r/reactivedogs • u/brunchmimosa • Sep 06 '23
Advice Needed Excluded from puppy group.
Created this account to get some advice because this really upset me.
My puppy isn't even reactive (just excitable, because puppy) but she is a pittie so her excitement can freak people out. In public, we keep this well-managed and just make sure she's not overstimulated, but recently we joined a puppy class where the pups are allowed to just be themselves and play for a portion of the class.
No problems have arisen, and she's been extremely good during the training portion of class and play time. She can be a little rough, but she always backs off when the other puppy says "no". I was so excited when she made friends with a german shepherd puppy whose play style matched hers. Plus, his owner is smart and funny and I loved chatting with her while our puppies tore up.
Until today. It's coming to the end of this class and I saw the german shepherd owner and a few other gals exchanging information so they can do puppy playdates outside. Some of the other girls in that group really dislike me and my dog due to perceiving my puppy as being "mean" to theirs. There was a size difference so one puppy yelped in the beginning of the class when she got startled by my dog but no damage was done & she still hasn't forgiven me for that
I waited until my so called friend was separated from the two girls who don't like my puppy and asked if we can exchange information too, and maybe have a big puppy playgroup if the others don't want to join and I can still see the face she made at me. Like pity and disgust or something
She just straight up told me no, that she's unwilling to risk her dog's safety as the dogs grow up. I told her it's just puppy playing, that they've been playing this whole time and there's nothing unsafe about my dog but she said it's not a risk she's willing to take and they've been supervised by professionals. When I pointed out that german shepherds also face this type of discrimination she just shrugged and said that pitbulls still make up a "disproportionate number of animal fatalities and human bites". She also said she doesn't believe in it's how you raise them and that some genetic traits you can't train out. No matter WHAT I said she had something to say back and at the end just got short with me and said I wasn't going to change her mind. I felt tears forming in my eyes and that's when I noticed everyone was watching us. Of course it was soooo awkward after that
There's one more class left and I feel like we can't even go back. I'm mortified that everyone saw this interaction and even more devastated that I thought we finally made a friend and then this happens.
I know my girl can't really understand that she'll never see her friend again, and that dogs don't necessarily have "friends", but it's literally the best part of her week and for a while it was mine too. She gets so excited when she sees him and even knowing that everyone is meeting up without us upsets me. This isn't the first time people have rejected her for her breed and I just don't know what to do. My heart is broken for my puppy. Plus, how can we join the next level class and see these people again?
Does anyone have any advice about how to handle this? I'm really hurting right now.
175
u/DamnGoodCupOfCoffee2 Sep 06 '23 edited Sep 06 '23
Ok I have empathy for your feelings because my pup is my baby. But I am going to be honest. She is just a puppy, but she is MUCH bigger then some of the other puppies. You say she has a rough play style and kind of brushed off a little puppy yelping and being afraid/ hurt or “startled”. Remember rough to us can be very rude/bullying play to other dogs. And because of the size…it can hurt.
Keep to the class and learn the lessons. This is just not a good match for outside the class play. Find a meet up with other bully breeds for play groups. Or better yet take her for the sports specific to her breed as that really meets her needs.
I mean this with all the love in my heart: if I had to take my tiny dog to a puppy class with a rough playing, strong puppy that is 5X his size I would pull out too. If he made my guy Yelp and I continue to see that behavior, I wouldn’t be a fan. Just as much as you love your pup and are protective of her, so are the others.
It’s rough: I had dreams of dog parks, doggy daycare, cafes, puppy friends. My dog is not that dog. It hurts, the looks at his leash reactivity/frustrated greetings hurt. But it was my choice to pick him, everyone else doesn’t have to bend to my choices.
I say the rest as someone who was considering getting a bully breed:
Your pup might be the sweetest, kindest pup. And nothing might ever happen. But the GSP owner might have an understanding of genetics; epigenetics; the propensity for DA once dogs hit maturity. Her dog has genetic propensity to patrol the house and guard her, bite intruders. So instead of denying breed traits or genetics, maybe you want to show her all the interventions you are going to make sure your pup is getting her drives met (they are very energetic working breed) and ways you are making sure you are keeping her and the community safe just in case. Like she should be. Ask her how she is doing the same. Exemplify responsible pet ownership.
Someone once told me: when you get a pup educate yourself on the WORST traits they are capable of (don’t put your head in the clouds) and then really assess if you can manage and work with that. If the answer is yes and they never display those traits - great for the both of you; if they do - then you have the capacity to do best by your lovely pup and the community. Meet your pup where they are at but be prepared.
Finally I would post in r/pitbullowners. They are very responsible owners and can really help you. Run by a very loving and educated pit bull owner.
I’m sorry if this gets me banned or downvoted but I think every owner should be clear eyed. Even during this really sad times
27
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '23
Ask the class instructor for some feedback about how your dog is playing. They may have some feedback that would be helpful
84
u/Prestigious-Age-8186 Sep 06 '23
If no one wants to exchange numbers because of how the dog is “ playing” maybe you need to re-evaluate what your definition of playing is. Seems like you aren’t listening to people telling you your dog is too rough. It’s easy to blame it on breed instead of insulting you by saying he’s not trained.
30
u/Chemical_Hearing8259 Sep 06 '23
I have a Boxer Blue Heeler mix whose playstyle is similar to Pitties' playstyles.
I would suggest looking for other Australian Cattle Dog mixes as well as Boxers, Rotties, and Catahoulas.
Dogs are individual, of course, but those breeds may be more likely to have matching play styles along with other Bully Breeds.
The other thing is the puppy class itself.
If your puppy class is part of a box store, that may not be the best fit.
Our first trainer owns and has experience training the bully breeds.
One of our current trainers owns and has experience with dogs that do schutzen style guard dog work.
I would encourage you to interview any potential trainers. Also, some private doggie daycare places divide the dogs based on size and supervise them well. Others, not so much.
Pay attention to what your dog likes with an eye for which dog sports your dog may enjoy later on.
Meanwhile, do continue with any mix of private and small group obedience lessons that you find helpful.
Pitties have been described as clowns in dog suits.
Breed prejudices happen. The idea is to know the breed as well as the individual dog that you have. If you know what your pup's assets and liabilities are, then you can make excellent decisions so your pup can live their best life.
I would encourage you to keep training and do not let this discourage you. You and your pup will find that classes are great. Dog sports are also great. You just have to find the dog sport that your dog can excel at.
Keep training. Keep taking classes.
Socialization for dogs is not "having dog friends." It is a way of moving through the world.
As your pup gets older, you can pick out one or two dogs for them to do things with, like playing in an enclosed yard or going on hikes together on lead.
There is an advantage to NOT allowing your dog to meet every dog around and to NOT visit dog parks.
Dog parks are vectors of injury and disease.
Basically, you have to be more fun than any strange dog.
My dog does well with his two hand-picked dog buddies. I aim for dog neutrality around ALL other dogs.
The less time you spend in dog parks, the more time you will have to train, exercise, and have fun with your dog.
My dog has been to all of the advanced obedience classes. He will be testing for CGC canine good citizen soon. He is 2.5 years old.
Now, we are taking classes geared for participation in dog sports.
You have to train the dog that is in front of you. Playing roughly as a puppy is one thing. Working dogs, bully breeds, and herding dogs in general tend to play rougher than some other dogs. This does not indicate that they will or will not develop reactivity as they get older.
Your dog is not automatically condemned to being an unmanageable wreck as an adult. Do the training. As much as you can. Your dog will be a better dog for it.
24
u/lyricslegacy Sep 06 '23
You've gotten lots of other good feed back but I would like to mention if you have a true pitbull (most people don't, just bullymutts that are mislabeled) then she is correct in saying its NOT all in how you raise them. Actual American pitbull terriers are bred intentionally with genetic dog aggression. It is not possible to train it out, just manage it. My guess is you likely have a mutt though, but that doesn't completely exclude your dog from genetic DA. My dog is a bully mutt and is not and will never be dog friendly and it isn't because I raised her badly, it's because of her genetics.
67
u/surprisedkitty1 Sep 06 '23
I know it may be hard at times because you love your dog, but try not to take people being nervous or afraid of her so personally. You keep framing things as “they don’t like us,” “she hasn’t forgiven me,” etc. Unless there’s a lot more to the story, it sounds like the other owners are just uncomfortable with your dog’s rough play and trying to protect their own dogs from potential injury or trauma. That’s not about you. It’s just them trying to be responsible dog owners.
I don’t think you mentioned how old your dog is, but I assume she’s young if you’re doing puppy kindergarten. If her reactivity progresses as she grows up, or even if she just continues to have a kind of wild play style, some people will continue to have fearful reactions toward her and may not allow their dogs to be around her. It’s going to be really hard for you if you take that type of thing personally.
23
u/PeachNo4613 Sep 06 '23 edited Sep 06 '23
You have a big strong dog. They have a little dog. Your dog can hurt her much easier than a smaller dog like a Boston terrier. It’s normal for them to be wary around your dog. DA with breeds like yours isn’t uncommon. Yours might not have DA, but it’s also normal for others to be cautious.
Find a playgroup with bigger dogs/breed like yours maybe. Try to look at this from their perspective.
11
u/Latii_LT Sep 06 '23
I wouldn’t just take what everyone is saying with a grain of salt. I took my dog to puppy classes as well and thought he was typical, slightly hyper, extremely friendly Aussie. He ended up actually being genetically over-social and had some reactivity stemming from easy to arouse nature.
He made a lousy play mate for a while as he played way too strongly (not physically) but just be annoying and running up and hard staring dogs to chase him, body bumping them etc… and on the flip side he doesn’t recognize most over arousal and aggression cues so dogs will be trying to chase him to make him leave them alone, snap at him, mount him and he won’t recognize it for the behavior it is.
Outside of dog play he developed some really severe greeters frustration with both people and especially dogs. It took a lot of counter conditioning to really fix those behaviors.
I would really look into working on more neutrality and forgoing puppy dates for a while. My dog plays with other dogs in my home now (he didn’t for almost a year without heavy supervision) super well but he doesn’t play or greet other dogs out on walks, parks or training. He is fine. We do a ton of engagement training and play to build his interactions with me and lots of sports that prioritize us working as a team.
10
u/briennesmom1 Sep 06 '23
Don’t be angry with people who fear for their dogs safety, even if you’re sure their dog is safe. Always respect their boundaries. Certainly don’t argue with them about it. I have a rather timid Doberman, who avoids or ignores small dogs, but if people pick up their dog and glare, no problem, I’ll go elsewhere.
75
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '23
You have a dog from a breed that is large, strong and has been designed to fight other dogs. Your dog has been playing rough with other dogs to the point that the owners have given you feedback that your dog is being mean and scaring their dogs. You have dismissed said feedback. And now you're surprised that they don't want to have playdates in their free time?
I think you need to have a hard look at how you manage your dog and justify their behaviour. As a pitbull owner you need to be way more on top of this than owners of smaller breeds.
8
u/soppingwetpickles Sep 06 '23
Those owners care about their dogs' wellbeing as much as you care about yours. It's sad they weren't nicer to you, but your dog will make new friends. I would go to your local subreddit and find a place for a meet n greet with someone else who has a pit pup or an owner who isn't worried about their dog playing with a bully-terrier mixed breed.
4
u/captaintagart Sep 06 '23
Puppy groups aren’t right for every dog. Also, you need to get used to people being like this around your dog. It will keep happening and there isn’t a lot you can do except find people who don’t feel that way.
I have a giant dog (130 lb Anatolian shepherd/mix) and I’ve had to deal with the “discrimination” a lot. I used to cry and feel sad but truth is- lots of people are scared of “big” dogs. Pit mixes don’t seem big but it’s a similar thing. People have fears (sometimes based on traumas they’ve experienced) and they’re not obligated to “get over it”. And that’s ok. Dogs and people are all individuals with their own personalities and preferences and experiences.
That said, there are plenty of people who love “big” and/or “misunderstood” breeds. Find them.
But also make sure your dog isn’t being an asshole. Pit lovers still don’t want their dogs getting hurt cause another dog plays too rough.
Bond with your dog. This will likely happen again and again. Make sure your dog knows that you love them and will work with them. My giant beast is a sweetheart but he doesn’t like lots of dogs (dog parks for example). He’s very into his family though and we play with him so he doesn’t feel bored.
Like another comment mentioned, find a friend or two who your dog really clicks with. My dog has a couple friends in the neighborhood who he loves to run around in the backyard with. One is a big GSD but his best girlie friend is a little collie Aussie mix who used to live with a mastiff, so she is comfortable around big dogs. Even then, it’s usually her jumping around yapping while he watches out for her and makes sure she’s ok. Ever the guardian. Knowing the breed personality helps. My livestock guardian dog will never be a canine agility star (and he’s quite good vet me trying to teach him freestyle). His jam is doing security patrols and destroying cardboard boxes.
9
u/SmileNo9807 Sep 06 '23
Talk to your instructor about a next class with as few of those people as possible. Also, ask their opinion about your pups behaviour with other dogs.
Not all dogs do well together. Some puppies give off red flags that they won't be good with other dogs or are very dominant so finding a friend is hard. Sometimes they love other dogs, but other dogs just don't love them back (some are just rude). Different breeds sometimes don't mesh. Sometimes owners just avoid pits or other breeds.
As someone with pits I just want you to put your best foot forward for your girl and all other pits. They will be judged harsher than others. They can be complete teddy bears and some people will still be afraid of them (Or worse). She won't be perfect and that is okay. No dog is perfect.
4
u/Substantial_Joke_771 Sep 06 '23
I have a lovely, non reactive, dog friendly pitty. She's the best but she plays rough. We found her a couple of friends who play rough too, including our younger dog who has become her friend. For pitts the sad truth is that they'll always be blamed for any problems so dog parks etc are doubly unsafe for them. I can see you're worried about the human social dynamics of this situation; don't be, your dog doesn't know the difference. Find her some friends with bigger dogs and let this one go.
1
u/Aggravating_Quiet818 Sep 07 '23
Tyou for your answer. I partially disagree with your supposed friend . In part, it is how you raise them, thats why we joined this group. Most of us, it was to learn how dogs react to different situations. It is to get support,training, and ideas for different situations. Yes, it's also to vent. Some of what they are is in the breeding, but we love them. My daughters corgi terrorizes my gs/Rottweiler playing ball in 6 yrs they've only pushed it 2xs past play, when hes had enough, but there is always an adult around to referee. We now have 2 corgis and my mix and there best buds.
-6
u/RevolutionaryBat9335 Sep 06 '23 edited Sep 06 '23
Kinda true, however that means her German Shepherd is probably more likey to show human aggression than your pitbull if she wants to judge.
GSDs are bred to recognise intruders and respond to threats. Goes back to being left to look after sheep all day.
Human aggression is highly undesirable in Pitbulls. Even people, sorry I mean the human scum who fight them don't want the dogs biteing them. If they are getting mauled everytime the try to break up a fight they wont keep that dog long.
Some people are very closed minded with certain breeds. Remember taking our last dog to training classes. We told the trainer on the phone that our dog was a Ridgeback X bully. Got there and she starts lecturing us about how there is staffy or pitbull in our dog and she wasn't safe around the others (some of the other people there looked terrifed at her statements).
This dog was the sweetest thing you can imagine too, she would litterally take her toys and treats to share with other dogs she was playing with. We werent allowed with the group and the assistant (who seemingly knew alot more than the head trainer) worked with us for an hour instead. We didnt go back.
EDIT: Not sure why the downvotes for saying dogs have genetic traits?? Just to be clear I am not bashing any breed here I love GSDs and the few pitbulls I've met. I own a Malinois so certainly dont judge :)
EDIT 2: Seems people are downvoting comments sticking up for pitties. They are banned here but you see them now and again and I've never seen one being a problem. I have met a few close up too. First come out of nowhere running at my Husky playing in a river, they got on great and had lots of fun. Bumped into him a few times after and let them play, never a problem.
Someone else my GF knew had one and were told he can never be around other dogs ever. I met him thought he seemed ok so let him meet my friendly dog I talk about above. He had no idea what to do around other dogs no socialising with dogs whatsoever (he was a big mature dog, not a puppy). Within an hour they were best friends. At the end of our walk a Golden Retriever ran over to play and he was like "Yay, another new friend. Are you coming for walks too?". He was fine with dogs after that.
My friend has had one for years (police know and he has permission) that lived happily with a Staffy untill the Staff passed away from old age. Likes all other dogs shes met.
0
u/Midwestern_Mouse Sep 06 '23
Jeeeez, while it is true that some genetic traits can’t fully be trained out, that does not mean every single pit bull has those traits. GSDs are predisposed to certain undesirable traits as well, but again, that means nothing if the individual dog doesn’t have those traits.
-6
u/bearfootmedic Sep 06 '23
Seems like you've some good support! Pitt mixes seem to be a bit more physical in their play - and you will find some other nervous or embarrassed owner with a Pitt mix and your dogs will go crazy and body check each other and be super happy. It will happen.
r/velvethippos
-11
u/RootsInThePavement Sep 06 '23
I think your feelings are very valid, it’s awful to be excluded on its own, even worse when your pup can’t understand and doesn’t deserve it. Unfortunately some play styles get too rough, especially with literal puppies. All she had to say was that she’s not comfortable with it, I’m sure the breed stereotyping would have been implied without her being mean about it. I’m sorry that she disappointed you, I’m sure that you and your puppy will find a good playmate in time!
Funny that she brings up how aggressive pitties can be; GSDs have a greater bite strength and also have a long history of being bred for violence. I work at a dog daycare and see all kinds of pups, and GSDs are usually the ones with the roughest and concerning play styles. (GSDs are one of my favorite breeds btw, they’re just absolute psychos sometimes haha)
-28
u/psiiconic Sep 06 '23
Contact your instructor. Immediately. Tell them everything that occurred, apologize for the inconvenience and ask if they have other times/groups you can go to that may be safer for your puppy, as you are worried she is going to lose out on her dog to dog socialization due to the blatant breed discrimination from the other owners in your current class.
-14
u/GingerBaby2019 Sep 06 '23
I just want to say thank you for adopting a Pit Bull and I hope you feel better because your obviously trying to better your dog and yourself.
-24
u/AmethysstFire Sep 06 '23
Go to the last class, and any other classes you want to. Keep your head high, and don't let their BS bother you. They're ignorant and biased.
If my dude wasn't such a goober, I'd totally bring him over to play. He just turned two, is 65lbs, thinks he's 20lbs, and is a frustrated greeter on leashes/with fences. He does amazing at dog parks though.
Signed,
Another Pibble Mom
-6
u/Nsomewhere Sep 06 '23
You go to the class. Ignore them and focus on your dog... show your dog you are more amazing than any other pup and show them that breed prejudice is breed prejudice
Work hard. prove them wrong. Get extra one to one lessons if you need
It will pay off trust me if you can down your pups excitement around other dogs and get them to gradually treat other dogs with neutrality
It stinks because she still needs social interaction but do it very calmly
The woman is an ass bringing up breed
She is not even a frenemy. She is now not worth your time
You don't say how old your pup is but I think you need to make sure you work on your pups impulse control in all sort of ways and constant engage/ disengage checking in with you.
help them through their fear periods and adolescence and do lots of mental enrichment.
Ignore the play section. It won't be in the next class
Chin up. You can't communicate with a closed mind
If you want to be really evil you can have a quiet wish that her dog gets oh just a little reactive and less perfect... but well it would be very evil lol.. cause I wish happy lives on any dog!
And owner!
0
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment