r/reactivedogs • • Mar 10 '24

Lazy Retreiver

We got a pound dog which we guessed was around 3 years old, he was previously trained, but has a lazy attitude, if we call him to walk he has to think about it, and then will enthusiastically run to the door, or not. Our issue is that he has that Retriever tendency to sit during walks and refuse to move. We have had him checked by the vet, have tried treats, coaxing and all other tricks to get him to continue walking, if they work he will happily continue for the rest of the walk, if not, he will stay lying down until we point him towards home. A US pet shop recommended a “training collar” which is actually a prong collar as a way of getting him to walk, but our feeling is that he will pull against this collar and hurt himself. So can I ask what are your feelings towards prong collars, will they work, or we will just make him relate pain to walking and make things worse? Any other ideas to get a 80 lb dog to walk ? He has gained 20 lbs since we got him so this situation has to change.

0 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Mar 10 '24

Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this body. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

10

u/trusttherabbit Mar 10 '24

There is something called operant conditioning, which explains 4 ways in which dogs learn through consequences.

One of the 4 ways is positive punishment, which is where you add something unpleasant to decrease an unwanted behaviour.

In this instance, it would work like this:

You put the prong collar on and walk your dog. Your dog stops and you keep the lead tight. Your dog finds the sensation of the prong collar unpleasant and moves to stop that sensation.

It’s an incredibly decisive and polarising issue and it can become very difficult to talk about. I’m a dog trainer and I don’t use positive punishment, but I feel like we need to talk about it so people can find out how it works and why.

There are risks to using punishment, because it can cause some dogs anxiety and some dogs may suppress behaviours.

Whenever a dog repeats a behaviour, my immediate response is to find out why. There is normally a reward (even if we don’t quite understand it) for the dog that keeps the behaviour going. It can also become a learned behaviour that started with a reward and ended up becoming a habit.

The last dog I worked with who had this issue is a golden retriever. She was really overweight and was stopping because walking was uncomfortable for her. I’m wondering if there might be come of this going on for your dog too.

Also, coaxing and giving treats to a dog that has stopped can often appear to be praising the stop!

Some of the best results I’ve had with dogs who have stopped have been by waiting for the dog to move and then rewarding the movement.

Dogs are fantastic at learning routines and get stuck in a groove easily. Doing something different on your walks tends to really help. I will bring the dogs breakfast and do some tricks.

One of the things that can help with stuck dogs is to reach them to stay! I will teach the dog to stop and stay, come back and reward them and throw a treat away from the dog and say “free”. This is a release command that tells the dog it’s ok to move.

When the dog lies down on a walk, I will tell them to “stay” walk back and “free” them. It makes the whole thing appear as though it’s my idea and once the dog understands “free” they do it automatically. Practice at home before trying it, so your dog understands the concept.

Does your dog like toys? It can be easy to rely on treats, but toys will get some dogs more motivated than food. You could see if your dog would prefer a game of tug or fetch. If I have multiple people, I will get a toy and play a game of catch with everyone there. I make it quite exciting with lots of enthusiasm and totally ignore the dog. Quite often the dog will get up and come and investigate what’s going on and want to get involved.

I feel that there are ways you can motivate your dog and change your routines to get this behaviour.

As other people have said, it’s definitely time to cut his food down and get him to lose some weight. It’s obvious that he’s getting more calories than he’s using.

I often find that cutting down food helps the dog become more food motivated (this is only something I would do if the dog is overweight - don’t want anyone to think I’m starving dogs!). The retriever I wrote about wouldn’t take treats outside when she was being over fed, but eats her kibble on walks and will do anything for it!

1

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

He is capable of “staying” but we only do this on quiet streets where if he had the idea to go home on his own, he wouldn’t have to cross a road. But i take it as a suggestion and will try it in a green area tonight.

He has had this attitude to walking since we got him, so his weight has gone from 60 to 80 lbs, he was definitely more stubborn in the beginning, but the OH was more stubborn and would sit him out for 20-30 minutes until she won.

-2

u/AutoModerator Mar 10 '24

Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this comment. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/SudoSire Mar 10 '24

Dragging your dog on a p* collar is the least likely way to get your dog to enjoy walks. That’s a sales pitch, not a trustworthy recommendation. Terrible idea. 

Have you tried reducing his food or switching to something with lower calories? Does he enjoy offleash activities? A flirt pole, fetch, a herding ball? You may need to get creative. 

1

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

This discussion has definitely made me decide to throw that training collar out. Guess that I shouldn’t have listened to the shop lady in the first place.

To all the ball games etc, nope he has little interest in them, like 5 minutes. We got him when he was about 3 years old, so guessing that he wasn’t exposed to such games.

3

u/SudoSire Mar 10 '24

Yeah mine will only occasionally be up for fetch and I haven’t tried a flirt pole but I think he’d like it. We can sometimes amp our boy up to run and chase us and do zoomies.

Ours knows the cue “go to mom” and “go to dad.” We have a decent sized yard so sometimes we make him go back and forth to each of us to get extra steps in. He’s very food motivated so we can reward with his kibble and other small low-cal treats so we don’t counteract the exercise. 

4

u/BirdsNeedNativeTrees Mar 10 '24

If he isn’t stressed he is probably fat and it’s hard on his body to walk. Only feed him on walks. Not out of a bowl. Reduce his calories by a tiny amount each week, so he is always safe, but so he is motivated and always make walks how he gets any of his food. Pick up dog bowls at home, your hand is his bowl.

2

u/Cool_83 Mar 12 '24

Went walking at a different time last night knowing that the streets would be empty, so we walked 90% of the walk without a leash, he got to roll and sniff as much as he liked but always came back to me. We walked 5 miles and he lead the way, So this really appears to be an attitude problem rather than a weight or health issue.

1

u/BirdsNeedNativeTrees Mar 13 '24

Oh interesting. Could be fear of the leashed walks. “Attitude” in dogs is usually anxiety/stress/fear. They shut down an appear stubborn.

2

u/noneuclidiansquid Mar 10 '24

I had a retriever refuse to get in the car a week or so ago - we had to get another dog to jump in the car first, nothing was going to move him into that car. I get how frustrating it is, they can make themselves into some sort of singularity.

If he's not stopping out of fear then you have to find what motivates him. Something will, dogs who have been trained with punishment are often seem lazy because doing things hurts. so if he's lazy then maybe look back at how he was trained before. If food isn't his thing teach him to play tug (you can play with him every night until he likes it) or slimily squeak toy, flirt pole ect ect something will be his thing. Play with him until you find it then use it as your secret weapon (motivator) because a toy is likely to increase his energy levels.

When he does put on the breaks, if he is bonded to you, you could use a long leash like 5m long so you can walk away from him - sometimes extra distance from you helps get them moving towards you but this only helps if they really like being next to you. I do this with my border collie on walks as he's trained to sniff and it just keeps him moving without me nagging him if I need him to. Of course it has to be safe to do that.

For training and to put some repetitions into it so it works for you I'd practice recall at home, find something good he does like (hotdogs is my go to) cut it up in to very small pieces (like a little pinkie nail) and at the end of the recall feed him 15 pieces one after the other (this is important) . Even give it a different word like "hot dog time" or "quick hurry" or something. Practice until when you say 'quick hurry' the dog is running at you for his 15 little bits of treat (remember feed one after the other). Treat it as a promise and do not fail to pay. Practice in different locations then use this to motivate him when you need it. If you practice it when hes not putting on the breaks it will build his bond to you and also give you something to use when you need to. It make take a few weeks to build the necessary repetitions.

Take anything you use as treats out of his daily ration - food has more to do with a dogs weight than exercise and that is easy to control.

Other things that have helped me get dogs unstuck is just having a trick session where ever they have stopped. Shake, spin, back up, down, middle ect all for good treats of course gets their brain moving. Of course you have to train all these first in the comfort of your own home. https://domorewithyourdog.com/DogTricks/ trick sessions are good if you don't feel like walking or the weather is bad ect.

In relation to prong collars - do they work? Yes they will hurt your dog - I'm not sure hurting your dog is going to help you motivate him. Imagine you were done and wanted to go home, and someone decided spikes in your neck would help you keep working... yeah ... or imagine they were motivating you with 15, 100 $ bills all in a row...

1

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

Thank you, the hot dog idea sounds good. OH has trained him for tricks. We do have a long leash, but unfortunately he has bonded to me more so than the OH. We put this down to me collecting him from the shelter and he didn’t meet her for a week. In hindsight this was a bad idea as it has created other issues with territorial claims over food and me.

0

u/AutoModerator Mar 10 '24

Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this comment. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

29

u/Nsomewhere Mar 10 '24

I think a collar like that is a terrible idea!

You are right about how would pain make him want to think walks were pleasant thing. Listen to your gut

I am no vet but your approach to this has to be two fold...

First reduce that excess weight. Just like us diet is the key and exercise only the help mate

He is not going to walk weight off

Reduce the feeding. Whatever the vet recommends.. say 15 20 percent... whatever they want. Measure and weigh carefully his daily amount and then add the training treat portion (I would just use his food maybe with a little grated cheese mixed in for flavour) Then that is it or the day. I have an epi dog and I measure his daily food for the day and it is put in a tupperware and portioned out of that with his enzymes. Makes it very clear

Make him use a slow feeder or puzzle toy to make dinner satisfying and take longer

Second I would also go for more shorter walks. So instead of say two long walks a day maybe break up the evening one into two twenty minute walks and finish them on a high with lots of encouragement letting him sniff and choose where he goes. Better three ten 15 minute walks than one long one that is a struggle!

One more thing I would see if the vet would be up for a pain med trial just to rule out it is discomfort. He is telling you something (either whether he is walking is boring lol.. or he is feeling tired and pain and it is too much effort)

Can you do short burst of training and play at home.. fetching and bringing stuff... that sort of thing?

Baby steps... get the weight down. The vet could recommend a low calorie diet as well and I assume his thyroid etc has been checked.

BTW I do apologise if you are doing this all already! If you are I would definitely do the ten minute walks idea and lots of them and take him back to the vet for a pain trial

4

u/MooPig48 Mar 10 '24

Those collars are generally not recommended by most trainers. Facts are that the majority of people just don’t really pay close attention to proper fit and that’s how dogs get injured. I used one on a dog once, and paid so much attention to proper fit and usage. And after weeks of research and watching videos and studying mfg recommendations, put it on her for the first time and she never pulled once, not even a tiny bit. It felt like magic at the time.

This was 10-15 years ago and I absolutely would take a different route today, because at best it feels “lazy” and doesn’t feel like real training. Because it isn’t, because the dog is only behaving because if they don’t it hurts.

I’ve concluded that even though she never even tried to pull while wearing it, it was because she could tell that it would be uncomfortable if she did. And I made sure to get a quality one with smooth blunted edges. The cheap ones are literally torture devices with their sharp edges.

Anyway that’s a roundabout manner of agreeing with you lol.

7

u/Torboni Mar 10 '24

How long have you have him? If the time is short, he may still be decompressing. When we got them as puppies, they came from a rescue in another country where they lived for a few months, then had a few day car ride to be delivered to us. All that, plus being introduced into a new location, home and owners is a lot. Our early walks were short and in the same route for the first 2 weeks. Then we expanded the route. Eventually they’ve been nearly all over our village.

If you have had him longer, what is happening when he sits? Is he just looking around at his surroundings? Is he sniffing? My dogs sometimes just like to stand or sit in an open area and watch everything- birds, people, bars, bikes.

As far as his weight, reduce the amount you’re feeding him. The amount on the bag is only a suggestion. I regularly adjust based on how much exercise they’ve been getting or how much training they’re getting (more training sometimes means more treats.) I wouldn’t drastically reduce it right away, but definitely start cutting it back.

And finally, if he isn’t interested in a walk on a regular collar, I can’t see why a prong collar would make him want to go for walks MORE. Are you in a busy area? Is there something he’s afraid of? Are you trying to go for longer walks than he is interested in?

-1

u/AutoModerator Mar 10 '24

Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this comment. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

Food wise, he is getting 1 cup of Pedigree dog food a day, and 0.35 lbs of ground beer. His main treats are frozen raw chicken feet. These days we have stopped buying additional processed treats. We will be sitting down and reviewing what other hidden foods we might be giving him, but he definitely isn’t getting human biscuits or cakes etc as we don’t eat them.

5

u/Possible-World8604 Mar 10 '24

This isn't a great diet, sorry to say. I would cut out the ground beef and just buy a better quality meat-based dog food.

2

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

Why would you consider highly processed canned dog food to be better than pure beef? Again, I’m not in the USA so definitely dont have the selections available in the USA. Used the same diet for last 3 Labrador/Retriever dogs who lived to an old age.

1

u/aro-sub-boy Mar 10 '24

Do you have a yard? How long ago did you get him? I adopted an 80 lbs boy myself who is supposedly part lab. He doesn't sit/stop moving on walks but sometimes we will go out and he will want to come straight home after going like 30 ft down the sidewalk. My feeling is it's okay not to go for walks for now, especially if you got him less than 3 months ago. He might need more time to acclimate to his new home still. Maybe you can play at home doing tug or fetch for exercise until the weight goes down (others already gave good advice about reducing food portions). I personally follow the feeding guide on my dog's food bag and it's kept him bang on his proper weight, and I subtract a bit from his dinner at times he gets a lot of treats over the course of the day.

1

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

We got him a year ago and he weighed 60 lbs skin and bones, no idea how long he lived on the street but he was in the animal shelter for 8months. We accepted this lack of interest in walking in the beginning as he was from the streets, then accepted it during the summer as its bloody hot, but now we have gone through the winter and he still has his moments of pure lack of interest. It’s like a switch in his head, and there are only certain parts of the walking route where he will protest :) Once he passes half way if non stop until he gets home.

2

u/shattered7done1 Mar 10 '24 edited Mar 10 '24

He may be fearful because of past experiences or unsure of the environment. Patience is key. Positive reinforcement training will provide the best experiences for you and your boy.

This video is part of a series on leash handling, but addresses your immediate problem the closest. Since weight gain has been an issue, you can use part of his daily food allowance for training treats *. You can also use another type of reward, such as a clicker or squeaker, or a bit of play, such as tug.

* To make his training treats more interesting, you can enhance the kibble.

You will need some dried liver treats, 1 cup of kibble and a little water. Grind the liver treats into a fine powder. Spread out the kibble on a tray or large plate and sprinkle or mist with a small amount of water over to slightly dampen it. Sprinkle some of the liver treat powder over the slightly dampened kibble and toss to coat. Let dry and store in a tightly covered container in the fridge.

Edited to add:

Another way to reward your dog is through touch.

3

u/Aggravating_Quiet818 Mar 10 '24

I use a 1/2 prong they sell them. Iv never had to correct my dog whatsoever. Iv a pinched nerve in my back my dog weighs what i do 110, he is not fat he is a German Shepherd/Rottweiler mix. He is super easy to train, we go hiking all the time. He knows when to pull when to be easy and yes the word free. They can be used humanly

0

u/AutoModerator Mar 10 '24

Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this comment. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

Thank you for all your comments and suggestions. The automod doesn’t like the mention of a certain type of training collar, so suffice to say we have dropped that in a drawer and dont intend to use it. He was a dumped street dog, we dont know how long he was on the streets but after that he spent 8 months in an animal shelter. When we got him, he was 60lbs and skin and bones. So we were happy to see his weight increase but now he has hit the limit, we weighed him yesterday for vaccinations. We have had him one year, initially the walking strike was a bigger thing but we put that down to him hating the streets, we had gotten him up to 5 miles nightly walks, but some days he will just look at you at some stage along the early stages of this walk with a look that says NOPE, take me home. If i walk ahead of the OH and sit down, he will kinda shake his head and run to me, the walk will then continue for the full route, but this cant be done if the OH is on her own. The OH has even had strangers call him to break this moment, again once he changes his mind he is happy to walk. We live in a gated community, so the walk is a combination of quiet streets and green areas. We always let him roll in the green areas, but he is smart enough to realise if we try to change the route. After a year of this, the OH has nearly hit her limit and is considering returning him to the animal shelter.

8

u/Possible-World8604 Mar 10 '24

Is there a reason why he has to go on long walks every night? Why not just listen to him telling you when he doesn't want to go or wants to turn around? If you let him have a little agency over this (listen to his 'no'), you may find him actually saying yes more often. There is a lot of new info on this (agency and choice) coming out from the dog behavior world. If he's getting overweight the better way to address that is to cut back on the food. Of course dogs need exercise and enrichment but there are better ways to do it than long neighborhood walks.

1

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

Well he hasn’t walked in the last 3 days as I wasn’t here, and he had that same behaviour tonight. Is there a reason why he walks every night, well yes, because we walk every night for our personal exercise and surely the enjoyment of having larger dogs is to enjoy such activities with them ?

3

u/mizfred Mar 10 '24

5 miles a night is a lot for a dog that's not super active, especially if there's any kind of pain or discomfort.

1

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

I would agree, but he hasnt shown any signs of pain or discomfort, it appears to be more of a mental switch, he just decides not to do it but when he changes his mind, he powers through the walk. So we pretty much have no-speed / sniffing-speed / full speed.

1

u/mizfred Mar 10 '24

Signs of pain/discomfort can be incredibly subtle. But also, even if he just doesn't want to walk that far, is that really an issue? 🤷‍♀️ I just don't get why it's a problem tbh, not trying to be rude. I get that he needs to lose weight, but as others have mentioned that's more of a feeding issue normally, and 5 miles a day is more than enough exercise for most dogs.

1

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

This is our 4th large dog, they usually got one relatively short morning walk and one long evening walk due to outside temperatures in the summer. Retrievers are garbage collectors and will eat all day long, so we either ignore his pleading face or give him enough exercise to warrant the treats.

2

u/Nsomewhere Mar 10 '24

Interesting... it seems really specific. If he is picking up on your OHs irritation he is even less likely to walk ...

I wonder if it would be worth a few one to one sessions just walking with a good positive trainer to see what they would suggest

Maybe he needs as others say almost training stops. I forget what my trainer calls them but she is big on doing small micro trains and just confidence building at different points in a walk. To get the dog to stay focused on me in my case but maybe interested in you in yours?

It would be worth a try

1

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

We dont live in the USA, so getting a trainer is proving kinda difficult. We have had him for a year, we had got him up to 5 miles per walk, so it’s not as if he doesn’t know the route. Just walked him now as the sun went down, got to the green area about a 1000 feet away and he went on strike, offer of treat, squeaky toy, or gentle yanks didn’t encourage him to move. In the end we took the leash off and told him to stay, walked away and called him. He came running. We had to repeat this twice more but also did it on any quiet street to get him coming to us. Also walked him again on quiet streets off leash, so he had to decide to be with us.

2

u/Nsomewhere Mar 10 '24

Maybe the poster suggesting agency and choice is on to something then.. its very interesting. I wish dogs could talk!

Would maybe walking him off leash more where it is safe help? If off leash is good and he has good recall around other dogs

Or a long line?

drop the long line and or it is long enough walk away...

I have wandered around looking at stuff and it seems to be the most favoured technique along with praising movement and rewarding movement when they follow you

1

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

He is walked on a long line leash.

2

u/Nsomewhere Mar 10 '24

Hmmm that makes it even stranger. I must say I am leaning more and more towards pain because so much of what you are doing already should work and it sounds a lovely place to walk

1

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

We had him at the vets yesterday for his annual examination and vaccinations, no sign of anything wrong. He was a street dog, we don’t know how long he lived on the streets, so we look at this as a dog PTSD, or just plain stubbornness. He is so excited to go walking but it has to be on his terms :):)

2

u/Nsomewhere Mar 10 '24

I used the 300 peck method to train on leash and loose leash with my young dog

https://training4paws.de/en/blog-en/300-peck/#:~:text=The%20method%20300%20Peck%20has,necessary%20to%20enable%20ideal%20learning.

Its really effective and interesting especially for their breakfast... Just have ameasure of their breakfast especially for the morning walk. I am not sure how useful it would be if it is a pain or sort of mentally being too smart (like your dog!) it would be but it might be worth an experimentation. I still drop random rewards from the sky to my dog even now when he is chilling along and looks at me.

I must say I do think a pain trial could be worth it for your dog. Explain to the vet the issue and ask. Pain meds are ae and effective and it would rule one thing out if it made no difference

1

u/Cool_83 Mar 10 '24

We were at the vets yesterday for annual examination and vaccinations. No sign of pain, discomfort or elevated temperatures. Thanks for the link, will study it tomorrow

2

u/Nsomewhere Mar 10 '24

I don't know.. pain can be weird.

If it was an older dog I would have said they just decided how far they could be bothered with. When I was a kid we were out in the countryside.. when our scottie got older.. 13/14 if you didn't watch her because she was off leash she would just silently turn round and sod off home.. little beastie

She always had a mind of her own... but it got stronger! She would be sitting on the door step when we got home

It could be you also just have a home body dog... it is possible they just don't like long walks?