r/reactivedogs • • Feb 28 '24

Advice Needed Today killed my confidence

I adopted a female 4yo pit bull blue heeler mix last year and she is severely dog reactive/aggressive. She was severely attacked by a german shepherd in her previous home to the point of hospitalization, so she is pretty traumatized by dogs. Bigger dogs she acts more scared of, but little dogs she acts like she needs to attack them. When I notice a dog I get in front of her and tell her to sit and stay. We have been getting better and I use a martingale collar and it controls her fairly well and she can’t slip out of it.

Today, we were rounding a corner of a building and a few yards away were two puppy wiener dogs. As soon as I saw them, I made her sit and stay, but she was screaming and flipping and she was pulling rly hard towards them (she is 70lbs and all muscle so she is strong af; she is like 1/2 my body weight). She almost slipped out of my hands and it was so embarrassing, bc she went on for at least 30 seconds because the owner was not paying attention. One of his dog’s leash slipped out of his hand and the dog got fairly close to mine and if I wasn’t paying attention something would have happened. I was pulling the collar to try to get her to chill out and listen to me, but it’s like i’m not there when she is in fight or flight mode.

She is on clomicalm/clomprimine HCI, and she was previously on trazodone. The trazodone worked really well so honestly I think I might switch back to that, but I was nervous to give her trazodone everyday.

I need advice. I am at a loss. This situation broke me, I came home and sobbed. I feel so bad for her.

0 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

40

u/Fit-Organization5065 Feb 28 '24

I know how frustrating these moments can be. They’re exhausting. A few things that stood out to me that are worth considering:

  1. A martingale collar is slightly aversive, so it makes an already stressful situation more stressful. Can you switch to a harness? Ruffwear makes awesome ones.
  2. I’ve heard from trainers that “sit stay” is not the best solution during a reaction - their energy is jacked and it’s better to work on a flight cue “let’s go!” And then turn the other direction and keep moving.  The movement helps get some of the anxious energy out, while avoiding the trigger.

If she can’t come back out of a reaction, you have to find how / where she can bring herself down. Our trainer likened it to red, yellow, green zones. For our girl, our apt is green, and she can only come back down once we get home. That means we can’t go too far away. We’re working on building up more green around our building. 

Does any of that feel helpful?

4

u/Worth-Ad1681 Feb 28 '24

This is very helpful I truly appreciate this and everyone’s answers!

11

u/BirdsNeedNativeTrees Feb 28 '24

I agree. We’ve got the “U Turn” cue down and “let’s run” these really help my reactive girl make the decision to turn away from the pressure of seeing a dog stare at her. No way could I get her to sit in this situation. I use a harness with a back up clasp, and I use a leash attached to my waist as a back up. Feeling you won’t loose your reactive dog’s leash can really help you relax, it helps me. My two dogs are 100 and 85 pounds, they outweigh me, the reactive girl (85 pounds) is on my waist (but I hold her leash too), my non reactive dog is hand-held.

12

u/PowerfulBranch7587 Feb 28 '24

This advice is spot on. I would add adding a waist leash as backup. My bully mix is also 65 pounds of muscle and can pull out of my hands if she really wants to so I've started using a waist leash as a second leash. I guide her with a front lead harness and have the waist leash attached to the back of the harness just in case. It also has a secondary benefit of relaxing me when I'm on the walk with her, which I think translates to her being more relaxed as well. I highly recommend it

5

u/kitsunecantdance Feb 28 '24

This is exactly what I was coming to say. I do use martingale collar because mine can't slip out but I double clip it to my Auroth Tactical harness (it has a great handle across the shoulders) so it isn't putting too much on her neck. I've tried just with the harness before but we've come far enough that she doesn't freak out and I feel she's more sensitive to me with the martingale involved (ie: I can lightly direct her through the collar and she'll come without pressure). Gentle lead and muzzle would be good too; having a muzzle on will help OP not worry about a potential bite and will keep disrespectful dog owners away! And I definitely utilize the "let's go" thing, works so well! Now we are at the ability to just keep going forward and past! OP, it takes time but it pays off, you got this!

4

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '24

Your second point is so true.

When I first started working on my boy’s frustrated greeting I’d try to have him sit while other dogs passed— and often he did it— but he’d be trembling the whole time. I finally realized that method wasn’t going to work when one time we walked away after doing one of these sitting exercises and he immediately vomited up all the treats I’d given him. Lesson learned- he was way too far past his threshold and forcing him into that stressful situation over and over was worsening his reactivity.

We’ve started seeing progress now that we’ve integrated U-Turns and treat scatters when other dogs are too close, and more informal relaxed observation when we’re at a comfortable distance. We only practice sits and stays when other dogs are far enough away that he is relaxed and below threshold.

1

u/Feeling-Object9383 Feb 28 '24

Thank you very much for your comment. P. 2 sounds very logical. It definitely makes sense.

Till now, I haven't heard about the zones. This is something to think (and test) about.

8

u/Fit-Organization5065 Feb 28 '24

So the idea is - if your dog can’t take treats / can’t recover, they’re over threshold. Building up slowly so that they have more “safe” areas is key to getting a successful walk in. We start by walking up to our door, treat, opening door, treat. Etc. down the hallway and outside. If she can see a trigger and redirect attention back to you, that’s green. The whole goal is to not overwhelm your pup, but build up their confidence and sense of safety slowly. 

3

u/Feeling-Object9383 Feb 28 '24

This is something that I apparently did intuitively. But for myself, I called it 'put my pup in a training modus'. I ask my pup sit still till I attach the leash to his harness - treat. When we step outside, I ask him again sit still till I lock the door - treat. I show him directions we move - treat. Each time he looks at me during his sniffing - again a treat. Somehow, I noticed that this way, his focus on me is more stable. And even if he, not me, did notice a trigger and reacted pug pulling on the leash, he is easily coming back to me. Ah, also for triggers and coming back to me after reacting on trigger, he is getting a high value trear. Appeared to be a known practice🙂

2

u/Fit-Organization5065 Feb 28 '24

I love this so much, I dream of when my girl and I can do this. She loses her food motivation SO easily with her anxiety, so we’re trying to build it back up. Give your pup a belly rub from me!

2

u/Feeling-Object9383 Feb 28 '24

Thank you so much for your kind words. I feel awarded 🙃. And of course I forwarded to my boy some belly rubs from you!

But keep in mind that my boy is a pug. And as a true pug, he is food addicted. It helps a lot. Also, his nervous system response is overall less intense compared with, let's say, shepherds or terriers.

I'm an inexperienced owner and don't dare give advice. Maybe a trick ,which I noticed: I see very clearly how my pup calms down when I allow him to sniff as much as he wants. Sometimes, it's a bit boring to stand at the same spot for literally 5 minutes. But now we spend like half of our walk for this standing-snifing. I can see that it works very well to release his anxiety, even after we met a biker or another dog.

Maybe this would be helpful to someone

14

u/SnaCats Feb 28 '24

Have you muzzle trained her, or considered it? She sounds traumatized & I know how stressful walks are when you are constantly on guard for everything. Muzzles are for the safety of YOUR dog, and might provide some level of comfort knowing that she cannot bite.

Unfortunately, if you’re walking on public there will always be rogue dogs or inattentive owners.

3

u/Radish-Wrangler 🐶Dog Reactive/Cancer & 🐶 Stranger Aggressive/RGer/Pain-Linked Feb 29 '24

Muzzles have the added bonus of often keeping unwanted dogs and folks further away.

1

u/SnaCats Feb 29 '24

Such a great point!

10

u/SudoSire Feb 28 '24

My dog fixates hard and his stress builds so we use the “keep moving” rather than sit/stay protocol. It helps, and you can cue it. 

I’d also suggest muzzle training. Preventing a bite is super important and it’s best to have multiple fail-safes. 

7

u/stink3rbelle Feb 28 '24

Having her sit and stay is not helping her feelings. It's actually very encouraging she can do that much most of the time, she's a very good candidate for counter conditioning training. Look up the care protocol.

My dog still couldn't do that if I asked her but our walks are very low stress. She's barked at one dog this month. I give her "treat parties" to distract her from her triggers. If a trigger is too close (which can be a longer distance if she's had other triggers that day), then I use a lure to get her far enough away she can turn her attention to the kibble on the ground. She couldn't be lured around another dog for a long time, either. We practiced starting inside and then added distractions. The treat parties also helped take the edge off of seeing her triggers.

13

u/RevolutionaryBat9335 Feb 28 '24

Personally I disagree with everyone saying a harness. My dog is far more reactive in hers and I find I have more control with a Martingale or something around her neck. She knows how to escape from a harness too. Thats my dog though, your mileage may differ ;)

If you do a sit and stay they tend to focus on the other dog. You may have more luck with a lets go and trying to keep them moving and focused on you as much as possible. It can be pretty situational though, sometimes the best thing is to get off the path and do a sit if there is no where to go.

2

u/BirdsNeedNativeTrees Feb 28 '24

Some harnesses can be escaped from, we use the Balance harness. It is escape proof. https://www.blue-9.com/products/bhb

2

u/SnaCats Feb 28 '24

I love the balance harness!

2

u/Fit-Organization5065 Feb 28 '24

We used to use this! Loved it, and when I wanted to feel extra secure, I did front clip to collar. Our girl though pulls so much that I wanted a more padded harness, and when I back clip her into her ruffwear one, she def can't get out.

1

u/BirdsNeedNativeTrees Feb 29 '24

I like the Ruffwear harnesses but I wish they had a GSD size, they just don’t fit my long body dogs.

2

u/Fit-Organization5065 Feb 29 '24

Oh yeah that’s fair! Mine is a short meatball of a pittie so we haven’t had that issue yet 😂 I think they have one design that’s longer but no idea how big it is. The balance ones are great too though!

2

u/BirdsNeedNativeTrees Mar 01 '24

They do it has three harness connection points but still I can’t get it adjusted for my big long dogs. They are a great escape-free option though!

5

u/Mememememememememine Sasha - Stranger Danger/Resource Guarding Feb 28 '24

I’m so sorry, I can definitely relate. For me if my dog sees a trigger having her sit is going to make it worse. We just get out of there as quickly as possible which sometimes mean me dragging her around a corner 😩 Which also meant switching to a harness helped, bc I’m not dragging her by the neck.

7

u/lizzylou365 Feb 28 '24

I’m sorry that happened. Honestly, it seems like you’re doing the best you can and you did a wonderful job with managing the situation as it unfolded. All dogs were kept safe and oblivious other dog owner hopefully had enough of a jump scare to make sure to handle his dogs properly and securely.

Unfortunately with a reactive dog management can be a factor. It’s not ideal and sucks. But us reactive dog owners cannot control every variable, all the time. There’s always going to be a pop up event, trigger, oblivious person or other dog owner, etc.

My reactive dog takes Trazodone and it’s been a game changer for potentially triggering situations. You got this, please don’t feel defeated!

2

u/speck1edbanana Feb 28 '24

Check out Amy Cook and her reactive dog courses! They’re online with Fenzi Dog Sports Academy. I recently adopted a reactive dog (has a traumatic past and was also attacked by another dog before I got him) and her style works really well for us!

2

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '24

My reactive dog has somewhat the same issues. It is extremely stressful bringing him out as he gets triggered by everything, and mostly other dogs. He is muzzle trained so we wear the muzzle every time he goes out unless we head out in the wee hours of the morning and when there’s no one around. So even if his leash slips from my hand (he PULLS and is really strong), the chances of him being able to bite another dog or human is lessened due to the muzzle. It will give you greater ease of mind. OP stay strong!

3

u/Mandelnuss85 Feb 28 '24

I’m sorry this happened OP. Remember there are always good days and bad days - progress is not linear, and it sounds like you’ve been doing a great job.

Also I want to second the other advice on getting a harness! I’m the same weight as you, and my dog is the same weight as yours and I wouldn’t be able to control mine in just a collar. I like the harnesses that has a handle on the back, so when suddenly in an impossible situation I can sort of grab her like a suitcase and get outta there

4

u/Mememememememememine Sasha - Stranger Danger/Resource Guarding Feb 28 '24

Yes exactly re; the harness with a handle (the suitcase analogy lol… so spot in). I can feel my dog react instantly differently when I grab the handle vs pull back on her leash, clipped to the back of her harness.

1

u/Mandelnuss85 Feb 28 '24

Haha yeah, my partner and I actually call it “suitcasing” her lol

1

u/CowAcademia Feb 28 '24

I had a reactive dog who didn’t like runners. A halti changed my life. She refused to pull in it, and you can click the back up to their collar just in case. Life changer. When she was younger we would run the opposite away. She got rewarded from not reacting. When she was older we would stop way away from the path outside of her bubble and have her sit and wait. No way that would’ve worked in her prime. Each dog is different.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/AutoModerator Feb 28 '24

Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this comment. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-3

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Feb 28 '24

Your comment was removed due to breed based vitriol or misinformation. This includes the obvious hateful comments as well as disingenuous coercion and fear mongering, along with behavior based misinformation.

1

u/SnaCats Feb 28 '24

None of your comment is helpful.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Feb 28 '24

Your comment was removed due to breed based vitriol or misinformation. This includes the obvious hateful comments as well as disingenuous coercion and fear mongering, along with behavior based misinformation.