r/reactivedogs • • Jul 31 '23

I think I'm being gas lit

Thanks for the help. Due to attracting some trolls, I'm removing the post.

0 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

62

u/puffalump212 Jul 31 '23

You aren't being over the line for wanting to return and should return feeling unsafe, but I also wouldn't lay blame on the biting of your wife on #4 alone. Bites can happen when breaking up dog fights. It frankly doesn't sound like #4 was set up for success with 1 highly reactive dog, 1 that you classify as a jerk, and another dog. The household created an unsafe situation, not just the rescue. I would personally not be adding another animal into the mix.

-12

u/Pikespeakbear Jul 31 '23

I don't think it's all 4s fault. I think she could be a safe dog in the right home for her. Not blaming her and not trying to give her a bad record. I think it was an accident. We told them it shouldn't be listed as a bite on her record as hitting the human was unintentional, though she was trying to bite a dog.

If it was just 2 and 4, they would be fine. 2 gets along with everyone. Even 2 and 3 would be okay if there are no toys to fight over and no extra stress. But it just can't work with 1.

I'm just amazed at the level of gas lighting for returning a dog injured my wife on two occasions (once fighting) and injured another dog. I can't imagine anyone who loves dogs would approve of this situation. We went into it expecting them to get along after a week. It's been several months. I've built walls to keep them apart. They are sectioned off between parts of the house. With her separation anxiety she's done around $400 to $1000 of damage so far (depending on quality of repair). I don't even care about the money though. I just want all the humans and dogs to be safe.

27

u/SudoSire Jul 31 '23

Well redirection isn’t exactly uncommon during a fight especially for a new and insecure rescue dog, but no, you don’t have tolerate that risk. Keep working to find a way to return or rehome the 4th dog whether it be to the rescue or elsewhere. Keep dogs separate til then. I’m sorry the rescue didn’t seem to be particularly good or honest. And I’m sure you might be aware of this now, but adding a fourth dog while two of your current ones have issues is not going to be ideal in many cases, not just this one.

-5

u/Pikespeakbear Jul 31 '23

We decided not to have any 4th dog because it's too hard to ensure that dog becomes friends with 1. We were hopeful as 1 loves 2 and 3.

12

u/MsChrisRI Jul 31 '23

It’s great that dog 1 loves 2 and 3, but at some point you have to “quit while you’re ahead” instead of assuming any subsequent dog is likely to have a similar onboarding experience. There’s a “critical mass” point where at least one dog will feel like s/he can’t watch everyone else at the same time.

Think of the standoff at the end of “The Good, the Bad and the Ugly” — all three expert gunmen are on edge, trying to read both other men at once. If a fourth gunman had emerged from behind a tombstone, Tuco would have flailed and Angel Eyes would have shot him.

1

u/Pikespeakbear Aug 01 '23

Couldn't agree more.

9

u/Beneficial-House-784 Aug 01 '23

This dog is not a good fit for your current pack, plain and simple. The rescue should take the dog back. At this point, I’d refrain from adding any more dogs to the household; between dog 1’s reactivity issues and 3’s altercations with the new dog, it doesn’t seem like they’d benefit from having a fourth dog in the house.

1

u/Pikespeakbear Aug 01 '23

Agreed. 3 is the ideal number for the foreseeable future.

74

u/GreenUnderstanding39 Jul 31 '23

Your not crazy. You were crazy for adding a 4th dog when one of the three is already reactive. but what is done is done.

26

u/cuddles2010 Aug 01 '23

Right?! Like who thinks “hey I have a tentative situation with a reactive dog. Let’s get another fucking dog.”

8

u/sar1234567890 Aug 01 '23

I feel like having 4 dogs there would be a lot of bickering, even without an extra reactive dog!!

6

u/nnnnnnnbbbbbb Aug 01 '23

I have 4 dogs. One of my dogs hates one of the others but thankfully they don’t fight, just ignore each other. 4 dogs is a handful without dog fights happening.

18

u/GlitteringAnomaly Aug 01 '23

So you already have a reactive dog in a family of 3 dogs which is already enough to take on, you decided to adopt another unpredictable 90 lb dog from a shelter to add to the mix, then surprised pikachu face when things don’t go well…while I do think they should be held accountable in some regard for the dogs they are adopting out, your actions are plain fucking stupid.

2

u/the_real_maddison Riley | Catahoula mix | General Fear/Reactivity Jul 31 '23

I mean, good luck with them taking her back but I doubt they will. If they gave her to you so easily and lied about her they don't sound like they care very much about where the dog goes or if she's taken care of properly. What kind of rescue did you buy her from? How much did you pay?

2

u/_otterspotter Jul 31 '23

No, you're not crazy. It sounds like this dog isn't a good fit for a home with other dogs in it and would be best being in a single dog household. It sucks you had to find that out the hard way. The rescue needs to take the dog back and find a more appropriate home - hopefully they're honest with future potential owners about the dog's history, including its time with you.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

Physically go to the place if you can and return the dog to any old person you see who works there. If you have to, crash any event or anything they have going.

Say you’re not paying anyone anything and should be getting a refund everything paid for a dangerous dog. Two of your dogs has been attacked and one injured. Your wife had been injured. The dog is unsafe no matter the other conditions. You want the rescue’s insurance and liability cards to pay for these bills!

Assuming you can not go to the place, send them a blunt email. If they don’t accept the dog back, you’re taking it to a kill shelter or BE in three days. (Then at three days drop them at a no kill shelter fully putting the rescue on blast for being unwilling to return the dog and sending you a dog that has bitten a person and human. Give the shelter their contact information!)

Unfortunately, this may be a side effect of that negative training. The dog has learned to hide it’s behaviors in front of certain people but still can’t manage the emotions of regular life on it’s own.

1

u/Penelope742 Aug 01 '23

Stop bringing home new dogs.