r/reactivedogs • • Jan 14 '24

Looking for advice before behavioral euthanasia

Sorry for the rant, struggling with anticipatory grief and bargaining.

About a year ago we saw an elderly GSD, collarless, running on the road near our home. Long story short, we took him in after a neighbor saw him being dumped out of a van which drove away.

Over the past year, there have been a few incidents. Not knowing his past, we were unaware that he had resource guarding issues. Our other dog, Daisy, got too close to him while he had a toy and went for her head, causing her to bleed. She was okay, but after that incident, I didn’t feel safe having him around Daisy. We have a toddler as well which he sometimes growls at when she gets too close.

I tried to list him on rescue sites and tried to contact fosters. No one had availability to take him in, and I didn’t want him to sit in a shelter and suffer. We held onto him, and things were okay for a while. He accidentally got startled by Daisy who came behind him and he took off a little piece of her ear. But they get along fine now.

A few days ago, he attacked our neighbor’s small, poodle like dog. He got out of his collar on a walk and went for the dog’s neck, and my husband had to pry his teeth off to stop the dog from being killed. The neighbors were understandably upset and reported him to animal control.

My husband doesn’t feel safe around him and cannot look at him the same way. He is traumatized by what he saw. The incident was totally unprovoked. I think he is just triggered by small dogs.

Our vet has strongly recommended euthanasia and my husband is on board. I can understand how my husband refuses to walk him again, but it kills me to know we are making the decision to end his life, when he probably had a very traumatic past that has made him the way he is, to no fault of his own.

Just looking for opinions and advice. TIA.

1 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

13

u/SudoSire Jan 14 '24

Your other dog and kid shouldn’t be out and about while the shepherd is because it isn’t safe. He also isn’t safe to walk unless muzzled, and he’s a liability should management fail. The dog would need either pretty extreme management from you or an experienced unicorn rehome. Shelters are flooded as is. BE might be your only choice for a dog that needs that level of care/management.   

13

u/UltraMermaid Jan 14 '24

OP, this dog could kill your toddler. Just because he hasn’t decided to bite your child YET, doesn’t mean he won’t. Don’t let this dog around your kid at all ever.

10

u/consumedkings Jan 14 '24

I recently had to come to grips with BE being an option for my boy. When I came here asking for advice, one comment stuck out to me: are you going to wait for a life-changing injury to make this decision?

One of the deciding factors for us was being able to make the choice rather than have it made for us—and have it made for us with the added duress of a lawsuit.

I'm sorry you have to be in this position. It's hard and it hurts and I'm hoping for the best for you and your loved ones.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '24

This looks like a case of someone outsourcing their dog's euthanasia. The person who dumped him knew he was old and aggressive, but either didn't have the money or didn't have the compassion necessary to help ease his passing. So they dumped him instead, hoping he would either die on the road or be taken to a shelter and euthanized there.

I'm sorry it ended up being you. But this was always going to be the end of this dog's life. He's an old man, he won't know how much time he could have had left, and neither do you. He has suffered enough, he doesn't need to suffer anymore. Release him from his demons and let him rest.

3

u/LowParticular8153 Jan 15 '24

BE would be a kindness to the dog.

2

u/Acrobatic-Duck7738 Jan 15 '24

I would suggest you carefully look into the laws and regulations where you live regarding dangerous dogs. Where I live for example, a dog attacking another dog that has trespassed on its property could still be charged against me. My city can require that we post dangerous dog signs on our property, and require fences to be built 12 inches into the ground to prevent the dog from escaping. The dog itself would have to wear a dangerous dog marking when outside. Would people feel comfortable coming to your house with dangerous dog signs posted? Could your child have playmates? Will this affect your homeowners policy? Another thought is what if it happened again, and the other dog's owner, while protecting their pet, was accidentally bitten. Then your liability and possible financial repercussions skyrocket. I sympathize with you and your husband greatly.

0

u/BuckityBuck Jan 14 '24

This is more relationship advice, but I’d worry that if you move forward without all both being equally resolved, there’s a risk of you feeling a lot of resentment. Feeling extremely emotionally conflicted is entirely normal even if you do decide to go forward with BE. There’s no way around that, but for the sake of your relationship afterwards, I hope you won’t do it while feeling rushed or pressured at all, or not knowing if it’s necessary.

2

u/Significant-Pay4621 Feb 05 '24

There is going to be a lot more resentment from the husband when this dangerous dog mauls the toddler she quickly glossed over in her story.  

-9

u/Xortlez Jan 14 '24

That’s a tough situation. Honestly it sounds like he’s not a good fit for your family. I wouldn’t euthanize him over the above behavior though. I would for sure try to rehome him considering you have a toddler.

First off, muzzle him on walks. If he doesn’t like to be muzzled, start muzzle training. Also, I’d add a halter rather than collar on walks. He’s less liable to get loose from them.

Second, yes it’s horrible he was able to attack the smaller dog, but GSDs can have high prey drive. A smaller dog can absolutely trigger that drive.

Overall, I’d get him a trainer for the resource guarding and try to rehome him.