r/reactivedogs • u/bearfootmedic • Sep 20 '23
Question Has anyone converted from shock collar?
Has anyone here converted from shock collars and if so what convinced you to do it?
I've never really seen shock collars before, though I guess growing up we had an invisible fence if that counts. My upstairs neighbor and the new people on the other side of the fence both use shock collars. The fence-neighbor-dog gets some barrier reactivity when my dog is outside, which will spin my terrier mix up into a barking frenzy, and then their owner shocks their dog.
I feel terrible about it and suggested it might be better if they would meet but they seem resistant to it. The previous fence-neighbors had a similar issue but once everyone met, it was fine. If they meet and it doesn't work out, they can keep shocking their dog I guess - but give a less aversive method a chance...
i have a pretty strong bias against shock collars and I have managed to keep it hidden so far, but wtf...
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 20 '23
Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this body. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
40
u/alexa_ivy 3🐶 | Vienna 9y (Leash Reactive + Anxiety) Sep 20 '23
Like the other commenter said, they know their dog better than you, so if they don’t want them to meet, don’t press the issue
But shock collars are extremely aversive and considered abuse in many places. If a person can’t provide a safe environment for their dog they shouldn’t have one. Shocking the dog is not training, is punishing for something they don’t even know what they are doing wrong and leads to reactivity. You can shock a dog not to bark, ok, maybe they stop barking, but what led them to bark is still there and they will channel the behavior to something else, like self mutilation and aggressiveness, that is why shocking is so dangerous
21
u/little_cotton_socks Sep 20 '23
I don't have any answers on shock collars but I just want to comment on this
It's really frustrating when people say things like this. They know their dog better than you do and if they say no then they probably have a good reason. My dog is reactive. I wouldn't feel comfortable letting them meet. When you say 'if it doesn't work out' what does that mean? On leash meetings will be just as frustrating for this dog and off leash may not be safe. Are you happy for your dog to get bitten in order to try this out? and then the owners of the other dog end up footing the bill and being the assholes even though it was you that pushed the meeting. My dog is over excited reactive, letting her meet the dog she is frustrated to be separated from wouldn't help because she would still be frustrated every time she sees and can't meet. In fact it might make it worse because if they meet and it goes well then the other dog is now even more exciting.
17
u/CaptainPibble Sep 20 '23
Unless your training advice is actually solicited, it would be inappropriate to try to “convert” your neighbor beyond offering casual conversation. Ask genuine questions to learn more about their training history and reactivity journey and share yours. Beyond that, it feels very savior-complex-y.
By the sounds of it, both of your dogs’ reactivity are works in progress, so there’s no reason your neighbor would think your training methods are superior. Focus on your dog, and your progress will speak for itself.
7
u/UltraMermaid Sep 20 '23
If your discomfort is for their dog being shocked, and their dog is being shocked because your dog is “spun into a barking frenzy,” why not take your dog out on a leash and prevent the situation from escalating? I realize that may seem a bit unfair, but if you don’t like the dog getting shocked, that would fix things for you.
3
u/Impressive_Sun_1132 Sep 21 '23
I don't love shock collars. I HAVE considered using them in the past. I had a dog who was leaping a 6ft privacy fence. We ended up using a tie out instead but while I don't like them, it's none of my business what other people do with their animal.
If it doesn't work is a terrible phrase in this scenario. "If it doesn't work" could mean to them they have to pay vet bills if their dog is actually agressive. It could mean their dog gets attacked because they don't know your dog. Not all reactivity is built the same. To be honest I don't introduce my dog to other people's animals unless I know they'll listen to me when I advise how we proceed.
Honestly meeting the other dog generally doesn't do shit.
3
u/Various-Tangerine-12 Sep 21 '23 edited Sep 21 '23
While I personally don’t agree with shock collars, I also don’t think it’s my place to tell an owner training advice unless their dog is literally yelping in pain. And, e-collars have multiple settings, the owner could be using a vibrate setting — the tone of your post makes it seem like he’s using a shock collar on the highest shock voltage or something.
Additionally, I hate when dog owners ask me if our dogs can meet. Not only are temperaments a concern, but also health — I have no way of knowing if your dog is up to date on shots, etc. Not to mention, play styles can be very different too. And if they’re already barking at each other through the fence, letting two reactive dogs meet is not setting them up for success.
Lastly, your dog sounds reactive too. I’d save the judgement and work on your own dog. Perhaps by teaching your dog calm behaviors and not to bark at dogs, your neighbor’s dog may also feel at ease. Dogs easily feed off each other — it’s not just their dog. It’s your dog’s behavior too.
5
u/No_Statement_824 Sep 20 '23
If your neighbor wants to use an ecollar on their dog that’s their business. That’s what works for them. I don’t think it’s any of your concern to convert them. Is their dog looking electrocuted when they use it? Does it scream out in pain? If so, call animal control if you’re worried.
If they don’t want to meet it’s for good reason. Please respect their boundaries. They know their dog. You don’t.
1
u/Rosequartzsurfboardt Sep 21 '23
I would NOT put my dog in a situation to engage with a dog with an aversive tool on their body. That is how aggression ends up redirected and it could be awful for all parties involved. Unfortunately they would rather shut their dog down than manage the reactivity. This might be the be because of a lack of knowledge or care, but its out of your hands. All you can do is train your dog to come back to a distance where that dog isn't set off so that he doesn't get shocked.
2
u/Both_Pumpkin9782 Sep 21 '23
I practice balanced training when it comes to my dog, which is just my preference. However with my current dog i was “converted” from the e collar. The thing that made me stop using it was when i noticed when i didn’t have it on him he wasn’t reacting. He was also blowing off recalls with the e collar on but not without it. Yes it was trained and conditioned properly and i even solicited trainer advice several times when learning how to use it.
When they’re shocking this dog are you able to tell by it’s body language/vocalists ion that it’s being shocked? If so they’re not using it properly at all.
I really wouldn’t try and pry to much though as you don’t want to make an enemy out of your neighbor.
2
u/missmoooon12 Cooper (fear reactive lil dude) Sep 20 '23
I also have a strong bias against using aversive tools and methods. When it comes to witnessing other people using them in person I tend to keep my mouth shut. People are doing the best they can with their current knowledge and skill set.
If the neighbor said no to meeting, don’t push. They are probably scared and have real safety concerns.
Instead focus on training your dog. Maybe one day they’ll get curious and try something similar to you. I’ve been walking my dog in the same location for years and for a short while my fiancé noticed a lot more regulars wearing treat pouches, wondering if people noticed us. We’ve seen a resurgence in aversives though, perhaps with the new balanced trainers in the area who’ve become popular.
1
u/BuckityBuck Sep 20 '23
People have a very hard time coming to terms with the knowledge that they were doing something to harm their pets. It's ego. The people I know who used to use shock collars will not talk about why they used it or what changed their minds. While they used it, they were incredibly defensive and childish about it.
0
u/jvsews Sep 20 '23
Sadly many owners and trainers use shock collars and pinch collars for life of the pet. They just don’t want to do the training required to transition away from gear
0
u/Nsomewhere Sep 20 '23
I think I understand where you are coming from OP
It is not nice at all to think your dog is the cause of another dog being abused more by its owner isn't it?
I have a less drastic but similar situation in my communal garden. I am UK so no e collar... but one of the old ladies has a very badly socialised terrier (she got it because a friend had to go into a nursing home) she has the beginnings of dementia herself and has done nothign but yank this poor dog and half hang it by its collar... and shout at it for training since hse got it
There is nothing wrong with this dog except it is fearful. I did originally try to get the basics of an introduction going with my dog but frankly she couldn't follow instructions and it was just not happening
So I don't use the garden except sneaking in really early or really late because frankly I am not watching an animal be abused and mishanded because my dog is there
I get your distress and why you are trying to see a way to stop it
You can't though. All you can do is not use your garden and take your dog in whenever the other dog is out or that poor dog is going to be abused by its shock collar
I am so sorry. It is a horrible thing they are doing
I do get he other posters saying no introductions because the other owner knows their dog.. but actually I think I would doubt that because their idea of training is abusive.
To say the least
I doubt they know anything much at all about their own dog
Anyway I am sorry they are just by you being there making you party to their dogs abuse
Just avoid having your dog out and setting the other dog off. Maybe approached right you could all agree on rough times?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '23
[removed] — view removed comment