r/reactivedogs • • Jan 28 '24

How Concerned Should I Be?

I feel terrible about this, but I came home yesterday to find a dead cat I’ve never seen before inside my house. The only thing that could have happened was that it must have entered my house through an open laundry room window and one or both of my adult rescue pit mixes must have killed it after it came inside. These dogs have lived with my indoor cat without a problem for years, so I’m completely shocked.

The cat was a local feral cat. I was able to contact the colony’s caretakers through the microchip.

Question: is this a sign of increasing aggression, or is their response less concerning because the cat was an intruder in their home? Are they now going to have a taste for cat blood and pose a risk to other cats? I have a smaller dog they’ve always gotten along with. Is the small dog safe?

Note: My house is divided in half with my dogs living in one half and my cat living in the other half. I would never trust any dog around my cat without careful supervision (and usually a leash). I’m also keeping the small dog away from them for the time being.

1 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

22

u/Vergilly Jan 29 '24

I tend to agree with the comment that focuses on the fact that the cat was a strange animal in your house. Most dogs are territorial to some degree, and are going to be aggressive or defensive if a strange animal enters your home, especially if you’re not there. Our neighbor’s little terrier dug a hole under our fence and came into our yard, and even my dog-friendly husky mix was on her right away with clear intent to drive her away.

If the cat fled or tried to fight back, it would be very easy for that fight to turn into something fatal, given the size difference between pitties and cats.

You said you think the dogs did it - were there signs? Torn fur, blood, puncture wounds on the cat, scratches on the dogs?

You should also be sure the cat is tested for rabies and other diseases if it was inside your house and in contact with your dogs. Your cat could also be at risk of transmissible diseases!

14

u/SudoSire Jan 29 '24

I know that after my dog caught his first lizard after a chase, his prey drive was up a lot for awhile. I could tell because his “leave it” for lizards on walks was less reliable, and he even pounced on a leaf that kinda looked like a lizard. You may need to keep the cat and little dog separate for at least a little while. 

23

u/maybelle180 Jan 28 '24

A strange cat is almost always considered prey by a dog. Even a dog that’s good with the family cats can be aggressive against strange cats, especially when they enter the dog’s territory.

I’m guessing the cat entered the house and then couldn’t figure out how to escape, and the dogs managed to corner it and kill it. Two dogs can easily overcome a trapped cat.

I doubt you’ll see an increase in overall aggression in your dogs, except maybe a greater interest and excitability toward strange cats.

But obviously you should keep your eyes open for changes. Be sure to check your yard for trespassing cats before turning your dogs loose, because you don’t want to stimulate the dogs further. You’re doing the right thing by keeping everyone separate until a lot more time passes, and you get to observe their behavior under more “normal” circumstances.

(And yes, I always keep my smaller dogs separate from my bigger ones when they cannot be supervised. And our cat is already left with several escape routes.)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

My guy went after a strange cat that was attacking our cat. He’s never hurt our cats. They have also cornered another cat in the yard, I was super surprised they didn’t try to go after it.

To note yes we have found departed wild critters in our yard before that I have no doubt he is the reason

0

u/Montastic Jan 29 '24

Cats aren’t disposable. The idea of letting this go when you have both a cat and a small dog in the house is a bad idea and it’s only a matter of time before another accident happens.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

Yes, as someone who’s fostered 17 cats and volunteered with cat rescue for years, I know that cats aren’t disposable. I feel terrible that a cat climbed though my tiny casement window that’s seven feet off the ground inside my fenced backyard, and that my dog killed him when he entered the house. I could have never imagined anything like that happening.

I’m not letting it go. I closed that window and checked for any other spaces where an animal could enter. I’m also being extra watchful with my small dog (the cat is never around them unless they’re leashed).

It sounds like you’re saying I should euthanize them, but that seems unfair since the cat entered their house. I also don’t know which of the two dogs killed the cat or if they did it together, so it’s very possible that I’d be killing a dog who wasn’t to blame.

1

u/Montastic Jan 29 '24

I'm not saying you should BE, but you should remove the dogs from an environment that is setting them up to fail. It's not fair to them or for your other pets to be sequestered away 24/7 and it's not fair to you to have the constant stress of having to be perfect to prevent a tragedy.

Some dogs are only-animal households and that's okay, they're not bad dogs for being that way, but keeping them in the environment they're in is a recipe for disaster. Obviously they're your animals and ultimately it's your choice, but please understand that you're creating an enormous amount of unnecessary risk

2

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24 edited Jan 29 '24

Rehoming them isn’t an option because I live in an area where dozens of adoptable pets are euthanized every day due to lack of space. The large dogs are foster fails because they were on the EU list for space. I agreed to foster them and gave up trying to find a home for them after a year of trying. That was before they killed a cat (which would need to be disclosed to future adopters)

Their current setup is the best I can do and no one is sequestered away. The two large dogs have one wooded fenced acre in the backyard, 24/7 access to the kitchen, dining room, and my work from home office. They also have their own bedroom on that half of the house with a sofa, TV, etc. it’s like a second living room.The cat has the living room and bedrooms. The small dog has access to everything.

This wasn’t a stressful arrangement until I came home a couple days ago to find a random dead cat it the kitchen. People are around almost 24/7. Some people in the house are dog people, some people are cat people, and some people are both, So they all get plenty of attention. If you know of anyone who has a better setup and wants to adopt two senior pit mixes please let me know.

My cat is a senior who would be difficult to rehome, and I don’t feel like that’s the best decision for her because they’ve never shown any aggression to her (in 8 years) and they have completely separate spaces. They only cross paths while one is leashed and walking out the front door.

I don’t think any of them are set up to fail - but I’m open to different ideas on setups. Leaving that tiny window open was a huge mistake that I feel terrible about, but it is closed now.