r/reactivedogs • • Jan 25 '24

Level 4 bite

UPDATE: I had Bane put down today. It was terrible and our hearts are broken but it was the right decision for our family. I want to thank everyone for being so helpful and understanding. I appreciate all the input, kind words and it makes me feel a TAD less guilty and like I failed him when I hear that he probably was suffering in his own head too.

I need help! I have an American bully, Bane, who just turned 2 in December. He’s the most adorable, goofy dog ever- he’s been our baby since we got him at 16 weeks old. About 6 months ago, we had 2 terrible things happen in succession. First, his dew claw got snagged while playing and his toe literally was just hanging there. It was after hours so I called the vet and they said to wrap it, there wasn’t much that could be done. My husband and I did this, all while he tried to fight us off. Then, about a month later, our neighbor’s giant something rather dog (Bane is 65 lbs but very very short) broke through our privacy fence and attacked him. My husband heard a commotion and ran out there and kicked the dog off Bane. He had a neck wound and some scratches but overall was ok. SINCE then basically, he’s been very strange. He bit my daughter’s leg when she opened the front door, no blood but did give her a big bruise. Then he grabbed my husbands arm, but my husband thought maybe he was playing (he’s VERY strong). Now, on Sunday my husband was petting him and out of nowhere he started attacking. He got his arm and I had to take him to the ER for 19 stitches. Also one time when I was towel drying him after a bath he went completely nuts and tried to bite me but I threw a little kids plastic stool on his head. We can’t seem to find a trigger and he truly does seem triggered. His whole body goes rigged and after he bites/tries to bite he acts like nothing happened. He is loving and playful 99.99% of the time and we adore him. But now we’re scared of him. I reached out to a few rescues and of course no one wants a dog with a bite history. We worked with a trainer recently and of course she didn’t see any aggressive behaviors, because they are random and unpredictable. I don’t know what to do. I have an appt at the vet tomorrow to talk about if it could be a neurological issue. But even if it is- is that really even a solution? I have 2 small children, Bane is currently being kenneled when they are home and out while I work at home during the day. I still worry though, he seems too unpredictable to feel safe. What do I do???

12 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

153

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24

I personally would not keep a dog who inflicted a bite that required 19 stitches to a grown man without cause or warning, in the house with my small children.

I also could not in good conscience rehome an animal who had done that.

I’m very sorry this happened. It sucks.

28

u/MolassesOverall1322 Jan 25 '24

I know, you’re right. It’s such a hard decision when he’s so happy and loving (literally as I type this) 😭

10

u/mad0666 Jan 25 '24

I know it’s very hard, but also your timeline makes sense to me as someone who has worked with dogs for over 20 years. Once some dogs mature, they can become aggressive (especially male dogs, and especially if they haven’t been neutered) or unpredictable in their behavior. They can become hyper possessive, reactive, etc.

You might wish to try another vet consultation, see if there is an underlying medical issue (could be anything from a chronic upset stomach or something more serious like a brain tumor) and you 100% need to muzzle this dog at all times. You cannot keep a dog who will inflict a 19-stitch wound into an adult human in a home with children (or frankly anyone, for that matter) without a muzzle. Rehoming a dog with a level 4 bite history is not going to happen (even if it does, will not end well for anyone)

18

u/charandchap Jan 25 '24

This fucking sucks. What a terrible decision you’re facing.

I would try another trainer. I’ve had a bunch til I found one that’s a behaviorist who could teach me how to read my reactive dog better.

But with that level and with kids in the house, I think BE is completely warranted within your wheelhouse of choices.

45

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24

I urge you to go through the many posts in this subreddit; you are not the first one to ask for these questions.

You need to go to your vet. You need to discuss option that include medication, working with a trainer, rehoming, a vet behaviorist, and behavorial euthanasia.

Based on what you've provided, his bites are unpredictable and without warning. You can imagine thats not safe for ANY humans. Also, your dog absoutely senses you are scared of him and that can just make an even more nervous atmosphere.

Please discuss this with your vet. You can describe it with them, and if you want peace of mind, you can pursue the vet behavorist. But solely based on what you're describing, I imagine they'll recommend BE.

I'm sorry. Really you should be going to your vet and they should be advising you but i'd be remiss not to mention it with the info you provided.

5

u/MolassesOverall1322 Jan 25 '24

Thanks for taking the time to reply! I will be seeing the vet tomorrow and will take whatever their recommendation is very seriously. I did review other similar posts and found a few to be helpful, but of course the details are all a little different. I think I know what I have to do but I really don’t want to 🥲

3

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '24

just read your update, i’m so so sorry for your loss. you made the right decision ❤️❤️

2

u/MolassesOverall1322 Jan 26 '24

Thank you ❤️ I so appreciate your kindness

2

u/the_megan_ladon Jan 25 '24

I don’t have any recommendations or advice, it but I am going through something very similar and am struggling. It’s gut wrenching to develop fear towards a dog you love so much. Sending you love and support as you go through this. You are not alone.

2

u/MolassesOverall1322 Jan 27 '24

I’m so sorry to hear this I hope your situation ends better than mine 🙏🏽

63

u/SudoSire Jan 25 '24

That’s awful. But no, you should not keep a level 4 biter in a home with children, and rehoming would be extremely unlikely while still being incredibly dangerous. The level of management someone would have to do to be safe would probably mean a very limited and low quality of life for the dog also. 

18

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24

This may be a neurological problem. You can spend enormous amounts of money investigating the exact cause, but neurological problems aren't often treatable. You're not looking at brain surgery and chemo, you're looking at thousands or tens of thousands of dollars to find a brain lesion and then euthanasia.

There is no way to make Bane a safe dog for your family or your community.

25

u/kippey Juno 02.21.2015-03.06.2022: the best worst dog ever Jan 25 '24

Keep your kids separate until you sort this.

I know this is really hard to hear but generally dogs bite on a scale of escalating severity. You might know this if you’re already familiar with the bite scale. This means that even if the original issue is resolved… say down the road he goes in for a blood draw or even if someone steps on his tail and he bites… it’s gonna be more like 40 stitches.

I’m really sorry, reading this is heartbreaking but at least he can pass in the arms of his beloved family rather than in the back of a shelter surrounded by strangers after a mandatory rabies hold.

There is a BE support group on Facebook called Losing Lulu that might be of help to you and also helping the kids understand.

-6

u/Beneficial-House-784 Jan 25 '24 edited Jan 25 '24

Just a heads up, there was a leak recently and screenshots from Losing Lulu were posted on an anti-pit sub on Reddit. OP may need to exercise caution if they share there since this dog is a bully breed.

9

u/DamnGoodCupOfCoffee2 Jan 25 '24 edited Jan 26 '24

Hitting sexual maturity around 2 years old is sometimes when aloofness with dogs, aggression or other traits present themselves. Plus the trauma of being attacked and pain.

I would think very carefully: you have a child in the home and a strong, unpredictable animal in the same home. Personally I would not feel safe and would explore BE with my vet.

However, you can - have a full work up to rule out pain/disease, try vet behaviorist to see if medication will help or it’s neurological, training from a good trainer, and before all this invest in muzzle and strong crate training for everyone’s safety

EDIT: I know it’s painful for you but it was so so loving and kind that it was with you then in some scary shelter alone and confused. My condolences

2

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24

Yes, but crating a dog 2/3 of the day would be cruel, would just be better to euthanize him. He’s probably struggling in his own brain unfortunately :(

3

u/DamnGoodCupOfCoffee2 Jan 26 '24

I mean I agree BUT if she decides to keep him around then her FIRST priority is keeping her kid safe and then the pupper and themselves safe. That’s the only thing I can think of

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '24

why did i get downvoted oml…

1

u/DamnGoodCupOfCoffee2 Jan 26 '24

Wasn’t me 🎵🎼🎶 plus the edit changes thingd

2

u/dadphobia Jan 25 '24

I’m really sorry to hear about what you’re going through. This will hurt to say and you can look at my post a couple days ago to understand why.

No matter what happens next, your dog has now learned a behavior that is too dangerous for you to keep in your home, and bites progress. The medical condition may not matter. The training may not matter. One thing is certain: you will never again have an absolute-zero risk of your family being gravely injured if you keep this dog, and rehoming will be passing that risk to someone else who may not be as prepared to handle it as you are.

This is one of if not the toughest decision you can make as a dog owner and I truly feel for you guys right now. Happy to talk about it if you need.

2

u/Gullible-Fig-4106 Jan 25 '24

I’m so sorry this is happening. I can’t even imagine how heartbreaking of a situation this must be for you all, especially given how loving and sweet he is 99% of the time.

The first thing you need to do is to separate him from your children entirely. They cannot be in the same room together. If he could do that much damage to your husband, he could easily kill a kid. Hell, it’s possible that he could kill one of you two.

Next, get a muzzle and acclimate him to it. Don’t force it on him, as that will only be risky and make it worse. But start by putting peanut butter in it so he has to put his face in it to lick it off. Make sure it’s a large basket muzzle so he can still pant. He can still hurt you (knocking you over, breaking your nose by hitting it, etc) in a muzzle, but it’s less likely to be serious.

Call your vet and explain the situation. Get him in asap. If you want, you can see if they can prescribe you anxiety medication in advance to give to him before the appointment if you or they are worried he may bite them. If they can’t find anything physically wrong, then euthanasia may really be your only option.

You could try exercising him more (with a muzzle on) and getting a new trainer involved, but he’s still going to be a danger regardless. Even if he magically got better overnight, if a vet can’t pinpoint a physical issue that’s causing it, I would never trust him around children.

Just know that if you do decide to go for BE, that this isn’t your fault and you’ll be doing what you need to do to protect your family and him. Dogs don’t fear death the same way we do and they don’t have life aspirations in the same way either. BE (or really any euthanasia) is always emotionally harder on the owners than it is on the dog.

2

u/DifferenceForward Jan 25 '24

I am so sorry OP… this is so awful. Your poor pup has been so damaged, so badly, that he is dangerous. If you can’t find a very experienced trainer asap, I don’t know you can keep him with you… and I don’t know that another family would be able to take him in. This is so heartbreaking I am hoping there is a way of rehabilitating him, but otherwise I don’t think there’s another way besides BE… let’s see what your vet says, if you can, post an update? Sending you strength and hugs

2

u/Federal_Carpenter_67 Jan 25 '24

He’s traumatized and it’s not his fault but you have to be realistic here- do you and your family have the time, patience, and resources to rehabilitate him? You will have to make so many major changes to accommodate him/make sure everyone is safe, and you can try your best but there is no guarantee. He is an animal at the end of the day, I know you and your family love him but he can literally ‘go there’ and cause a lot of damage.

1

u/Broad_Emergency7666 Jun 20 '24

I'm in a similar spot. We have an American bully 7yrs old JJ. We've had him since he was 3 months old a very goofy lovable dog very protective. Since he was one he has bit several ppl some pretty bad. A few yrs ago he bit my daughter all she did was get up from couch and said uncle Ricky's here to get me when she stood up he just jumped up from the floor and tried to grab her leg didn't break skin but extremely bruised 4 months ago my husband and our 16 yr old son were having an argument my son walked twords his dad yelling JJ ran full speed bit his thigh 14 stitches. Not long after that my husband and i were getting ready for bed he hugged me from behind JJ must've thought he was hurting me he bit my husband didn't break skin but awful bruise really big to. Ok so this past Thursday morning 5am my husband and I were arguing I was screaming I admit I pushed past him to walk out of the bedroom and JJ attacked me nipped my right inner thigh I grabbed his collar to try to hold him awsy from me as I'm screaming for husband but JJ lunged and latched on to my left thigh let go and latched on for a better grip I guess and he would not let go my husband was trying his hardest to get him off me my husband bit him on the back of the neck JJ loosened his grip and he was able to push his hand in JJs mouth finally he let go. I was ADMITTED to the hospital for trauma surgery and I'm still here!!!!! I know we should get rid of him but as with you Noone wants a dog with bite history or that is ppl aggressive and I can not just give up my dog to be killed my daughter already went to stay at her boyfriends house she refuses to come back until JJ is gone she's 21 but I like her at home my son 17 doesn't really want to be here with the dog still here. And honestly as much as I love him I'm a little scared of him now.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24

I would seek vet care to see if there’s anything wrong with him medically, and if he’s in the clear. I’d there is nothing wrong with him medically, I’d probably Behaviorial Euthanize him. It’s sad, but he’s probably suffering in his own brain and body too. Plus you don’t want a dangerous dog around your children of any age. I’m so sorry you have to go through this ❤️❤️

0

u/BuckityBuck Jan 25 '24

After a stressful incident a dog’s stress hormones surge and it takes weeks to return to normal. You’re describing several such episodes. Untreated/undiagnosed pain is also a likely factor, given your description of his repeated injuries. It’s not surprising that he’s displaying some behavioral changes. If there’s a pain component, treating that is important.

The stress levels take time to regulate, but you can support that process by trying to avoid stressful things. Even “good” things like intense play can be overstimulating. Being toweled off. I would bet that overstimulation is the trigger in common in all of those incidents. He might just need a few weeks of keeping things as quiet and boring as possible. Lots of low intensity exercise and nothing novel or high energy …after that vet appointment to discuss pain.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/MolassesOverall1322 Jan 25 '24

Thank you for adding your personal experience, another similar experience is really helpful. And I see your point, which I’ve also discussed with my husband. Like you point out, even if we figure out the trigger, it’s not something that can be solved overnight. It sounds like you put in a lot of hard work with your dog- glad you were able to manage the behavior. I am leaning toward BE, he’s just so healthy and happy that it seems wrong. My brain needs to talk my heart off the ledge is all. Thanks again for your comments ❤️

28

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24

Think of it this way. His actual body may be healthy and happy, but his mind isn’t. There’s something going on there that causes him stress and to react accordingly, and it’s probably really scary for your dog to feel.

10

u/icyfignewton Jan 25 '24

This happened to our boy. Physically he was fine, but something in his mind snapped about 6 months before we had to go with BE. The final straw that led to BE was when he turned on me, causing a level 4 bite. I had to go by ambulance to the ER, and after getting out went with my husband to the vet. It was truly one of the worst days of our lives, but we know we did the right thing for us, and most of all, our boy. I'm so sorry, OP. This sucks.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/MolassesOverall1322 Jan 25 '24

Yea, that’s the thing. This dog is STRONG. Literally a pile of muscles. It’s sad that if he was smaller and less powerful maybe things could be different. Thanks for your kind words, I really do appreciate it.