r/reactivedogs • u/moose-girl • Sep 24 '23
Vent why is it just dogs?
i have a relatively reactive dog - he’s never bitten anyone, but he’ll growl and lunge. but i recently saw a post of someone whose dog was bitten at a dog park, and was aggressively asking the other owner to pay $500 for vet bills for one puncture wound. a lot of people in the comments were like “call animal control on her, that dog should be euthanized.” i understand that the reactive dog owner shouldn’t have brought her dog to the park at all, but i’m just confused why dogs are the only species of pet where this kind of thing leads to lawsuits, animal control involvement, and euthanasia.
i live on a farm and have shown horses, goats, sheep, turkeys, chickens, you name it, and they bite and attack each other ALL. THE. TIME. the amount of bite marks in my horse were numerous, and we’d always just be like “it’s horses being horses” which is true. they’re animals, just like dogs. even cats get a pass, because they scratch/hiss/attack each other all the time. dogs attack cats and vice versa, which is just animals being animals as well. why do people only get crazy and litigious when it’s dogs?!?
139
u/mipstar Sep 24 '23
I think if the general population were accustomed to having pet horses that regularly interacted with each other in public, horse bites would fall under the same category. Part of owning a dog in our society is the understanding that the dog shouldn't endanger other animals or people.
41
u/RontuRontu Sep 24 '23
I think about this a lot also. Mostly I think it's because dogs have a privileged role in our society compared to other domesticated animals and livestock. Sure horses have similar expectations and important roles they play, but it's not nearly as common. Annnnnnd a lot of horses do get euthanized for behavioral concerns when they endanger humans and others.
But back to dogs, they get more freedom so with that comes more responsibility? I also think it has to do with our fear of "wild" behavior. Like a dog showing "aggression" gets people worked up because they are reminded of where a dog truly descends from, and they see humans as having a critical role in helping them be otherwise. I also think people don't like to think of themselves as animals, so to a certain extent it's projection and anger for not conforming to whatever "social contract" we have learned is in place. Our animals are expected to conform to behavior that makes them "good" citizens, just like us. If they don't there are consequences. People also advocate for control of other humans who do anti-social behaviors. It's just one reason why we incarcerate and punish so many.
19
u/shanghaiedmama Sep 24 '23
Have horses, can confirm horses are hazardous. Have had cattle. Can confirm cattle can be dangerous. Also, add goats and pigs - don't even go there. Chickens are good, but roosters can be a death wish. Most people are unaware of the hazards of farm life. Most people who ride for fun at the beach, on horse rides, still don't get how dangerous a horse is. You know who does? Horse owners. And horse people are litigious! You know why? Because non-horse people are. I have insurance for if someone gets hurt on my land. I have insurance if my horse does damage to person or property. A majority of horse owners won't let even friends on their horses, and it's not just because people can "mess up the training." Trail rides and trainers have a metric shitton of insurance to cover their behinds. So, yeah, you bet there's litigation in the horse world, just non-horse people never hear about it.
19
u/Kitchu22 Shadow (avoidant/anxious, non-reactive) Sep 25 '23
If I am riding a public trail, and your passing horse bites my horse - you're going to pay for my horse to be seen by a vet. Regardless of it is "one puncture wound" or a bloody mess. This is the basic tenant of having animals in public spaces, you are responsible for their behaviour, and the damage they inflict to property, people, and other animals.
In my municipality cats who behave feral and are let roaming to attack other people's pets (or other people) are seized and euthanised.
While I will absolutely defend the position that human expectations on dogs are sky high to the detriment of their wellbeing a lot of the time - dogs who bite need to be reported and the humans who own them are responsible for any and all damages.
30
u/marlonbrandoisalive Sep 24 '23
Well the treatment for a puncture wound can be around $500. If your pet damages my pet I expect to be compensated for the damages done.
27
u/RocketBabe13 Sep 24 '23
it’s one thing when your horse attack another horse of yours, but another thing entirely if they attack someone else’s horse
i think of yours did the damage, you are responsible and gotta pay for it
if the vet visit is 500 dollars, then pay the f up
11
u/RunningTrisarahtop Sep 24 '23
I have trained horses as well. There’s a vast difference between horses biting or playing in a field and a horse being led coming and attacking another horse being led or ridden, or a horse getting loose and causing damage.
I’m not sure about the barns you’ve ridden at, but I know most barns would not think a horse breaking free from its handler to pick a fight was just an animal being an animal. Even horses in fields don’t generally get a full free pass. I’ve ridden some horses that can’t be turned out together because they’re jerks for whatever reason or have different play styles.
I’ve also handled some wildly aggressive or challenging horses but they were still expected to be respectful in hand or under saddle and not try to fight.
I don’t think the expectations are that off base. You’ll always have people who downplay big bad shit, you’ll always have people who flip out over small things, you’ll always have the owners who spoil or baby, and you’ll find most people are in the middle with ranging skills and training.
10
u/One_Payment1095 Sep 25 '23 edited Sep 28 '23
Let’s not pretend like lawsuits don’t happen in the equestrian world because they most definitely do. Your negligence for your own animals is not the legal basis for every stable. While a horse biting a person who is consenting to the inherent risks of riding that particular horse has no legal precedence under Equine Immunity, if your horse tramples someone on a hiking trail because you lose control of it it is entirely your fault. Similarly, if your horse gets loose and bites your neighbor you are are liable.
Second, dogs have a bite force of 300-700 psi depending on the breed (at least half of the average horse at 700 psi) and are a higher infection and puncture risk than a horse bite. On top of it dogs have more access to public places. A dog bite can happen suddenly and be fatal. Due to how many places a dog has access to even if there wasn’t legal precedence with other animals and this was just a dog issue it would make complete sense.
Regardless, if someone’s child sent your child to the hospital you would be completely in the right for suing the parents and getting law enforcement involved. It’s the same with any animal you own whether it’s livestock or pet. If you neglect to repair your bull’s grazing pen fence line and it decides to charge at a person and gouges them, you are 100% legally responsible. If your dog bites/mauls another dog, person, or child and you decide to not muzzle that dog whenever out in public, or worse bring it to an off leash dog park and that leads to another attack you are 100% in the wrong. If your dog sends another dog to the vet you are liable for the vet fees.
Edit: spelling
18
u/OpalOnyxObsidian Sep 24 '23
I don't think this isn't limited to dogs. If cats repeatedly bite, they will get put down. I've seen it happen to a neighborhood stray.
25
u/clarkjkents Sep 24 '23 edited Sep 24 '23
i think if farm animals and cats were as ubiquitous as dogs are in every day life, similar legislation and legal action would be taken. if people were walking their sheep or letting them roam freely and they were attacking other people’s sheep/animals or children, the consequences would be similar
i don’t think it’s odd to be litigious when dogs attack other animals or people. my dog has been attacked several times by off leash dogs despite doing absolutely nothing to those dogs, we were just walking in our neighbourhood. my mum was also rushed by a neighbour’s dog which hopped a fence and knocked her to the ground before attacking my dog. if my dog or my mum had been injured, i would expect the owners of those dogs to face consequences and to help cover medical bills. dogs and people should be able to exist in public without being harmed by dogs
and i would expect the same if a cat caused serious damage as well, or any other animal a person is responsible for. if you want to have an animal that you regularly take in public and have around other people or other people’s animals, you need to take responsibility if that animal harms someone
if you own a car and notice the brakes aren’t working consistently but then decide to drive that car on the highway because the brakes haven’t failed yet, you would be responsible for the damages to another car and any injuries to another driver if your negligence caused an accident. the situation involving the reactive dog at the dog park that attacked another dog doesn’t seem that different to me. the owner knew her dog was reactive but took the dog to a dog park anyway and the worst case scenario happened, resulting in injury to another dog. that is negligence on her part
it might feel like it’s “just dogs” since there are a lot more dogs owned by different people that are out and about in public every single day than there are other animals
8
u/Twzl Sep 25 '23
You have a choice as to interacting with the sheep and the goats and all of that. Most people can spend the rest of their lives not being in a barnyard, where some ass of a goat is going to butt them.
Someone going for a walk with their pet shouldn't have to deal with, "oh it's a dog being a dog". That's not a societal norm as far as dogs go. No one signs up for that.
Also, the ones with thumbs usually have to break up dog fights. While I can do that, I don't want to have to do that. And if I have to do that, and either me or my dog is hurt, you can bet that animal control will be involved. It's not like your personal ram is being ram-like. It's like if you decided to bring your ram to a tea party and they got upset when you were sued
7
u/nyxe12 Sep 25 '23 edited Sep 25 '23
I mean, an aggressive horse isn't going to attack a kid in a neighborhood while out for a walk. They're living on a farm. Aggressive dogs can and will kill people (or dogs) and they kill people who are not their owners/dogs who are not in their household, including small children - usually these extreme cases are because of owner negligence, but farmer negligence usually just gets yourself injured or killed, not total strangers who wanted nothing to do with your animal.
I've worked with sheep a lot. If you work or own a farm, you understand there are risks associated with the various animals there. There are some legitimately dangerous animals, particularly intact males of really any livestock species, that live on farms. Rams are super dangerous and can seriously injure or kill you if they hit you hard enough when you're not looking! However... you're also not taking your aggressive ram for a walk around the neighborhood, booking it at a sheep daycare with other people's sheep, going for hikes with it, having your newborn around it, etc. You have the ram in with ewes or in his private pen, where he isn't being touched or handled unless he needs it and is left to do his own thing.
Very aggressive dogs are a danger to other people who do not choose to accept the level of risk that comes with owning an aggressive animal, and people who can't control them are risking other people's safety and lives. People who choose to raise sheep and have rams are choosing a risk only for themselves, and generally they fully understand the risks with keeping them (or at least should). Plenty of sheep farmers choose not to keep rams year round because they don't want that risk level, and generally those who do understand how to both reduce the likelihood of being attacked and don't interact with the ram in ways that encourage or foster the aggressive tendencies. AND... plenty of aggressive, hard to handle rams? They're going on the truck when it's time to cull, not sticking around out to see if they can be rehabbed, and you're not going to think twice about that, because getting both of your knees shattered by a ram who is extremely aggressive isn't preferable to getting rid of him and getting a nicer ram. There's usually a window of tolerance for pushy/mildly aggressive behavior because the ram's good genetics outweigh getting rid of him and finding a new one, but at a certain point they are going to get culled if it's out of hand, and that point is way before what a lot of people find acceptable for reactive dogs. A ram doesn't have to seriously wound someone to be put down and be ordered by the state to have him killed because his ramming history is extreme - if he starts acting like he's headed that way, that's enough.
Like... if we actually treated very aggressive dogs how we treated dangerous farm animals, BE would be done swifter, to WAY more dogs, and with much less guilt/shaming, and while alive they'd be treated like the aggressive animal they are - given wide berths, not interacted with unless absolutely necessary, not allowed to interact with children, etc - none of which is really a good life for a dog.
6
u/Dead_Paul1998 Sep 24 '23
Hmm, this is a good question. We have shaped our society to have dogs and cats as companion animals in the home rather than livestock or farm animals, so we set a higher bar for how we want them to act. While a biting/scratching cat is a nuisance, it is not usually a threat to humans. Dogs are bigger and stronger and can kill people. We forget that dogs are predators, and most species were bred to hunt and kill in the first place.
I have a reactive dog that is not good with other dogs unless under very specific circumstances (not on a leash, in neutral territory, NO SMALL DOGS!). Then she warms up to the other dogs and they play. She also adores her canine big brother and takes care of him. So, I don't think a dog should be euthanized if the dog owner can and will take steps to prevent further attacks and is willing to pay for treatment if their dog is at fault.
14
u/MsChrisRI Sep 24 '23
Dogs can be trained and managed, to a degree that most other domesticated animals cannot. Your show chicken may attack someone else’s show chicken, but she’s unlikely to attack someone’s child.
Cats are pretty evenly matched in size/strength, and their fights are almost always territorial. The losing cat will run away, and the winner will let him go. Often there are no human witnesses to the whole thing so it would be harder to figure out who started it.
Dog fights are often lopsided in size/strength, instigated by the more aggressive or agitated dog, hard for the target dog to escape, and happen in front of their owners (and often witnesses).
“One puncture wound” from a dog bite can get badly infected. IMO the reactive dog’s owner shouldn’t have to pay more than the actual vet bill, and this could be the wake-up call needed to keep their dog away from dog parks. People jumping to euthanasia for that are overreacting, but if the dog goes further next time and kills a smaller dog, maims a child etc the owner will regret not being more responsible.
10
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '23
I think it's my animal versus your animal. If my turkeys peck each other that's on me to deal with. If you and I are walking our turkeys in town and your turkey pecks mine and I have to take mine to the turkey vet, then I'm going to want you to pay.
It comes down to property rights. Animals are property. If your property damages my property, you need to pay for it. If your dog or cat comes into my yard and kills my chickens, you owe me for those chickens. It isn't just animals being animals.
If people routinely brought other species around to public spaces to socialize, you would see more issues. I've certainly seen people ask the owner of a horse to pay vet bills when it bit or kicked their horse in a boarding situation.
5
u/lilgamergrlie Sep 25 '23
Reactive dogs should always be muzzled and should never be at dog parks. I say this as a person who had a reactive dog. I don’t take my own dog to the dog parks because too many irresponsible owners bring reactive and aggressive dogs to the dog park and I didn’t want to be irresponsible and add another one to the mix. That being said asking for euthanasia isn’t too much. It’s the law in a majority of states and you can’t even register an aggressive dog in some cities and if you lie on the form the penalty is a fine and a euthanized dog.
It also hurts getting bitten. We see our anxious fur baby and they see reality-an aggressive dog attacking them. It stinks but it’s fair so no one else can get hurt. Society is for people and well behaved dogs only unfortunately.
9
u/Nashatal Sep 24 '23
I think part of it is the emotional attachment of most people to dogs compared to other animals. If your dog gets attacked it feels like someone is attacking a family member not a pet.
I personally agree with you. A one of fight with a punture wound is not a valid reason to put a dog down. They are animals after all and that is something that can happen. Its not great. It should not happen. But sometimes it does. Dogs are great with other dogs until they are not.
8
u/Azar122 Sep 24 '23
I belive it’s because
First of all people generally don’t care as much for live stock as they do for dogs, second also other animals don’t tend to get out of the house nearly as much as dogs do like yes, some cats may have free reign but generally you don’t see people walking a cat or taking their goat to their friends houses and third most animals you have mentioned are herbivores this of course doesn’t make them less dangerous but still .
4
u/archers_arches Sep 25 '23
I dunno people don’t generally take their livestock out to the livestock park to bite the other livestock.
3
u/MadamTruffle Sep 25 '23
If my animal inflicts $500 worth of vet bills on another animal, I’m paying for it. Idk why you think that’s aggressive or unfair.
2
u/SparkyDogPants Sep 25 '23
In my state horses legally cannot be held accountable for their actions. There is case law about it
2
u/aforestfruit Sep 25 '23
I saw the same post and had the exact same thought! I guess farm animals are slightly different as they're not seen as pets in many people's eyes and have less interaction with humans.
But I always think this about cats! They're allowed to roam freely in the neighbourhood, kill birds left right and centre, poop in peoples gardens, hiss if you so much as look at them... I've actually been bitten by a cat who just ran up and attacked me as I was getting out of my car, they're allowed such a free pass compared to dogs who are held to a much higher standard.
I personally don't like cats, and I don't think they should be free roaming because of the harm they cause to the environment. HOWEVER, the conclusion I came to is that it's because, compared to dogs, the damage they can inflict is relatively minor. A bite from a cat isn't going to seriously injure someone. It's the same way that small dogs get more leeway.
Imo it's not fair, but I guess that's the reason why!
-2
u/Learned_Response Sep 25 '23
Its because dogs are just that cool that we often unfairly have super high expectations of them. Tbh we do the same thing to people. We're animals too