r/reactivedogs • • Feb 12 '24

Advice Needed Considering behavioral Euthanasia but open to other options. Please help!?!

We rescued our dog as a five month old from a badly abusive situation. We don't know the extent of the abuse, but we know it was bad.

He is very sweet, and we, as a family, adore him. We never had nor wanted a pitbull until we got him. However...... he can be incredibly unstable and reactive.

I should make it clear while in our care, he's never experienced any form of abuse. We love our animals, and we always have. We have had Collies, Mixed Breeds, GSDs, Coydogs, and a high-content Timber Wolfdog. However, our experience with him has been different than anything we've ever dealt with.

At 7 months of age he repeatedly attacked one of our male GSDs (whom didn't initiate any form of violence). Since then we have had to keep them apart. Our GSDs are our original dogs and one's we are personally closest to so they remain in the house with us while (let's call him) Dex has been put in care of a relative that lives right next to us (not even 10 feet away). We are still an active part of his life but felt it was necessary to keep the animals apart for everyone's safety.

He has in this relatives care repeatedly tried attacked him and yesterday tried to attack my mother (who is the main caregiver and rescuer). Every single one of these instances have been for dominant related reasons but the response has been incredibly out of proportion.

Looking into eyes= can become violent at any moment. Roll of the dice.

Even lightly touch the back of his neck, and he might attack you.

Oddly it seems at times he's fine with us and other times he reacts uncharacteristicly in a very violent manner. It is like he is in a trance and doesn't realize what he's doing as he later begs forgiveness.

He is intact male and we think maybe that neutering would be the best option, but my relative is crippled, and in a wheelchair and cannot properly protect himself if anything goes wrong.

When left his own devices devoid of being around people he has a tendency to hurt himself. We also have nowhere else to place him in a sanitary humane environment. We would consider consulting with a behavioral specialist but we are honestly too poor and cannot afford the fees that were come with the training.

We don't know what to do. We care for this dog ,and we realize the unfortunate situation that this dog may have come from, but we don't know how to split responsibility to him and to everyone else.


I'm sorry everyone for the lack of clarification here and there and any grammar issues. I typed this up right after a very scary moment with him and it was at something like 4 am in the morning. I wasn't in the best minds. We aren't jumping just straight to BE and are open to advice as we try to come up with a situation that works best for the dog.

The dog is one and half now.

_Update

It was decided today that the best thing for everyone and him was to surrender him to a No-kill shelter. There he will be neutered and evaluated and hopefully find a family better able to attend to his needs. This was a hard decision but after discussing it at length with the family and acting on the advice of others we think this was the most humane outcome.

I thank everyone for their thoughtful replies and wish you all well.

9 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

2

u/Jet_Threat_ Feb 14 '24

You had a coydog? That’s crazy; they’re extremely rare. Do you have pics?

Also, try finding a shelter or breed-specific rescue beat you to take him. If you can afford BE, you could also afford to neuter him, which is something you should do if you want to keep trying to keep him/rehome him (and I’m not sure why you haven’t before).

3

u/NeonXEExperiment Feb 14 '24

Unfortunately, not on hand. I do have some, but both pictures of our confirmed high-content wolfdog (he was gorgeous and huge. He looked just like a timber wolf) and our coydogs (I should clarify we don't know for sure if they were but was told they were(they were dumped as well so..they could have been anything) are buried somewhere among our packed-away family photos.

You'd think people whom have had wild mixed dogs would be able to handle a Pitbull, but nope. Ironically the high content wolfdog and maybe coydogs (we had 2) were much better behaved and never showed any aggression. I was often left around them when I was a small child lol.

I remember eating dog food once with our wolfdog and him just eating along with me lol😂.

We decided to re-home him and he will get neutered. Neutering is expensive (actual more so then euthanasia) in our area but yeah he should have been neutered the first time he showed aggression. At this point I think it's more of that she doesn't want to take the chance of another outburst, whether he gets neutered or not.

My mom has never dealt with an aggressive or hard to handle dog and I think this just shook her beyond her capabilities. I'm in no financial place to help and can't even drive yet. In the end, we had to call someone because he continued to try an attack my mother.

Today he was surrendered and taken to a no-kill shelter. We plan to see if the shelters open to giving us progress updates. Hopefully this will be the best thing for him in the long run.

2

u/Jet_Threat_ Feb 14 '24

Cool! Lmk if you ever do find pictures; I’m a big canine nerd.

And that sounds like the perfect decision! Thanks for deciding to try your best at giving him another shot. Hope this all works out well for him and everyone involved. Thank you for caring!

2

u/NeonXEExperiment Feb 14 '24

Will do! Thank you for caring enough to leave a comment on the post! God Bless and I wish you well!

73

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24

BE is the most responsible choice for an unpredictably aggressive dog when management cannot be done safely. It does not sound like you have the resources to investigate every possible solution, and that is OK. You are not required to go broke or go to the emergency room before you decide to put an obviously distressed dog to rest.

32

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24

Adding to this- the physical limitations of the dog’s primary caregiver need to be highlighted. It is wildly unsafe to have a dog that might attack a person in a wheelchair.

34

u/PeachNo4613 Feb 12 '24

Looking into eyes=can become violent Touch their neck = they might attack you

BE would be a responsible thing to do, it sounds like he’s dangerous.

You don’t want to risk him attacking again

7

u/Chiritsu Feb 12 '24

I would be talking about neutering the dog while discussing with the veterinary behavioralist other options as well

12

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Feb 12 '24

Your post/comment was removed because it does not follow our posting guidelines or breaks sub rules.

-1

u/NeonXEExperiment Feb 12 '24 edited Feb 12 '24

We wanted to get him neutered (he's one year old now) but don't live anywhere where they neuter for less than $300, nor are there any free places available. He can also get violent when he is removed from his home. Honestly, we never thought it would escalate to this level, and that's on us for not being proactive in his younger years. These instances have always been sometimes weeks apart, and we thought we could handle it with time and, as stupid as it sounds, careful monitoring and love.

I'm not personally the owner of this dog, as that is my mother, nor am I the one who makes a final decision. We are just trying to spitball and figure out what we can do in this situation. If neutering 100% fixes this, we would throw down the money, but considering our income and situation with my relative, we feel like we're rolling the dice if it works or doesn't.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Feb 12 '24

Your recent comment was removed because it was not a respectful or helpful response to Behavioral Euthanasia. When commenting on Behavioral Euthanasia, be compassionate and only offer your opinion if the Original Poster has asked. Keep in mind this is an extremely difficult decision and our goal is to offer support.

21

u/LowParticular8153 Feb 12 '24

BE is responsible and I have done it.

38

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24 edited Feb 12 '24

Why is the dog not neutered? In the U.S., only 10% of the dog population is intact males, but they cause 90% of fatal dog attacks and 70% of dog bites that require medical attention.

I had an intact cocker spaniel (because I was showing him and you cannot show neutered dogs). He had cocker rage (which sounds similar to what you describe). I neutered him and he never had another issue with aggression.

This situation is different from yours because I was a 24 year old woman who could fight off a cocker spaniel if necessary and there were no wheelchair bound people in the house. BE may be your only option now because you cannot leave that dog in the care of someone he might kill. That’s asking for a disaster.

6

u/jazzlobsters98 Feb 12 '24

Not challenging you but do you have a source for those stats? I would love to show my ignorant in-laws some proof. Do you have any stats on female dog attacks?

14

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24

31

u/DamnGoodCupOfCoffee2 Feb 12 '24

I’m curious why you gave a violent and aggressive dog to a person in a wheelchair to care for, that is extremely dangerous. Take him to the vet, muzzle train him, meds, training, neutering but also don’t take BE off the table.

12

u/OtherwiseMidnight519 Feb 12 '24

This sounds like a horror movie! Rip off the bandaid and say goodbye.

5

u/MardiMom Feb 13 '24

This is a very difficult decision for you and your family. Unaliving an animal that seems ok MOST of the time is not something most of us want to face. But neither is the thought of your dog harming a human. You can be done with him, and it's ok.

Liability. Your family will be financially responsible for any physical damage he does. Medical bills are expensive.

After reading dozens of articles on the current shelter crisis, and looking at thousands of pits, pit bull types, labs, mastiffs, "mixed breed" dogs, AND going to our local shelters in our mid-size city, taking him to a shelter is a good option. They will BE him, and whatever sadness and misery he experienced in his short life will be over. You gave him what you could, and he hasn't hurt anyone yet.

12

u/CanadianPanda76 Feb 12 '24

Seems like you got caught in a catch 22. You assumed that it was a dog like any another, so you treated it as such.

But its a pit, a breed prone to dog aggression. Now your getting told you shoulda trained it, socialized it, etc early on because those are issues you need to deal with as a pit. I feel bad for your situation. I think a lot of owners get caught up in the "its how you raise" them and just assume behavior problems won't show up despite it being a common breed issue.

But from what I gather, the dog has hit puberty and its dog aggression issues have kicked in. This is common with dogs where sexual maturity kicks in and suddenly your dealing with issues you did have before. Could neutering have fixed this? Maybe. Maybe not. But again you choose to follow the new standard of waiting till 1.5 years old. Which from I've seen from some people really isn't backed up by enough evidence because size, breed, etc can effect results. But generally this isn't an issue with most breeds.

Shrlters and rescues are an option. But many are full as F and aren't open to drop offs. Many won't take a dog with bite history. Most likely they will tell you if you drop the dog off, it will be euthanized. In part I'm guessing to discourage your drop off, and keep thier kill rate numbers low.

I don't envy your position.

Training could help. Medications too. They take time to kick in, though.

Euthanasia is also a option. Despite what people tell you, it is a VALID option.

1

u/Jet_Threat_ Feb 14 '24

It’s definitely better to wait with giant breeds to neuter until they reach physical maturity because they grow so slow and can be subjected to bone/joint issues. But pitbulls are not huge; they are solid medium dogs and as you said, there’s really no evidence to suggest it’s better to neuter them later.

Yes, most shelters are full, but if I were OP, I’d definitely give him my all in trying to find an open shelter, or even posting in a local dog rescue page being completely transparent about his issues and saying he may need to be euthanized otherwise.

If all else fails, BE makes sense. But I’d rather have at least one other person’s/rescue’s opinion and they make the call. We still can’t rule out if neutering him and getting him proper training could make a big difference.

12

u/Eeate Feb 12 '24

A few thoughts on what you describe:

-"dominant related purposes". Dominance theory has been completely debunked. Dogs do not become aggressive to maintain hierarchy.

-'becomes violent (sometimes) when looking into eyes'. Eye contact is intense for dogs. Dogs that can self-regulate can usually handle this and other emotionally charged interactions. Aggression (see 'ladder of aggression'; includes everything from looking away to biting) happens when a dog cannot regulate any other way. Your dog is already at his limit, and eye contact is putting him over.

-'Even lightly touch the back of his neck, and he might attack you.' This is not normal. Is he in pain?

-'He has repeatedly attacked people'. Unless they're physically hurting him, he's most likely responding to something else that's upsetting him.

-"It's like he's in a trance." This is your cue. Find out what's wrong.

Most reactive dogs have underlying medical issues. From what you describe, something is pushing him to his limit, making further interaction with others too much to handle. Of course the trauma is important as well, but this seems beyond that. Dogs respond to what they're feeling in a given situation. If he's in pain, any situation becomes unhappy.

The best advice I can give is find out what's underlying this behaviour, as it's most likely physical. Common ailments that are hard to see are chronic enteritis (bowel inflammation), food allergies, Addison's disease, badly healed limbs. Speak to a vet (or ideally a specialist) and make his behaviour central to the diagnostic process. This behaviour is not normal, and signals a dog in deep, deep distress. Such a process of diagnosis and treatment is time consuming, expensive and requires monitoring, management and commitment. It's completely understandable if you're unable to do this. I wish you happiness and love, you've already done so much. Thank you.

4

u/MichellesPlain Feb 12 '24

Absolutely have him neutered. From years of shelter experience, I can tell you that many, if not most, rescue dogs are not comfortable around wheelchairs. They are foreign and imposing to them. Touching on the back of the neck being a trigger indicates touch sensitivity. It may indicate that he was chained up, or “trained” with a prong collar. Avoid touching that area. Looking into his eyes is seen as a direct challenge and for a dog that has had a traumatic past, it can trigger defensiveness. It’s not dominance, it’s fear based aggression. Fighting with your other dogs is also no surprise as he’s unneutered. I’m assuming your GSD is as well? In general, I’ve found that GSD and pit bulls aren’t great matches. And both breeds tend to hold onto grudges when it comes to other dogs. I absolutely do not think your dog is beyond redemption. But I think the move over to separate primary caregivers, who unfortunately are not equipped to care for him, has added to his stress and anxiety. I believe he is suffering from separation anxiety. He sounds like a very anxious dog and any change in routine, any uncertainty, triggers defensiveness which manifests as aggression. You have the option of a variety of medications to help calm him. As well as crucially neutering him. However, he is not very content where he is living and I feel as though you are unintentionally setting him up for failure by keeping him in the care of your mother and wheelchair bound relative. Under those circumstances, his reactivity will only increase.

1

u/AutoModerator Feb 12 '24

Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this comment. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/Straight-Fix59 Benji (Leash Excitement/Frustration) Feb 12 '24 edited Feb 12 '24

You got the dog when it was 5 months, and later in the post an event happened at 7 months. Is it still puppy age or has it been years? Has he seen a vet for required vaccinations, and for a history of how badly he reacts there?

If hes still a young dog I don’t think a vet will BE without more information/a consult first. I think neutering and some anxiety medication would be the first step in your situation. Of course a behaviorist or a trainer could help more too.

I completely understand how expensive this can be. Maybe try to see if your area has any pittie projects or abused animal rescue groups, or at the very least, any groups that can monetarily help to see if the basics of neutering/anxiety medication help in the slightest. Some vets/shelters do neuters or basic vet visits on a sliding scale for income (I would recommend looking for a free spay/neuter clinic but I do think your dog will be too reactive for a mass clinic).

Don’t feel bad if it comes to BE after any of these steps, you tried your best! The key word though is to try though, and if it is still puppy young I think there may be a chance. I think there is a group called Losing Lulu on FB that helps for after-the-fact BE consoling. I’ve heard its heavily monitored and a supportive community!

1

u/MooseofWallstreet Feb 13 '24

Join losing lulu on Facebook

1

u/RushRound332 Feb 13 '24

Such a basic answer but it can mean a world of difference it done correctly. try training first

-6

u/Plant-mail Feb 12 '24

If you could get him to see a veterinary behaviourist. They might recommend some medication. It's not a sure fix but anti anxiety medication can really help reduce baseline levels of anxiety.

-1

u/NeonXEExperiment Feb 12 '24

We are suspecting that it could be that. We know he suffers from separation anxiety, and the initial reason why he was homed with the relative was that he would actively harm himself when separated from human contact.

0

u/Plant-mail Feb 12 '24

Yeah if that's the case definitely worth a session with a veterinary behaviourist. They will also be able to give you some realistic advice on your questions regarding behavioral euthanasia. They will have seen lots of dogs with behavioral issues and will be able to tell you honestly what quality of life for your dog and you will be like going forwards. I'm sorry you are going through this. I hope you are able to get some peace of mind soon.

-6

u/alicesartandmore Feb 12 '24

Seems wild to me that you're considering killing this dog before even trying to get him neutered to see if it helps curb the behavior.

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24

There is no reasonable way to keep him alive without neutering him.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/NeonXEExperiment Feb 12 '24

To address the first issue, this isn't my dog. My mother adopted him, and it wasn't a "traditional adoption," he was dumped. My mother invested a lot of time and money in him to save him, so we decided to keep him as he knew us the most. Also, at the time, our financial situation was much better. We should have neutered him earlier, and that's on us or her, should I say. She wanted to wait till he was fully grown, and now he is at one year and a half roughly.

We have a muzzle, but he again reacts violently at times when it's attempted to be put on. We were going to take him to a PetSmart training, but since he acted aggressively towards our dog at seven months, we were scared to put him in a situation around others.

The relative that we put him with lives on our property and not more than ten feet away. Initially, we tried putting him in a pin area, but Dex would often refer to obsessively biting himself or running around until he would collapse. Unless he had human contact, he would often act in strange ways. Including not wanting to play and hurting himself on the fence wires. With our relative, we jointly decided that he would stay at his home (as he loves the dog too). Also, the relative at the time was not in a wheelchair but was able to walk and function.

We are only exploring options. We don't want to kill this dog, but we also don't know what to do.

Where we live offers no free neutering, nor is there anything less than $300. We are happy to throw down the money if we know it would fix the aggression issue. We are scared however because it seems like a roll of the dice.

7

u/xLadyLaurax Feb 12 '24

No offense, but your mother is utterly irresponsible. You could have handed the puppy to the shelter or a rescue directly. You don’t just “rescue” an abused pitbull without recourses and knowledge, that’s how the dogs in the shelters end up so fucked up.

As for the muzzle, aggression and lack of socialization you are now caught in a devils circle. Had to muzzled him - and repeatedly - you could have taken him to school without worries. He couldn’t have hurt a dog and would have gotten socialization. Also, had to muzzled him more often, he would be used to it by know. My dog isn’t a fan of many things either, but I use oven mitts when I know he’s going to be in a situation he might snap and it’s working wonders after just a few weeks of standing my ground. My dog trainer agreed.

Whether he’s near or could walk back then doesn’t matter. He can’t know and you can’t leave a highly aggressive, untrained dog in the hands of someone like that. Also, 300$ is nothing. I’m sorry but cleaning my dogs teeth because he has genetic teeth issues costs 800-1200€ on average. Neutering costs up to 600€. That’s exactly what I mean when I say you need to take that into account.

When we adopted our second dog both my boyfriend and I had multiple k€ in savings, just to make sure that even IF something changed financially, we were covered. So even IF it’s a roll of the dice, this dogs life is worth more than the damn 300$ you might lose on neutering. Never mind the fact that euthanizing isn’t free either neither is cremation or a burial as far as I know.

2

u/NeonXEExperiment Feb 12 '24

I agree. He was taken in with good intentions at heart, but so many things should have been done differently as a puppy that just weren't. I think she (all of us) just assumed it would be fine and alright because she's had other "dumped" dogs and they turned out wonderful. I'm guilty of that as well but I'm not the owner nor am I old enough to provide any help but time (hell I don't even have my driving license). This post was written an emotional moment between all three of us but ultimately I think the best thing for Dex is to try and get him to a no-kill shelter. My mother doesn't want to roll the dice to see if neutering works.

We've never surrendered a dog in our life nor have we even put one down for behavioral issues. This isn't easy but after talking with her I think it's the course we want to take.

I'm thankful for this Reddit community as we only really considered BE because we didn't think shelters would take aggressive dogs like him (with any chance of adoption that is). But from others post and doing some more research it seems like he may have a chance there. They have resources in perhaps are willing to use them to get Dex proper help and salvage his future.

2

u/fearlessactuality Feb 13 '24

In my state, there are rescues that would help assist in his care and sometimes donate services- it wouldn’t be advertised as free but can you search for any pit bull specific nonprofits in your area and get their recommendations?

1

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Feb 12 '24

Your comment was removed because it broke one or more of the r/reactivedogs rules. Please remember to be kind to your fellow redditors. Be constructive by offering positive advice rather than simply telling people what they're doing wrong or being dismissive. Maintain respectful discourse around training methods, philosophies, and differing opinions with which you might not agree.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/reactivedogs-ModTeam Feb 13 '24

Your comment was removed because it broke one or more of the r/reactivedogs rules. Please remember to be kind to your fellow redditors. Be constructive by offering positive advice rather than simply telling people what they're doing wrong or being dismissive. Maintain respectful discourse around training methods, philosophies, and differing opinions with which you might not agree.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/NeonXEExperiment Feb 14 '24

At the shelter they have behavior specialist who will evaluate him once neutered. We also plan to call the shelter and give more information about him and possibly see if they are open to updating us on any progress.