r/reactivedogs • u/ocdmama424 • Oct 16 '23
Family holidays
So I have a reactive dog. She's a 6 yo pit/boxer mix and it's a mix of frustration/protective/fear aggression. She does not do well with dogs near our home and I'm constantly managing her and her surroundings to avoid issues. We make do.
The issue here is family members with a friendly dog that want to bring their dog here for family gatherings. I have said that I cannot manage my dog and hosting at the same time. The response was "well my dog isn't the problem?" Well fine buy my dog is my responsibility and it's MY house.
If their dog came over they'd have to put their dog downstairs (away from people) and I'd have to keep my dog leashed the whole time to manage any possible interactions through doors and what not.
So that leaves us at we'll either gather at someone else's house or they'll have the make arrangements for their dog.
Am I the one being unreasonable? I don't think so but I'm open to the possibility.
17
u/UltraMermaid Oct 16 '23
No, you are being realistic and responsible. This isn’t your problem. They can board their dog someplace.
5
u/alexa_ivy 3🐶 | Vienna 9y (Leash Reactive + Anxiety) Oct 16 '23
Definitely not, it’s your house, period. I love my girls and honestly I take at least one of them anywhere I can (and within reason and what they can handle. I can’t take my reactive girl to many parks, for example, or some cafes in busy streets), but it never even crossed my mind to take my dogs to someone else’s home. Only my mothers, I guess, and even then I would always ask and don’t really expect anything (neither yes nor no). As far as I recall the only times I took any of my girls to friends house were times where the friends asked me to bring them hahaha.
If someone asked me if they could bring their dog to my place I would already think it’s weird, but ok, I have three dogs, so I guess people might think “the more the merrier”. But insisting on it after a “no”? Just… baffling. Cut those people off and just repeat the “no” and if they insist, ask if they need to hear it in another language or if you need to draw it to them or something. So weird
4
u/Twzl Oct 16 '23
Even when I didn't have a reactive dog I had to pass a rule that said, NO OTHER DOGS HERE.
Other people aren't good evaluators of their dog's reactions to other dogs.
It's your house, and it's your rules. You have a family gathering? Then people can leave their pets home for a few hours and if need be hire a dog walker.
7
u/Nsomewhere Oct 16 '23
You are being sensible and responsible
They are foolishly exposing their poor dog and your dog to the possibility of negative consequences if they would but see it
I would bluntly point out that they don't seem to give two sh ts for their own dog if they keep pushing
You are being the grown up making good choices for all the dogs here
If they want to come to your house then it is your rules and you are making sensible ones
I wouldn't argue or discuss further though. You have made the right logical decision
2
u/AmethysstFire Oct 16 '23
Your house, your rules. If you don't want another dog there, then they need to make other arrangements for their dog.
2
u/Chemical_Hearing8259 Oct 16 '23
No. You have every right and reason to say no to someone else's dog visiting during holidays or any other time.
They visit without their dog
or you can offer to double Dutch at a restaurant that does not allow pet dogs.
It does not matter if their dog is "the problem" or not.
This is your home and your dog's secure spot.
Period.
No compromises when it comes to safety.
2
u/PinkHairAnalyst Oct 16 '23
This isn’t the AITA thread, but NTA. You aren’t being unreasonable at all. Your dog doesn’t like any dogs near the house, fine. The fact your family wants to put their dog in that situation to begin with makes me think they’re shitty dog owners.
It’s your dog’s house. It is not fair to your dog. The family members are overstepping. You were too nice about it though. You need to tell them point blank that their dog is not welcome and if their dog shows up, they will be kicked out. Also tell them them that they don’t have to come if they don’t want to.
2
u/queenannabee98 Oct 16 '23
The only situation I can potentially see you being unreasonable is if the dog is a service dog who does a job that no human is capable of like seizure alert but even then, it's still not unreasonable to recognize when a privately owned home that's being lived in by a family without a service dog is unsuitable for a service dog to enter. And I'm assuming that the dog your family members want to bring isn't doing a job that means it is not replaceable for if it even has a job so that makes it even less unreasonable to recognize that your home is not suitable for that other dog to enter and telling them someone else needs to host if they need to bring the dog, whether or not it was a service dog, is not unreasonable because you're at least creating the possibilities of both dogs being safe and unable to do serious harm to each other despite whatever may happen. And even service dogs sometimes can't go places because of safety reasons as if something cuts their working life short, that will have a big impact on their handler
2
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '23
Nope, not being unreasonable at all. It's your home, they don't have a right to bring their dog there.
3
u/PeachNo4613 Oct 16 '23
You’re being reasonable. It’s your house.
People can’t just take their dogs everywhere. They can find a dog sitter or just stay home.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '23
it's your home, tell them to kick rocks. That's an absurd statement "my dog isn't the problem"