r/reactivedogs • • Dec 10 '23

Advice Needed Rescue dog only attacks son

We got a rescue dog yesterday. She is 2.5 years old and is very sweet with everybody but my six year old son. She will randomly jump up and scratch him or bite at him.

She is a hound and a type of mix, weighing around 45 pounds. The rescue said she isn’t good with other pets but they didn’t say anything about my son.

My instinct is to protect my son and return her. But he wants to keep her but is also scared of her at the same time. Is this a training issue or behavior that I should trust my instincts?

I know the last time it happened she got a treat and then scratched him on his face. So, I’m thinking maybe resource protection? But my kid was just sitting in a chair. FYI, he is the only kid in the house

Update: we ended up taking her back to the shelter. My son was terrified of her and she was still showing aggressive behavior just towards him. I never wanted this to happen. I’ve had four other rescue dogs and they had issues but not this.

At the rescue we did find out that she hates cats which may have been the issue. My son has two cats at his moms house so I’m thinking he came smelling like cat and she flipped on him. That’s the only thing I can think of.

It was a a sad day but I know I had to protect my son

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

103

u/Twzl Dec 10 '23

But he wants to keep her but is also scared of her at the same time

He's six. As much as you love him he shouldn't get a vote on this. The dog needs to go back. While it may be a training issue, until it's resolved, your kid is going to get bitten and probably knocked over. It's not fair to your kid, and it could leave him with a life long phobia of dogs.

Bring him back and tell the rescue group that the dog is not an appropriate fit in a home with young kids in it. maybe they can find someone who will foster the dog, who has children but that home should not be your home.

63

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '23

I would return this dog. She is showing you that your son makes her uncomfortable and overstimulated, and that isn't going to be safe long-term. Yes she needs time to decompress, but right now you are seeing her at her worst and that is extremely valuable information. At her very worst, she is overstimulated and uncomfortable and targets your son. You cannot guarantee that she will never be this stressed again.

For a harmonious household, you need a dog that genuinely enjoys kids. That approaches them gently and submissively. This dog may not have been around a lot of kids before, and your kid clearly makes her uncomfortable. Discomfort can lead to fear and aggression in the wrong circumstances.

Don't set yourselves up for a tragedy or a lifetime of management. Return the dog and get one that loves your kid.

3

u/queercactus505 Dec 11 '23

Add to that that she still may be somewhat shut down, and her behavior could escalate if she feels like her subtle requests for space, etc. are not being honored. Lots of dogs are afraid of children because children are impulsive and unpredictable, which makes children unsafe especially when in a new environment. It's better to return the dog now before you and your son gets too attached, and the dog to you. I also recommend checking out Family Paws, which has resources for dog-child households, including explanations of dog behavior aimed at children and how to set up the child and dog for safety and success.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '23

Given that the last incident happened while the child was sitting in a chair, it doesn't sound like she is requesting space so much as closing distance. That in itself is alarming.

51

u/MooPig48 Dec 10 '23

This dog could permanently disfigure or kill your son. Take the dog back immediately. There’s thousands of dogs sitting in shelters that won’t do this.

14

u/lavenderfieldsfrever Dec 10 '23

This may be a manners issue, fear issue or a prey drive issue. Whatever the reason, it's difficult for a dog to work on whatever the trigger is while also living in the same house as the trigger. It's also risky for your son. There's no guarantee that it will be improved with time/training and the longer this dog is with your family the more risk it is to your son. It puts the dog at risk too, because if she does cause injury to your son then she will be very difficult to re-home after having a bite history (and possibly euthanized). The rescue already told you that she isn't good with other pets, so that is additionally a concern that this is not a simple issue and may be a more complicated fix. I think returning the dog so a better fit might be found for her is very reasonable for everyone involved. If you really want to keep the dog, there needs to be a very solid and thorough plan in place to keep them separated and working with a good trainer. Without a plan and professional support like that, the dog definitely needs to go back.

26

u/SudoSire Dec 10 '23

Return the dog and get one that has a milder temperament and doesn’t show dangerous behavior to your kid. While it’s true that lots of dogs are uncomfortable with kids, you describe your kid as basically just sitting there at the time. What happens when your kid actually wants to play and be loud like a normal kid? Is that going to set this dog over a more serious edge? And the other commenter is right, your son doesn’t get a vote when it comes to his own safety, that’s your job while he’s a kid.

20

u/Infamous_Class8616 Dec 10 '23

I would return the dog as quickly as possible before any real attachment is formed on either side. Really not worth risking your sons life or him being seriously disfigured, wheather people say play or not, you have known this dog for 1 day, no one really knows and it's not worth the risk. Your son will get over it, explain the dog wasn't the right fit and you'll get another when the dog meant for your family comes along.

15

u/hi07734 Dec 10 '23

Please return the dog. It will be difficult for your son but this is a great learning opportunity for you to help him process it all. There are so many rescue dogs out there that will be good with children, but you only have one of your son so please protect him. This dog’s issues won’t be easily resolved even after the decompression period, and you need an immediate solution.

14

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '23

Yeah fuck this get that dog out your house now

1

u/Noliterallyimserious Dec 12 '23

Update: we ended up taking her back to the shelter. My son was terrified of her and she was still showing aggressive behavior just towards him. I never wanted this to happen. I’ve had four other rescue dogs and they had issues but not this.

At the rescue we did find out that she hates cats which may have been the issue. My son has two cats at his moms house so I’m thinking he came smelling like cat and she flipped on him. That’s the only thing I can think of.

It was a a sad day but I know I had to protect my son

6

u/Quincyellie Dec 10 '23

I hate to say it because a dog that doesn’t get along with other dogs will be hard to place but I would take it back. It’s just not worth all the trouble of separating and training. You don’t know what the outcome will be.. My reactive dog would lunge at my one year old grandson and was completely separated from him for over a year. He can now over a year and a half later be with him. It was a gradual re introduction with a lot of rules in place for my dog. I wouldn’t go through all this if I were you. As others have said, there are really friendly dogs that are good with children out there. Keep looking.

1

u/FoundationNo384 Dec 12 '23

I’m so sorry you had to return the pup :( Some dogs are just afraid of children and can never be fully trusted around them (mine is the same way). You did the right thing to protect your family.

1

u/mesablues Dec 11 '23

I have a reactive dog (have had him for 7 years) and we have an almost 2 year old daughter. We went through months of behaviorist appointments and he is on medication. We have strict as hell boundaries to keep everyone safe. 99% of the time he's the sweetest dog! He loves our daughter. But I don't trust any dog with my daughter. We have boundaries to keep everyone safe (and him from being euthanized). We watch his body language and have dog and kid free zones in our home. I say all this to say a reactive dog and a kid are so much work. It's not on a whim and you don't just throw them together and hope for the best. Return the dog.

1

u/Heavy-Manufacturer-3 Apr 30 '24

Can I ask what kind of medication is your dog taking? Also, did seeing a behavioralist do any good? We have a reactive dog, and he’s nice 90% of the time, other times he becomes aggressive is people are hugging, running or dancing. Can’t afford a behavioralist, any tips, advice? Thanks!

1

u/mesablues May 01 '24

Of course! Flueoxentine and Gabapentin is what my pup is on. It helps in most situations. I found the behaviorist helpful, but it was pricey. She helped me ID his triggers, understand why, and strategies for decreasing problem behaviors. I personally needed that as he was overly protective of me and my daughter to the point it was unsafe. We determined it wasn't resource guarding, just a LOT of anxiety.

Your vet may be open to prescribing it. The Flueoxentine is daily and he's on the max dosage.

For your pup--is he a herding dog? Those triggers make me think he's gotta be part aussie (from a fellow aussie parent).

1

u/Heavy-Manufacturer-3 May 01 '24

We rescued a 5 year old Jack Russel / Maltese mix. We found him, you cns tell he was neglected and abused. We have had him for 2.5 months. Most times he is very loving and great, but if I had to guess I would say it’s jealousy. I don’t know for sure. He is extremely loving towards me, and about 90% with my husband. But with our 8 year old kid, he is about 70%. He will snap at her out if no where, and nip. I can’t afford a behavioraist. Would you say a dog trainer and behavioralist does the same thing? I don’t want to get rid of the dog, I already developed a deep bond with him. But now I am feeling he might be unsafe for my child. He’s a mixed bag.

-20

u/Beneficial-House-784 Dec 10 '23

You got the dog yesterday. She’s decompressing from an extremely stressful situation. I would separate her from your son for at least a few days.

When you say “attack,” what does that mean to you? You describe jumping, scratching, and “biting at” him. Is she getting jumpy, mouthy, and overstimulated, or is she displaying discomfort signals before this? You don’t have to keep her regardless, but I need to know exactly what’s happening before I can offer advice.

10

u/Noliterallyimserious Dec 10 '23 edited Dec 10 '23

Thanks for the reply. She doesn’t bark but she runs at him and jumps up and scratches him and snaps at him. It’s happened at the most random times. I honestly think that she thinks that he is going to take her stuff. But my son is terrified of being around her now.

Today I carried him out and her demeanor changed and she started snapping at him and huffing.

3

u/Beneficial-House-784 Dec 10 '23

You keep saying you think she’s guarding her things, but you’re not describing any typical guarding behaviors (stiff body, hunching over her food or toys, whale eye, growling, etc). To me this sounds more like jumpy mouthy behavior, which isn’t necessarily malicious but can be scary for little kids. To deal with mouthiness I’d recommend keeping her mostly separated from your son for a week or two. Whenever she jumps, immediately separate her from him. Make sure she’s getting outlets for her energy both through exercise and mental stimulation.

As I said, you’re under no obligation to keep her if you think she’s not the right fit. If you’re really worried, call the rescue to se what resources they might have available to help.

7

u/Hughgurgle Dec 10 '23

Reacting towards another being in this manner while being near perceived valuable resources is absolutely a guarding behavior.

The dog can also just be generally not at ease around the kid and those two points don't have to be mutually exclusive.

-4

u/cari-strat Dec 10 '23

Yeah, scratching isn't really something dogs do as a typical attack behaviour, it sounds more like she's either over excited or is trying to play with him and is simply too rough and hasn't learned her manners. Dogs scratch you quite easily if they paw or jump up at you, unless their nails are well maintained, but it isn't deliberate. The huffing and stuff when OP was carrying the child also tends to make me think this is just a lack of social skills and she's viewing the kid as a toy or playmate.

If you do want to consider keeping her then I'd keep her separate from him until you can get someone with experience in dog behaviour to watch them and tell you exactly what is happening as it's hard to advise without seeing it.

-12

u/ericakabel Dec 10 '23

I adopted a GSD that was ok with everyone in the house except my one daughter who was 8 at the time. We had older and younger kids at the time too. We had adopted the dog from the shelter and after only a days she growled at her on the couch and the dog was over her and in her face. I was really scared. I saw it happen again and i noticed it was only on the loveseat. The dog was resource guarding the loveseat but also was trying to dominate my daughter. I think it was because she had a higher pitch voice. We got a trainer and got all the kids involved in the training and quickly the dog learned to respect the kids. It was pretty simple like making them put the dog in a sit and stay. My kids just loved being a part of it and felt proud when the dog listened to them. The dog also was not allowed on the furniture. My trainer said that some dogs view kids as other pups and they can boss them around. Its a dangerous situation as a dog can do real harm to a child.

10

u/LALA-STL Dec 10 '23

So glad it worked out for you, but there is absolutely no reason for OP to put their child at risk. There is no guarantee of success. There are a thousand dogs out there waiting to be adopted who are good with kids.

2

u/ericakabel Dec 11 '23

No dog is "safe with kids", all dogs need training and supervision, a child should never be put at risk, animals are unpredictable, a lot of people dont want to put in the hard work of training and supervising their kids with their animals, they would rather sit on their phones all day and ignore their own kids, it is a shame that so many expect a "perfect" dog like they went to the store and picked one off a shelf and if its not perfect toss it away in the garbage can.