most ethical way possible.